Beyond the Debates of Which is Best: Investigating the Complementarity of Chinese and Western Aid, and Possible Lessons from China’s Development

Research Article
First Online:
Received:
Accepted:
  • 344 Downloads

Abstract

This paper will argue that contrary to popular opinion, Chinese engagement in the developing world is not too different from traditional donor engagement. In fact, the composition of similarities and differences among China and the broad variety of traditional donors indicate that it should be seen as complementary. In order to justify this view, an ideological categorization of foreign aid determinants is employed to analyze China’s foreign aid program since the 1950s; finding that Chinese foreign aid since 1978 falls broadly within the category of liberal internationalism. The preferred modalities of Chinese aid are presented, contextualized by China’s own developmental experience, its experience as a donor, and its own developmental needs. The complementarity with traditional donor modalities is assessed. Finally, lessons from China’s own development will be presented and their transferability assessed. This paper will conclude that while China’s aid is not too dissimilar from traditional donor aid, and areas of complementarity do exist; the most important lesson from China is that a country leadership committed to socio-economic development, employing policy design mechanisms that identify instruments most suited to local socio-economic and political conditions, is most conducive to socio-economic development.

Keywords

China Foreign aid Africa Development experience Aid complementarity 
This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.

References

  1. African Forum and Network on Debt and Development (AFRODAD). 2008. Mapping Chinese Development Assistance in Africa: A Synthesis Analysis of Angola, Mozambique, Zambia and Zimbabwe. Harare: AFRODAD.Google Scholar
  2. Barr, J., Y. Gu, Y. Guo, G. Liu, J. Keeley and J. Pennarz. 2010. China: Country program evaluation. Evaluation Report EV710. London: DfID.Google Scholar
  3. Becquelin, N. 2004. Staged development in Xinjiang. The China Quarterly 178: 358–378.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Berthélemy, J.-C. 2005. Bilateral donors’ interests vs recipients’ development motives in aid allocation: Do all donors behave the same? Review of Development Economics 10(2): 179–194.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Besada, H., Y. Wang, and J. Whalley. 2008. China’s growing economic activity in Africa. National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper No. 14024. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.Google Scholar
  6. Booth, D. 2011a. Introduction: Working with the grain? The African power and politics programme. IDS Bulletin 42(2): 1–10.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Booth, D. 2011b. Towards a theory of local governance and public goods provision. IDS Bulletin 42(2): 11–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Bosshard, P. 2007a. China’s Role in Financing African Infrastructure. Berkley: International Rivers Network.Google Scholar
  9. Bosshard, P. 2007b. China and the West in Africa: Shared interests? The China Monitor 19: 8–10.Google Scholar
  10. Bräutigam, D.A., and X.Y. Tang. 2009. China’s engagement in African agriculture: “Down to the Countryside”. The China Quarterly 199: 686–706.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Brautigam, D. 2009. The Dragon’s Gift: The Real Story of China in Africa. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  12. Brautigam, D. 2011. Chinese development aid in Africa: What, where, why, and how much. In Rising China: Global Challenges and Opportunities, ed. J. Golley and L.G. Song, 202–220. Canberra: The Australian National University Press.Google Scholar
  13. Chan-Fishel, M. 2007. Environmental impact: More of the same? In African Perspectives on China in Africa, ed. F. Manji and S. Marks. Oxford: Fahamu.Google Scholar
  14. Chang, H.-J. 2002. Kicking Away the Ladder: Development Strategy in Historical Perspective. London: Anthem Press.Google Scholar
