Abstract
The traditional assembly system consists of a series of balanced workstations operating at the same rate with fixed cycle times. Recent advances in technology allow more flexible assembly systems, in which workstations operate independently and cycle times vary from job to job.
This article develops an analytical model for comparing the throughputs (jobs per hour) of assembly systems with fixed and variable cycle times. The throughputs are compared on a common basis by requiring that both systems allow sufficient processing time to ensure product quality and that they have the same total times in system per job.
Results indicate that an assembly system with variable cycle times can operate at a significantly higher throughput than one with fixed cycle times, provided there is sufficient buffer storage space between workstations to accommodate queueing. This benefit must be weighed against possible increased capital investment and practical considerations associated with system control.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
AndersonD.R., and MoodieC.L., “Optimal Buffer Storage Capacity in Production Line Systems,” International Journal of Production Research 7(3), pp. 233–240 (1969).
AndreasenM.; KahlerS.; and LundT.; Design for Assembly, IFS (Publications) Ltd., Bedford, U.K., and Springer-Verlag, New York (1983).
BasuR.N., “The Interstage Buffer Storage Capacity of Non-Powered Assembly Lines: A Simple Mathematical Approach,” International Journal of Production Research 15(4), pp. 365–382 (1977).
BaybarsI., “A Survey of Exact Algorithms for the Simple Assembly Line Balancing Problem,” Management Science 32(8), pp. 909–932 (1986).
BlumenfeldD.E., “Performance Characteristics of Assembly Systems with Fixed and Variable Processing Times,” Research Publication GMR-5912, General Motors Research Laboratories, Warren, Michigan (1987).
BoothroydG., “Economics of Assembly Systems,” Journal of Manufacturing Systems 1(1), pp. 111–125 (1982).
BoothroydG., and DewhurstP., Design for Assembly, Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, Massachusetts (1983).
BoothroydG.; PoliC.; and MurchL.E.; Automatic Assembly. Marcel Dekker, Inc., New York (1982).
BurnsL.D., and DaganzoC.F., “Assembly Line Job Sequencing Principles,” International Journal of Production Research 25(1), pp. 71–99 (1987).
BuzacottJ.A., “Automatic Transfer Lines with Buffer Stocks,” International Journal of Production Research 5(3), pp. 183–200 (1967).
Buzacott, J.A., Notes on “Flow Lines,” Private communication (1988a).
BuzacottJ.A., “Abandoning the Moving Assembly Line: Models of Human Operators and Job Sequencing,” WATMIMS Research Group Working Paper 88–02, Department of Management Sciences, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario (1988b).
BuzacottJ.A., and YaoD.D., “Flexible Manufacturing Systems: A Review of Analytical Models,” Management Science 32(7), pp. 890–905 (1986).
Cardan, J., “De Cubo et Rebus Aequalibus Numero,” Ars Magna, XI, Nuremberg (1545).
ChowW., “Buffer Capacity Analysis for Sequential Production Lines with Variable Process Times,” International Journal of Production Research 25(8), pp. 1183–1196 (1987).
ConwayR.; MaxwellW.; McClainJ.O.; and ThomasL.J., “The Role of Work-in-Process Inventory in Serial Production Lines,” Operations Research 36(2), pp. 229–241 (1988).
CooperR.B., Introduction to Queueing Theory, Macmillan Company, New York (1972).
CoxD.R., and SmithW.L., Queues, Methuen, London (1961).
DudleyN.A., “Work-Time Distributions,” International Journal of Production Research 2, pp. 137–144 (1963).
Freeman, D.R., “A General Line Balancing Model,” Proceedings of the 19th Annual Conference, AIIE, Tampa, Florida, pp. 230–235 (1968).
GershwinS.B., “An Efficient Decomposition Method for the Approximate Evaluation of Tandem Queues with Finite Storage Space and Blocking,” Operations Research 35(3), pp. 291–305 (1987).
HillierF.S., and BolingR.W., “The Effect of Some Design Factors on the Efficiency of Production Lines with Variable Operation Times,” Journal of Industrial Engineering 17(12), pp. 651–658 (1966).
IgnallE.J., “A Review of Assembly Line Balancing,” Journal of Industrial Engineering 16(4), pp. 244–254 (1965).
JonejaD., and MaxwellW.L., “Buffer Placement in Sequential Production Lines: Considerations of Processing Time Variability,” Technical Report No. 700, School of Operations Research and Industrial Engineering, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York (1986).
Kamath, M.; Suri, R.J. and Sanders, J.L., “Analytical Performance Models for Closed-Loop Flexible Assembly Systems,” International Journal of Flexible Manufacturing Systems 1(1) (1988).
KendallD.G., “Some Problems in the Theory of Queues,” Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B 13, pp. 151–185 (1951).
