Advertisement

Netherlands International Law Review

, Volume 65, Issue 3, pp 391–412 | Cite as

The Next Frontier: Dual Nationality as a Multi-layered Concept

  • Patrick Wautelet
Article
  • 8 Downloads

Abstract

Scholarly debate, legal rules and policy on dual nationality suffer from a fatal flaw: the various situations of dual nationality are conflated in one single category, linked to a single policy. This article argues that the debate would win in clarity if the various situations were untangled. In order to demonstrate the need for more discrimination in situations of multiple citizenship, two cases are discussed: the first one relates to the various situations which may come under the heading of dual nationality. In particular, the argument is made that dual nationality arising out of birthright citizenship should not be confused with situations where a second nationality is voluntarily acquired. The second case where more segregation is in order relates to the treatment of the two nationalities possessed by an individual. The argument goes that the two nationalities should not be treated on equal par, as they rarely have the same value and weight.

Keywords

Dual nationality Birthright citizenship Multiple citizenship Discrimination 

References

  1. Aghahosseini A (2007) Claims of dual nationals and the development of customary international law. Issues before the Iran-United States Claims Tribunal. Martinus Nijhoff, LeidenCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Alarian HM, Goodman SW (2017) Dual citizenship allowance and migration flow. Comp Polit Stud 50(1):133–167CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Basedow J (2013) The law of open societies: private ordering and public regulation of international relations. General Course on Private International Law. Collected Courses Hague Academy, vol 360. Hague Academy of International Law, The Hague, pp 9–516Google Scholar
  4. Bauböck R (2007) The trade-off between transnational citizenship and political autonomy. In: Faist T, Kivisto P (eds) Dual citizenship in global perspective. From unitary to multiple citizenship. Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, pp 69–91Google Scholar
  5. Bauböck R, Perchinig R (2006) Evaluation and recommendations. In: Bauböck R, Ersboll E, Groenendijk K, Waldrauch H (eds) Acquisition and loss of nationality, vol 1. Comparative analyses. Amsterdam University Press, Amsterdam, pp 431–477Google Scholar
  6. Blatter JK, Erdmann S, Schwanke K (2009) Acceptance of dual citizenship: empirical data and political contexts. Working Paper Series ‘Glocal Governance and Democracy’ No 2, Institute of Political Science, University of LucerneGoogle Scholar
  7. Boll AM (2007) Multiple nationality and international law. Martinus Nijhoff, LeidenGoogle Scholar
  8. Bücken L, de Groot R (2018) Deprivation of nationality under Article 8 (3) of the 1961 Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness. Maastricht J Eur Comp Law 25(1):38–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Carrera Nuñez S (2015) How much does EU citizenship cost? The Maltese citizenship-for-sale-affair. A breakthrough for sincere cooperation in citizenship of the Union? In: Carrera Nuñez S, de Groot G-R (eds) European citizenship at the crossroads. The Role of the European Union on loss and acquisition of nationality. Wolf Legal Publishers, Oisterwijk, pp 293–326Google Scholar
  10. Chan JMM (1991) The right to a nationality as a human right. Hum Rts Law J 12:3–17Google Scholar
  11. De Groot G-R, Vink M (2008) Meervoudige nationaliteit in Europees perspectief. Een landenvergelijkend overzicht. Adviescommissie voor Vreemdelingenzaken, The Hague. https://acvz.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/VS-ACVZ-NR19-2008.pdf. Accessed 5 Nov 2018
  12. De Groot G-R, Vink M (2015) A comparative analysis of regulations on involuntary loss of nationality in the European Union. CEPS Liberty and Security in Europe, No 75. https://www.ceps.eu/publications/comparative-analysis-regulations-involuntary-loss-nationality-european-union. Accessed 5 Nov 2018
  13. De Hart B (2007) The end of multiculturalism: the end of dual citizenship? Political and Public Debates on Dual Citizenship in the Netherlands (1980–2004). In: Faist T, Kivisto P (eds) Dual citizenship in Europe. From nationhood to societal integration. Routledge, Abingdon, pp 77–102Google Scholar
