Fiscal Consolidation, Growth and Employment: International Evidence and Implications for India
The paper argues that many national governments, including the one in India, focus on insufficiently robust point estimates pertaining to specific debt/deficit thresholds that create a fiscal consolidation bias. This is costly in terms of output and employment losses. The paper points out that labour market reforms to support fiscal consolidation are often advocated by international agencies, but one should not ignore the high short-run costs of such reforms. These lessons of international experience are highly pertinent to India as it is poised to implement a new fiscal framework. The paper emphasizes that India faces the major challenge of providing productive and durable jobs for its burgeoning work force while ensuring improved social indicators. Adequate and sustainable financing of such critical development needs ought to be at the centre of any fiscal framework.
KeywordsFiscal consolidation Fiscal rules Structural reforms Growth Employment FRBM Review Committee
The author gratefully acknowledges helpful and incisive comments received from Sher Verick and Rizwanul Islam. The standard disclaimer applies: the author bears sole responsibility for any remaining errors and omissions.
- Akun, C., et al. 2017. Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act in India: A Review and Recommendations for Reform. ADB South Asia Working Paper Series, No. 52, July.Google Scholar
- Alesina, A. 2010. Fiscal Adjustments: Lessons from Recent History. Prepared for the Ecofin meeting in Madrid, April, 15.Google Scholar
- Anand, R., and P. Khera. 2016. Macroeconomic Impact of Product and Labor Market Reforms on Informality and Unemployment in India. IMF Working Paper No. 16.Google Scholar
- Asonuma, T. 2016. Serial Sovereign Defaults ad Debt Restructurings. IMF Working Paper No. 66.Google Scholar
- Ball, L., et al. 2013. The Distributional Effects of Fiscal Austerity. UN-DESA Working Paper No. 129, New York, United Nations.Google Scholar
- Basu, K. 2017. Reviving India’s Economy. Project Syndicate, September 19. https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/reversing-india-growth-slowdown-by-kaushik-basu-2017-09; http://www.thehindubusinessline.com/economy/i-do-see-a-case-for-fiscal-stimulus-says-niti-aayogs-rajiv-kumar/article9909609.ece.
- Beetsma, R., and X. Debrun. 2016. Fiscal Councils: Rationale and Effectiveness. IMP Working Paper No. 86.Google Scholar
- Bhanumurthy, N., S. Bose, and P.D. Adhikari. 2015. Targeting Debts and Deficits in India, October. http://nipfp.org.in/media/medialibrary/2015/10/OP_2015_20.pdf.
- Bova, E., et al. 2014. A Fiscal Job’? An Analysis of Fiscal Policy and the Labor Market. IMF Working Paper No. 216.Google Scholar
- Chakraborty, L. 2016. Fiscal Consolidation, Budget Deficits and the Macro-Economy. New Delhi: Sage.Google Scholar
- Chakraborty, P., and L. Chakraborty. 2018. Budget 2018–2019: Time to Recast Union Government Expenditure Needs. Economic and Political Weekly 53(9), March.https://www.indiabudget.gov.in/ub2018-19/frbm/frbm2.pdf.
- Chowdhury, A., and I. Islam. 2014. Fiscal Consolidation: Issues and Evidence, in Islam and Kucera (op.cit).Google Scholar
- Cobham, D. 2016. The Weakness of the Academic Case for Austerity. In German Macro: How it is Different and Why it Matters, ed. G. Bratsiositis and D. Cobham. Brussels: European Policy Centre.Google Scholar
- Debrun, X. 2017. The Fiscal Council Dataset: A Primer to the 2016 Vintage. IMF.Google Scholar
- Dermott, C.J., and R. Wescott. 1996. Fiscal Reforms that Work. Economic Issues, No. 4.Google Scholar
- Easterly, W. 2004. The Widening Gyre: The Dynamics of Rising Public Debt and Falling Growth. Paper Presented at IMF/NIPFP Conference on Fiscal Policy in India, New Delhi, India, January 16–17.Google Scholar
- Easterly, W. 2013. The Role of Growth Slowdowns and Forecast Errors in Public Debt Crises. In Fiscal Policy After the Financial Crisis, ed. A. Alesina and F. Giavazzi. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
- Easterly, W., T.C. Irwin, and L. Serven. 2007. Walking Up the Down Escalator: Public Investment and Fiscal Stability. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 4158.Google Scholar
- Estevao, M., and I. Samake. 2013. The Economic Effects of Fiscal Consolidation with Debt Feedback. IMF Working Paper No. 136.Google Scholar
- Financial Times. 2017. 25 October, 2017. https://qell.co.uk/india-state-banks-tiffin-doubt-recapitalise/.
- FRBM Review Committee. 2017. Responsible Growth: A Debt and Fiscal Framework for 21st Century India, January, New Delhi.Google Scholar
- Government of India. Medium-Term Fiscal Policy Statement, 2018–2019. https://www.indiabudget.gov.in/ub2018-19/frbm/frbm3.pdf. Accessed 30 Aug 2018.
