Abstract
In the absence of site-specific data, generic guidelines are important to indicate whether soils contaminated with As require attention or remediation. It is important that the data used to set generic guidelines come from as broad a survey as possible. The objective of this paper is to summarize the data on the phytotoxicity of As from the literature, and to analyze the associated variance. The very narrow margin between background and toxic concentrations of As in soils is clearly shown. The source of As is important; the inorganic sources are less toxic than the organic sources. When only the inorganic sources are considered, soil type is the only other significant variable. Monocotyledonous and dicotyledonous plants did not differ significantly in response to soil As. Inorganic As is 5-fold more toxic in sands and loams (the geometric mean, GM, of the reported toxicity thresholds is 40 mg kg−1) than in clay soils (where the GM is 200 mg kg−1). Deviation of a single geometric standard deviation is 3.6-fold above and below these GM values. The results show that it is appropriate to set generic regulatory criteria by soil type, but that site- or soil-specific data is likely needed past a screening stage.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anastasia, F. B. and Kender, W. J.: 1973, J. Environ. Qual. 2, 335.
Arnott, J. T. and Leaf, A. L.: 1967, Weeds 15, 121.
Baker, R. S., Arle, H. F., Miller, J. H., andHolston, J. T. Jr.: 1969, Weed Sci. 17, 37.
Barrow, N. J.: 1974, Soil Sci. 117, 28.
Benson, A. A., Cooney, R. V., and Herrera-Lasso, J. M.: 1981, J. of Plant Nutrition 3, 285.
Benson, N. R.: 1953, Soil Sci. 76, 215.
Benson, N. R.: 1968, ‘Can Profitable Orchards Be Grown an Old Orchard Soils?’ in Proc. 64th Annual Meeting Washington State Horticultural Association, pp. 109–114.
Bishop, R. F. and Chisholm, D.: 1962, Can. J. Soil Sci. 42, 77.
Chisholm, D. and MacPhee, A. W.: 1972, J. Econ. Entomol. 65, 1010.
Clements, H. F. and Munson, J.: 1947, Pacific Sci. 1, 151.
Cooper, H. P., Paden, W. R., Hall, E. E., Albert, W. B., Rogers, W. B., and Riley, J. A.: 1931, ‘Effect of Calcium Arsenate on the Productivity of Certain Soil Types’, South Carolina Agric. Exp. Sta. Ann. Rep. 44, cited by National Research Council 1977, pp. 28–36.
Cooper, H. P., Paden, W. R., Hall, E. E., Albert, W. B., Rogers, W. B., and Riley, J. A.: 1932, ‘Soils Differ Markedly in Their Response to Additions of Calcium Arsenate’, South Carolina Agric. Exp. Sta. Ann. Rep. 45, cited by National Research Council 1977, pp. 23–27.
Covey, R. P., Koch, B. L., and Larsen, H. J.: 1981, Phytopathology 71, 712.
Davis, R. D., Beckett, P. H. T., and Wollan, E.: 1978, Plant Soil 49, 395.
Deuel, L. E. and Swoboda, A. R.: 1972a, Soil Sci. Soc. Am. Proc. 36, 276.
Deuel, L. E. and Swoboda, A. R.: 1972b, J. Environ. Qual. 1, 317.
Dudas, M. J., Warren, C. J., and Spiers, G. A.: 1988, Comm. in Soil Sci. Plant Anal. 19, 887.
Environment Ontario: 1989, ‘Guidelines for the Decommissioning and Cleanup of Sites in Ontario’, Waste Management Branch, Ontario Min. Environ., Queen's Printer for Ontario, Toronto.
Epps, E. A. and Sturgis, M. B.: 1939, Soil Sci. Soc. Amer. Proc. 4, 215.
Furlong, C. B.: 1978, ‘Effects of Arsenic in the Canadian Environment’, National Research Council of Canada, Publ. No. NRCC 15391.
Gile, P. L.: 1936, J. Agr. Res. 52, 477.
Hiltbold, A. E.: 1975, ‘Behaviour of Organoarsenicals in Plants and Soils’, in Woolson, E. A. (ed.), Arsenical pesticides, Amer. Chem. Soc. Symp. Ser. 7, Amer. Chem. Soc., Washington, cited by Furlong 1978, pp. 124–147.
Jacobs, L. W., Keeney, D. R., and Walsh, L. M.: Agron. J. 62, 588.
Jacobs, L. W. and Keeney, D. R.: 1970, Commun. Soil Sci. Plant Anal. 1, 85.
Koranda, J. J., Cohen, J. J., Smith, C. F., and Ciminesi, F. J.: 1981, ‘Geotoxic Materials in the Surface Environment’, Lawrence Livermore Laboratory, California, UCRL-53215.
Lee, C. R., Folsom, B. L. Jr., and Engler, R. M.: 1982, Env. International 7, 65.
Li, G.-C. and Fei W.-C.: 1980, Plant Prot. Bull. (Taiwan) 22, 101.
MacPhee, A. W., Chisholm, D., and MacEachern, C. R.: 1960, Can. J. Soil Sci. 40, 59.
McKeague, J. A., Desjardins, J. G., and Wolynetz, M. S.: 1979, ‘Minor Elements in Canadian Soils’, Agriculture Canada, Research Branch. Land Resource Research Institute Contribution No. LRRI 27.
