Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry

, Volume 1, Issue 1, pp 9–23 | Cite as

Disease and illness Distinctions between professional and popular ideas of sickness

  • Leon Eisenberg
Article

Abstract

The dysfunctional consequences of the Cartesian dichotomy have been enhanced by the power of biomedical technology. Technical virtuosity reifies the mechanical model and widens the gap between what patients seek and doctors provide.

Patients suffer “illnesses”; doctors diagnose and treat “diseases”. Illnesses are experiences of discontinuities in states of being and perceived role performances. Diseases, in the scientific paradigm of modern medicine, are abnormalities in the function and/or structure of body organs and systems. Traditional healers also redefine illness as disease: because they share symbols and metaphors consonant with lay beliefs, their healing rituals are more responsive to the psychosocial context of illness.

Psychiatric disorders offer an illuminating perspective on the basic medical dilemma. The paradigms for psychiatric practice include multiple and ostensibly contradictory models: organic, psychodynamic, behavioural and social. This melange of concepts stems from the fact that the fundamental manifestations of psychosis are disordered behaviours. The psychotic patient remains a person; his self-concept and relationships with others are central to the therapeutic encounter, whatever pharmacological adjuncts are employed.

The same truths hold for all patients. The social matrix determines when and how the patient seeks what kind of help, his “compliance” with the recommended regimen and, to a significant extent, the functional outcome. When physicians dismiss illness because ascertainable “disease” is absent, they fail to meet their socially assigned responsibility. It is essential to reintegrate “scientific” and “social” concepts of disease and illness as a basis for a functional system of medical research and care.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Baker, S. L. 1975 Military Psychiatry. In Comprehensive Textbook of Psychiatry, II., A. M. Freedman, H. I. Kaplan and B. J. Sadock, eds. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins; pp. 2355–2367.Google Scholar
  2. Beecher, H. K. 1956 Relationship of Significance of Wound to the Pain Experienced. Journal of the American Medical Association 161: 1609–1613.Google Scholar
  3. Burge, P. S. et al. 1975 Quality and Quantity of Survival in Acute Myeloid Leukemia. Lancet 2: 621–624.Google Scholar
  4. Calin, A. and J. F. Fries 1975 Striking Prevalence of Ankylosing Spondylitis in ‘Healthy’ W-27 Positive Males and Females. New England Journal of Medicine 293: 835–839.Google Scholar
  5. Chodoff, P. 1954 A Reexamination of Some Aspects of Conversion Hysteria. Psychiatry 17: 75–81.Google Scholar
  6. Descartes, R. 1951 The Passions of the Soul. In Philosophical Works of Descartes, Vol. 1. E. S. Haldane and G. R. T. Ross, trans. New York: Dover (original date of publication 1649).Google Scholar
  7. Eisenberg, L. 1973 The Future of Psychiatry. Lancet 2: 1371–1375.Google Scholar
  8. Eisenberg, L. 1975 The Ethics of Intervention: Acting Amidst Ambiguity. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines 16: 93–104.Google Scholar
  9. Eisenberg, L. 1977 The Search for Care Daedalus 106: 235–246.Google Scholar
  10. Engel, G. L. 1976 The Need for a New Medical Model: A Challenge for Medicine and Psychiatry. Unpublished Manuscript.Google Scholar
  11. Engelhardt, H. T. 1974 Explanatory Models in Medicine. Texas Reports on Biology and Medicine 32: 225–239.Google Scholar
  12. Fabrega, H. 1972 Concepts of Disease: Logical Features and Social Implications. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 15: 583–616.Google Scholar
