Abstract
Modifying the descriptive and theoretical generalizations of Relativized Minimality, we argue that a significant subset of weak island violations arise when an extracted phrase should scope over some intervener but is unable to. Harmless interveners seem harmless because they can support an alternative reading. This paper focuses on why certain wh-phrases are poor wide scope takers, and offers an algebraic perspective on scope interaction. Each scopal element SE is associated with certain operations (e.g., not with complements). When a wh-phrase scopes over some SE, the operations associated with that SE are performed in its denotation domain. The requisite operations may or may not be available in a domain, however. We present an empirical analysis of a variety of wh-phrases. It is argued that the wh-phrases that escape all weak islands (i.e., can scope over any intervener) are those that range over individuals, the reason being that all Boolean operations are defined for their domain. Collectives, manners, amounts, numbers, etc. all denote in domains with fewer operations and are thus selectively sensitive to scopal interveners—a “semantic relativized minimality effect”.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aoun, Joseph: 1986, Generalized Binding, Foris, Dordrecht.
Barwise, Jon: 1979, ‘On Branching Quantifiers in English,’ Journal of Philosophical Logic 8, 47–80.
Beghelli, Filippo: 1992, ‘A Minimalist Approach to Quantifier Scope,’ Proceedings of NELS 22, University of Massachusetts, Amherst.
Carlson, Gregory: 1984, ‘Thematic Roles and Their Role in Semantic Interpretation,’ Linguistics 22, 259–279.
Cattell, Ray: 1978, ‘On the Source of Interrogative Adverbs,’ Language 54, 61–77.
Chierchia, Gennaro: 1984, Topics in the Syntax and Semantics of Infinitives and Gerunds, Ph.D. dissertation, University of Massachusetts, Amherst.
Chierchia, Gennaro: 1992, ‘Functional WH and Weak Crossover,’ in Dawn Bates (ed.), Proceedings of the Tenth WCCFL, CSLI, Stanford, pp. 75–91.
Chung, Sandra: 1992, ‘Wh-Agreement and “Referentiality” in Chamorro,’ ms., UCSC.
Cinque, Guglielmo: 1991, Types of A'-Dependencies, MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Comorovski, Ileana: 1989, Discourse and the Syntax of Multiple Constituent Questions, Ph.D. dissertation, Cornell University.
Dobrovie-Sorin, Carmen: 1992, ‘LF Representations, Weak Islands, and the ECP,’ GLOW Newsletter 28, 14–15.
Dukes, Michael: 1992, ‘Factives, “Stance” Predicates, and Weak Islandhood,’ ms., UCLA.
Enç, Mürvet: 1991, ‘The Semantics of Specificity,’ Linguistic Inquiry 22, 1–25.
Engdahl, Elisabet: 1985, Constituent Questions, Reidel, Dordrecht.
Frampton, John: 1990, ‘The Fine Structure of WH Movement and the Proper Formulation of the ECP,’ ms., Northeastern University.
Groenendijk, Jeroen and Martin Stokhof: 1984, Studies on the Semantics of Questions and the Pragmatics of Answers, Ph.D. dissertation, Amsterdam University.
Harada, Yasunari and Naohiko, Noguchi: 1992, ‘On the Semantics and Pragmatics of dake (and only),’ in Chris Barker and David Dowty (eds.), SALT II: Proceedings of the Second Conference on Semantics and Linguistic Theory (OSU WPL 40), The Ohio State University, Columbus, pp. 125–145.
Hegarty, Michael: 1992, ‘Adjunct Extraction Without Traces,’ in Dawn Bates (ed.), Proceedings of the Tenth WCCFL, CSLI, Stanford, pp. 209–223.
Hepple, Mark: 1990, The Grammar and Processing of Order and Dependency: A Categorial Approach, Ph.D. dissertation, Edinburgh University.
