Comparing the Effectiveness of EMDR and TF-CBT for Children and Adolescents: a Meta-Analysis
- 1.6k Downloads
Efficacy of EMDR and TF-CBT for posttraumatic stress symptoms (PTSS) was explored through meta-analysis. A comprehensive search yielded 494 studies of children and adolescents with PTSS who received treatment with these evidence-based therapeutic modalities. Thirty total studies were included in the meta-analysis. The overall Cohen’s d was small (−0.359) and statistically significant (p < 0.05), indicating EMDR and TF-CBT are effective in treating PTSS. Major findings posit TF-CBT is marginally more effective than EMDR; those with sub-clinical PTSS responded more favorably in treatment than those with PTSD; and greater reductions in PTSS were observed with presence of comorbidity in diagnosis. Assessment of publication bias with Classic fail-safe N revealed it would take 457 nonsignificant studies to nullify these findings.
KeywordsEye movement and desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR) Trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy (TF-CBT) Effectiveness Posttraumatic stress symptoms (PTSS) Posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) Meta-analysis Children Adolescents
The authors would first like to posthumously thank our professor, advisor, mentor, and co-author, Dr. Siobhan K. O’Toole, for her guidance and tutelage, as well as sharing with us her passion for meta-analysis. The authors would like to thank Jennie L. Bedsworth, LCSW, who serves as a Licensed Clinical Social Worker in the state of Missouri, for her knowledge and expertise in trauma-focused therapies for vulnerable populations that have significantly informed our discussion for this research endeavor. And finally, the authors would like to thank Colt J. Blunt, Psy.D., L.P., for his thoughtful editing of this manuscript.
Compliance with Ethical Standards
Disclosure of Interest
On behalf of all authors, the corresponding author states that there is no conflict of interest.
Ethical Standards and Informed Consent
All procedures followed were in accordance with the ethical standards of the responsible committee on human experimentation [institutional and national] and with the Helsinki Declaration of 1975, as revised in 2000.
*References marked with an asterisk indicate studies included in the meta-analysis.
- Biostat. (2005). Comprehensive meta-analysis [computer software] [version 2.0]. Englewood: Author.Google Scholar
- Cavett, A. M., & Drewes, A. A. (2012). Play applications and skills components. In J. A. Cohen, A. P. Mannarino, & E. Deblinger (Eds.), Trauma-focused CBT for children and adolescents: Treatment applications (pp. 105–123). New York: Guilford Press.Google Scholar
- Child Welfare Information Gateway. (2012). Trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy for children affected by sexual abuse or trauma. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Children’s Bureau.Google Scholar
- *Cohen, J. A., Deblinger, E., Mannarino, A. P., & Steer, R. A. (2004a). A multisite, randomized controlled trial for children with sexual abuse-related PTSD symptoms. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 43(4), 393–402. https://doi.org/10.1097/00004583-200404000-00005.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- *Cohen, J. A., Mannarino, A. P., & Knudsen, K. (2004b). Treating childhood traumatic grief: A pilot study. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 43(10), 1225–1233. https://doi.org/10.1097/01.chi.0000135620.15522.38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- *Cohen, J. A., Mannarino, A. P., & Iyengar, S. (2011). Community treatment of posttraumatic stress disorder for children exposed to intimate partner violence: a randomized controlled trial. Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine, 165(1), 16–21. https://doi.org/10.1001/archpediatrics.2010.247.
