Environmental Biology of Fishes

, Volume 17, Issue 2, pp 93–116 | Cite as

Comparative analysis of visual census techniques for highly mobile, reef-associated piscivores (Carangidae)

  • Ronald E. Thresher
  • John S. Gunn
Article

Synopsis

Visual census techniques applicable to coral reef-associated fishes are reviewed and the results of field tests using six (three transect-based and three point-based) to estimate the density of carangids at Carter Reef, Great Barrier Reef, are presented. Data are analyzed with respect to the effects of observers on fishes seen, observer biasses, precision of the estimates and, as far as possible, accuracy of the estimates. Transects generate estimates of population density and structure different from those of point-based estimates. Various point-based census methods, however, generate density estimates consistent with one another and are generally more precise than transect-based methods. The results of the field study obviously cannot be generalized to other quite different types of reef fishes. The problems we encountered and a review of the techniques used to census reef fishes visually in the past, however, suggest that: (1) interval counts, such as Rapid Visual Census techniques, are likely to be inaccurate and difficult to compare; (2) for species with high probabilities of detection, instantaneous area counts appear to be the most effective way to estimate densities, whereas cryptic species are best censused using instantaneous variable distance point counts, and (3) strip transects may often be less efficient than line transects, due to inconstant levels of subject detectability.

Keywords

Great Barrier Reef Observer bias Point counts Transects Fishes Coral reef 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References cited

