Periodontal Stem Cells: a Historical Background and Current Perspectives
- 787 Downloads
In this review we discuss the historical perspective of stem cell populations from oral tissues in light of our current understanding of stem cell biology. Stem cells and their niches have been identified in the periodontium starting from the late 1970s. Applying new criteria for the identification and characterization reveals that oral tissues comprise a multipotent primitive neural crest-like stem cell population capable of differentiating into neural crest derived cell lineages of the cranial-facial zone. This population supplies cells to a more restricted stem cell type with tissue specific epigenetic memory that differentiates into cell lineages characteristic of their tissue origin. We believe that the microenvironment plays an essential role in maintaining stem cell populations and directing their migration and differentiation, and that this factor needs to be considered for utilization of stem cell-based therapy for periodontal regeneration and regenerative dental medicine.
KeywordsStem cells Progenitors Stem cell niche Microenvironment Extracellular matrix Stem cell differentiation Oral mucosa Periodontal ligament Gingiva Alveolar bone Cementum Endosteal space Paravascular zone Periodontal regeneration Neural crest
Stem cell biotechnology has become an active research area for the development of novel therapeutic strategies in regenerative dental medicine. Recent advances in stem cell biology have made it possible to identify stem cell niches in the oral/dental tissues, and stem cells have been isolated from dental pulp, periodontal ligament, gingiva and oral mucosa [1•, 2, 3, 4••, 5]. Although these are relatively newer efforts, the concept of a dividing population within periodontal tissues capable of supplying new cells for homeostasis and wound healing is not new. Indeed, the idea was originally conceptualized more than 35 years ago by investigators such as Weiss et al.  and Brunette et al. . Here we review the historical perspective of the evolution of stem cell biology in dental research. We also highlight the importance of interactions between stem cells and their progenies with matrix components available in the microenvironment for their selection and differentiation.
Stem Cells: Definitions and Types
Two important characteristics that distinguish stem cells from other cells are the ability to self-renew without losing development potential, and to give rise to multiple differentiated cell types [8, 9, 10, 11••]. Stem cells can divide for long periods without differentiating, and under certain physiologic or experimental conditions they can be induced to become tissue- or organ-specific cells with special functions. Two major stem cell types are the embryonic stem cells and adult stem cells. The embryonic stem cells are pluripotent and capable of differentiating into cells of the three germ layers in vitro and in vivo, and theoretically can give rise to any cell type of the body. In contrast, adult stem cells are multipotent and they differentiate into a restricted number of cell lineages derived from the same germ layer that gave rise to the specific adult stem cell. The adult stem cells, also called somatic stem cells, are present in virtually all tissues, including muscle and brain. The large majority of these cells are believed to divide relatively slowly in most tissues under homeostatic conditions; however, in tissues such as epithelium in the small intestine they divide at a fast rate and cycle continuously. The slow cycling adult stem cells respond to wounding and stress by cycling faster and dividing asymmetrically to produce tissue-restricted progenitors and differentiated cells in order to replace destroyed cells [10, 11••].
Recently, pluripotency was induced in adult cells, including those from the teeth, by transducing them with the transcription factors Oct4, Sox2, c-Myc and Klf4; these cells, called induced pluripotent stem cells (iPS), are currently under intensive study [12, 13, 14, 15].
Stem Cells of Oral Tissues—a Retrospective Analysis in the Perspective of Current Knowledge
The concept of “stem cells” in adult oral tissues can be traced back to the identification of a subset of cycling populations that possessed self-renewal characteristics with extensive proliferative capacity in epithelial tissues: oral epithelium, junctional epithelium, salivary glands, ectomesenchymally derived tissue lamina propria of the oral mucosa, pulp, and the attachment apparatus of the oral cavity [6, 16, 17, 18, 19]. In the late 1970s and early 1980s, Melcher’s group at the University of Toronto focused on the biology of the periodontium with specific emphasis on the periodontal ligament. This group was the first to culture periodontal ligament cells from porcine premolars and demonstrate that cells located within periodontal ligament explants adjacent to blood vessels incorporate [H3]-thymidine and could migrate to the culture dish, where they further proliferated to form a periodontal ligament cell culture . Almost 40 years later paravascular (or perivascular) cells expressing mesenchymal stem cell markers Stro1 and CD146 have been identified in the human periodontal ligament , demonstrating that the cultures generated by Brunette et al.  comprised, at least in part, stem cells. To the best of our knowledge this was the first attempt to show that the perivascular zone might be the niche for periodontal ligament stem cells, similar to adult mesenchymal stem cells located in bone marrow, fat and other tissues [8, 21, 22, 23]. Melcher's group also found a pool of mitotic cells in the vicinity of blood vessels following wounding of the alveolar bone and periodontal ligament that shifted within the repopulated wound area [24, 25]; this provided evidence for the presence of progenitor/stem cells within the perivascular niche in the periodontal ligament that respond to wounding.