- de Arellano, M. R., Lyman, D. R., Jobe-Shields, L., George, P., Dougherty, R. H., Daniels, A. S., … Delphin-Rittmon, M. E. (2014). Trauma-focused cognitive-behavioral therapy for children and adolescents: Assessing the evidence. Psychiatric Services, 65(5), 591–602. https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ps.201300255.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- *de Roos, C., Greenwald, R., den Hollander-Gijsman, M., Noorthoorn, E., van Buuren, S., & de Jongh, A. (2011). A randomised comparison of cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) and eye movement desensitisation and reprocessing (EMDR) in disaster-exposed children. European Journal of Psychotraumatology, 2, 5694–5705. https://doi.org/10.3402/ejpt.v2i0.5694.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- *Diehle, J., Opmeer, B. C., Boer, F., Mannarino, A. P., & Lindauer, R. L. (2015). Trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy or eye movement desensitization and reprocessing: What works in children with posttraumatic stress symptoms? A randomized controlled trial. European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 24(2), 227–236. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00787-014-0572-5.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Dozier, M., Peloso, E., Lewis, E., Laurenceau, J., & Levine, S. (2008). Effects of an attachment-based intervention of the cortisol production of infants and toddlers in foster care. Development and Psychopathology, 20(3), 845–859. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0954579408000400.CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
- Foa, E. B., Keane, T. M., Friedman, M. J., & Cohen, J. A. (2009). Effective treatments for PTSD: Practice guidelines from the International Society for Traumatic Stress Studies (2nd ed.). New York: Guilford Press.Google Scholar
- Ford, J. D., Steinberg, K., Hawke, J., Levine, J., & Zhang, W. (2012). Evaluation of trauma affect regulation—Guide for education and therapy (TARGET) with traumatized girls involved in delinquency. Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology, 41(1), 27–37. https://doi.org/10.1080/15374416.2012.632343.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Greenwald, R. (1999). Eye-movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR) in child and adolescent psychotherapy. New York: Jason Aronson.Google Scholar
- Greyber, L. R., Dulmus, C. N., & Cristalli, M. E. (2012). Eye movement desensitization reprocessing, posttraumatic stress disorder, and trauma: A review of randomized controlled trials with children and adolescents. Child and Adolescent Social Work Journal, 29(5), 409–425. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10560-012-0266-0.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- *Hebert, M., & Daignault, I. V. (2015). Challenges in treatment of sexually abused preschoolers: A pilot study of TF-CBT in Quebec. Sexologies: European Journal of Sexology and Sexual Health / Revue Européenne De Sexologie Et De Santé Sexuelle, 24(1), e21-e27. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sexol.2014.09.003.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Helland, M. J., & Mathiesen, K. S. (2009). 13–15 aringer fra vanlige familier i Norge: Hverdagsliv og psykisk helse [13–15 year-olds from regular families in Norway: Everyday life and mental health]. Retrieved from the Norwegian Institute of Public Health website: http://www.fhi.no/dokumenter/d2d94780d4.pdf
- Herman, J. L. (1992). Trauma and recovery: The aftermath of violence—From domestic abuse to political terror. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
- Ho, M. K., & Lee, C. W. (2012). Cognitive behaviour therapy versus eye movement desensitization and reprocessing for post-traumatic disorder—Is it all in the homework then? European Review of Applied Psychology / Revue Européenne De Psychologie Appliquée, 62(4), 253–260. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.erap.2012.08.001.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- *Jaycox. L. H., Cohen, J. A., Mannarino, A. P., Walker, D. W., Langley, A. K., Gegenheimer, K. L., Scott M. Schonlau, M. (2010). Children's mental health care following hurricane Katrina: A field trial of trauma-focused psychotherapies. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 23(2), 223–231. https://doi.org/10.1002/jts.20518.