Higginbotham, James: 1991, ‘Interrogatives I,’ in Lisa, Cheng and Hamida, Demirdash (eds.), More Papers on WH-Movement (MIT WPL 15), MIT, Cambridge, pp. 47–76.
Keenan, Edward and Leonard, Faltz: 1985, Boolean Semantics for Natural Language, Reidel, Dordrecht.
Keenan, Edward and Alan, Timberlake: 1988, ‘Natural Language Motivation for Extending Categorial Grammar,’ in Richard, Oehrle, Emmon, Bach and Deirdre, Wheeler (eds.), Categorial Grammars and Natural Language Structures, Reidel, Dordrecht.
É. Kiss, Katalin: 1991, ‘Logical Structure in Syntactic Structure: The Case of Hungarian,’ in James, Huang and Robert, May (eds.), Logical Structure and Linguistic Structure, Kluwer, Dordrecht, pp. 387–426.
É. Kiss, Katalin: 1992, ‘Wh-Movement and Specificity,’ to appear in Natural Language and Linguistic Theory.
Kiss, Tibor: 1991, ‘Some Properties of Negation in German,’ ms., IBM, Stuttgart.
Krifka, Manfred: 1990, ‘Four Thousand Ships Passed Through the Lock,’ Linguistics and Philosophy 13, 487–520.
Kroch, Anthony: 1989, ‘Amount Quantification, Referentiality and Long WH-Movement,’ ms., University of Pennsylvania.
Ladusaw, William: 1980, ‘Affective OR, Factive Verbs, and Negative Polarity Items,’ in Proceedings of the Sixteenth CLS, pp. 170–184.
Landman, Fred: 1986, Towards a Theory of Information, Foris, Dordrecht.
Landman, Fred: 1991, Structures for Semantics, Kluwer, Dordrecht.
Liu, Feng-hsi: 1990, Scope Dependency in English and Chinese, Ph.D. dissertation, UCLA.
Liu, Feng-hsi: 1991, ‘Branching Quantification and Scope Independence,’ in Jaap van der, Does and Jan van, Eijck (eds.), Generalized Quantifier Theory and Applications, Dutch Network for Language, Logic and Information, Amsterdam, pp. 297–331.
May, Robert: 1985, Logical Form: Its Structure and Derivation, MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
McDaniel, Dana: 1989, ‘Partial and Multiple WH-Movement,’ Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 7, 565–604.
Melvold, Janis: 1991, ‘Factivity and Definiteness,’ in Lisa, Cheng and Hamida Demirdash (eds.), More Papers on WH-Movement (MIT WPL 15), MIT, Cambridge, pp. 97–117.
Molnár, Ilona: 1982, ‘Existential Relations in hogy ‘that-sentences,’ in Ferenc Kiefer (ed.), Hungarian Linguistics John Benjamins, Amsterdam, pp. 111–147.
Pesetsky, David: 1987, ‘Wh-In-Situ: Movement and Unselective Binding,’ in Eric, Reuland and Alice ter Meulen (eds.), The Representation of (In)definiteness, MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, pp. 98–130.
Philip, William and Jill de Villiers: 1992, ‘Monotonicity and the Acquisition of Weak Islands,’ presented at the Stanford Conference on Child Language, Stanford University, May 1992.
Progovac, Ljiljana: 1988, A Binding Approach to Polarity Sensitivity, Ph.D. dissertation, University of Southern California.
Rizzi, Luigi: 1990, Relativized Minimality, MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Rizzi, Luigi: 1992, ‘Argument/Adjunct (A)symmetries,’ to appear in Proceedings of NELS 21.
Sántha, Miklós: 1980, ‘Some Problems of the Semantic Treatment of that-clauses in Montague Grammar,’ Computational Linguistics and Computer Languages 14, 67–79.
Scha, Remko: 1981, ‘Distributive, Collective, and Cumulative Quantification,’ in Jeroen, Groenendijk, Theo Janssen, and Martin Stokhof (eds.), Formal Methods in the Study of Language, Mathematisch Centrum, Amsterdam, pp. 483–512.
