Biology and Philosophy

, Volume 19, Issue 4, pp 609–631 | Cite as

Instinct in the '50s: the British reception of Konrad Lorenz's theory of instinctive behavior*

  • Paul E. Griffiths
Article

Abstract

At the beginning of the 1950s most students of animal behavior in Britain saw the instinct concept developed by Konrad Lorenz in the 1930s as the central theoretical construct of the new ethology. In the mid 1950s J.B.S. Haldane made substantial efforts to undermine Lorenz's status as the founder of the new discipline, challenging his priority on key ethological concepts. Haldane was also critical of Lorenz's sharp distinction between instinctive and learnt behavior. This was inconsistent with Haldane's account of the evolution of language, and, according to Haldane, inconsistent with elementary genetics. British attitudes to the instinct concept changed dramatically in the wake of Daniel S. Lehraman's 1953 critique of Lorenz, and by the 1960s Lorenz drew a clear distinction between his own views and those of the ‘English-speaking ethologists’. The inconsistencies between Lorenz's ideas and the trends in contemporary evolutionary genetics that are reflected in Haldane's critiques may help to explain why the Lorenzian instinct concept was unable to maintain itself in Britian.

Conrad Waddington Ethology Instinct J.B.S. Haldane Konrad Lorenz 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Baldwin J.M. 1896. A new factor in evolution. Am. Nat. 30 (June and July):441-451, 536-553.Google Scholar
  2. Barrington Daines. 1773. Experiments and observations on the singing of birds. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. 63:249-291.Google Scholar
  3. Beer C.G. 1975. Was professor Lehrman an ethologist? Anim. Behav. 23:957-964.Google Scholar
  4. Brigandt Ingo. 2003. Gestalt experiments and inductive observations:Konrad Lorenz 's early epistemological writings and the methods of classical ethology. Evol. Cogn. 9:157-170.Google Scholar
  5. Brigandt Ingo. 2003. The instinct concept of the early Konrad Lorenz. J.Hist. Biol. 99:88-99.Under consideration.Google Scholar
  6. Burkhardt Richard W.Jr. 1981. On the emergence of ethology as a scienti c discipline. Conspect. Hist. 1(7):62-81.Google Scholar
  7. Burkhardt Richard W.Jr. 1983. The development of an evolutionary ethology. In:Bendall D.S. (ed. ), Evolution:From Molecules to Men. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
  8. Corballis Michael C. 2002. From Hand to Mouth:The Origins of Language. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.Google Scholar
  9. Dewsbury D.A.(ed.) 1985. Studying Animal Behavior:Autobiographies of the Founders. Uni-versity of Chicago Press, Chicago. Original edition, Lewisburg, Bucknell University Press, 1985.Google Scholar
  10. Dobzhansky Theodosius and Bruce Wallace. 1953. The genetics of homeostasis in drosophila. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 39(3):162-171.Google Scholar
  11. Dunlap K. 1919. Are there any instincts? J. Abnorm. Psychol. 14:307-311.Google Scholar
  12. Durant John R. 1981. Innate character in animal and man:a perspective on the origins of ethology. In:Webster C.(ed.), Biology, Medicine and Society 1840-1940. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
  13. Durant John R. 1986. The making of ethology:the association for the study of animal behaviour,1936-1986. Anim. Behav. 34: 1601-616.Google Scholar
  14. Griffiths Paul E. 1995. The cronin controversy. Brit. J.Philos. Sci. 46:122-138.Google Scholar
