Summary
Nine selected sera were studied using radioim-munoassay and enzyme linked immunosorbent assay; eight contained insulin antibodies and were from Type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetic patients, one of whom had antibody-mediated insulin resistance, and one contained insulin-auto-antibodies and was from an asymptomatic blood donor. Sera were assayed in serial dilution to assess their suitability for use as reference standards. Dilution curves were non-parallel in radioimmunoassay but were parallel in immunosorbent assay. In all sera, insulin antibodies were readily detected in both assays whereas the low avidity insulin autoantibodies were only detected by immunosorbent assay and not at all by radioimmunoassay, suggesting that the assays respond differently to antibodies of different avidity. Avidity was estimated in liquid phase from the dissociation rate of preformed complexes of antibody and 125-iodinated insulin. When high avidity antibodies are used as a reference in radioimmunoassay, lower avidity antibodies are underestimated and vice versa. In contrast, in immunosorbent assay, any serum could be used as a reference regardless of avidity; furthermore competition experiments comparing the highest avidity insulin antibodies, from the insulin-resistant patient, with the insulin autoantibodies from the asymptomatic blood donor yielded nearsuperimposable curves. We conclude that radioimmunoassay is selective for high avidity antibodies whereas enzyme linked immunosorbent assay is not; computer modelling of the two assays supports this conclusion. In practice immunosorbent assay can be standardized using a reference serum, whereas experimental findings and mathematical considerations preclude the use of a standard serum in radioimmunoassay.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Banting FG, Franks WR, Gairns S (1938) Physiological studies in metrazole shock. VII. Anti-insulin activity of serum of insulin treated patients. Am J Psychol 95: 562–566
Kahn CR, Rosenthal AS (1979) Immunologic reactions to insulin: insulin allergy, insulin resistance, and the autoimmune insulin syndrome. Diabetes Care 2: 283–295
Berson SA, Yalow RS (1959) Quantitative aspects of the reaction between insulin and insulin-binding antibody. J Clin Invest 38: 1996–2016
Christiansen AH (1970) A new method for determination of insulin-binding immuno-globulins in insulin-treated diabetic patients. Horm Metab Res 2: 187–188
Telford ME, Wisdom GB (1979) Enzyme-immunoassay of anti(bovine insulin) antibodies. Biochem Soc Trans 7: 527–529
Nell LJ, Virta VJ, Thomas JW (1985) Application of a rapid enzyme-linked immunosorbent microassay (ELISA) to study human anti-insulin antibody. Diabetes 34: 60–66
Wilkin T, Nicholson S, Casey C (1985) A micro enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for insulin antibodies in serum. J Immunol Meth 76: 185–194
Koch M, Francois-Gerard C, Sodoyez-Goffaux F, Sodoyez JC (1986) Semi-quantitative assessment of antiinsulin total IgG and IgG subclasses in insulin-immunised patients using a highly sensitive immunochemical micromethod. Diabetologia 29: 720–726
Palmer JP, Asplin CM, Clemons P, Lyen K, Tatpati O, Raghu FK, Paquette TL (1983) Insulin antibodies in insulin-dependent diabetics before insulin treatment. Science 222: 1337–1339
Arslanian SA, Becker DJ, Rabin B, Atchison R, Eberhardt M, Cavender D, Dorman J, Drash AL (1985) Correlates of insulin antibodies in newly diagnosed children with insulin-dependent diabetes before insulin therapy. Diabetes 34: 926–930
Dean BM, Becker F, McNally JM, Tarn AC, Schwartz G, Gale EAM, Bottazzo GF (1986) Insulin autoantibodies in the prediabetic period: correlation with islet cell antibodies and development of diabetes. Diabetologia 29: 339–342
Ichihara K, Shima K, Saito Y, Nonaka K, Tarui S, Nishikawa M (1977) Mechanism of hypoglycemia observed in a patient with insulin autoimmune syndrome. Diabetes 26: 500–506
Hirata Y (1983) Methimazole and insulin autoimmune syndrome with hypoglycaemia. Lancet II: 1037–1038
Benson EA, Healey LA, Barren EJ (1985) Insulin antibodies in patients receiving penicillamine. Am J Med 78: 857–860
Trenn G, Eysselein V, Mellinghoff HU, Muller R, Benker G, Reinwein D, Federlin K (1986) Clinical and biochemical aspects of the insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAIS). Klin Wochenschr 64: 929–934
Faguer B, Burgard M, Boitard C, Desplanque N, Fanjoux J, Tchobroutsky G (1986) Syndrome hypoglyçémique d'origine autoimmune. Journ Annu Diabetol Hotel Dieu, pp 165–172
Sklenar I, Wilkin TJ, Diaz JL, Erb P, Keller U (1987) Spontaneous hypoglycemia associated with autoimmunity specific to human insulin. Diabetes Care 10: 152–159
Wilkin T, Palmer J, Bonifacio E, Diaz JL, Kruse V (1987) On be-half of the immunology and diabetes workshop and participating laboratories. Workshop report First International Workshop on the Standardization of Insulin Autoantibodies. Diabetologia 30: 676–677
Sodoyez-Goffaux F, Koch M, Dozio N, Brandenburg D, Sodoyez JC (1988) Advantages and pitfalls of radioimmune and enzyme linked immunosorbent assays of insulin antibodies. Diabetologia 31: 694–702
Kurtz AB, Matthews JA, Mustaffa BE, Daggett PR, Nabarro JDN (1980) Decrease of antibodies to insulin, proinsulin and contaminating hormones after changing treatment from conventional beef to purified pork insulin. Diabetologia 18: 147–150
Sodoyez-Goffaux F, Sodoyez JC, Koch M, Dozio N, Arquilla ER, McDougall B, De Vos CJ, von Frenckell R (1987) Scintigraphic distribution of complexes of antiinsulin antibodies and 123I-insulin. In vivo studies in rats. J Clin Invest 80: 466–474
Markussen J, Larsen UD (1980) The application of HPLC to the analysis of radio-iodinated tracers of glucagon and insulin. In: Brandenburg D, Wollmer A (eds) Insulin, chemistry, structure and function of insulin and related hormones. W. De Gruyter, Berlin, pp 161–168
Sodoyez JC, Sodoyez Goffaux F, Guillaume M, Merchie G (1983) (123-1) Insulin metabolism in normal rats and humans: external detection by a scintillation camera. Science 219: 865–867
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Koch, M., Sodoyez, J.C., Sodoyez-Goffaux, F. et al. Is quantitative assessment of insulin-antibodies and autoantibodies feasible?. Diabetologia 32, 774–778 (1989). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00264906
Received:
Revised:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00264906