  1. Alevizon, W.S. & M.G. Brooks. 1975. The comparative structure of two western Atlantic reef-fish assemblages. Bull. Mar. Sci. 25: 482–490.Google Scholar
  2. Amman, G.D. & P.H. Baldwin. 1960. A comparison of methods for censusing wookpeckers in spruce-fir forests of Colorado. Ecology 41: 699–706.Google Scholar
  3. Anderson, B.W. & R.D. Ohmart. 1981. Comparisons of avian census results using variable distance transect and variable circular plot techniques. pp. 186–192. In: C.J. Ralph & J.M. Scott (ed.) Estimating Numbers of Terrestrial Birds, Studies in Avaian Biology 6, Allen Press, Lawrence.Google Scholar
  4. Anderson, G.R.V., A.H. Ehrich, J.D. Roughgarden, B.C. Russell & F.H. Talbot. 1982. The community structure of coral reef fishes. Amer. Nat. 117: 476–495.Google Scholar
  5. Anonymous. 1979. Aerial surveys of fauna populations. Special Publ. No. 1, Australian Nat. Parks and Wildl. Serv., Canberra. 126 pp.Google Scholar
  6. Balph, M.H., L.C. Stoddart & D.F. Balph. 1977. A simple technique for analyzing bird transect counts. Auk 94: 606–607.Google Scholar
  7. Bardach, J.E. 1958. On the movements of certain Bermuda reef fishes. Ecology 39: 139–146.Google Scholar
  8. Blondel, J., C. Ferry & B. Frochot. 1981. Point counts with unlimited distance. pp. 414–420.In: C.J. Ralph & J.M. Scott.Google Scholar
  9. Blower, J.G., L.M. Cook & J.A. Bishop. 1981. Estimating the size of animal populations. George Allen & Unwin, London. 127 pp.Google Scholar
  10. Bohnsack, J.A. & S.P. Bannerot. 1982. A random point census technique for visually assessing coral reef fishes. pp. 5–7. In: The Visual Assessment of Fish Populations in the Southeastern United States, S. C. Sea Grant Tech. Rpt. 1.Google Scholar
  11. Brewer, R. 1972. An evaluation of winter bird-population studies. Wilson Bull. 47: 371–395.Google Scholar
  12. Brock, R.E. 1982. A critique of the visual census method for assesing coral reef fish populations. Bull. Mar. Sci. 32: 269–276.Google Scholar
  13. Brock, V.E. 1954. A preliminary report on a method of estimating reef fish populations. J. Wildl. Manage. 18: 297–308.Google Scholar
  14. Buckman, N.S. & J.C. Ogden. 1973. Territorial behavior of the striped parrotfishScarus croicensis Bloch (Scaridae). Ecology 54: 1377–1382.Google Scholar
  15. Burnham, K.P., D.R. Anderson & J.L. Laake, 1980. Estimation of density from line transect sampling of biological populations. Wildl. Monogr. 72. 202 pp.Google Scholar
  16. Burnham, K.P., D.R. Anderson & J.L. Laake. 1981. Line transect estimation of bird population density using a Fourier series. pp. 466–482. In: C.J. Ralph & J.M. Scott (ed.) Estimating Numbers of Terrestrial Birds, Studies in Avian Biology 6, Allen Press, Lawrence.Google Scholar
  17. Caughley, G. 1974. Bias in aerial survey. J. Wildl. Manage. 38: 921–933.Google Scholar
  18. Caughley, G. 1977. Analysis of vertebrate populations. Wiley, London. 234 pp.Google Scholar
  19. Caughley, G. 1979. Design for aerial censuses. pp. 15–23. In: Aerial surveys of faunal populations, Spec. Publ. 1, Australian Nat. Parks Wildl. Serv., Canberra. 126 pp.Google Scholar
  20. Caughley, G., R. Sinclair & D. Scott-Kemmis. 1976. Experiments in aerial survey. J. Wildl. Manage. 40: 290–300.Google Scholar
  21. Chave, E.H. & D.B. Eckert. 1974. Ecological aspects of the distributions of fishes at Fanning Island. Pac. Sci. 28: 297–317.Google Scholar
  22. Clarke, R.D. 1977. Habitat distribution and species diversity of chaetodontid and pomacentrid fishes near Bimini, Bahamas. Mar. Biol. 40: 277–287.Google Scholar
  23. Cochran, W.G. 1953. Sampling techniques. Wiley, New York. 330 pp.Google Scholar
  24. Cormack, R.M. 1973. Commonsense estimates from capture-recapture studies. pp. 225–234. In: M.S. Bartlett & R.W. Hiorns (ed.) The Mathematical Theory of the Dynamics of Biological Populations, Academic Press, New York.Google Scholar
  25. Cormack, R.M. 1979. Models for capture-recapture. pp. 217–255. In: R.M. Cormack, G.P. Patil & D.S. Robson (ed.) Sampling Biological Populations, Internat. Co-op. Publ. House, Fairland.Google Scholar
  26. Cormack, R.M., G.P. Patil & Robson (ed.). 1979. Sampling biological populations. Internat. Coop. Publ. House. Fairland. 392 pp.Google Scholar
  27. Dawson, D.G. 1981. Experimental design when counting birds. pp. 392–398. In: C.J. Ralph & J.M. Scott (ed.) Estimating Numbers of Terrestrial Birds, Studies in Avian Biology 6, Allen Press, Lawrence.Google Scholar