  15. Griffiths Paul E. 2003. Beyond the Baldwin effect:James Mark Baldwin's 'social heredity ', epigenetic inheritance and niche-construction. In:Weber B.H. and Depew D.J.(eds), Evolution and Learning:The Baldwin Effect Reconsidered. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
  16. Haldane J.B.S. 1952. The origin of language. Rationalist Annual:38-45.Google Scholar
  17. Haldane J.B.S. 1954. Introducing Douglas Spalding. Brit. J.Anim. Behav. 2(1):1.Google Scholar
  18. Haldane J.B.S. 1956. The argument from animals to men:an examination of its validity for anthropology. J.R.Anthropol. Soc. Great Britain and Ireland 86(2):1-14.Google Scholar
  19. Haldane J.B.S. 1956. The sources of some ethological notions. Brit. J.Anim. Behav. 4(4):162-164.Google Scholar
  20. Haldane J.B.S. 1992 [ 1955 ]. Animal communication and the origin of human language. Curr. Sci. 63 (9-10):604-611.Google Scholar
  21. Haldane J.B.S.and Helen Spurway. 1954. A statistical analysis of communication in 'Apis Mel-lifera 'and a comparison with communication in other animals. Insect. Soc. 1(3):247-284.Google Scholar
  22. Hinde Robert A. 1991. Konrad Lorenz and Nikolaas Tinbergen.Google Scholar
  23. Hocking W.E. 1921. The dilemma in the conception of instinct as applied to human psychology. J. Abnorm. Soc. Psychol. 16(2-3):73-96.Google Scholar
  24. Huxley Julian. 1942. Evolution:The Modern Synthesis. Harper and Brothers, New York and London.Google Scholar
  25. Kalikow T.J. 1975. History of Konrad Lorenz 's ethological theory, 1927-1939. Stud. Hist. Philos. Sci. 6(4):331-341.Google Scholar
  26. Klopfer P. 1999. Politics and People in Ethology:Personal Reffections on the Study of Animal Behavior. Bucknell University Press, Lewisburg.Google Scholar
  27. Kuo Z.Y. 1921. Giving up instincts in psychology. J.Philos. 18:645-664.Google Scholar
  28. Kuo Z.Y. 1922. How are our instincts acquired? Psychol. Rev. 29:344-365.Google Scholar
  29. Kuo Z.Y. 1929. The net result of the anti-heredity movement in psychiatry. Psychol. Rev. 36:181-199.Google Scholar
  30. Lehrman Daniel S. 1953. Critique of Konrad Lorenz 's theory of instinctive behavior. Quart. Rev. Biol. 28(4): 337-363.Google Scholar
  31. Lehrman Daniel S. 1970. Semantic & conceptual issues in the nature-nurture problem. In:Lehrman D.S.(ed.), Development & Evolution of Behaviour. W.H.Freeman and Co., San Francisco.Google Scholar
  32. Lloyd Morgan C. 1896. On modi cation and variation. Science 4(20 November):733-740.Google Scholar
  33. Lorenz K. 1935. Der Kumpan in der Umwelt des Vogels. J.Ornithologie 83:137-213.Google Scholar
  34. Lorenz K. 1957 (1935). Companionship in bird life. In:Schiller C.H.(ed.), Instinctive Behavior: The development of a Modern Concept. International Universities Press, New York.Google Scholar
  35. Lorenz K. 1957 (1937). The nature of instinct. In:Schiller C.H.(ed.), Instinctive Behavior:The development of a Modern Concept. International Universities Press, New York.Google Scholar
  36. Lorenz K. 1965. Evolution & the Modi cation of Behaviour. US ed. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.Google Scholar
  37. Lorenz K. 1996. The Natural Science of the Human Species:An Introduction to Comparative Behavioral Research. The Russian Manuscript (1944-1948). Translated by R.D. Martin. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
  38. Lorenz Konrad. 1943. Die angeboren Formen möglicher Erfahrung. Zeitschrift für Tierpsychologie 5:235-409.Google Scholar
  39. Lorenz Konrad. 1950. The comparative method in studying innate behaviour patterns. Symposium of the Society of Experimental Biology (Physiol. Mech. Anim. Behav.) 4:221-268.Google Scholar