KimuraT., “A Two-Moment Approximation for the Mean Watting Time in the GI/G/s Queue,” Management Science 32(6), pp. 751–763 (1986).
KnottA.D., “The Inefficiency of a Series of Work Stations: A Simple Formula,” International Journal of Production Research 8(2), pp. 109–119 (1970).
KnottK., and SuryR.J., “A Study of Work-Time Distributions on Unpaced Tasks,” IIE Transactions 19(1), pp. 50–55 (1987).
Kraemer, W., and Langenbach-Belz, M., “Approximate Formulae for the Delay in the Queueing System GI/G/l,” Proceedings of the 8th International Teletraffic Congress, Melbourne, Australia, no. 235, pp. 1–8 (1976). (Concise version “Approximate Formulae for General Single Server Systems with Single and Batch Arrivals,” published in Angewandte Informatik pp. 396–402 (1978)).
LittleJ.D.C., “A Proof for the Queueing Formula: L=λW,” Operations Research 9(3), pp. 383–387 1961.
MarshallK.T., “Some Inequalities in Queueing,” Operations Research 16(3), pp. 651–668 (1968).
MoodieC.L. A Heuristic Method of Assembly Line Balancing for Assumptions of Constant or Variable Work Element Times, Ph.D. Thesis, Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana (1964).
Moodie, C.L., and Young, H.H., “A Heuristic Method of Assembly Line Balancing for Assumptions of Constant or Variable Work Element Times,” Journal of Industrial Engineering 16(1) (1965)
MuthE.J., “The Production Rate of a Series of Work Stations with Variable Service Times, International Journal of Production Research 11(2), pp. 155–169 (1973).
PollockS.M.; BirgeJ.R.; and AldenJ.M., “Approximation Analysis for Open Tandem Queues with Blocking: Exponential and General Service Time Distributions,” Technical Report 85–30, Department of Industrial and Operations Engineering, The University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan (1985).
SakesegawaH., “An Approximation Formula 222–1,” Annals of the Institute of Statistical Mathematics, part A, 29 pp. 67–75 (1977).
ShanthikumarJ.G., and BuzacottJ.A., “On the Approximations to the Single Server Queue,” International Journal of Production Research 18(6), pp. 761–773 (1980).
SilvermanF.N., and CarterJ.C., “A Cost-Based Methodology for Stochastic Line Balancing with Intermittent Line Stoppages,” Management Science 32(4), pp. 455–463 (1986).
SmithD.E., A Source Book in Mathematics, McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc., New York (1929).
SteckeK.E., “Formulation and Solution of Nonlinear Integer Production Planning Problems for Flexible Manufacturing Systems,” Management Science 29(3), pp. 273–288 (1983).
SteckeK.E. “Design, Planning, Scheduling, and Control Problems of Flexible Manufacturing Systems,” in K.E.Stecke and R.Suri (eds.), Flexible Manufacturing Systems: Operations Research Models and Applications, J.C. Baltzer AG, Scientific Publishing Company, Basel, Switzerland (1985).
SuriR. “An Overview of Evaluative Models for Flexible Manufacturing Systems,” in K.E.Stecke and R.Suri (eds.), Flexible Manufacturing Systems: Operations Research Models and Applications, J.C. Baltzer AG, Scientific Publishing Company, Basel, Switzerland (1985).
UdomkesmaleeN., “Work-in-Process Inventory for Assembly Systems with Variable Processing Times,” Research Publication GMR-5981, General Motors Research Laboratories, Warren, Michigan (1987).
UdomkesmaleeN., and DaganzoC.F., “Impact of Parallel Processing on Job Sequences in Flexible Assembly Systems,” International Journal of Production Research 27(1), pp. 73–89 (1989).
WhitneyC.K., and SuriR.J., “Decision Aids for FMS Part and Machine Selection,” in K.E.Stecke and R.Suri (eds.), Flexible Manufacturing Systems: Operations Research Models and Applications, J.C. Baltzer AG. Scientific Publishing Company, Basel, Switzerland (1985).
WhittW., “The Queueing Network Analyzer,” Bell System Technical Journal 62(9), pp. 2779–2815 (1983).
WhittW., “The Best Order for Queues in Series,” Management Science 31(4), pp. 475–487 (1985).
YuP.S., “On Accuracy Improvement and Applicability Conditions of Diffusion Approximation with Applications to Modeling of Computer Systems,” Technical Report No. TR-129, Digital Systems Laboratory, Departments of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, Stanford University, Stanford, California (1977).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Blumenfeld, D.E. Performance comparison of assembly systems with fixed and flexible cycle times. Int J Flex Manuf Syst 1, 207–222 (1989). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00235265
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00235265