Effects of mineral turbidity on freshwater plankton communities: Three exploratory tank experiments of factorial design

Abstract

We conducted three exploratory experiments of factorial design on the effects of mineral turbidity in 18 large (7 000 1) fiberglass tanks containing plankton communities derived from Lake Texoma (Oklahoma-Texas), a large reservoir often subject to turbid inflows. Replicate plankton communities developed for 30–45 d in response to 4–9 treatments of planktivorous fish, dead fish, nutrient additions and artificial removal of zooplankton with plankton netting (or combinations of these manipulations). In one experiment we then added three concentrations of kaolin and in the other two experiments we added bentonite or powdered silica to the replicate tank communities. We measured the responses of the diverse plankton communities to the addition of mineral turbidity for an additional period of 30–45 d.

Effects of introduced minerals (quality or concentration effects) and food web treatments after mineral addition (fish, nutrients, etc.) were determined by analysis of covariance after observations were adjusted for the value of each response variable at the time of mineral addition. Covariance analysis resulted in a statistical model explaining > 80% of the variance for most response variables. The values of response variables at the time of mineral addition were often the most important source of variation, suggesting the importance of biotic community resiliency to the effects of mineral turbidity. There were few effects of mineral particles on physical or chemical (temperature, conductivity, oxygen, pH), nutrient (nitrate, phosphate, alkalinity) or biotic (algal or zooplankton populations) components of the tank communities. Mineral effects were found for several measures of water clarity (Secchi depth, turbidity, and the concentration of small sestonic particles).