  14. De Hart B (2012) Een tweede paspoort. Dubbele nationaliteit in de Verenigde Staten, Duitsland en Nederland. Amsterdam University Press, AmsterdamCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. De Hart B (2017) Modern family. Transnational families in nationality law and migration law in protecting the rights of families and children in a changing world. Mededelingen KNVIR No 144. Asser Press, The Hague, pp 1–34Google Scholar
  16. Donner R (2006) Dual nationality in international law. Acta Juridica Hungarica 47(1):15–25CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Faist T, Kivisto P (eds) (2007) Dual citizenship in global perspective. From unitary to multiple citizenship. Palgrave Macmillan, BasingstokeGoogle Scholar
  18. Faist T, Gerdes J, Rieple B (2004) Dual citizenship as a path-dependent process. Int Migr Rev 38:913–944CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Fitzgerald J, Leblang D, Teets J (2014) Defying the law of gravity: the political economy of international migration. World Polit 66:406–445CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Franzina P (2013) The evolving role of nationality in private international law. In: Annoni A (ed) The changing role of nationality in international law. Routledge, London, pp 193–208Google Scholar
  21. Ganczer M (2015) The right to a nationality as a human right?. Hungarian Yearbook of International Law and European Law 2014. Eleven International Publishing, The Hague, pp 15–33Google Scholar
  22. Hailbronner K (2006a) Germany. In: Bauböck R, Ersboll E, Groenendijk K, Waldrauch H (eds) Acquisition and loss of nationality, vol 2. Country analyses. Policies and Trends in 15 European countries. Amsterdam University Press, Amsterdam, pp 213–251Google Scholar
  23. Hailbronner K (2006b) Multiple nationality and diplomatic protection. In: Arkan S, Yongalik A (eds) Liber amicorum/Festschrift für Tugrul Ansay. Kluwer Law International, Alphen aan den Rijn, pp 117–124Google Scholar
  24. Harvard Law School (1929) The law of nationality. Am J Int Law 23(S5):21–79Google Scholar
  25. Hirsch Ballin E (2014) Citizens’ rights and the right to be a citizen. Brill Nijhoff, LeidenCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Howard MM (2005) Variation in dual citizenship policies in the countries of the EU. Int Migr Rev 39(3):697–720CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Jault-Seseke F, Corneloup S, Barbou des Places S (2015) Droit de la nationalité et des étrangers. PUF, ParisGoogle Scholar
  28. Jessurun d’Oliveira U (2016) Vreemde nationaliteit en de Basisregistratie Personen. Hoe lang nog schoorvoeten? Asiel Migr 10:480–483Google Scholar
  29. Jessurun d’Oliveira U (2018) Once again: plural nationality. Maastricht J Eur Comp Law 25(1):22–37CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Kochenov D, Lindeboom J (eds) (2018) Quality of nationality index. Nationalities of the world in 2017, 3rd edn. Ideos, ZurichGoogle Scholar
  31. Kondo A (2018) Japan. In: Vonk O (ed) Nationality law in the Eastern hemisphere. Acquisition and loss of citizenship in Asian perspective. Wolf Legal Publishers, Oisterwijk, pp 199–217Google Scholar
  32. Kovacs MM (2006) The politics of dual citizenship in Hungary. Citizsh Stud 10(4):431:451Google Scholar
  33. Lahssaini L (2012) Quelle protection des doubles nationaux en Belgique? Réflexions sur l’affaire Ali Aarrass. Revue Belge Droit Int 45:634–659Google Scholar
  34. Leurent B (1985) Problèmes soulevés par les demandes des doubles nationaux devant le Tribunal des différends irano-américains. Revue Critique de Droit International Privé 74:273–325 (part I), 74:477–503 (part II)Google Scholar
  35. Low CC (2014) The 1963 Strasbourg convention on single nationality movement: the German experience. J Eur Hist Law 2:41–50Google Scholar
  36. Mahoney P (1984) The standing of dual nationals before the Iran-United States Claims Tribunal. Va J Int Law 24:695–728Google Scholar
  37. Manby B (2009) Struggles for citizenship in Africa. African arguments. Zed Books, LondonGoogle Scholar
  38. Manby B (2015) Citizenship and statelessness in Africa: the law and politics of belonging. Wolf Legal Publishers, OisterwijkGoogle Scholar