  28. De Martini, E.E. & D. Roberts. 1982. An empirical test of biases in the rapid visual technique for species-time censuses of reef fish assemblages. Mar. Biol. 70: 129–134.Google Scholar
  29. Eberhardt, L.L. 1978. Transect methods for population studies. J. Wildl. Manage. 38: 921–933.Google Scholar
  30. Ekman, J. 1981. Problems of unequal observability. pp. 230–234. In: C.J. Ralph & J.M. Scott (ed.) Estimating Numbers of Terrestrial Birds, Studies in Avian Biology 6, Allen Press, Lawrence.Google Scholar
  31. Emlen, J.T. 1971. Population densities of birds derived from transect counts. Auk 88: 323–342.Google Scholar
  32. Emlen, J.T. 1977. Estimating breeding season bird densities from transect counts. Auk 94: 455–468.Google Scholar
  33. Franzreb, K.E. 1981. The determination of avian densities using the variable-strip and fixed-width transect surveying methods. pp. 139–145. In: C.J. Ralph & J.M. Scott (ed.) Estimating Numbers of Terrestrial Birds, Studies in Avian Biology 6, Allen Press, Lawrence.Google Scholar
  34. Gates, C.E. 1969. Simulation study of estimators for the line transect sampling method. Biometrics 25: 317–328.Google Scholar
  35. Gates, C.E. 1979. Line transects and related issues. pp. 71–154. In: R.M. Cormack, G.P. Patil & D.S. Robson (ed.) Sampling Biological Populations, Internat. Co-op. Publ. House, Fairland.Google Scholar
  36. Gates, C.E. 1981. Optimizing sampling frequency and numbers of transects and stations. pp. 399–404. In: C.J. Ralph & J.M. Scott (ed.) Estimating Numbers of Terrestrial Birds, Studies in Avian Biology 6, Allen Press, Lawrence.Google Scholar
  37. Gilbert, P.F. & J.R. Grieb. 1957. Comparison of aerial and ground deer counts in Colorado. J. Wildl. Manage. 21: 33–37.Google Scholar
  38. Gladfelter, W.B. & W.S. Johnson. 1983. Feeding niche separation in a guild of tropical reef fishes (Holocentridae). Ecology 64: 552–563.Google Scholar
  39. Granholm, S.L. 1983. Bias in density estimates due to movement of birds. Condor 85: 243–248.Google Scholar
  40. Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority. 1978. Workshop on reef fish assessment and monitoring. G.B.R.M.P.A. Workshop Ser. Townsville, Aust. 66 pp.Google Scholar
  41. Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority. 1979. Workshop on coral trout assessment techniques. G.B.R.M.P.A. Workshop Ser. Townsville, Aust. 85 pp.Google Scholar
  42. Gronell, A.M. 1980. Space utilization by the cocoa damselfish,Eupomacentrus variables (Pisces: Pomacentridae). Bull. Mar. Sci. 30: 237–251.Google Scholar
  43. Gronell, A.M. 1984. Courtship, spawning and social organization of the pipefish,Coryhoichthys intestinalis (Pisces: Syngnathidae) with notes on two congeneric species. Z. Tierpsychol. 65: 1–24.Google Scholar
  44. Hall, G.A. 1964. Breeding bird censuses — why and how. Audubon Field Notes 18: 413–416.Google Scholar
  45. Heckel, D.G. & J. Roughgarden. 1979. A technique for estimating the size of lizard populations. Ecology 60: 966–975.Google Scholar
  46. Jones, R.S. & J.A. Chase. 1975. Community structure and distribution of fishes in an enclosed high island lagoon in Guam. Micronesica 11: 127–148.Google Scholar
  47. Jones, R.S. & M.J. Thompson. 1978. Comparison of Florida reef fish assemblages using a rapid visual technique. Bull. Mar. Sci. 28: 159–172.Google Scholar
  48. Keenleyside, M.H.A. 1972. The behavior ofAbudefduf zonatus (Pisces, Pomacentridae) at Heron Island, Great Barrier Reef. Anim. Behav. 20: 763–774.Google Scholar
  49. Kelker, G.H. 1946. Measurement and interpretation of forces that determine populations of managed deer herds. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor. 443 pp.Google Scholar
  50. Kendeigh, S.C. 1944. Measurement of bird populations. Ecol. Monogr. 14: 67–106.Google Scholar
  51. Kimmel, J.J. 1985. A new species-time method for visual assessment of fishes and its comparison with established methods. Env. Biol. Fish. 12: 23–32.Google Scholar
  52. Le Resche, R.E. & R.A. Rausch. 1974. Accuracy and precision of aerial moose censusing. J. Wildl. Manage. 38: 175–182.Google Scholar
  53. Luckhurst, B.E. & K. Luckhurst. 1978. Analysis of the influence of substrate variables on coral reef fish communities. Mar. Biol. 49: 317–323.Google Scholar
  54. Moyer, J.T. & A. Nakazono. 1978. Population structure, reproductive behavior and protogynous hermaphroditism in the angel fishCentropyge interruptus at Miyake-jima, Japan. Japan. J. Ichthyol. 25: 25–39.Google Scholar