- *Jensen, T. K., Holt, T., Ormhaug, S. M., Egeland, K., Granly, L., Hoaas, L. C., … Wentzel-Larsen, T. (2014). A randomized effectiveness study comparing trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy with therapy as usual for youth. Journal of Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology, 43(3), 356–369. https://doi.org/10.1080/15374416.2013.822307.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Kagan, R. (2009). Transforming troubled children into tomorrow's heroes. In D. Brom, R. Pat-Horenczyk, J. D. Ford, D. Brom, R. Pat-Horenczyk, & J. D. Ford (Eds.), Treating traumatized children: Risk, resilience and recovery (pp. 255–268). New York: Routledge/Taylor & Francis Group.Google Scholar
- *Kemp, M., Drummond, P., & McDermott, B. (2010). A wait-list controlled pilot study of eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR) for children with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptoms from motor vehicle accidents. Clinical Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 15(1), 5–25. https://doi.org/10.1177/1359104509339086.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Kessler, R. C., Sonnega, A., Bromet, E., Hughes, M., & Nelson, C. B. (1995). Posttraumatic stress disorder in the National Comorbidity Survey. Archives of General Psychiatry, 52(12), 1048–1060. https://doi.org/10.1001/archpsyc.1995.03950240066012.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- *Konanur, S., & Muller, R. (2012). A community-based study of the effectiveness of trauma-focused cognitive behavioral with trauma-exposed school-aged children in Toronto, Canada. International Society for Traumatic Stress Studies (ISTSS) 28th Annual Meeting: Innovations to Expand Services and Tailor Traumatic Stress Treatments, November 1–3, 2012, Los Angeles, CA [Abstracts]. https://doi.org/10.1037/e533652013-128.
- Kowalik, J., Weller, J., Venter, J., & Drachman, D. (2011). Cognitive behavioral therapy for the treatment of pediatric posttraumatic stress disorder: A review and meta-analysis. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 42(3), 405–413. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbtep.2011.02.002.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- *Layne, C. M., Pynoos, R. S., Saltzman, W. R., Arslanagić, B., Black, M., Savjak, N., Popović T., Duraković E., Mušić M., Ćampara N., Djapo N. Houston, R. (2001). Trauma/grief-focused group psychotherapy: School-based postwar intervention with traumatized Bosnian adolescents. Group Dynamics: Theory, Research, and Practice, 5(4), 277–290. https://doi.org/10.1037/1089-2618.104.22.1687.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Lenz, A. S., & Hollenbaugh, K. M. (2015). Meta-analysis of trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy for treating PTSD and co-occurring depression among children and adolescents. Counseling Outcome Research and Evaluation, 6(1), 18–32. https://doi.org/10.1177/2150137815573790.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Lipsey, M. W., & Wilson, D. B. (2001). Practical meta-analysis. Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications, Inc..Google Scholar
- Little, S. G., & Akin-Little, A. (2009). Trauma-focused cognitive behavior therapy. In A. Akin-Little, S. G. Little, M. A. Bray, & T. J. Kehle (Eds.), Behavioral interventions in schools: Evidence-based positive strategies (pp. 325–333). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association. https://doi.org/10.1037/11886-021.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Lohr, J. M., Kleinknecht, R. A., Tolin, D. F., & Barrett, R. H. (1995). The empirical status of the clinical application of eye movement desensitization and reprocessing. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 26(4), 285–302. https://doi.org/10.1016/0005-7916(95)00041-0.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Lovett, J. (1999). Small wonders: Healing childhood trauma with EMDR. New York: The Free Press.Google Scholar
- Lowell, D. I., Carter, A. S., Godoy, L., Paulicin, B., & Briggs-Gowan, M. J. (2011). A randomized controlled trial of child FIRST: A comprehensive home-based intervention translating research into early childhood practice. Child Development, 82(1), 193–208. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8624.2010.01550.x.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- *Madigan, S., Vaillancourt, K., McKibbon, A., & Benoit, D. (2015). Trauma and traumatic loss in pregnant adolescents: The impact of trauma-focused cognitive behavior therapy on maternal unresolved states of mind and posttraumatic stress disorder. Attachment and Human Development, 17(2), 175–198. https://doi.org/10.1080/14616734.2015.1006386.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Mannarino, A. P., Cohen, J. A., Deblinger, E., Runyon, M. K., & Steer, R. A. (2012). Trauma-focused cognitive-behavioral therapy for children: Sustained impact of treatment 6 and 12 months later. Child Maltreatment, 17(3), 231–241. https://doi.org/10.1177/1077559512451787.