  39. Mantu S (2015) Contingent citizenship: The law and practice of citizenship deprivation in international. European and national perspectives. Brill, LeidenCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Martin DA (2003) Introduction: the trend toward dual nationality. In: Martin DA, Hailbronner K (eds) Rights and duties of dual nationals: evolution and prospects. Kluwer Law International, The Hague, pp 3–18Google Scholar
  41. Meeusen J (2011) Le droit international privé et le principe de non-discrimination. Collected Courses of the Hague Academy, vol 353. Brill, LeidenGoogle Scholar
  42. Neumann GL (1998) Nationality law in the United States and Germany: structure and current problems. In: Schuck PH, Münz R (eds) Paths to inclusion. The integration of migrants in the United States and Germany. Berghahn Books, New York, pp 247–297Google Scholar
  43. Onguene Onana DE (2012) La compétence en arbitrage international relatif aux investissements. Les conditions d’investissement et de nationalité devant le CIRDI. Bruylant, BrusselsGoogle Scholar
  44. Peter FWC, Schmeets H, Vink MP (2015) Naturalisatie in Nederland: wie en waarom?. CBS Bevolkingstrends juli 2015, pp 1–11. https://www.cbs.nl/nl-nl/achtergrond/2015/32/naturalisatie-in-nederland-wie-en-waarom. Accessed 5 Nov 2018
  45. Rishmawi M (2005) The revised Arab charter on human rights: a step forward? Hum Rights Law Rev 5(2):361–376CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Schmeets H, Vink M (2011) Opvattingen over dubbele nationaliteit: wie is tegen en wie niet? Bevolkingstrends 59(3):28–32Google Scholar
  47. Sejersen T (2008) ‘I vow to thee my countries’—the expansion of dual citizenship in the 21st century. Int Migr Rev 42:523–549CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Spiro PJ (2008) Multiple nationality. In: Wolfrum R (ed) Max planck encyclopedia of public international law. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  49. Spiro PJ (2011) A new international law of citizenship. Am J Int Law 105:694–746CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Spiro PJ (2018) At home in two countries. The past and future of dual citizenship. New York University Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  51. Swider K (2018) A rights-based approach to statelessness. PhD, University of AmsterdamGoogle Scholar
  52. Tanasoca A (2018) The ethics of multiple citizenship. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Van der Baaren L (2015) Ius pecuniae en het vreemdelingenrecht. Asiel Migr 2015(1):107–111Google Scholar
  54. Van der Baaren L, Li H (2018) Wealth influx, wealth exodus: investment migration from China to Portugal. Investment Migration Working Paper 2018/1. https://investmentmigration.org/download/wealth-influx-wealth-exodus-investment-migration-china-portugal/. Accessed 5 Nov 2018
  55. Van Waas L (2008) Nationality matters: statelessness under international law. Intersentia, AntwerpGoogle Scholar
  56. Verwilghen M (1999) Conflit de nationalités. Plurinationalité et apatridie. Collected courses of the Hague Academy, vol 277. Hague Academy of International Law, The HagueGoogle Scholar
  57. Vink MP, de Groot G-R, Luk NC (2015) MACIMIDE global expatriate dual citizenship dataset. Harvard Dataverse, [V2].  https://doi.org/10.7910/dvn/ttmz08
  58. Vonk O (2010) Dual nationality in the European Union. Martinus Nijhoff, LeidenGoogle Scholar
  59. Vonk O (ed) (2018) Nationality law in the Eastern hemisphere. Acquisition and loss of citizenship in Asian perspective. Wolf Legal Publishers, OisterwijkGoogle Scholar
  60. Wautelet P (2017) Deprivation of citizenship for ‘jihadists’. Analysis of the Belgian and French practice and policy in light of the priciple of equal treatment. In: Kruiniger P (ed) Jihad, islam en recht. Jihadisme en reacties vanuit het Nederlandse en Belgische recht. Recht van de islam, vol 30. Boom Juridisch, The Hague, pp 49–74Google Scholar
  61. Wiedemann M (2003) Development of dual nationality under German law. In: Martin DA, Hailbronner K (eds) Rights and duties of dual nationals. Kluwer Law International, The Hague, pp 335–345Google Scholar

Copyright information

© T.M.C. Asser Press 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.University of LiègeLiègeBelgium

Personalised recommendations