The ActivityStat Hypothesis
The ActivityStat hypothesis suggests that when physical activity is increased or decreased in one domain, there will be a compensatory change in another domain, in order to maintain an overall stable level of physical activity or energy expenditure over time. The ActivityStat debate is gaining momentum in the literature and most of the research to date is based on observational studies.
The objective of this paper is to conceptually clarify the ActivityStat hypothesis and to examine the experimental research aiming to demonstrate or refute compensation using a systematic review process.
A systematic review was conducted using electronic database searches with the aim of detecting studies experimentally investigating the ActivityStat hypothesis or compensation in physical activity or energy expenditure. Included studies were critically appraised using a specifically designed tool to address the conceptual considerations of the ActivityStat hypothesis.
Searches identified 28 studies that met the inclusion criteria. Publications spanned 26 years and had multiple methodological approaches, including randomized and non-randomized controlled trials, crossover designs, cluster randomized controlled trials and pre-post trials. Populations of the included studies ranged from children, to adults and the elderly, across a range of weight statuses and used both aerobic, resistance and mixed-exercise interventions. The timeframe of interventions ranged from 1 day to 4 years and outcomes were measured using doubly labelled water, accelerometry, heart rate monitoring, resting metabolic rate, indirect calorimetry, pedometry, subjective recall questionnaire and the activity-related time index. Fifteen of 28 included studies provided evidence of compensation, while 13 did not. Subgroup analyses by population, type and duration of intervention, weight status and study quality also showed mixed findings.
There is a substantial body of experimental literature investigating compensation that has largely been overlooked in the ActivityStat debate. However, this evidence is currently inconclusive and lacks a cohesive approach to the question of an ActivityStat. Recommendations for the design of future experimental research investigating the ActivityStat hypothesis are presented.
KeywordsPhysical Activity Energy Expenditure Sedentary Behaviour Total Energy Expenditure Rest Metabolic Rate
This review was partially funded by a National Health and Medical Research Council Project Grant (#631916). Ms Gomersall is supported by an Australian Postgraduate Award Scholarship. Dr English is supported by a National Health and Medical Research Council Training Fellowship (#610312). Dr Maher is supported by an Australian Research Council post-doctoral fellowship. The authors have no conflicts of interest that are directly related to the content of this review.
The authors would like to acknowledge a reviewer of this manuscript who suggested the term ‘EnergyStat’.
- 6.Bouchard C, Rankinen T. Are people physically active because of their genes. Pres Counc Phys Fit. 2006;7:1–8.Google Scholar
- 8.Tortora G, Derrickson B. Principles of anatomy and physiology. 12th ed. Hoboken: Wiley; 2009.Google Scholar
- 27.Goran MI, Poehlman ET. Endurance training does not enhance total energy expenditure in healthy elderly persons. Am J Physiol Endocrinol Metab. 1992;263(5):E950–7.Google Scholar
- 35.Manthou E, Gill JMR, Wright A, et al. Behavioral compensatory adjustments to exercise training in overweight women. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2010;42(6):1221–8.Google Scholar
- 54.Starling R. Use of doubly labeled water and indirect calorimetry to assess physical activity. In: Welk G, editor. Physical activity assessments for health-related research. Champaign (IL): Human Kinetics; 2002. p. 197–209.Google Scholar
- 56.Swartz A, Strath S, Bassett D, et al. Estimation of energy expenditure using CSA accelerometers at hip and wrist sites. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2000;39(9):S450–6.Google Scholar
- 57.Rennie K, Hennings S, Mitchell J, et al. Estimating energy expenditure by heart-rate monitoring without individual calibration. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2000;3(6):939–45.Google Scholar
- 60.Australian Government. National physical activity guidelines for adults. Canberra (ACT): Department of Health and Aged Care; 1999.Google Scholar
- 61.Cole T, Howard W. Precision and accuracy of doubly labeled water energy expenditure by multipoint and two point methods. Am J Physiol Endocrinol Metab. 1992;263(26):E965–73.Google Scholar