Advertisement

The fiction of democracy in FIFA’s governance of football and the case of Football Federation Australia

  • Lloyd FreeburnEmail author
Article

Abstract

In its governance of football, FIFA claims to be democratic. In addition, FIFA purports to apply standards of democracy to its members. This article examines the nature and validity of the basis of these claims to democratic legitimacy. In particular, it considers the application of the principles of representative democracy within the governance of football by reference to the governance structure of FIFA and by reference to the example of one of its members, Football Federation Australia. It is argued that the governance structure of FIFA is not democratic, notwithstanding the associations’ pretensions to democracy, and that fundamental reform is required to make both FIFA and its member associations democratic.

Keywords

Football Governance Democracy Legitimacy FIFA International federations 

Notes

References

Journal Articles

  1. Black J (1996) Constitutionalising self-regulation. Mod Law Rev 59:24CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Black J (2008) Constructing and contesting legitimacy and accountability in polycentric regulatory regimes. Regul Gov 2:137CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Blackshaw I (2009) Arbitration: olympic athlete consent to CAS arbitration. World Sports Law Rep 7(11):6Google Scholar
  4. Bodansky D (1999) The legitimacy of international governance: a coming challenge for international environmental law. Am Soc Int Law 93:596CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Buchanan A, Keohane RO (2006) The legitimacy of global governance institutions. Eth Int Aff 20:405CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Coleman JL (2007) Beyond the separability thesis: moral semantics and the methodology of jurisprudence. Oxf J Leg Stud 27:581CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Collingwood V (2006) Non-governmental organisations, power and legitimacy in international society. Rev Int Stud 32:439CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Cooke CA (1936) Legal rule and economic function: competition and restraint of trade. Econ J 46(181):21CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Duval A (2013) Lex sportiva: a playground for transnational law. Eur Law J 19:822CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Geeraert et al (2014) Int J Sport Policy Polit 6(3):281–282CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Houlihan B (2004) Civil rights, doping control and the world anti-doping code. Sport Soc 7:420CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Jong-Sung Y, Khagram S (2005) A comparative study of inequality and corruption. Am Sociolog Rev 70(1):136CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Kolstad I, Wiig A (2016) Does democracy reduce corruption? Democratization 23:1198CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Loveless M, Whitefield S (2011) Being unequal and seeing inequality: explaining the political significance of social inequality in new market democracies. Eur J Political Res 50:239CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Pilon R (1993) Freedom, responsibility, and the constitution: on recovering our founding principles. Notre Dame Law Rev 68:510Google Scholar
  16. Roughan N (2016) Mind the gaps: authority and legality in international law. The Eur J Int Law 27:329CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Schultz T (2011) The concept of law in transnational arbitral legal orders and some of its consequences. J Int Dis Settl 2:59CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Shapiro S (2002) Authority. In: Coleman J, Shapiro S (eds) The Oxford Handbook of Jurisprudence and Philosophy of Law. Oxford University Press, Oxford, p 385Google Scholar
  19. Silance L (1977) Interaction of the rules in sports law and the laws and treaties made by public authorities. Olym Rev 120:618Google Scholar
  20. van Kleef R (2014) The legal status of disciplinary regulations in sport. Int Sports Law J 14:24–28Google Scholar
  21. Verheyden D (2010) The organization of sports in France. Int Sports Law J 1/2:27Google Scholar
  22. Weatherill S (2005) Is the pyramid compatible with EC law? Int Sports Law J 3-4:3Google Scholar

