Abstract
The traditional wisdom that there are increasing returns to scale among bus transit systems has been shaken with recent research findings. The implication from the literature is that unless many transit systems restructure along new organizational lines the financial and service provision difficulties will continue. Very few public transit systems have attempted to strategically manage change and “turnaround” organizationally.
The objectives of this research were to identify the salient factors in organizational turnarounds and to determine whether these factors were evident within transit organizations that have attempted to manage change strategically. The author reviewed the corporate turnaround literature and conducted four case studies of strategic planning/management within the transit industry.
All four cases exhibited organizational declines or perceived declines as imminent. They initiated turnarounds through reorganizations and efforts at strategic management. The reorganizations that occurred at all four cases were relatively minor, involving some changes in function. Only minor changes in management occurred and commitment to strategic management varied. Strategic objectives were not quantifiable. All of the cases could have improved their communication below the middle-management levels. The measures of performance in general did not relate a specific strategy and program to a particular turnaround effect. Through management commitment and some minor organizational restructuring two cases achieved some degree of turnaround. Total commitment to strategic management, organizational change, adequate communication, and accurate performance measures are keys to definitive turnarounds.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Berechman, J & Giuliano, G (1985) Economies of scale in bus transit: a review of concepts and evidence. Transportation 12: 313–332.
Downs, C (1988) Private and public local bus services compared: the case of New York City. Transportation Quarterly 4: 553–570.
Farkas, Z & Ayele, M (1988) A Guide to Strategic Planning for Transit Properties. Washington, DC: Urban Mass Transportation Administration.
Gellert W, Evertett C & Kirby R (1987) Strategic Management for Transit Agencies in a More Competitive Environment. Washington, DC: The Urban Institute.
Goodman S (1982) How to Manage a Turnaround. New York: The Free Press.
Guy M (1989) From Organizational Decline to Organizational Renewal. New York: Quorum Books.
Harrigan, K (1988) Managing Maturing Businesses. Lexington: Lexington Books.
Heany D (1985) Business in profit trouble. Journal of Business Strategy 2: 4–12.
Hofer C (1980) Turnaround strategies. Journal of Business Strategy 2: 19–31.
Keough M (1987) Scale economies among United States bus transit systems. Journal of the Transportation Research Forum 1: 58–64.
Lorange P & Nelson R (1987) How to recognize and avoid organizational decline. Sloane Management Review 1: 41–48.
Morlock E & Viton P (1985) Recent experience with successful private transit in large US cities. In: Lave, C (Ed) Urban Transit: The Private Challenge to Public Transportation (pp 121–149). Pacific Institute for Public Policy Research, San Francisco.
Pucher J (1988) Urban public transport subsidies in Western Europe and North America. Transportation Quarterly 3: 377–402.
Sloma R (1985) The Turnaround Manager's Handbook. New York: The Free Press.
The Urban Institute (1987) The Nation's Public Works: Report on Mass Transit. Washington. DC: National Council on Public Works Improvement.
Urban Mass Transportation Administration (1987) The Status of the Nation's Local Mass Transportation: Performance and Conditions. Washington, DC: United States Department of Transportation.
Whitney J (1987) Turnaround management everyday. Harvard Business Review 5: 49–55.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Farkas, Z.A. Strategic management of organizational turnarounds in the transit industry. Transportation 18, 223–238 (1991). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00172937
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00172937