Abstract
Kornai's thesis that shortage results from demand expansions bred by the soft budget constraint, derives from his implicit assumption that price regimes of input and output firms are different. Since any firm is both an input and an output firm, which discards the assumption as logically untenable, excess demand can only turn up because of lower than contracted inputs of labor and management that are not offset by an adequate downward adjustment of earnings. Expansions of demand that appear to be autonomous, are incited by uncertain deliveries of inputs, that is, by inefficiency (of output firms) as well. A by far the largest part of excess demand can be explained by state preferences for fast growth. As planners are more successful in generating investment, and the ensuing consumer, demand than in expanding production, shortage is inevitable regardless of the character of the firms' budget constraints.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
AlchianA.A. and DemsetzH. (1972), ‘Production, information costs and economic organization’, American Economic Review 62, 777–95.
BajtA. (1971), ‘Investment cycles in European socialist economies: A review article’, The Journal of Economic Literature 9, 53–63.
Bajt, A. (1990), ‘Economic reforms versus central planning and monoparty control’, Int. Ec. Ass., forthcoming.
GomulkaS. (1985), ‘Kornai's soft budget constraint and the shortage phenomenon: A criticism and restatement’, Economics of Planning 19, 1–11.
KornaiJ. (1979), ‘Resource-constrained versus demand-constrained systems’, Econometrica 47, 801–19.
KornaiJ. (1980), Economics of Shortage, Amsterdam, North Holland.
KornaiJ. (1985a), ‘Gomulka on the soft budget constraint: A Reply’, Economics of Planning 19, 49–55.
KornaiJ. (1985b), ‘On the explanatory theory of shortage: Comments on two articles by K. Soós’, Acta Oeconomica 34, 145–164.
KornaiJ. (1986), ‘The soft budget constraint’, Kyklos 39, 3–30.
MarreseM. and MitchellJ.L. (1984), ‘Kornai's resource-constrained economy: A survey and an appraisal’, Journal of Comparative Economics 8, 74–84.
SzabóJ. (1988), ‘Preliminary and incremental softness of the budget constraint: A comment on the Gomulka-Kornai debate’, Economics of Planning 22, 109–116.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bajt, A. Irrelevance of the soft budget constraint for the shortage phenomenon. Economics of Planning 24, 1–12 (1991). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00361111
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00361111