McLean, H. C., Weber, A. L. and Joffe, J. S.: 1944, J. Econ. Entomol. 37, 315.
Millhollon, R. W.: 1970, Weed Sci. 18, 333.
National Research Council: 1977, ‘Arsenic’, Printing and Publishing Office, National Academy of Sciences, Washington, D.C.
Nriagu, J. O. and Pacyna, J. M.: 1988, Nature 333, 134.
Pollard, A. J.: 1980, New Phytol. 86, 109.
Raab, H. E.: 1972a, Weed Sci. Soc. Amer. Abstr. pp. 32.
Raab, H. E.: 1972b, Weed Sci. Soc. Amer. Abstr. pp. 32.
Ray, B.: 1975, Int. Pest Control 17, 9.
Reed, J. F. and Sturgis, M. B.: 1936, J. Amer. Soc. Agron. 28, 432.
Rosehart, R. G. and Lee, J. Y.: 1973, Water, Air, and Soil Pollut. 2, 439.
Rosenfels, R. S. and Crafts, A. S.: 1940, Hilgardia 12, 203.
Sadiq, M., Zaidi, T. H., and Mian, A. A.: 1983, Water, Air, and Soil Pollut. 20, 369.
Sadiq, M.: 1986, Plant Soil 91, 241.
Sandberg, G. R. and Allen, I. K.: 1975, ‘A Proposed Arsenic Cycle in an Agronomie Ecosystem’, in Woolson, E. A. (ed.), Arsenical pesticides, Amer. Chem. Soc. Symp. Ser. 7, Amer. Chem. Soc., Washington, cited by Furlong 1978, pp. 124–147.
Scharpenseel, H.-W. and Becker-Heidmann, P.: 1990, ‘Pollution as a Geomedical Factor’, in Läg, J. (ed.), Geomedicine, CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida, pp. 141–162.
Sheppard, M. I., Sheppard, S. C. and Thibault, D. H.: 1982, ‘Identification of the Problem Phytotoxicant in Soil from a Radioactive Waste Disposal Area’, Atomic Energy of Canada Limited, Pinawa, Manitoba, Report WNRE-461.
Sheppard, M. I., Thibault, D. H., and Sheppard, S. C.: 1985, Water, Air, and Soil Pollut. 26, 85.
Sheppard, S. C.: 1991, Can. J. Botany 69, 63.
Sheppard, S. C. and Evenden, W. G.: 1988, J. Environ. Radioactivity 8, 255.
Sheppard, S. C., Tamm, J. A., and Barnard, J. W.: 1990, ‘A Review and Assessment of Certain Technical Aspects Related to Establishing Cleanup Criteria for the Port Hope Properties’, Report to the Low-Level Radioactive Waste Management Office, Atomic Energy of Canada Limited, Ottawa, Ontario, Technical Record TR-496.
Sinclair, W. A., Stone, E. L., and Scheer, C. F. Jr.: 1975, HortSci. 10, 35.
Steevens, D. R., Walsh, L. M., and Keeney, D. R.: 1972, J. Environ. Qual. 1, 301.
Stewart, J. and Smith, E. S.: 1922, Soil Sci. 14, 111.
Thompson, A. H. and Batjer, L. P.: 1950, Soil Sci. 69, 281.
Tsutsumi, M.: 1981, ‘Arsenic Pollution in Arable Land’, in Kitagishi K. and Yamane I. (eds.), Heavy Metal Pollution in Soils of Japan, Japan Scientific Societies Press, Tokyo, pp. 181–192.
von Endt, D. W., Kearney, P. C., and Kaufman, D. D.: 1968, J. Agric. Food Chem. 16, 17.
Walsh, L. M. and Keeney, D. R.: 1975, ‘Behaviour and Phytotoxicity of Inorganic Arsenicals in Soils’, in: Woolson, E. A. (ed.), Arsenical pesticides, Amer. Chem. Soc. Symp. Ser. 7, Amer. Chem. Soc., Washington, cited by Furlong 1978, pp. 35–54.
Weaver, R. W., Melton, J. R., Wang, D., and Duble, R. L.: 1984. Env. Pollut. Ser. A 33, 133.
Wells, B. R. and Gilmour, J. T.: 1977, Agronomy J. 69, 451.
Woolson, E. A., Axley, J. H., and Kearney, P. C.: 1971a, Soil Sci. Soc. Amer. Proc. 35, 938.
Woolson, E. A., Axley, J. H., and Kearney, P. C.: 1971b, Soil Sci. Soc. Amer. Proc. 35, 101.
Woolson, E. A.: 1972, J. Sci. Food Agric. 23, 1477.
Woolson, E. A.: 1973, Weed Sci. 21, 524.
Woolson, E. A., Axley, J. H., and Kearney, P. C.: 1973, Soil Sci. Soc. Amer. Proc. 37, 254.
Woolson, E. A. and Isensee, A. R.: 1981, Weed Sci. 29, 17.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Sheppard, S.C. Summary of phytotoxic levels of soil arsenic. Water Air Soil Pollut 64, 539–550 (1992). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00483364
Received:
Revised:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00483364