The current paradigm is that tissue specific stem cell populations isolated in vitro should be tested in functional experiments for capacity to develop into the tissue of origin . In 1981, Boyko et al. , possibly influenced by the work of Till and McCulloch , demonstrated that periodontal ligament progenitors isolated by explantation and loaded on the denuded roots in vitro formed new periodontium when implanted in an edentulous ridge in the dog. This was the first controlled functional experiment that provided evidence for the existence of a functional stem cell population within the periodontal ligament in particular, and oral cavity in general, and the first experiment demonstrating the feasibility and benefit of stem cells expanded in vitro for periodontal regeneration.
A hallmark of stem cells is their clonal properties. Approximately 42 % of cultured adult human periodontal ligament cells are clonogenic which could be expanded by over 222 doublings ; therefore, these clones could represent cultured stem cell population of the periodontal ligament. About 20 % of these putative stem cells do not differentiate into mineralized tissue in the presence of dexamethasone unless they were first induced with BMP2 . These observations further support the existence of a primitive multipotent common stem cell for fibroblastic, cementoblastic and osteoblastic lineages in the periodontal ligament.
Advances in the identification and understanding of the biology of mesenchymal (stromal) stem cells in the bone marrow [35, 36] paved the way to the identification and characterization of mesenchymal stem cells from cultures from adult dental pulp  and periodontal ligament . A putative multipotent stem cell population isolated from adult human periodontal ligament by cell sorting, using the perivascular pericyte markers Stro-1 and CD146 differentiates into osteoblastic and adipogenic lineages in vitro [38, 39]; however, when transplanted subcutaneously into immunodeficient mice, this population develops into periodontal-like tissues consisting of a cementum-like tissue, bone and a periodontal like tissue with Sharpey’s fiber inserted into the bone. These findings, in which cells with certain stem cell properties and ability to recapitulate periodontal development in an ectopic site was isolated, strengthen the results and concepts of Melcher’s and McCulloch’s groups.
The Alveolar Bone
Although the kinetic study of McCulloch et al.  pointed to the existence of a cycling population within the endosteal spaces in mice, it is only recently that stromal cells have been isolated from human, canine and murine mandibles and alveolar bone [40, 41, 42]. The stromal alveolar bone marrow cells proliferate faster, have higher capacity to form single cell-derived colonies and differentiate into the osteoblastic lineage in culture relative to bone marrow cells derived from the iliac crest or long bones, but they have lower propensity to differentiate into chondroblastic and adipocytic lineages. When implanted in ectopic sites in immunodeficient mice the stromal alveolar bone marrow cells form bone without the hematopoietic component and with less bone marrow space than the stromal bone marrow cells from long bones or iliac crest. These observations indicate that alveolar bone derived stromal cell cultures are more restricted in their multilineage differentiation potency than non-oral skeleton bone marrow stromal cells. However, they appear to be more potent in new bone formation. Whether the stem/progenitor cells isolated in culture represent the stem cells observed by McCulloch  that migrate from the endosteal spaces through the vascular channels into the periodontal ligament, and possibly contribute to the homeostasis and repair, remains to be elucidated.
The Oral Mucosa
The oral mucosa consists of the oral epithelium and lamina propria. The oral epithelium contains a basal cell layer attached to the basal membrane that comprises a stem cell compartment; this supplies new cells to the overlying epithelial tissue. The nature of the oral epithelium (keratinized or nonkeratinized) is dictated by the lamina propria of the various oral mucosa types—masticatory and lining. The composition and instructive properties of the lamina propria differs in various oral zones indicating heterogeneity in the fibroblast populations [43, 44]. Studies on cell populations of rodent gingival lamina propria indicate the existence of a stem cell/progenitor compartment adjacent to blood vessels  similar to the periodontal ligament and alveolar bone. These cells also exhibit clonal migration. In hamsters, approximately 44 % of the cells in the gingival lamina propria cycle in vivo and in vitro, and upon explantation additional ~39 % start cycling in vitro ; this indicates the existence of a dormant population activated by culture conditions. Clinical observations indicate that incisional and excisional surgical wounds in oral mucosa heal substantially faster than wounds in other connective tissues [47, 48]. These wounds heal by regeneration without scar formation similar to fetal tissues and adult tissues of low vertebrates .
