Abstract
Standard economic theory predicts that the forced tying of an insurance policy to the purchase of a risky product cannot be welfare enhancing. At best, such insurance is redundant due to cheaper methods of insuring against loss, and, at worst, such coverage is not demanded at all. Exploiting the change in the liability environment which occurred in the vaccine market in the early 1980s, this article seeks to identify the value that consumers place on the insurance component of producer liability. The principal finding is that the demand for immunization is not increased, and may have been reduced, by liability. This implies that consumers place no value on the insurance which they are forced to buy under this regime, leaving them worse off than they would have been without producer liability for vaccine injuries. The best estimate is that by 1985, the change in liability environment had reduced the number of children properly immunized with the DPT and polio vaccines by approximately 1 million.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Calfee, John E., and Paul, H., Rubin. (1992). “Some Implications of Damage Payments for Nonpecuniary Losses,” Journal of Legal Studies 21 (June, 371–411.
Cody, C.L., L.J., Baraff, J.D., Cherry, S.M., Marcy, C.R., Manclark. (1981). “Nature and Rates of Adverse Reactions Associated with DTP and DT Immunizations in Infants and Children,” Pediatrics 68, 650–660.
Cook P.J., and D.A. Graham. “The Demand for Insurance and Protection: The Case of Irreplaceable Commodities,” Quartly Journal of Economics 91, 143–56.
David, A.B. (1986). “DPT: Drug Manufacturers' Liability in Vaccine Related Injuries,” Journal of Products Liability 9, 361–405.
Epstein, R.A. (1980). Modern Products Liability Law. Westport, CT: Quorum Books. Epstein, R.A. (1985). “Products Liability as an Insurance Market,” Journal of Legal Studies 14, 645–670.
Frech, H.E.III. (1994). “State Dependent Utility and the Tort System as Insurance: Strict Liability versus Negligence,” International Review of Law and Economics 14, 261–271.
Friedman, David. (1982). “What is ‘Fair Compensation’ for Death or Injury,” International Review of Law and Economics 2, 81–93.
Gaebler John W. Martin B. Kleiman, Morris L. French, Gordon Chastain, Charles Barrett, and Charles Griffin. “Neurologic Complications in Oral Polio Vaccine Recipients,” Journal of Pediatrics. 108, 878–881.
Garber, Steven. (1993). Products Liability and the Economics of Pharmaceuticals and Medical Devices. Santa Monica, CA: The Rand Corporation.
Health Insurance Institute. (Various issues). Source of Health Insurance Data. Washington, D.C.
Hearst Corporation. (Various issues). American Druggist Blue Book. New York.
Hinman, Alan R. (1986). “DTP Vaccine Litigation,” American Journal of Diseases of Children 140 528–530.
Hinman, Alan R. (1988). “DTP Vaccine Litigation Updata,” American Journal of Diseases of Children 142, 1275–1276.
Hinman, Alan R. (1991). “What Will it Take to Fully Protect All American Children With Vaccines?” American Journal of Diseases of Children 145, 559–562.
Kakalik, James S., and Nicholas M., Pace. (1986). Costs and Compensation Paid in Tort Litigation. Santa Monica, CA: The Rand Corporation.
Kitch, Edmund W. (1958). “Vaccines and Product Liability: A Case of Contagious Litigation,” Regulation (May/June), 11–18.
Landes, W. M., and R. A., Posner. (1984). “Tort Law as a Regulatory Regime for Catastrophic Personal Injuries,” Journal of Legal Studies 13, 417–434.
Landes, W. M., and R. A., Posner. The Economic Structure of Tort Law. (1987). Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Manning, Richard L. (1994). “Changing Rules in Tort Law and the Market for Childhood Vaccines,” Journal of Law and Economics. 37 (April), 247–276.
Medical Economics Co. (Various issues). Drug Topics Redbook. Oradell, NJ.
Miller, D. L., R., Alderslade, and E. M., Ross. (1982). “Whooping Cough and Whooping Cough Vaccine: The Risks and Benefits Debate,” Epidemiologic Reviews 4, 1–24.
Moore, M., P., Katana, J. E., Kaplan, L. B., Schonberger, and M. H., Hatch. (1982). “Poliomyelitis in the United States, 1969–1981,” Journal of Infectious Diseases 146, 558–563.
Posner, R. A. (1986). Economic Analysis of Law, 3d ed. Boston: Little Brown and Company.
Rea, Samuel A. (1982). “Nonpecuniary Loss and Breach of Contract,” Journal of Legal Studies 11, 35–53.
Rubin, Paul H. (1993). Tort Reform by Contract. Washington, D.C.: American Enterprise Institute.
Rubin, Paul H. (1993). Tort Reform by Contract. Washington, D.C.: American Enterprise Institute.
Schlesinger, H. (1984). “Optimal Insurance for Irreplaceable Commodities,” Journal of Risk and Insurance 51, 131–137.
Shavell, S. (1982). “On Liability and Insurance,” Bell Journal of Economics 13, 120–132.
Shioshansi, F. P. (1982). “Insurance for Irreplaceable Commodities,” Journal of Risk and Insurance 49, 309–320.
Spence, M. (1977). “Consumer Misperceptions, Product Failure and Producer Liability,” Review of Economic Studies 44, 561–572.
Stratton, K. R., C. J., Howe, and R. B., Johnston, eds. (1994). Adverse Events Associated with Childhood Vaccines: Evidence Bearing on Causality. Washington, D.C.: National Academy Press.
U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (Various issues). Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report. Atlanta, GA.
U.S. Congress Office of Technology Assessment. (1979). A Review of Selected Federal Vaccine and Immunization Policies. Washington, D.C., September.
U.S. Congress. (1980). Compensation for Vaccine Related Injuries. Washington, D.C., November.
U.S. Senate. (1985). National Childhood Vaccine Injury Compensation Act of 1985: Hearings Before the Senate Subcommittee on Labor and Human Resources, 99th Cong. 1st Sess., 245.
U.S. Department of Commerce. (Various issues). Statistical Abstract of the United States. Washington, D.C.
Viscusi, W. Kip. (1990). “Do Smokers Underestimate Risks?” Journal of Political Economy 98, 1253–1269.
Viscusi, W. Kip. Reforming Products Liability. (1991). Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Viscusi, W. Kip, and William N., Evans. (1990). “Utility Functions that Depend on Health Status: Estimates and Economic Implications,” American Economic Review 80, 353–374.
Viscusi, W. Kip, and Michael J., Moore. (1987). “Workers' Compensation: Wage Effects, Benefit Inadequacies, and the Value of Health Losses,” Review of Economics and Statistics 69(2), 249–261.
Wilson, Thomas, G., and James A. McKowen. (1988). “Federal Preemption in DPT Cases,” Trial (January), 59–64.
Zell, Elizabeth R. et al. (1994). “Low Vaccination Levels of US Preschool and School-age Children,” JAMA 271 (March 16) 833–839.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Manning, R.L. Is the insurance aspect of producer liability valued by consumers? Liability changes and childhood vaccine consumption. J Risk Uncertainty 13, 37–51 (1996). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00055337
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00055337