  55. Nichols, J.D., B.R. Noon, S.L. Stokes & J.E. Hines. 1981. Remarks on the use of mark-recapture methodology in estimating avian population size. pp. 121–136. In: C.J. Ralph & J.M. Scott (ed.) Estimating Numbers of Terrestrial Birds, Studies in Avian Biology 6, Allen Press, Lawrence.Google Scholar
  56. Nilsson, S.G. 1974. Methods of estimating bird population densities during the winter. Ornis Scand. 5: 37–46.Google Scholar
  57. Nursall, J.R. 1977. Territoriality in redlip blennies (Ophioblenius atlanticus — Pisces: Blenniidae). J. Zool. (Lond.) 182: 205–223.Google Scholar
  58. Odum, H.T. & E.P. Odum. 1955. Trophic structure and productivity of a winward coral reef community on Eniwetok Atoll. Ecol. Monogr. 25: 291–320.Google Scholar
  59. Pollard, K.H. 1981. Capture-recapture models: a review of current methods, assumptions, and experimental design. pp. 426–435. In: C.J. Ralph & J.M. Scott (ed.) Estimating Numbers of Terrestrial Birds, Studies in Avian Biology 6, Allen Press, Lawrence.Google Scholar
  60. Popper, D. & L. Fishelson. 1973. Ecology and behavior ofAnthias squamipinnis (Peters, 1855) (Anthiidae, Teleostei) in the coral habitat of Eilat (Red Sea). J. Exp. Zool. 184: 409–424.Google Scholar
  61. Potts, G.W. 1980. The predatory behavior ofCaranx melampygus (Pisces) in the channel environment of Aldabra Atoll (Indian Ocean). J. Zool. (Lond.) 192: 323–350.Google Scholar
  62. Pyke, G. 1983. Analysis of an instantaneous method for heathland birds. Aust. Wildl. Res. 10: 521–526.Google Scholar
  63. Pyke, G.H., H.R. Pulliam & E.L. Charnov. 1977. Optimal foraging: a selective review of theory and tests. Q. Rev. Biol. 52: 137–154.Google Scholar
  64. Pyke, G.H. & H.F. Recher. 1984. Censusing Australian birds: a summary of procedures and a scheme for standardisation of data presentation and storage. pp. 55–63. In: S.J.J.F. Davies (ed.) Methods of Censusing Birds in Australia, Dept. cons. Environ., Perth.Google Scholar
  65. Ralp, C.J. & J.M. Scott (ed.) Estimating numbers of terrestrial birds, Studies in Avian Biology, 6, Allen Press, Lawrence. 630 pp.Google Scholar
  66. Ramsey, F.L. & J.M. Scott. 1979. Estimating population densities from variable circular plot surveys. pp. 155–181. In: R.M. Cormack, G.P. Patil & D.S. Robson (ed.) Sampling Biological Populations, Internat. Co-op. Publ. House, Fairland.Google Scholar
  67. Randall, J.E. 1961. Tagging reef fishes in the Virgin Islands. Proc. Gulf. Caribb. Fish. Inst. 14: 201–241.Google Scholar
  68. Reese, E.S. 1973. Duration of residence by coral reef fishes on ‘home’ reefs. Copeia 1973: 145–149.Google Scholar
  69. Reese, E.S. 1975. A comparative field study of the social behavior and related ecology of reef fishes of the family Chaetodontidae. Z. Tierpsychol. 37: 37–61.Google Scholar
  70. Reynolds, R.T., J.M. Scott & R.A. Nausbaum. 1980. A variable circular-plot method for estimating bird numbers. Condor 82: 309–313.Google Scholar
  71. Riper, C. van, III. 1981. Summarizing remarks: comparison of methods. pp. 217–218. In: C.J. Ralph & J.M. Scott (ed.) Estimating Numbers of Terrestrial Birds, Studies in Avian Biology 6, Allen Press, Lawrence.Google Scholar
  72. Risk, M.J. 1972. Fish diversity on a coral reef in the Virgin Islands. Atoll Res. Bull. 153: 1–6.Google Scholar
  73. Robertson, D.R. & B. Lassig. 1980. Spatial distribution patterns and coexistence of a group of territorial damselfishes from the Great Barrier Reef. Bull. Mar. Sci. 30: 187–203.Google Scholar
  74. Robinette, W.L., C.M. Loveless & D.A. Jones. 1974. Field tests of strip census methods. J. Wildl. Manage. 38: 81–96.Google Scholar
  75. Russell, B.C., F.H. Talbot, G.R.V. Anderson & B. Goldman. 1978. Collection and sampling of reef fishes. pp. 329–345. In: D.R. Stoddart & R.E. Johannes (ed.) Monographs on Oceanographic Methodology 5, Coral reefs: Research Methods, UNESCO, Norwich.Google Scholar
  76. Sale, P.F. 1974. Mechanisms of coexistence in a guild of territorial fishes at Heron Island. Proc. Second Internat. Coral Reef Symp. 1: 193–206.Google Scholar
  77. Sale, P.F. 1980. The ecology of fishes on coral reefs. Annu. Rev. Oceanogr. Mar. Biol. 18: 367–421.Google Scholar
  78. Sale, P.F. & W.A. Douglas. 1981. Precision and accuracy of visual census technique for fish assemblages on coral patch reefs. Env. Biol. Fish. 6: 333–339.Google Scholar