In contrast to other tissues, in healthy subjects with no habits (e.g. smoking), the oral mucosa exhibits marginal signs of aging at the clinical  and cellular levels . The proliferation rate of oral mucosa derived-fibroblasts is not affected by aging . These observations and the findings that fibroblasts of the lamina propria exhibit fetal-like migratory and extracellular matrix (ECM) organization characteristics [48, 52, 53] indicate the existence of a fetal-like population in the lamina propria of the adult oral mucosa which is preserved during adult life. These findings and the hierarchical structure of cell populations [9, 54] further indicate that a primitive, possibly multipotent/pluripotent, population is present at the top of these fetal-like populations. Based on these principles, we have reported the existence of a putative pluripotent population derived from the lamina propria of either the masticatory or lining oral mucosa . Widera et al.  identified Klf4 and c-Myc, two of four transcription factors used to generate iPS, in the human palate, further strengthening the notion of a primitive stem cell population harnessed in the lamina propria of the oral mucosa. These authors also generated a cell population derived from the rat palate capable of forming proliferating neurospheres and expressing neural crest markers, suggestive of neural crest-derived stem cells in the rat oral mucosa. Marynka-Kalmani et al. [4••] provided the first strong evidence for the presence of a primitive neural crest-like stem cell population within the lamina propria of the adult human oral mucosa and gingiva. Apparently, this population—termed human oral mucosa-derived stem cells (hOMSC)—appears to be a mixed population. Approximately 50 % of the hOMSC express the pluripotency associated markers Oct4, Sox2 and Nanog and the embryonic markers SSEA4, Tra2-49 and Tra2-54. The entire population expresses the classical mesenchymal stem cell markers CD29, CD73, CD90 and CD105. When transplanted into immunodeficient SCID mice, the hOMSC develop to most of the tissues known to be derived from the neural crest including bone, cartilage, fat, neural tissues and fibrous tissue. In addition, myogenic and epithelial tissues were also identified. Interestingly, these tissues form a two-lineage teratoma-like structure reminiscent of the true three-lineage teratoma formed by embryonic stem cells transplanted into scid mice. The hOMSC are highly clonogenic (1 out of 1.7 cells give rise to clones); therefore these are likely to be stem cells [4••]. Davies et al.  also demonstrated the neural crest origin of clonogenic cells derived from lamina propria of the oral mucosa and their multipotent differentiation into mesenchymal and neuroectodermal cell lineages. However, several other studies have reported that mesenchymal stem cells transplanted on hydroxyapatite/tricalcium phosphate into nude mice develop only into fibrous tissue . These apparently contracting data can be explained by the existence of two different populations in expandable cells isolated from the gingiva: (1) a primitive multipotent neural crest like population [4••, 57]; (2) a less potent and more restricted mesenchymal stromal population  reminiscent of transient amplifying cells. This notion has been recently addressed by Xu et al. , who demonstrated by lineage tracing that two such populations co-exist in the gingiva and that the neural crest-derived population cycles and forms the majority of the clonogenic cells in vitro. Notably, mesenchymal stem cells isolated from adult human pulp and periodontal ligament [2, 37, 60] develop into dentin-pulp complex, cementum and periodontal ligament-like tissues, respectively. On the other hand, both pulp and periodontal ligament stem cells express neural crest properties [61, 62] and exhibit a high propensity to differentiate into neural lineages [60, 63], indicating the existence of a primitive neural crest-like stem cell population in the pulp and periodontal ligament. Collectively, these data show that the mesenchymal stem cells isolated from oral tissues based on Stro-1 and CD146 expression represent a restricted and less potent stem/progenitor cell population that proliferates faster in culture but retains tissue-specific epigenetic memory.
Stem Cell Niche and Stem Cell Differentiation
In vivo, stem cells reside in specific microenvironments or niches that maintain their ground base status, “stemness”. Within their niche, stem cells are normally believed to divide asymmetrically into a new stem cell (self-renewal) and a committed progenitor with restricted developmental potential and closer to its final fate. In Drosophila and Caenorhabditis elegans a single population of germ cells resides in a single niche  cycling constantly until nutritionally challenged; in contrast, in higher organisms stem cells reside in tissue-specific niches in an actively growing or quiescent state [11••].