Other Articles

  1. AAP (2018) FIFA poised to intervene in Australian football governance war. Fox Sports, 2 October 2018Google Scholar
  2. AAP (2015) Steven lowy defends route to succeeding his father as FFA Chairman. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/football/2015/nov/18/steven-lowy-defends-route-to-succeeding-his-father-as-ffa-chairman
  3. Associated Press (2017) Pakistan hit by FIFA suspension over government interferenceGoogle Scholar
  4. Blatter JS, Valke J (2010) Why standard statutes are needed? FIFAGoogle Scholar
  5. Doldge M, Carter TF (2015) How UEFA could leave FIFA and launch its own World Cup. The Convers. http://theconversation.com/how-uefa-could-leave-fifa-and-launch-its-own-world-cup-42629
  6. Guardian Sport (2018) Football Federation Australia governance stoush resolved after two-year struggle. The GuardianGoogle Scholar
  7. Heinrich F (2017) Corruption and inequality: How populists mislead people. Transpar Int. http://www.transparency.org/news/feature/corruption_and_inequality_how_populists_mislead_people
  8. Infantino G (2017) FIFA president, quoted by Sam Borden, Gianni Infantino blasts “fake news” as he defends “democratic” FIFA, ESPN. http://www.espn.com/soccer/blog-fifa/story/3123708/gianni-infantino-blasts-fake-news-as-he-defends-democratic-fifa
  9. Kerr J (2016) FIFA pushes for football federation Australia reform. The Saturday Paper, 24Google Scholar
  10. Lynch J (2018) Ahead of Tuesday’s vote, FFA breaks down objections to CRWG reforms, The Daily Football Show. https://dailyfootballshow.com/ahead-of-tuesday-vote-ffa-breaks-down-objections-to-crwg-reforms/
  11. Marcuccitti P (2015) The problem with FIFA? Democracy. InDailyGoogle Scholar
  12. Mungiu-Pippidi A (2015) If FIFA were a country. Open Democracy. https://www.opendemocracy.net/can-europe-make-it/alina-mungiu-pippidi/if-fifa-were-country
  13. Nightingale E (2015) A critical analysis of the relationship between democracy and corruption. E-Int Relat StudGoogle Scholar
  14. On-side Law (2015) Has democracy failed FIFA?. On-side Law. https://www.onsidelaw.co.uk/has-democracy-failed-fifa/
  15. Onside Law (2017) Has democracy failed FIFA. https://www.onsidelaw.co.uk/has-democracy-failed-fifa/
  16. Siciliano L, Jamieson S (2016) FIFA: a timeline of corruption—in 90 Seconds. The Telegraph (UK)Google Scholar
  17. Stensholt J (2015) Frank lowy passes to son Steven as he blows whistle on soccer. Financ Rev. https://www.afr.com/business/sport/frank-lowy-passes-to-son-steven-as-he-blows-whistle-on-soccer-20151112-gkxc7g
  18. Verba S (2001) Political equality: What is? Why do we want it? Review Paper for Russell Sage Foundation, p 2. https://www.russellsage.org/sites/all/files/u4/Verba.pdf

Books

  1. Anderson J (2010) Modern sports law. Hart PublishingGoogle Scholar
  2. Atiyah PS (1979) The rise and fall of freedom of contract. Clarendon Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  3. Atiyah PS, Smith SA (2005) Atiyah’s introduction to the law of contract. Clarendon Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  4. Chitty J, Beale HG (2012) Chitty on contracts, 31st ed. Sweet & MaxwellGoogle Scholar
  5. Coleman J, Shapiro S (2002) The Oxford handbook of jurisprudence and philosophy of law. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  6. Cormick NM (2007) Institutions of law. Oxford University Press, Oxford, p 223CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Cutler AC (2003) Private power and global authority: transnational merchant law in the global political economy. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, p 242CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Dahl RA (2006) On political equality. Yale University Press, New HavenGoogle Scholar
  9. Dunlop T (2018) The future of everything. New South PublishingGoogle Scholar
  10. Dworkin R (1993) Life’s dominion: an argument about abortion, euthanasia, and individual freedom. KnopfGoogle Scholar
  11. Dworkin R (2000) Sovereign virtue: the theory and practice of equality. Harvard University PressGoogle Scholar
  12. Focarelli C (2012) International law as social construct: the struggle for global justice. Oxford University Press, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Freeburn L (2018) Regulating international sport. Brill NijhoffGoogle Scholar
  14. Gardiner S et al. (2012) Sports law, 4th ed. RoutledgeGoogle Scholar
  15. Holmes S (1993) The anatomy of antiliberalism. Harvard University PressGoogle Scholar
  16. Jennings A (2015) The dirty game. CenturyGoogle Scholar
  17. Lewis A, Taylor J (2014) Sport: law and practice, 3rd ed. Bloomsbury ProfessionalGoogle Scholar
  18. M Elliott (2001) The constitutional foundations of judicial review. Hart PublishingGoogle Scholar
  19. Furmston MP (2006) Cheshire, Fifoot and Furmston’s law of contract, 15th ed. Oxford University Press: OxfordGoogle Scholar
  20. Macedo S (1991) Liberal virtues: citizenship, virtue, and community in liberal constitutionalism. Clarendon PressGoogle Scholar
  21. Mill JS (1859) On liberty. Yale University Press, New HavenGoogle Scholar
  22. Mueller JE (1999) Capitalism, democracy, and Ralph’s pretty good grocery. Princeton University Press: PrincetonGoogle Scholar
  23. Mulgan R (2003) Holding power to account: accountability in modern democracies. Palgrave MacmillanGoogle Scholar
  24. Nafziger JAR (2004) International sports law, 2nd ed. Transnational PublishersGoogle Scholar
  25. Nagel T (1991) Equality and partiality. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  26. Orwell G (1945) Animal farmGoogle Scholar
  27. Paterson J, Robertson R, Duke A (2012) Principles of contract law. Thomson Reuters (Professional), 3rd edGoogle Scholar
  28. Phillips A (1998) The politics of presence. Oxford University Press, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Rawls J (1971) A theory of justice. Belknap PressGoogle Scholar
  30. Rawls J (2005) Political liberalism. Columbia University PressGoogle Scholar
  31. Raz J (1989) The morality of freedom, vol 23. Oxford Scholarship OnlineGoogle Scholar
  32. Rothstein B (2011) The quality of government. University of Chicago Press, ChicagoCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Samuel G (2010) Law of obligations. Edward ElgarGoogle Scholar
  34. Sen A (1999) Development as freedom. KnopfGoogle Scholar
  35. Sorensen G (2007) Democracy and democratisation: processes and prospects in a changing world, 3rd edn. RoutledgeGoogle Scholar
  36. Uslaner EM (2008) Corruption, inequality and the rule of lawGoogle Scholar
  37. Vekas L (1986) Landmarks in the development of the contractual system. Akademiai KiadoGoogle Scholar
  38. Wade SW and Forsyth (2019) Administrative Law. Oxford University Press, Oxford, p 4Google Scholar
  39. Woolf LH et al. (2013) De Smith’s judicial review. Sweet and MaxwellGoogle Scholar