  79. Sale, P.F. & B.J. Sharp. 1983. Correction for bias in visual transect censuses of coral reef fishes. Coral Reefs 2: 37–42.Google Scholar
  80. Sanderson, S.L. & A.C. Solonsky. 1980. A comparison of two visual survey techniques for fish populations. Pac. Sci. 34: 237.Google Scholar
  81. Schweder, T. 1977. Point process models for line transect experiments. pp. 221–242. In: J.R. Barba, F. Brodeau, G. Romier & B. Van Cutsem (ed.) Recent Developments in Statistics, North Holland, New York.Google Scholar
  82. Seber, G.A. 1973. Estimation of animal abundance and related parameters. Griffin, London. 506.Google Scholar
  83. Seber, G.A. 1979. General mathematical principles and theory of fauna sampling. pp. 1–7.In: Aerial Surveys of Fauna Populations, Australian Nat. Parks Wildl. Serv., Spec. Publ. 1, Canberra.Google Scholar
  84. Shields, W.M. 1979. Avian census techniques: an analytical review. pp. 23–51. In: J.G. Dickson, R.N. Conner, R.R. Fleet, J.C. Kroll & J.A. Jackson (ed.) The Role of Insectivorous Birds in Forest Ecosystems, Academic Press, New York.Google Scholar
  85. Skirvin, A.A. 1981. Effect of time of day and time of season on the number of observations and density estimates of breeding birds. pp. 271–274. In: C.J. Ralph & J.M. Scott (ed.) Estimating Numbers of Terrestrial Birds, Studies in Avian Biology 6, Allen Press, Lawrence.Google Scholar
  86. Slobodkin, L. & L. Fishelson. 1974. The effects of the cleanerfish,Labroides dimidiatus, on the point diversity of fishes on the reef front of Eilat. Amer. Nat. 108: 369–376.Google Scholar
  87. Smith, C.L. 1973. Small rotenone stations: a tool for studying coral reef fish communities. Amer. Mus. Novitat. (2512): 1–21.Google Scholar
  88. Smith, C.L. & J.C. Tyler. 1972. Space resource sharing in a coral reef fish community. Nat. Hist. Mus. Los Angeles County, Sci. Bull. 14: 125–170.Google Scholar
  89. Smith, C.L. & J.C. Tyler. 1975. Succession and stability in fish communities of dome-shaped patch reefs in the West Indies. Amer. Mus. Novitat. (2572): 1–18.Google Scholar
  90. Stuart, A. 1962. Basic ideas of scientific sampling. Griffin, London. 99 pp.Google Scholar
  91. Talbot, F.H., B.C. Russell & G.R.V. Anderson. 1978. Coral reef fish communities: unstable, high-diversity systems. Ecol. Monogr. 48: 425–440.Google Scholar
  92. Thompson, M.J. & T.W. Schmidt. 1977. Validation of the species/time random count technique sampling fish assemblages at Dry Tortugas. Proc. Third Intern. Coral Reef Symp. 1: 283–288.Google Scholar
  93. Thresher, R.E. 1979. Social behavior and ecology of two sympatric wrasses (Labridae:Halichoeres spp.) off the coast of Florida. Mar. Biol. 53: 161–172.Google Scholar
  94. Thresher, R.E. 1983. Habitat effects on reproductive success in the coral reef fish,Acanthochromis polyacanthus (Pomacentridae). Ecology 64: 1184–1199.Google Scholar
  95. Thresher, R.E. & J.T. Moyer. 1983. Male success, courtship complexity and patterns of sexual selection in three congeneric species of sexually monochromatic and dichromatic damselfishes (Pisces: Pomacentridae). Anim. Behav. 31: 113–127.Google Scholar
  96. Tilghman, N.G. & D.H. Rusch. 1981. Comparison of line-transect methods for estimating breeding bird densities in deciduous woodlots. pp. 202–208. In: C.J. Ralph & J.M. Scott (ed.) Estimating Numbers of Terrestrial Birds, Studies in Avian Biology 6, Allen Press, Lawrence.Google Scholar
  97. Wiens, J.A. 1981. Scale problems in avian censusing. pp. 513–521. In: C.J. Ralph & J.M. Scott (ed.) Estimating Numbers of Terrestrial Birds, Studies in Avian Biology 6, Allen Press, Lawrence.Google Scholar
  98. Williams, A.B. 1936. The composition and dynamics of a beechmaple climax community. Ecol. Monogr. 6: 317–408.Google Scholar
  99. Williams, D.M. & A.I. Hatcher. 1983. Structure of fish communities on outer slopes of inshore, mid-shelf and outer shelf reefs of the Great Barrier Reef. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Set. 10: 239–250.Google Scholar
  100. Yapp, W.B. 1956. The theory of line transects. Bird Study 3: 93–104.Google Scholar
  101. Yates, F. 1949. Sampling methods for censuses and surveys. Griffin, London. 318 pp.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Dr W. Junk Publishers 1986

Authors and Affiliations

  • Ronald E. Thresher
    • 1
  • John S. Gunn
    • 1
  1. 1.CSIRO Marine LaboratoriesHobartAustralia

Personalised recommendations