Noninvasive and Low-Cost Technique for Early Detection of Clinically Relevant Breast Lesions Using a Handheld Point-of-Care Medical Device (iBreastExam): Prospective Three-Arm Triple-Blinded Comparative Study
- 190 Downloads
With limited access to mechanisms of early detection, the vast majority of breast cancer cases present at late stages in developing countries.
To determine the clinical efficacy of a handheld point-of-care medical device that could potentially assist allied healthcare workers to perform standardized Clinical Breast Examination in low-resource settings.
Design, Setting and Participants
Nine hundred and eighty-nine healthy women visiting Manipal Hospital, Bangalore, for annual health check were recruited for bilateral breast examinations. Additionally, 20 women attending the hospital with breast-related symptoms were also recruited as part of the opportunistic screening program. Each woman was examined by three independent methods, each blinded to the other two: iBreastExam (iBE), Clinical Breast Examination (CBE) by an expert clinician and Breast Imaging (mammography or breast ultrasound).
Main Outcome Measures
Sensitivity, Specificity, PPV, NPV for iBE and CBE were derived with Breast Imaging tests used as reference standard.
Out of 916 enrolled participants, 93 were confirmed by imaging to have at least one breast lesion. Clinical Breast Examination in comparison with imaging detected breast lesions with Sn = 65 %, Sp = 94 %, PPV = 52 %, NPV = 96 %, and iBreastExam reported Sn = 84 %, Sp = 94 %, PPV = 60 % and NPV = 98 %. In women below age 40 (314 participants), iBE detected breast lesions with Sn = 85 %, Sp = 93 %. All malignant lesions were identified by iBE, while one non-palpable malignant lesion was missed by clinician CBE.
The point-of-care Breast Imaging device (iBreastExam) performed with significantly better sensitivity, by 19 %, than CBE to detect breast lesions while reporting high specificity (94 %) and NPV (98 %). In younger women population under the age of 40 years, where the prevalence of dense breast is high, iBreastExam demonstrated high-performance characteristics. iBreastExam detected all malignant lesions in this study, while the clinician’s CBE missed to detect a non-palpable malignant lesion. iBreastExam can be a promising tool to provide clinically effective and standardized breast examinations in low-resource settings to detect breast lesions at early stages. The device can also be an effective screening tool for younger women with dense breasts.
KeywordsiBreastExam Breast cancer screening India Low-cost setting
Sources of Funding
iBreastExam medical device was loaned by UE Lifesciences Inc. (Philadelphia, PA, USA) to the research team for the duration of the study.
Compliance with Ethical Standards
Conflict of interest
No researcher of this study has any conflicts of interest to report.
- 1.Kingsbury K. Global breast cancer: the changing face of breast cancer. Time Specials. 2007. http://www.time.com/time/specials/2007/article/0,28804,1666089_1666563,00.html.
- 7.Kahn KL, Goldberg RJ. Screening for breast cancer in the ambulatory setting. Clin Res. 1984;32:649A.Google Scholar
- 11.Lehmann U, Sanders D. Community health workers: What do we know about them? Evidence and information for policy. Geneva: Department of Human Resources for Health, World Health Organization; 2007.Google Scholar
- 12.GLOBOCAN 2012 (IARC). Section of cancer information. http://www-dep.iarc.fr/. Accessed 27 Dec 2013.