The fate of the stem cells is determined by many factors, which include polypeptide mediators, microenvironment, tensional forces and interaction with other cells [65, 66, 67, 68]. The polypeptide mediators are the major agonists that determine, regulate and direct cell functions, and this family includes growth factors, cytokines and lymphokines. However, how the cells respond to these molecules depends upon their microenvironment. The microenvironment of the niche regulates stem cell survival and renewal, and it also regulates their differentiation at the destination site. It consists of the ECM and molecules that remain bound to and associated with it. The ECM is a three-dimensional structure composed of collagens, fibronectin, elastin, laminin and other noncollagenous proteins and proteoglycans, and it serves as substratum for cell adhesion, promotes cell spreading and cytoskeletal organization [65, 66, 69]. More importantly, it determines the outcome of a cell’s response to agonists by regulating the expression of genes for growth factors, receptors, transcription factors and other proteins. For example, in the presence of ECM cell division is suppressed and cells differentiate [65, 66, 69]. The ECM, through its constituent collagen types and adhesive and anti-adhesive proteins, can selectively recruit specific cell types and exclude others from among a population of stem/progenitor cells and mesenchymal cell subtypes [66, 70, 71, 72, 73•].
The molecular interactions and signaling cues between stem cells and their niches have been studied for some tissues, such as the hair follicle, intestinal crypt and bone marrow [11••, 74]. In these tissues, cycling and quiescent stem cells are located in discrete niches/zones. The niches provide a microenvironment with stimulatory or inhibitory stimuli. For example, bone marrow contains hematopoietic stems cells (HSC) and mesenchymal stem cells (MSC). There are two niches for HSCs: (1) the osteoblastic niche containing quiescent HSCs in the endosteal region, and (2) the vascular niche located in the central marrow region and containing active HSCs . The osteoblastic niche supports and maintains the HSCs, regulates hematopoiesis, and provides a microenvironment for quiescence, whereas the vascular niche promotes proliferation and further differentiation, and serves as a backup niche for HSC expansion. The endosteal zone is composed of osteoblastic, vascular, CXCL12 abundant reticular (CAR) cells and osteoclasts, and the signals are largely inhibitory through Wnt-off/BMP-on signaling that promote quiescence. In contrast, the central marrow region is without osteoblastic signals and is growth stimulatory mediated chiefly by Wnt, FGF and SDF1. In general BMP, osteopontin and sFRP1 signals are inhibitory while Wnt signals and noggin promote an active state [11••]. Stem cell regulation also involves apoptosis signaling .
The signals involved in the crosstalk between the stem cell populations and their niche and those controlling the migration and differentiation of various cell lineages within the periodontal ligament and gingiva are unknown. Very little is also known about the nature and role of the microenvironment. Recent findings indicate that epithelial cell rests of Malassez (ERM) retain stem cell properties and possibly secrete and respond to soluble factors in the adult periodontium [76, 77, 78]. It would be of interest to determine whether morphological and functional interactions exist between the ERM and stem cell niche in the periodontal ligament. It is also likely that fibroblastic populations in the periodontal ligament form the niche is required for the maintenance of ERM in the adult periodontal tissues.
Another intriguing question is about the mechanisms that instruct a stem cell to leave the paravascular niche and migrate towards the cementum and bone. A gradient of chemotactic factors are possibly involved in this process. Evidence indicates that cementum proteins in combination with BMP2 are possible soluble factors involved in the chemotaxis and differentiation to cementoblastic lineage (Fig. 1) [33, 34, 66, 79, 80, 81, 82, 83].
The stem cells niche in the gingiva has been recently located to cord-like structure comprising cells positive to the neural crest marker p75 and to pluripotency associated markers Oct4 and Nanog [4••]. Nestin positive cells are located in the subepithelial papillae of the palatal rugae in Meissner Corpuscles and Merkel cell-neurite complexes and in apical papilla of immature permanent teeth [56, 84]. These cells bear properties of multipotent stem cells indicating the presence of stem cells in a neural related niche. Under physiological microenvironment, the gingival stem cells differentiate into the “fibroblastic lineages” of the gingiva [43, 85]. However, after release from their niche the remote microenvironment containing cementum attachment protein appears to influence these cells to form a mineralized-like structure and express cementoblastic /osteoblastic markers (our unpublished data). When transplanted into immunocompromised mice these cells form a cementum-like tissue with ECM characteristic of the cementum . These observations underscore the crucial role played by the microenvironment in the selective recruitment of stem/progenitor cells, their expansion and subsequent differentiation [65, 66, 73•].
