Temporal trends among childhood brain tumor biopsies

Abstract

We sought temporal trends in the demographic, clinical, histologic feature, diagnostic class, and quality of life data over the interval 1930–1979 in the Childhood Brain Tumor Consortium database. The proportion of children younger than eight years old declined from 72% to 55% and the proportion of those older than ten more than doubled from 12% to 27%. The relative frequency of tumors in the supratentorial compartment increased significantly, while infratentorial tumors decreased. We found significant declines in supratentorial ependymomas and pilocytic astrocytomas. Similarly, some infratentorial tumors, especially ependymomas, decreased and brain stem tumors increased. Infratentorial medulloblastoma (primitive neuroectodermal tumor) increased significantly. Some individual histologic features which are markers of anaplasia increased in frequency in both supratentorial and infratentorial tumors. There was a significant increase in biopsies that contained nonneoplastic neural tissue in addition to tumor for both compartments and among supratentorial tumors there was a marked increase in the proportion of cases containing an indistinct neural tissue boundary. The probability of postoperative death declined, but the probability of survival five or ten years after surgery did not improve significantly for children who had tumors in either compartment. Among children who survived five years after the initial craniotomy, the proportion who had significant long term deficits increased. Most of this increase occurred in the last decade (1970–79). In this decade, the proportion of children for whom no deficits were reported five years following operation was 4% if they had a supratentorial tumor and 27% if they had an infratentorial tumor. The proportions of children alive five years following first surgery who had arachnoidal metastases increased significantly for infratentorial tumors.