Advertisement

The International Sports Law Journal

, Volume 16, Issue 1–2, pp 82–98 | Cite as

Egg-shell skulls or institutional negligence? The liability of World Rugby for incidents of concussion suffered by professional players in England and Ireland

  • Richard BunworthEmail author
Article

Abstract

The number of incidents of concussion in professional rugby union is increasing steadily. In the English Rugby Premiership, concussion was the most frequent injury suffered by professional players in each of the last 3 seasons. Further, there is developing evidence of a link between suffering repeated concussions and chronic traumatic encephalopathy, a degenerative brain disease. World Rugby’s principal response to the growing problem of concussion in rugby has been through the introduction of the Pitch Side Concussion Assessment and the Return to Play protocols. Few amendments have been made to the playing rules of the sport with the express intention of reducing the frequency with which concussions occur. The article explores whether World Rugby could be found to owe professional rugby players a duty of care under the laws of negligence in England and Ireland. The article then goes on to examine if World Rugby could be found to have acted negligently in its response to the issue of concussion, through the adoption of its concussion management rules and its failure to amend the playing rules of the sport in an attempt to prevent concussions from occurring. Following this, the article analyses the difficulty which a potential plaintiff would face in establishing causation in a negligence action against World Rugby. The article concludes with suggested changes which World Rugby could implement to lessen the possibility of a finding that it has acted negligently in relation to players’ safety.

Keywords

Negligence Duty of care Liability Concussion Rugby Governing body 

References

Books and journal articles

  1. Bachynski K, Goldberg D (2014) Youth sports & public health: framing risks of mild traumatic brain injury in American Football and Ice Hockey. J Law Med Ethics 42:323CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Baugh C et al (2014) Perceived coach support and concussion symptom-reporting: differences between freshmen and non-freshmen college football players. J Law Med Ethics 42:314CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Bird et al (2001) The New Zealand rugby injury and performance project. VI. A prospective cohort study of risk factors for injury in rugby union football. Br J Sports Med 35(3):157–166CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Edwards J, Bodle J (2014) Causes and consequences of sports concussion. J Law Med Ethics 42:128CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Gavett B, Stern R, McKee A (2011) Chronic traumatic encephalopathy: a potential late effect of sport-related concussive and subconcussive trauma. Clin Sports Med 30:179–188CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. George J (2002) Watson v British Board of Boxing Control: negligent rule-making in the court of appeal. Mod Law Rev 65:106–119CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Goldberg D (2009) Concussion, professional sports, and conflicts of interest: why the National Football League’s Current Policies are bad for its (players’) Herald. HEC Forum 20(337–355):4Google Scholar
  8. Greenfield S et al (2015) Reconceptualising the standard of care in sport: the case of youth rugby in England and South Africa. 18 Potchefstroom elec. L.J. 2183 2015Google Scholar
  9. Jones M, Dugdale A, Simpson M (2014) Clerk & Lindsell on Torts, 21st edn. Sweet & Maxwell Ltd, UKGoogle Scholar
  10. Kirby J (2015) Employers’ liability and concussive injury in professional rugby union: the application of health and safety legislation to concussive injury in professional rugby union in the UK and Ireland. ESLJ 13:18Google Scholar
  11. Lewis A, Talyor J (2014) Sport: Law and Practice, 3rd edn. Bloomsbury Publishing, UKGoogle Scholar
  12. McCrory P, Meeuwisse WH, Aubry M et al (2013) Consensus statement on concussion in sport: the 4th international conference on concussion in sport held in Zurich, November 2012. Br J Sports Med 47:250–258Google Scholar
  13. McMahon B, Binchy W (2013) Law of Torts, 4th edn. Bloomsbury Publishing, UKGoogle Scholar
  14. Omalu B et al (2005) Chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) in a National Football League player. Neurosurgery 57:128–134CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Reade D (2014) What impact will the studies into concussion have on the risk of litigation from rugby players? LawInSport. Published 19 Sept 2014Google Scholar
  16. Robeson R, King N (2014) Loss of possession: concussions, informed consent, and autonomy. J Law Med Ethics 42:334CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Sade R (2014) Brain science in the 21st century: clinical controversies and ethical and legal implications. J Law Med Ethics 42:124CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Savage J et al (2013) The incidence of concussion in a professional australian Rugby league team, 1998–2012. J Sports Med 2013:304576CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Slobounov S et al (2007) Differential rate of recovery in athletes after first and second concussion episodes. Neurosurgery 61(2):338–344CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Online articles

  1. Carolan, Student awarded €2.75 m over rugby match brain injury. http://www.irishtimes.com/news/crime-and-law/student-awarded-2-75m-over-rugby-match-brain-injury-1.1736310. March 2014
  2. Doward, Rugby World Cup organisers hope new safety rules will broaden sport’s appeal, http://www.theguardian.com/sport/2015/sep/13/rugby-world-cup-new-rules-braoden-appeal-scrum-changes. September 2015
  3. English Professional Rugby Injury Surveillance Report 2013–14Google Scholar
  4. Enhancements Made To Pitchside Head Injury Assessment Process (May 2014). http://www.irishrugby.ie/news/31851.php#.Vq_x4Mf3dHg. Accessed 15 Jan 2016
  5. Frank Warren column: Only boxing has got its head round concussion problem (January 2015). http://www.independent.co.uk/sport/general/boxing/frank-warren-column-only-boxing-has-got-its-head-round-concussion-problem-9981269.html. Accessed 12 Feb 2016
  6. Head Injury Assessment Adopted Into World Rugby Law (Mary 2015). http://www.irishrugby.ie/news/34606.php#.VrG8-tInzow. Accessed Jan 2016
  7. IRB Members not Sold on Controversial PSCA, http://www.superxv.com/40865/13/irb-members-not-sold-on-controversial-pcsa#.VrJ2AMf3dHg.November 2013
  8. Johnson, Concussion in rugby no longer a ‘badge of honour’, http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/2/8e165cc4-2637-11e5-bd83-71cb60e8f08c.html#axzz3yxoLRbyt.September 2015
  9. McGeady, Suspected Concussion Stats From the Ulster Bank League, http://www.andymcgeady.com/suspected-concussion-stats-from-the-ulster-bank-league/.September 2015
  10. Rossingh, Rugby Is Having an NFL Moment as Concussions Bring Legal Scrutiny, http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-03-20/rugby-is-having-an-nfl-moment-as-concussions-bring-legal-scrutiny. March 2015
  11. Rumsby, Rugby World Cup 2015: World Rugby planning law change to cut concussion risk http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/rugbyunion/rugby-world-cup/11878932/Rugby-World-Cup-2015-World-Rugby-planning-law-change-to-cut-concussion-risk.html. Accessed 7 Jan 2016
  12. World Rugby confirms closed law trial programme, http://www.worldrugby.org/news/90108

Copyright information

© T.M.C. Asser Instituut 2016

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.DublinIreland

Personalised recommendations