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- *McMullen, J., O'Callaghan, P., Shannon, C., Black, A., & Eakin, J. (2013). Group trauma-focused cognitive-behavioural therapy with former child soldiers and other war-affected boys in the DR Congo: A randomised controlled trial. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 54(11), 1231–1241. https://doi.org/10.1111/jcpp.12094.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Najavits, L. M., Gallop, R. J., & Weiss, R. D. (2006). Seeking safety therapy for adolescent girls with PTSD and substance use disorder: A randomized controlled trial. The Journal of Behavioral Health Services & Research, 33(4), 453–463. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11414-006-9034-2.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- National Child Traumatic Stress Network. (2014). Complex trauma: Facts for service providers working with homeless youth and young adults. Los Angeles: National Center for Child Traumatic Stress.Google Scholar
- *O'Callaghan, P., McMullen, J., Shannon, C., Rafferty, H., & Black, A. (2013). A randomized controlled trial of trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy for sexually exploited, war-affected Congolese girls. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 52(4), 359–369. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jaac.2013.01.013.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- *O'Donnell, K., Dorsey, S., Gong, W., Ostermann, J., Whetten, R., Cohen, J. A., Itemba D., Manongi R. Whetten, K. (2014). Treating maladaptive grief and posttraumatic stress symptoms in orphaned children in Tanzania: Group-based trauma-focused cognitive-behavioral therapy. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 27(6), 664–671. https://doi.org/10.1002/jts.21970.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- *Ormhaug, S. M., Jensen, T. K., Wentzel-Larsen, T., & Shirk, S. R. (2014). The therapeutic alliance in treatment of traumatized youths: Relation to outcome in a randomized clinical trial. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 82(1), 52–64. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0033884.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- *Puffer, M. K., Greenwald, R., & Elrod, D. E. (1998). A single session EMDR study with twenty traumatized children and adolescents. Traumatology, 3(2). https://doi.org/10.1037/h0101053.
- Puttre, J. J. (2011). A meta-analytic review of the treatment outcome literature for traumatized children and adolescents. Dissertation Abstracts International, 72, 2445.Google Scholar
- *Ready, C. B., Hayes, A. M., Yasinski, C. W., Webb, C., Gallop, R., Deblinger, E., & Laurenceau, J. P. (2015). Overgeneralized beliefs, accommodation, and symptom outcome in youth receiving trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy for childhood trauma. Behavior Therapy, 46(5), 671–88. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.beth.2015.03.004.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- *Scheeringa, M. S., Weems, C. F., Cohen, J. A., Amaya-Jackson, L., & Guthrie, D. (2011). Trauma-focused cognitive-behavioral therapy for posttraumatic stress disorder in three-through six year-old children: A randomized clinical trial. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 52(8), 853–860. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-7610.2010.02354.x.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Shapiro, F. (2001). Eye movement desensitization and reprocessing: Basic principles, protocols, and procedures (2nd ed.). New York: Guilford Press.Google Scholar
- Silverman, W. K., Ortiz, C. D., Viswesvaran, C., Burns, B. J., Kolko, D. J., Putnam, F. W., & Amaya-Jackson, L. (2008). Evidence-based psychosocial treatments for children and adolescents exposed to traumatic events. Journal of Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology, 37(1), 156–183. https://doi.org/10.1080/15374410701818293.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- *Smith, P., Yule, W., Perrin, S., Tranah, T., Dagleish, T., & Clark, D. M. (2007). Cognitive-behavioral therapy for PTSD in children and adolescents: A preliminary randomized controlled trial. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 46(8), 1051–1061. https://doi.org/10.1097/CHI.0b013e318067e288.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Spinhoven, P., Slee, N., Garnefski, N., & Arensman, E. (2009). Childhood sexual abuse differentially predicts outcome of cognitive-behavioral therapy for deliberate self-harm. The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 197(6), 455–457. https://doi.org/10.1097/NMD.0b013e3181a620c8.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Tinker, R. H., & Wilson, S. A. (1999). Through the eyes of a child: EMDR with children. New York: W. W. Norton & Company.Google Scholar
- World Health Organization (2013). Guidelines for the management of conditions specifically related to stress. Geneva: WHO.Google Scholar