  15. Chen, L., A. de Haan, X.L. Zhang, and W. Warmerdam. 2012. Addressing vulnerability in an emerging economy: China’s New Cooperative Medical Scheme. Canadian Journal of Development Studies/Revue canadienne d’études du développement 32(4): 399–413.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Chen, S.H., M. Ravallion and Y.J. Wang. 2006. Di Bao: A guaranteed minimum income in China’s cities? World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 3805. Washington, DC: World Bank.Google Scholar
  17. Cheng, G. 2003. Politically and economically China and Africa need each other and support each other. Available online: http://view.news.qq.com/a/20031127/000001.htm.
  18. Cook, S. 2009. China’s development model: What is there to learn? DevIssues 11(1): 4–6.Google Scholar
  19. Davies, P. 2007. China and the End of Poverty in Africa: Towards Mutual Benefit? Sundbyberg: Diakonia.Google Scholar
  20. Davies, M.J. 2008. Special economic zones: China’s developmental model comes to Africa. In China into Africa: Aid, Trade, and Influence, ed. R.I. Rotberg, 137–154. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.Google Scholar
  21. Davies, M., H. Edinger, N. Tay, and S. Naidu. 2008. How China Delivers Development Assistance to Africa. Centre for Chinese Studies: University of Stellenbosch.Google Scholar
  22. de Haan, Arjan. 2009. Will China change international development as we know it? ISS Working Paper No. 475. Den Haag: Institute of Social Studies.Google Scholar
  23. de Haan, A. 2010. Will emerging powers change international cooperation? Implications of China’s foreign aid for Dutch and other donors. In The Netherlands Yearbook on International Cooperation 2009, ed. P. Hoebink. The Hague: Van Gorcum.Google Scholar
  24. de Haan, A., and W. Warmerdam. 2013. New donors and old practices: The role of China in the multilateral system. In Multilateral Development Cooperation in a Changing Global Order, ed. H. Besada and S. Kindornay. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
  25. Dittmer, L. 2010. China’s rise, global identity, and the developing world. In China, the Developing World, and the New Global Dynamic, ed. L. Dittmer and G. Yu, 203–230. London: Lynne Rienner.Google Scholar
  26. Dollar, D. 2008. Lessons from China for Africa. World Bank Policy Research Paper 4531. Washington, DC: The World Bank.Google Scholar
  27. Dumoulin-Smith, A. 2008. Social health insurance in China: An example of nascent social security in China. Available online: http://inequality.cornell.edu/people/PapersAbstracts/Dumoulin%20Smith_paper.pdf.
  28. Fan, S.G., L.X. Zhang, and X.B. Zhang. 2004. Reforms, investment, and poverty in rural China. Economic Development and Cultural Change 52(2): 394–421.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Freedom House, Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty and Radio Free Asia. 2009. Undermining Democracy: 21st Century Authoritarians. Washington, DC: Freedom House.Google Scholar
  30. Foster, V., W. Butterfield, C. Chenand N. Pushak. 2008. Building Bridges: China’s Growing Role as Infrastructure Financier for Sub-Saharan Africa. Trends and Policy Options, 5. Washington, DC: The World Bank.Google Scholar
  31. Fu, X.L., and V.N. Balasubramanyam. 2003. Township and village enterprises in China. Journal of Development Studies 39(4): 27–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Gao, Q. 2011. Anti-poverty family policies in China: A critical evaluation. Paper prepared for the United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs (DESA) Division for Social Policy and Development (DSPD) Expert Group Meeting on Assessing family policies: Confronting family poverty and social exclusion and ensuring family balance, 1–3 June, New York.Google Scholar
  33. Heilmann, S. 2008. From local experiments to national policy: The origins of China’s distinctive policy process. The China Journal 59: 1–30.Google Scholar
  34. Holder, A., and R. Jackson. 2008. Mutual benefit?—The impact of China’s investment in Africa on children. In New Impulses from the South: China’s Engagement of Africa, ed. Edinger, H., H. Hermanand and J. Jansson. Stellenbosch: University of Stellenbosch, Centre for Chinese Studies.Google Scholar