Book Chapters

  1. Banakas S (2006) The constitutionalisation of private law in the UK: is there an emperor inside the new clothes? In: Tom B, Siewert L (eds) Constitutionalisation of private law. Koninklijke Brill, p 83Google Scholar
  2. Bourg JF, Gouguet J-J (2007) Sport and globalisation: sport as a global public good. In: Andreff W, Szymanski S Handbook on the economics of sport. Edward ElgarGoogle Scholar
  3. Brownsword R (2010) General considerations. In: Michael F (ed) The law of contract, 4th edn. LexisNexisGoogle Scholar
  4. Buchanan A (2010) The legitimacy of international law. In: Samantha and John TB (ed) Philosophy of international law. Oxford University Press, p 79Google Scholar
  5. Perry S (2013) Political authority and political obligation. In: Leslie G, Brian L (eds) Oxford studies in philosophy of law. Oxford University Press, vol 2, 1Google Scholar
  6. Smith SA (2000) Towards a theory of contract. In: Jeremy H (ed) Oxford Essays in Jurisprudence, 4th edn. Oxford University Press, Oxford, p 107Google Scholar
  7. Smits JM (2006) Private law and fundamental rights: a sceptical view. In: Tom B, Siewert L (eds) Constitutionalisation of private law. Koninklijke Brill, p 9Google Scholar

Cases

  1. Abbott v Sullivan [1952] 1 KB 189 (CA)Google Scholar
  2. AEK Athens v UEFA CAS 98/200, award of 20 August 1988, Digest of CAS Awards II 1998-2000 (Kluwer, 2002) 38Google Scholar
  3. Anthony v Syracuse University 224 App Div 487, 231 NY Supp 435 (1928)Google Scholar
  4. Australian Football League v Carlton Football Club [1998] 2 VR 546Google Scholar
  5. Byrne v Kinematograph Renters Society Ltd [1958] 1 WLR 762 (Ch)Google Scholar
  6. Canas v ATP Tour 4P.172/2006 (2007) (Swiss Federal Tribunal) ATF 133 III 235, translated in 1 Swiss Int’l Arb L Rep 65Google Scholar
  7. Clements v Racing Victoria Limited (Occupational and Business Regulation) [2010] VCAT 1144Google Scholar
  8. Davis v Carew-Pole & Others [1956] 1 WLR 833 (QB)Google Scholar
  9. Doyle v White City Stadium Ltd [1935] 1 KB 110Google Scholar
  10. Eastham v Newcastle United Football Club Ltd [1964] Ch 413, 438Google Scholar
  11. Elizabeth Hospital Inc v Richardson 167 F Supp 155 (WD Ark 1958), aff’d 269 F 2d 167 (8th Cir), cert denied 361 US 884 (1959)Google Scholar
  12. Forbes and Bundock v Australian Yachting Federation Inc (1996) 131 FLR 241Google Scholar
  13. International Skating Union v Claudia Pechstein, German Federal Court of Justice, judgment of 7 June 2016, KZR 6/15Google Scholar
  14. Law v National Greyhound Racing Club Ltd [1983] 1 WLR 1302Google Scholar
  15. Lawson v Hewell 118 Cal 613, 50 Pac 763 (1897)Google Scholar
  16. Lee v Showmens Guild [1952] 2 QB 329Google Scholar
  17. Mayer v Journeymen Stonecutters’ Ass’n 47 NJ Eq 519, 20 Atl 492 (Ch 1890)Google Scholar
  18. McClelland v Burning Palms Surf Life Saving Club [2002] NSWSC 470; (2002) 191 ALR 759Google Scholar
  19. Nagle v Feilden [1966] 2 QB 633Google Scholar
  20. Pechstein and Mutu v Switzerland, ECHR, 2 October 2018, nos 40575/10 et 67474/10 (‘Mutu and Pechstein’)Google Scholar
  21. R (on the Application of Mullins) v Appeal Board of the Jockey Club [2005] EWHC 2197 (Admin)Google Scholar
  22. R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board; Ex parte Lain [1967] 2 QB 864Google Scholar
  23. R v Disciplinary Committee of the Jockey Club; Ex parte Aga Kahn [1993] 1 WLR 909, CAGoogle Scholar
  24. R v Football Association of Wales; Ex parte Flint Town United Football Club [1991] COD 44Google Scholar
  25. R v Jockey Club; Ex parte RAM Racecourses Ltd [1993] 2 All ER 225Google Scholar
  26. Shearson Lehman Hutton Inc v Maclaine Watson & Co Ltd [1989] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 570Google Scholar
  27. Wilander v Tobin [1997] 2 CMLR 346Google Scholar