  13. Firman, G. J. and M. S. Goldstein 1975 The Future of Chiropractic: A Psychosocial View. New England Journal of Medicine 293: 639–642.Google Scholar
  14. Flexner, A. 1910 Medical Education in the United States and Canada. New York: The Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Education, Bulletin No. 4.Google Scholar
  15. Fox, R. C. 1977 The Medicalization and Demedicalization of American Society. Daedalus.106: 9–22Google Scholar
  16. Gruenberg, E. 1967 The Social Breakdown Syndrome: Some Origins. American Journal of Psychiatry 123: 1481–1489.Google Scholar
  17. Guillain, G. 1959 J.-M. Charcot: His Life -His Work, P. Bailey, trans. New York: Hoeber.Google Scholar
  18. Haggerty, R. J., K. J. Roghman and I. B. Pless 1975 Child Health and the Community. New York: Wiley.Google Scholar
  19. Hippocrates 1886 The Genuine Works, Vol. 2 F. Adams, trans. New York: William Wood; p. 344.Google Scholar
  20. Illich, I. 1975 Medical Nemesis: The Expropriation of Health. London: Calder and Boyars.Google Scholar
  21. Kane, R. L. et al. 1974 Manipulating the Patient: A Comparison of the Effectiveness of Physician and Chiropractic Care. Lancet 1: 1333–1336.Google Scholar
  22. Kleinman, A. M. 1974 The Cognitive Structure of Traditional Medical Systems. Ethnomedicine 3: 27–45.Google Scholar
  23. Kleinman, A. 1975 Explanatory Models in Health Care Relationships. In Proceedings of the 1974 International Health Conference on Health of the Family. Washington, D.C.: National Council for International Health; pp. 159–172.Google Scholar
  24. Lazare, A. 1973 Hidden Conceptual Models in Clinical Psychiatry. New England Journal of Medicine 288: 345–351.Google Scholar
  25. Leslie, C., ed. 1976 Asian Medical Systems. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
  26. Luborsky, L. et al. 1975 Comparative Studies of Psychotherapies: Is It True That ‘Everyone Has Won and All Must Have Prizes’? Archives of General Psychiatry 32: 995–1008.Google Scholar
  27. Medical Department, U.S. Army 1974 Neuropsychiatry in World War II, Vol. 2. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.Google Scholar
  28. Miller, N. E. 1969 Learning of Visceral and Glandular Responses. Science 163: 434–445.Google Scholar
  29. Munthe, A. 1930 The Story of San Michele. New York: Dutton.Google Scholar
  30. Polanyi, M. and H. Prosch 1975 Meaning. Chicago: University of Chicago Press; pp. 22–45.Google Scholar
  31. Sirois, F. 1973 Les Épidémies d' Hystérie: Revue de la Littérature. L'Union Médicale du Canada 102: 1906–1915.Google Scholar
  32. Smith, H. C. T. and E. J. Eastham 1973 Outbreak of Abdominal Pain. Lancet 2: 956–958.Google Scholar
  33. Solecki, R. S. 1975 Shanidar IV, A Neanderthal Flower Burial in Northern Iraq. Science 190: 880–881.Google Scholar
  34. Stoeckle, J. et al. 1964 The Quantity and Significance of Psychological Distress in Medical Patients. Journal of Chronic Diseases 17: 959–970.Google Scholar
  35. Szasz, T. 1964 The Myth of Mental Illness. New York: Hoeber/Harper and Row.Google Scholar
  36. Veith, I. 1965 Hysteria: The History of a Disease. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  37. Virchow, R. 1958 Diseas1e, Life and Man. Stanford: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
  38. Weissman, M. M. et al. 1974 Treatment Effects on the Social Adjustment of Depressed Out-Patients. Archives of General Psychiatry 30: 771–778.Google Scholar
  39. Zola, I. K. 1966 Culture and Symptoms: An Analysis of Patients' Presenting Complaints. American Sociological Review 31: 615–630.Google Scholar
  40. Zola, I. K. 1972 Medicine as an Institution of Social Control. Sociological Review 20: 487–504.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© D. Reidel Publishing Company 1977

Authors and Affiliations

  • Leon Eisenberg

There are no affiliations available

Personalised recommendations