  35. Hook, S.W. 1995. National Interest and Foreign Aid. Boulder: Lynne Rienner.Google Scholar
  36. Hougaard, J.L., L.P. Østerdal, and F. Yu. 2008. The Chinese health care system: Structure, problems and challenges. Discussion Papers. Copenhagen: Department of Economics, University of Copenhagen.Google Scholar
  37. Huang, C.-H. 2008. China’s renewed partnership with Africa: Implications for the United States. In China into Africa: Trade, Aid, and Influence, ed. R.I. Rotberg, 296–312. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.Google Scholar
  38. Human Rights Watch. 2011. Promises Unfulfilled: An Assessment of China’s National Human Rights Action Plan. New York: HRW.Google Scholar
  39. Huo, K., and T. Li. 2009. China’s IMF quota set to surpass Japan’s. Available online: http://english.caijing.com.cn/2009-04-02/110132520.html.
  40. Information Office of the State Council of the People’s Republic of China. 2005. China’s Peaceful Development Road. Beijing: Information Office of the State Council of the People’s Republic of China.Google Scholar
  41. Information Office of the State Council of the People’s Republic of China. 2011. China’s Foreign Aid. Beijing: Information Office of the State Council of the People’s Republic of China.Google Scholar
  42. International Social Security Association. 2009. Chinese health-care reforms move towards universal coverage. Available online: http://www.issa.int/content/search?SearchText=Chinese+health-care+reforms+move+towards+universal+coverage&x=0&y=0.
  43. Jiang, W.R. 2008. China’s emerging strategic partnerships in Africa. In China into Africa: Trade, Aid, and Influence, ed. R.I. Rotberg, 50–64. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.Google Scholar
  44. Juma, V. 2011. Chinese manufacturers go local in battle for Kenya’s consumers. Business Daily, April 15th, 2011.Google Scholar
  45. Kaplinsky, R. 2005. Impact of Asian Drivers on the Developing World. Brighton: IDS.Google Scholar
  46. Kaplinsky, R., D. McCormick, and M. Morris. 2007. The impact of China on sub-Saharan Africa. IDS Working Paper 291.Google Scholar
  47. Lancaster, C. 2007. Foreign Aid: Diplomacy, Development, Domestic Politics. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  48. Lee, Margaret C. 2006. The 21st century scramble for Africa. Journal of Contemporary African Studies 24(3): 303–330.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Lee, Margaret C. 2007. Uganda and China: Unleashing the power of the dragon. In China in Africa, ed. M. Henning, 26–40. Uppsala: Nordiska Afrikainstitutet.Google Scholar
  50. Lewis, D. 2011. Africa can gain from dearer Chinese labor: World Bank. Reuters, July 4th, 2011.Google Scholar
  51. Li, A.S. 2007. China and Africa: Policy and challenges. China Security 3(3): 69–93.Google Scholar
  52. Li, S., and H. Yang. 2009. Impact of minimum living standard guarantee on income distribution and poverty reduction in urban China. Chinese Journal of Population Science 5: 19–27.Google Scholar
  53. Lin, Y.F. 2009. Economic Development and Transition: Thought, Strategy, and Viability. New York: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Ma, Q.S. 2002. The governance of NGOs in China since 1978: How much autonomy? Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 31(3): 305–328.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Maizels, A., and M.K. Nissanke. 1984. Motivations for aid to developing countries. World Development 12(9): 879–900.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Melber, H. 2007. The (not so) new kid on the block: China and the scramble for Africa’s resources—an introductory review. In China in Africa, ed. M. Henning, 6–9. Uppsala: Nordiska Afrikainstitutet.Google Scholar
  57. Meng, Q.Y. 2009. New directions in China’s health sector reform. China Brief 9(5): 12–15.Google Scholar
  58. Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the People’s Republic of China. 2006. China’s African Policy. Beijing: Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the People’s Republic of China.Google Scholar
