Are health nudges coercive?
- 536 Downloads
Governments and policy-makers have of late displayed renewed attention to behavioural research in an attempt to achieve a range of policy goals, including health promotion. In particular, approaches which could be labelled as ‘nudges’ have gained traction with policy-makers. A range of objections to nudging have been raised in the literature. These include claims that nudges undermine autonomy and liberty, may lead to a decrease in responsibility in decision-making, lack transparency, involve deception, and involve manipulation, potentially occasioning coercion. In this article I focus on claims of coercion, examining nudges within two of the main approaches to coercion—the pressure approach and the more recent enforcement approach. I argue that coercion entails an element of control over the behaviour of agents which is not plausibly displayed by the kinds of serious examples of nudges posited in the literature.
KeywordsNudges Coercion Health policy Behavioural research Decision-making
- Amir, O., and O. Lobel. 2008. Stumble, predict, nudge: How behavioral economics informs law and policy. Columbia Law Review 108: 2098–2138.Google Scholar
- Anderson, S. 2010. The enforcement approach to coercion. Journal of Ethics and Social Philosophy 5: 1–31.Google Scholar
- Anderson, S. 2014 Coercion. In Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Spring 2014 Edition, ed. E. N. Zalta. http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2014/entries/coercion/. Retrieved 3 Sept 2014.
- Behavioural Insights Team. 2010. Applying behavioural insights to health. https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/60524/403936_BehaviouralInsight_acc.pdf. Retrieved 3 Sept 2014.
- Behavioural Insights Team. 2013. Applying behavioural insights to organ donation: preliminary results from a randomised controlled trial. http://www.behaviouralinsights.co.uk/publications/applying-behavioural-insights-organ-donation. Retrieved 3 Sept 2014.
- Caloia, B. 2014. Psychic costs and broad learning effects: Locating coercion and threats to autonomy in the use of ‘nudges’ in public policy. http://people.hws.edu/caloia/BroadLearningEffectsandPsychicCosts.pdf. Retrieved 3 Sept 2014.
- Conly, S. 2013b. Against autonomy: Justifying coercive paternalism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Day, P. 1992. Coercive offers do not exist. Philosophical Notes No. 24. http://www.libertarian.co.uk/lapubs/philn/philn024.pdf. Retrieved 3 Sept 2014.
- Feinberg, J. 1986. Harm to self. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Lammond, G. 2013. Coercion. In International encyclopedia of ethics 1–7. West Sussex: Blackwell. doi: 10.1002/9781444367072.wbiee696. http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/9781444367072.wbiee696/abstract. Retrieved 3 Sept 2014.
- Nozick, R. 1969. Coercion. In Philosophy, science, and method: essays in honor of ernest nagel, ed. S. Morgenbesser, P. Suppes, and M. White, 440–472. New York: St. Martin’s Press.Google Scholar
- Pallikkathayil, J. 2011. The possibility of choice: Three accounts of the problem of coercion. Philosophers’ Imprint 11: 1–20.Google Scholar
- Rozin, P., S. Scott, M. Dingle, et al. 2011. Nudge to nobesity I: Minor changes in accessibility decrease food intake. Judgment & Decision Making 6: 323–332.Google Scholar
- Scoccia, D. 2014. Paternalism and manipulation. http://philos.nmsu.edu/files/2014/07/pat-and-manip-2.pdf. Retrieved 3 Sept 2014.
- Steverman, B. 2014. Manipulate me: The booming business in behavioral finance. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-04-07/manipulate-me-the-booming-business-in-behavioral-finance.html. Retrieved 3 Sept 2014.
- Sunstein, C. 2014. Why nudge?. New Haven & London: Yale University Pres.Google Scholar
- Thaler, R.H., and C. Sunstein. 2009. Nudge: Improving decisions about health, wealth, and happiness. London: Penguin Books.Google Scholar
- van Bavel, R., Herrmann, B., Esposito, G., and Proestakis, A. (2013). Applying behavioural sciences to EU policy-making. EUR 26033 EN, 8. ftp://jrc.es/pub/EURdoc/JRC83284.pdf. Retrieved 3 Sept 2014.
- Wertheimer, A. 1987. Coercion. Oxford: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
- White, M.D. 2011. We’ve been nudged: The effects of the downturn on dignity and responsibility. In Consequences of economic downturn: Beyond the usual economics, ed. M.A. Starr, 103–118. New York: Palgrave MacMillan.Google Scholar
- Willis, B.H., and M. Quigley 2014. Opt out organ donation: On evidence and public policy. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 107: 56-60. Google Scholar
- Zimmerman, D. 1981. Coercive wage offers. Philosophy & Public Affairs 10: 121–145.Google Scholar