Conclusion and Future Perspectives
Although pluripotent embryonic stem cells are the cells of choice because of their therapeutic plasticity, adult stem-/progenitor cells from the same tissue are preferable to avoid ethical and legal issues because these are closer to the differentiative target, and they can be obtained from same patients. It is now clear that the main component necessary for regeneration of oral tissues, the cells—stem cells or progenitors—are available in the local niches. What appears lacking is the needed local microenvironment, which is destroyed by injury and not restored during the wound healing process. Therefore, if the reservoir of stem cells capable of regenerating the destroyed tissues is sufficiently large, finding ways to recruit these cells and control their differentiation and lineage commitment in time and space is the next challenge for periodontal and tooth regeneration research. The oral mucosa heals by regeneration, indicating that, similar to liver, its regenerative capacity is preserved in the adult. This occurs even though wounding of the oral mucosa takes place in a bacterially contaminated environment. We need to gain further insight into the molecular and cellular mechanisms that govern wound healing in the oral mucosa and apply this knowledge to periodontal and pulp-dentin complex wound healing. These challenges are also relevant for regenerative medicine in general. However, controlling the spatial-temporal behavior of stem cells in the wound healing environment might prove a difficult task. Advances in the biology of oral stem cells teach us that all the oral tissues comprise pools of multipotent stem cells with high level of plasticity. Thus, obtaining stem cells from one or more of these tissues, delivering them at the right time and place and manipulating them in vitro to the desired stage of differentiation is a feasible task capable of opening new horizons in the field of oral/dental and periodontal regenerative medicine.
We thank Rina Kazakov for her help in preparing this review. This work was supported by the US-Israel Binational Foundation, grant no. 2011017, Israeli Science Foundation grants 646/09 and 384/13, and NIH grants DE 13069, DE-08229, DE-013061 and DE39584.
Compliance with Ethics Guidelines
Conflict of Interest
Dr. Sandu Pitaru and Dr. Sandra Treves-Manusevitz received grants from BSF (#2011017, 646/09 and 384/13).
Dr. Sampath Narayanan and Dr. Anusha Etikala, received grants from NIH (DE 13069, DE-08229, DE-013061, and DE39584).
Human and Animal Rights and Informed Consent
This article does not contain any studies with human or animal subjects performed by any of the authors.
Papers of particular interest, published recently, have been highlighted as: • Of importance •• Of major importance
- 1.•Estrela C, Alencar AH, Kitten GT, Vencio EF, Gava E. Mesenchymal stem cells in the dental tissues: perspectives for tissue regeneration. Braz Dent J. 2011;22:91–8. This review provides a historical evolution of stem cells from various dental tissues and their prospective use in regenerative dental medicine.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 4.••Marynka-Kalmani K, Treves S, Yafee M, Rachima H, Gafni Y, Cohen MA, et al. The lamina propria of adult human oral mucosa harbors a novel stem cell population. Stem Cells. 2010;28:984–95. This is the first comprehensive report demonstrating that the human adult oral mucosa harbors a primitive stem cell population with neural crest characteristics capable of giving rise to cell lineages derived from the cephalic neural crest.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- 5.Bartold PM, Shi S, Gronthos S. Stem cells and periodontal regeneration. Periodontology 2000. 2006;40:164–72.Google Scholar
- 11.••Li L, Clovers H. Coexistence of quiescent and active adult stem cells in mammals. Science. 2010;327:542–5. This article describes how pools of stem cells are maintained in quiescent and active states in niches of different tissues and discusses the molecular signals involved.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 22.Bianco P, Cao X, Frenette PS, et al. The meaning, the sense and the significance: translating the science of mesenchymal stem cells into medicine. Nat Med. 2013;13:31–42.Google Scholar
- 55.Marynka K, Treves S, Pitaru S. Human oral mucosa is highly enriched with pluripotent stem cells. Presented at the Sixth ISSCR Annual Meeting. Philadelphia, PA, 2008.Google Scholar
- 73.•Greenbaum LE, Wells RG. The role of stem cells in liver repair and fibrosis. Int J Biochem Cell Biol. 2011;43:222–9. This review highlights the cellular and functional plasticity of stem/progenitor cell niche in the liver, and the role of the cross-talk between these cells and other cells, especially myofibroblasts, and matrix in regeneration and fibrosis.PubMedCentralPubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 78.Xiong J, Gronthos S, Bartold PM. Role of the epithelial cell rests of Malassez in the development, maintenance and regeneration of periodontal ligament tissues. Periodontol 2000. 2013;63:217–33.Google Scholar