  59. Morgenthau, H. 1962. A political theory for foreign aid. The American Political Science Review 56(2): 209–301.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Moyo, D. 2009. Dead Aid. Why Aid is Not Working and How there is Another Way for Africa. London: Penguin.Google Scholar
  61. National Development and Reform Commission. 2009. Opinions of the CPC Central Committee and the State Council on the deepening of the health care system reform. Available online: http://shs.ndrc.gov.cn/ygjd/ygwj/t20090408_271138.htm.
  62. Nelson, J.M. 1968. Aid, Influence, and Foreign Policy. New York: MacMillan.Google Scholar
  63. Obiorah, N., D. Kew, and Y. Tanko. 2008. “Peaceful rise” and human rights: China’s expanding relations with Nigeria. In China into Africa: Trade, Aid, and Influence, ed. R.I. Rotberg, 272–295. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.Google Scholar
  64. OECD. 2011. Progress Report on Enhanced Engagement. Paris: OECD.Google Scholar
  65. Oi, J.C. 1999. Two decades of rural reform in China: An overview and assessment. The China Quarterly 159: 616–628.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Perkins, F.C. 1997. Export performance and enterprise reform in China’s coastal provinces. Economic Development and Cultural Change 45(3): 501–539.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Ping, A. 1999. From proletarian internationalism to mutual development: China’s cooperation with Tanzania, 1965–1995. In Agencies in Foreign Aid: Comparing China, Sweden and the United States in Tanzania, ed. G. Hyden and R. Mukandala, 156–201. New York: Macmillan Press Ltd and St. Martin’s Press Inc.Google Scholar
  68. Qian, Y.Y. 2003. How reform worked in China. In Search of Prosperity: Analytic Narratives on Economic Growth, ed. D. Rodrik. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
  69. Radio86.com. 2007. World Bank welcomes China’s contribution to IDA: Zoellick. Available online: http://en.radio86.com/news/world-bank-welcomes-chinas-contribution-ida-zoellick.
  70. Ramo, J.C. 2004. The Beijing Consensus. London: The Foreign Policy Centre.Google Scholar
  71. Ravallion, M. 2008. Are there lessons for Africa from China’s success against poverty? World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 4463.Google Scholar
  72. Rotberg, R.I. (ed.). 2008a. China into Africa: Aid, Trade, and Influence. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.Google Scholar
  73. Rotberg, R.I. 2008b. China’s quest for resources, opportunities, and influence in Africa. In: China into Africa: Aid, Trade, and Influence, ed. Rotberg, R.I 1-20. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.Google Scholar
  74. Rupp, S. 2008. Africa and China: Engaging postcolonial interdependencies. In China into Africa: Aid, Trade and Influence, ed. R.I. Rotberg, 65–85. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.Google Scholar
  75. Saich, T. 2000. Negotiating the state: The development of social organizations in China. The China Quarterly 161: 124–141.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  76. Shu, Y. 2010. Correcting foreign assistance that is not suited to the nation’s strengths. Zhengzhou Wanbao (Zhengzhou Evening Paper), August 16th, 2010. Available online: http://view.news.qq.com/a/20100816/000039.htm.
  77. Stokke, Olav (ed.). 1989. Western Middle Powers and Global Poverty: The Determinants of the Aid Policies of Canada, Denmark, The Netherlands, Norway and Sweden. Uppsala: The Scandinavian Institute of African Studies.Google Scholar
  78. Sun, L.X. 2007. Looking at China’s foreign aid policy since the foundation of new China from a national interests perspective. Times Finance 11(356): 9–10.Google Scholar
  79. Sun, X.Y., A.C. Sleigh, G.A. Carmichael, and S. Jackson. 2010. Health payment-induced poverty under China’s New Cooperative Medical Scheme in rural Shandong. Health Policy and Planning 25(5): 419–426.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  80. Taylor, I. 2007. Unpacking China’s Resource Diplomacy in Africa. In China in Africa, ed. M. Henning, 10–25. Uppsala: Nordiska Afrikainstitutet.Google Scholar