Schein, Barry: 1992, Plurals and Events, MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts (in press).
Sher, Gila: 1991, The Bounds of Logic: A Generalized Viewpoint, MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Steedman, Mark: 1987, ‘Combinatory Grammar and parasitic Gaps,’ Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 5, 403–440.
de Swart, Henriëtte: 1992, ‘Intervention Effects, Monotonicity and Scope,’ in Chris Barker and David Dowty (eds.), SALT II: Proceedings of the Second Conference on Semantics and Linguistic Theory (OSU WPL 40), The Ohio State University, Columbus, pp. 387–406.
Szabolcsi, Anna: 1983, ‘Focussing Properties, or The Trap of First Order,’ Theoretical Linguistics 10, 125–145.
Szabolcsi, Anna: 1986, ‘From the Definiteness Effect to Lexical Integrity,’ in Werner, Abraham and Sjaak de Meij (eds.), Topic, Focus and Configurationality, John Benjamins, Amsterdam, pp. 321–348.
Szabolcsi, Anna: 1991, ‘Islands, Monotonicity, Composition, and Heads,’ GLOW Newsletter 26, 58–59.
Szabolcsi, Anna: 1992a, ‘Combinatory Grammar and Projection from the Lexicon,’ in Ivan, Sag and Anna Szabolcsi (eds.), Lexical Matters, CSLI, Stanford, pp. 241–268.
Szabolcsi, Anna: 1992b, ‘Weak Islands, Individuals, and Scope,’ in Chris Barker and David Dowty (eds.), SALT II: Proceedings of the Second Conference on Semantics and Linguistic Theory (OSU WPL 40), The Ohio State University, Columbus, pp. 407–438.
Szabolcsi, Anna and Frans Zwarts: 1990, ‘Semantic Properties of Composed Functions and the Distribution of Wh-Phrases,’ in Martin Stokhof and Leen Torenvliet (eds.), Proceedings of the Seventh Amsterdam Colloquium, Institute for Language, Logic, and Information, Amsterdam, pp. 529–555.
Szabolcsi, Anna and Frans Zwarts: 1991, Unbounded Dependencies and Algebraic Semantics, lecture notes, Third European Summer School in Language, Logic and Information, Saarbrücken.
Szabolcsi, Anna and Frans Zwarts: 1992, ‘Weak Islands and Scope,’ ms., UCLA and Rijksuniversiteit Groningen.
Westerståhl, Dag: 1985, ‘Logical Constants in Quantifier Languages,’ Linguistics and Philosophy 8, 387–413.
Zimmermann, Ede: 1991, ‘Scopeless Quantifiers and Operators,’ in Jaap van der Does and Jan van Eijck (eds.), Generalized Quantifier Theory and Applications, Dutch Network for Language, Logic and Information, Amsterdam, pp. 207–223.
Zwarts, Frans: 1986, Categoriale Grammatika en Algebraïsche Semantiek, Ph.D. dissertation, Rijksuniversiteit Groningen.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
Parts of this paper appeared in Szabolcsi (1992b). We have had extremely helpful discussions with many colleagues, at UCLA and elsewhere, over the past two years. We wish to thank them all, especially F. Beghelli, D. Ben-Shalom, C. Dobrovie-Sorin, I. Heim, J. Higginbotham, J. Hoeksema, E. Engdahl, M. Krifka, L. Moritz, D. Oehrle, B. Partee, D. Pesetsky, B. Schein, D. Sportiche, E. Stabler, T. Stowell, and H. de Swart, and two anonymous NALS reviewers of an earlier version of this paper entitled ‘Weak Islands and Algebraic Semantics’.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Szabolcsi, A., Zwarts, F. Weak islands and an algebraic semantics for scope taking. Nat Lang Seman 1, 235–284 (1993). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00263545
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00263545