- IMF. 2008. World Economic Outlook, October, Chapter 5.Google Scholar
- IMF. 2015. Fiscal Policy and Long-Term Growth, April 20.Google Scholar
- IMF. 2016. World Economic Outlook, April.Google Scholar
- IMF. 2017a. Tackling Inequality. IMF Fiscal Monitor, October.Google Scholar
- IMF. 2017b. India: Selected Issues, Country Report No. 17.Google Scholar
- IMF. 2017c. India: Selected Issues, February.Google Scholar
- Islam, I. 2014. The Rise and Decline of the Fiscal Austerity Doctrine: Implications for the Euro Area Crisis. In The Governance of Policy Reforms in Europe, ed. K. Papadakis and G. Youcef. Geneva: ILO.Google Scholar
- Islam, I. 2017. Comparing Development indicators: Revisiting the Sen-Dreze thesis on India’s ‘Uncertain Glory’, October 10. https://blogs.griffith.edu.au/asiainsights/comparing-development-indicators-revisiting-the-sen-dreze-thesis-of-indias-uncertain-glory/.
- Islam, I., and A. Chowdhury. 2012. Revisiting the Evidence on Fiscal Austerity: Alesina’s Hour? http://voxeu.org/debates/commentaries/revisiting-evidence-expansionary-fiscal-austerity-alesina-s-hour. Accessed 28 Feb 2012.
- Islam, I., and M. Hengge. 2012. Fiscal Austerity, Borrowing Costs and the Eurozone Economies, July 12, Social Europe. Google Scholar
- Islam, I., and D. Kucera (eds.). 2014. Beyond Macroeconomic Stability: Structural Transformation and Inclusive Development. Geneva and London: ILO and Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
- Jain, R., and P. Kumar. 2013. Size of Government Expenditure Multipliers in India: A Structural VAR Analysis. RBI, Department of Economic and Policy Research, Working Paper No. 7, September.Google Scholar
- Kraay, A. 2014. Government Spending Multipliers in Developing Countries: Evidence from Lending by Official Creditors. American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics 6(4): 170–208.Google Scholar
- Lledo, V., et al. 2017a. Fiscal Rules at a Glance, March, IMF, p. 8.Google Scholar
- Lledo, V., et al. 2017b. IMF: Fiscal Rules at a Glance. Google Scholar
- Mason, J.W., and A. Jayadev. 2013. How the New Consensus in Macroeconomics Let Austerity Lose all the Battles and Still Win the War. Economic and Political Weekly 48(2): 102–111.Google Scholar
- Matheson, T., and J. Pereira. 2016. Fiscal Multipliers in Brazil. IMF Working Paper, No. 79.Google Scholar
- Menukulasi, G. 2016. Are Fiscal Rules a Recipe for Growth in Developing Economies? PhD thesis, University of Delaware, Fall.Google Scholar
- OECD. 2012. Looking to 2060: A Global Vision of Long-Term Growth. OECD Economics Department Policy Notes No. 15, November.Google Scholar
- OECD. 2015. Achieving Prudent Debt Targets Using Fiscal Rules. Economics Department Policy Note No. 28, July.Google Scholar
- Ostry, J., P. Loungani, and D. Furceri. 2016. Neoliberalism: Oversold? Finance and Development, June.Google Scholar
- Ranenberg, A. 2015. The Consequences of Europe’s Fiscal Consolidation. World Economic Forum, November 16.Google Scholar
- Ray, N., and L. Schmitz. 2016. The IMF and Social Dimensions of Growth: A Content Analysis of Recent Article IV Surveillance Reports 2014–2015. Employment Working Paper No. 202, ILO, Geneva.Google Scholar
- Ray, N., A. Velasquez, and I. Islam. 2015. Fiscal Rules, Growth and Employment: A Developing Country Perspective. Employment Working Paper No. 184, ILO, Geneva.Google Scholar
- Reserve Bank of India. 2017. Monetary Policy Report, October.Google Scholar
- Serven, L. 2007. Fiscal Rules, Public Investment and Growth. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 4382.Google Scholar
- Tapsoba, S. 2013. Options and Strategies for Fiscal Consolidation in India. IMF Working Paper No. 127.Google Scholar
- The Economist. 2010. Fiscal Tightening and Growth, 31 March.Google Scholar
- Willamson, J. 1990. What Washington Means by Policy Reform. In Latin American Adjustment: How Much Has Happened, ed. J. Williamson. Washington, DC: Institute for International Economics.Google Scholar
- World Bank. 2017. Doing Business: Reforming for Creating Jobs, 13. Washington, DC: World Bank.Google Scholar
- Wren-Lewis, S. 2015. The Austerity Con. London Review of Books, 19 February.Google Scholar