  81. Teets, J.C. 2009. Post-earthquake relief and reconstruction efforts: The emergence of civil society in China? The China Quarterly 198: 330–347.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  82. Times of Zambia. 2011. Zambia: Chinese investments boost nation’s economy. April 4, 2011. Available online: http://allafrica.com/stories/201104050690.html.
  83. Tjønneland, E.N., B. Brandtzæg, Å. Kolås, and G. le Pere. 2006. China in Africa Implications for Norwegian Foreign and Development Policies. Bergen: Chr. Michelsen Institute.Google Scholar
  84. Wagstaff, A., M. Lindelow, J. Gao, L. Xuand J. and C. Qian. 2007. Extending health insurance to the rural population: An impact evaluation of China’s new cooperative medical scheme. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 4150.Google Scholar
  85. Warmerdam, W. 2012. Is China a liberal internationalist? Chinese Journal of International Politics 5(3): 201–243.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. Wen, M. 2009. Averting crisis: A path forward for China’s healthcare system. Issue Briefing from Beijing, March 2009. Washington DC: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.Google Scholar
  87. Wissenbach, U. 2009. The EU’s response to China’s Africa safari: Can triangular cooperation match needs? European Journal of Development Research 21: 662–674.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  88. Wood, B., D. Kabell, N. Muwanga, and F. Sagasti. 2008. Synthesis Report on the First Phase of the Evaluation of the Implementation of the Paris Declaration. Copenhagen: Ministry of Foreign Affairs.Google Scholar
  89. Wood, B., J. Betts, J. Gayfer, D. Kabell, N. Ngwira, F. Sagasti, and M. Samaranayake. 2011. The Evaluation of the Paris Declaration: Main Report. Copenhagen: Danish Institute for International Studies.Google Scholar
  90. World Bank. 2007a. China and the World Bank: A Partnership for Innovation. Washington, DC: World Bank.Google Scholar
  92. World Bank. 2008. Mid-Term Evaluation of China’s 11th Five Year Plan. Washington, DC: World Bank.Google Scholar
  93. You, X.D., and Y. Kobayashi. 2009. The New Cooperative Medical Scheme in China. Health Policy 91(1): 1–9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  94. Zambian Watchdog. 2011. China rejects Clinton’s ‘New Colonialism’ rantings in Zambia. June 13, 2011. Available online: http://www.zambianwatchdog.com/?p=14376.
  95. Zhang, L. X., S. Rozelle, and J. K. Huang. 2007. Poverty alleviation in China: Successes and lessons. The Dragon and the Elephant. Baltimore: The John Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar
  96. Zhang, L.X., H.M. Yiand, and S. Rozelle. 2010a. Good and bad news from China’s New Cooperative Medical Scheme. IDS Bulletin 41(4): 95–106.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  97. Zhang, L.Y., X.M. Cheng, R. Tolhurst, S.L. Tangand, and X.Y. Liu. 2010b. How effectively can the New Cooperative Medical Scheme reduce catastrophic health expenditure for the poor and non-poor in rural China? Tropical Medicine and International Health 15(4): 468–475.Google Scholar
  98. Zhang, X. B and L. X. Sun. 2008. Social security system in rural China: An overview. Chinese Agricultural Transition: Trade, Social and Environmental Impacts. Available online: http://www.catsei.org/contents/75/1138.html.
  99. Zhang, X.B., A. de Haan, and S.G. Fan. 2010c. Narratives of Chinese Economic Reforms: How Does China Cross the River?. Singapore: World Scientific Publishing.Google Scholar
  100. Zhao, Y.Y. 2001. Pivot or periphery? Xinjiang’s regional development. Asian Ethnicity 2(2): 197–224.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  101. Zhou, H. 2008. Chinese overseas assistance and 30 years of “reforming and opening up”. World Economics and Politics 11: 33–43.Google Scholar
  102. Zinyama, F. 2010. Rupiah lists mobile hospitals among projects to be funded by China. The Post Newspapers Zambia. February 28, 2010. Available online: http://www.postzambia.com/post-print_article.php?articleId=6449.

Copyright information

© Fudan University and Springer-Verlag GmbH Berlin Heidelberg 2014

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.ProfundoAmsterdamThe Netherlands
  2. 2.International Institute of Social StudiesErasmus UniversityRotterdamThe Netherlands

Personalised recommendations