  40. Lorenz Konrad. 1955. Morphology and behavior patterns in closely allied species. In:Schaffner B. (ed.), Group Processes:Transactions of the First Conference, September 26-30, Ithaca, NY. Josiah Macy Foundation, New York.Google Scholar
  41. Marler Peter. 1952. Variation in the song of the chaffinch Fringilla coelebs. Ibis 94:458-72.Google Scholar
  42. McDougall William. 1913. The sources and direction of psychophysical energy. Am. J.Insanity 69: 861-872.Google Scholar
  43. McDougall William. 1922. The Use and Abuse of Instinct in Social Psychology. J.Abnorm. Psychol. Soc. Psychol. 16(5-6):285-333.Google Scholar
  44. McDougall William. 1923. Outline of Psychology. Charles Scribner 's Sons, New York.Google Scholar
  45. Richards R.J. 1974. The innate and the learned:the evolution of Konrad Lorenz 's theory of instinct. Philos. Soc. Sci. 4:111-133.Google Scholar
  46. Rosenblatt J.S. 1995. Daniel sanford lehrman. Biographical memoirs of the Members of the Na-tional Academy of Sciences 66:227-245.Google Scholar
  47. Schaffiner Kenneth F., Ullica Segestralle, Paul E. Griffiths and Steven Pinker. Liberals Ate My Genes Review symposium with author 's response on The Blank Slate by Steven Pinker.Metascience 13:28-58.Google Scholar
  48. Schmalhausen I.I. 1949. Factors of Evolution:The Theory of Stabilising Selection. Translated by I. Dordick. Blakeston, Philadelphia and Toronto.Google Scholar
  49. Simpson G.G. 1953. The Baldwin Effect. Evolution 7:110-117.Google Scholar
  50. Spalding Douglas. 1873. Instinct:with original observations on young animals. Macmillan 's Magazine 27:282-293.Google Scholar
  51. Spurway Helen. 1955. The Causes of domestication:an attempt to integrate some ideas of Konrad Lorenz with evolution theory. J.Genet. 53:325-362.Google Scholar
  52. Spurway Helen and Haldane J.B.S. 1953. The comparative ethology of vertebrate breathing. I. Breathing in newts, with a general survey. Behaviour 6:8-34.Google Scholar
  53. Thorpe W.H. 1950. The definition of some terms used in animal behaviour studies. Bull. Anim. Behav. 8:34-40.Google Scholar
  54. Thorpe William H. 1954. The process of song-learning in the chaffinch studied by means of the sound spectrograph. Nature 173:465.Google Scholar
  55. Tinbergen N. 1951. The Study of Instinct. Oxford, Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  56. Tinbergen N. 1952. Derived activities:their causation, biological signi cance, origin and emancipation during evolution. Quart. Rev. Biol. 27(1):1-32.Google Scholar
  57. Tinbergen Nikolaas. 1963a. On the aims and methods of ethology. Zietschrift für Tierpsychologie 20:410-433.Google Scholar
  58. Tinbergen N. 1963b. The work of the animal behaviour research group in the Department of zoology, University of Oxford. Anim. Behav. 11:206-209.Google Scholar
  59. Waddington C.H. 1942. Canalisation of development and the inheritance of acquired characters. Nature 150:563-565.Google Scholar
  60. Waddington Conrad H. 1953a. The 'Baldwin Effect ', 'Genetic Assimilation 'and 'Homeostasis’. Evolution 7:386-387.Google Scholar
  61. Waddington Conrad H. 1953b. Genetic assimilation of an acquired character. Evolution 7:118-26.Google Scholar
  62. White Gilbert. 1939 [1789]. The natural history of Selborne. In:Rhys E.(ed.), Everyman Library. J. M.Dent & Sons/E. P Dutton & Co, London and New York.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2004

Authors and Affiliations

  • Paul E. Griffiths
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of History and Philosophy of ScienceUniversity of PittsburghPittsburghUSA

Personalised recommendations