Other

  1. Commission of the European Communities (2007) White paper on sportGoogle Scholar
  2. European Commission (2011) Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions—Developing the European Dimension in SportGoogle Scholar
  3. European Commission (1998) The European model of sport. Consultation Document of DG XGoogle Scholar
  4. Federation International de Football Association (xxxx) Regulations governing the admission of associations to FIFA. https://resources.fifa.com/mm/document/tournament/competition/01/11/80/00/regulationsgoverningtheadmissionofassociationstofifa_efsd_neutral.pdf
  5. Federation International de Football Association (2007) Standard Electoral Code. https://resources.fifa.com/image/upload/standard-electoral-code-671785.pdf?cloudid=hmibzu4ifupjffao2gor
  6. Football Federation Australia (2018) Message from FFA board to Australian football community—information statement to members. https://www.ffa.com.au/news/message-ffa-board-australian-football-community-information-statement-members
  7. FIFA (2008) Professional football player contract minimum requirements. In: FIFA Circular no. 1171Google Scholar
  8. FIFA (2018) FIFA statement of congress review working group (CRWG)Google Scholar
  9. FIFA (2019) FIFA’s Bureau of the council establishes congress review working group for football federation AustraliaGoogle Scholar
  10. FIFA (2015) Regulations 2018 FIFA world cup RussiaGoogle Scholar
  11. FIFA (2017) Statement concerning football federation AustraliaGoogle Scholar
  12. Football Federation Australia (2018) Board information statement and recommendation to membersGoogle Scholar
  13. Football Federation Australia (2018) Board information statement and recommendation to membersGoogle Scholar
  14. Football Federation Australia (2018) ConstitutionGoogle Scholar
  15. Football Federation Northern Territory Incorporated (2011) Constitution. http://www.footballnt.com.au/365_docs/attachments/protarea/1310-503f161d.pdf
  16. Football Federation SA Incorporated (2012) Constitution. https://www.ffsa.com.au/sites/ffsa/files/2018-08/FFSAConstitution2017.pdf
  17. Football Federation Tasmania Limited (2009) Constitution. https://footballfedtas.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/FFT-Constitution.pdf
  18. Football Federation Victoria Incorporated (2016) Constitution. http://www.footballfedvic.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/FFV-Constitution-March16.pdf
  19. Football Internationale de Football (2018) StatutesGoogle Scholar
  20. IOC (2008) Basic Universal principles of good governance of the olympic and sports movement. In: Seminar of autonomy of olympic and sport movementGoogle Scholar
  21. Joint Statement by Football Federation Australia Congress Members & PFA. 30 September 2018Google Scholar
  22. Roitman F, David G (2018) Governance structures at national association level. CIES Sports IntellGoogle Scholar
  23. Sport Australia (2018) Comment on FFA governance reform. https://www.sportaus.gov.au/media_centre/news/comment_on_ffa_governance_reform
  24. Sport Australia (2018) Comment on FFA governance reformGoogle Scholar
  25. Sport Australia (xxxx) What is sport Australia? https://www.sportaus.gov.au/sportaus/about
  26. Sport England, UK Sport (2016) A code for sports governanceGoogle Scholar
  27. Statement from the Board of Football Federation Australia. Media Release, 2 October 2018Google Scholar
  28. United Nations Educational, Scientific and cultural organization (2013) Mineps V Declaration of Berlin. http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0022/002211/221114e.pdf
  29. United Nations (1948) Universal declaration of human rights. http://www.un.org/en/universal-declaration-human-rights/index.html

Copyright information

© T.M.C. Asser Instituut 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.St KildaAustralia
  2. 2.University of MelbourneCarltonAustralia

Personalised recommendations