Abstract
This paper makes a number of critical comments on a recent article by Andrews and Inglehart (1979), where the similarity of subjective well-being data from nine different countries was investigated. It is first shown that different MDS representations can be constructed for the data which differ considerably among each other and with respect to the similarity hypothesis. The goodness of the MDS solutions is discussed by using finer indices than overall Stress. Then, the measures of configurational similarity are evaluated statistically. Finally, it is shown that other, equally valid measures lead to completely different conclusions. It is argued that this poses an insurmountable problem. A facet theoretical approach which looks for prototypical structures rather than a single similarity index avoids this dilemma.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
Bibliography
Andrews, F. M. and Inglehart, R. F.: ‘The structure of subjective well-being in nine Western societies’, Social Indicators Research 6 (1979), pp. 73–90.
Borg, I.: ‘PAL: point-wise alienation coefficients in multidimensional scaling’, Journal of Marketing Research 15 (1978a), pp. 478–479.
Borg, I.: ‘Ein Vergleich verschiedener Studien zur Levensqualität’, Zeitschrift für Sozial-psychologie 9, (1978b), pp. 152–164.
Borg, I.: ‘Some basic concepts of facet theory’, in J. C.Lingoes, E. E.Roskam, and I.Borg (eds.), Geometric Representations of Relational Data (Mathesis Press, Ann Arbor, Mich., 1979, 2nd ed.).
Borg, I.: Angewandte Multidimensionale Skalierung (Klett, Stuttgart, Germany, 1981, in press).
Borg, I. and Bergermaier, R.: ‘Die Ähnlichkeit von Einstellungsstrukturen zur Lebensqualität in elf westlichen Gesellschaften’, Zeitschrift für Sozialpsychologie 10 (1979), pp. 253–261.
Borg, I. and Lingoes, J. C.: ‘Multidimensional scaling with side constraints on the distances’, in J. C.Lingoes, E. E.Roskam, and I.Borg (eds.), Geometric Representations of Relational Data (Mathesis Press, Ann Arbor, Mich., 1979, 2nd ed.).
Borg, I. and Lingoes, J. C.: ‘A model and algorithm for multidimensional scaling with external constraints on the distances’, Psychometrika 45 (1980), pp. 25–38.
Gower, J. C.: ‘Generalized Proscrustes analysis’, Psychometrika 40 (1975), pp. 33–51.
Guttman, L.: ‘What is not what in statistics’, The Statistician 26 (1978), pp. 81–107.
Kruskal, J. B., Young, F. W., and Seery, J. B.: ‘How to use KYST-2, a very flexible program to do multidimensional scaling and unfolding’, Unpublished manuscript, Bell Labs, Murry Hill, N.J., 1978.
Langeheine, R.: ‘Approximate norms and significance tests for the Lingoes-Borg Procrustean Individual Difference Scaling (PINDIS)’ (Arbeitsbericht No. 39, Institut für die Pädagogik der Naturwissenschaften Universität Kiel, West Germany, 1980a).
Langeheine, R.: ‘Erwartete Fitwerte für Zufallskonfigurationen in PINDIS’, Zeitschritt für Sozialpsychologie 11, (1980b), pp. 38–49.
Levy, S.: ‘Lawful roles of facets in social theories’, in I.Borg (ed.), Multidimensional Data Representations: When and Why (Mathesis Press, Ann Arbor, Mich. 1981, in press).
Levy, S. and Guttman, L.: ‘On the multivariate structure of well-being’, Social Indicators Research 2 (1975), pp. 361–388.
Levy, S. and Guttman, L.: ‘Structure and level of values for rewards and allocation criteria in several life areas’, in I.Borg (ed.), Multidimensional Data Representations: When and Why (Mathesis Press, Ann Arbor, Mich., 1981, in press).
Lingoes, J. C. and Borg, I.: ‘A direct approach to individual differences scaling using increasingly complex transformations’, Psychometrika 43 (1978), pp. 491–519.
Lingoes, J. C. and Roskam, E. E.: ‘A mathematical and empirical comparison of two multidimensional scaling algorithms’, Psychometrika 38 (1973), Monograph Supplement.
Lingoes, J. C. and Schönemann, P. H.: ‘Alternative measures of fit for the Schönemann-Carroll matrix fitting algorithm’, Psychometrika 39 (1974), pp. 423–427.
Lissitz, R., Schönemann, P. H., and Lingoes, J. C.: ‘A solution to the weighted Procrustes problem in which the transformation is in agreement with the loss function’, Psychometrika 41 (1976), pp. 547–550.
Poor, D. and Wherry, R. J.: ‘Invariance of multidimensional configurations’, British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology 26 (1976), pp. 114–125.
Shye, S. (ed.): ‘Theory Construction and Data Analysis in the Behavioral Sciences (Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, 1978).
Spence, I. and Ogilvie, J. C.: ‘A table of expected stress values for random rankings in nonmetric multidimensional scaling’, Multivariate Behavioral Research 8 (1973), pp. 511–517.
tenBerge, J. M. F.: ‘Orthogonal procrustes rotation for two or more matrices’, Psychometrika 42 (1977), pp. 267–276.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
We would like to thank Frank Andrews for making the data available to us, and for a number of helpful comments on an earlier version of this paper.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Borg, I., Bergermaier, R. Some comments on ‘the structure of subjective well-being in nine western societies’ by andrews and inglehart. Soc Indic Res 9, 265–278 (1981). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00300657
Received:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00300657