Biblical Literalism: A Test of the Compensatory Schema Hypothesis Among Anglicans in England
- 121 Downloads
The compensatory schema hypothesis (Hoffmann and Bartkowski, Soc Forces 86:1245–1272, 2008) has been used to explain why women seem to have higher levels of biblical literalism than men in some Christian denominations. Based on social structuration and gender theories, it proposes that biblical literalism is a key social schema in some denominations that deny women access to institutional power. Women compensate for the lack of access to institutional social resources (leadership) by stressing the accepted schema (literalism) more strongly than men. The theory was tested using two samples from the Church of England, one lay (N = 394) and one ordained (N = 1,052). Laywomen were more literal than laymen among evangelicals and Anglo-catholics, where opposition to women’s ordination is highest, but in both cases the difference was largely explained by differences in education levels between the sexes. Clergywomen, with access to leadership resources, were less literal than clergymen in both Anglo-catholic and evangelical traditions. The results offer rather weak support for the compensatory schema hypothesis, and alternative explanations of the findings are discussed.
KeywordAnglican Biblical literalism Clergy Gender Social structuration
I thank Leslie Francis and Mandy Robbins for allowing me to use a dataset on clergy which we collected together.
- Ammerman, Nancy T. 1987. Bible believers. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.Google Scholar
- Bader, Christopher, and Paul Froese. 2005. Images of God: The effect of personal theologies on moral attitudes, political affiliation and religious behaviour. Interdisciplinary Journal of Research on Religion 1: Article 11.Google Scholar
- Bielo, James S. 2009. Words upon the word: An ethnography of evangelical group Bible study. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
- Boone, K.C. 1989. The Bible tells them so: The discourse of Protestant fundamentalism. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.Google Scholar
- Bramadat, Paul. 2000. The church on the world’s turf: An evangelical Christian group at a secular university. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Brasher, Brenda E. 1998. Godly women: Fundamentalism and female power. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.Google Scholar
- Chadwick, Henry. 1998. Tradtion, fathers and councils. In The study of Anglicanism, ed. Stephen Sykes, John E. Booty, and Jonathan Knight, 100–115. London: SPCK/Fortress Press.Google Scholar
- Church of England. 1993a. The Episcopal Ministry Act of Synod 1993. http://www.ChurchofEngland.org/media/35648/episactofsynod.rtf. Accessed 17 January 2012.
- Church of England. 1993b. Priests (Ordination of Women) Measure 1993. http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukcm/1993/2/contents. Accessed 17 January 2012.
- Church of England. 2010. Ordinations and Reader admissions 1994 to 2009. http://www.ChurchofEngland.org/about-us/facts-stats/research-statistics/licensed-ministry.aspx. Accessed 7 August 2011.
- Church Society. Women priests. http://www.churchsociety.org/issues_new/ministry/wompriest/iss_ministry_wompriest_intro.asp. Accessed 6 January 2012.
- Crapanzano, Vincent. 2000. Serving the Word: Literalism in America from the pulpit to the bench. New York: The New Press.Google Scholar
- DeBerg, Betty A. 1990. Ungodly women: Gender and the first wave of American fundamentalism. Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press.Google Scholar
- Field-Bibb, Jacqueline. 1991. Women towards priesthood: Ministerial politics and feminist praxis. Cambridge; New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Forward in Faith. http://www.forwardinfaith.com/about/uk_index-uk.html. Accessed 6 January 2012.
- Francis, Leslie J., Mandy Robbins, and Jeff Astley. 2005. Fragmented faith? Exposing the fault-lines in the Church of England. Milton Keynes: Paternoster Press.Google Scholar
- Funk, Robert W. 2001. The Jesus Seminar and the quest. In Jesus then & now: Images of Jesus in history and christology, ed. Marvin W. Meyer, and Charles T. Hughes, 130–139. Harrisburg, PA: Trinity Press International.Google Scholar
- Funk, Robert W. (ed.). 1998. The acts of Jesus: The search for the authentic deeds of Jesus. San Francisco: HarperSanFrancisco.Google Scholar
- Funk, Robert W., and Roy W. Hoover (eds.). 1993. The five Gospels: The search for the authentic words of Jesus: A new translation and commentary. New York: Macmillan.Google Scholar
- Giddens, Anthony. 1984. The constitution of society: Outline of the theory of structuration. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.Google Scholar
- Gill, Sean. 1994. Women and the Church of England: From the eighteenth century to the present. London: SPCK.Google Scholar
- Gore, Charles (ed.). 1889. Lux Mundi. A series of studies in the religion of the incarnation. London: John Murray.Google Scholar
- Hayter, Mary. 1987. The new Eve in Christ: The use and abuse of the Bible in the debate about women in the Church. London: SPCK.Google Scholar
- Hylson-Smith, Kenneth. 1989. Evangelicals in the Church of England 1734–1984. Edinburgh: T & T Clark.Google Scholar
- Hylson-Smith, Kenneth. 1993. High churchmanship in the Church of England from the sixteenth century to the late twentieth century. Edinburgh: T & T Clark.Google Scholar
- Jelen, Ted G. (ed.). 1989b. Religion and political behavior in the United States. New York: Praeger.Google Scholar
- Jones, Ian. 2004. Women and priesthood in the Church of England: Ten years on. London: Church House Publishing.Google Scholar
- Jones, Tod E. 2003. The Broad Church: A biography of a movement. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.Google Scholar
- Kellstedt, L.A. 1989. The meaning and measurement of evangelicalism: Problems and prospects. In Religion and political behavior in the United States, ed. Ted G. Jelen, 3–22. New York: Praeger.Google Scholar
- Kling, David William. 2004. The Bible in history: How the texts have shaped the times. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Leege, D.C. 1989. Toward a mental measure of religiosity in research on religion and politics. In Religion and political behavior in the United States, ed. Ted G. Jelen, 46–63. New York: Praeger.Google Scholar
- Marsden, George M. 1991. Understanding fundamentalism and evangelicalism. Grand Rapids, MI: W.B. Eerdmans.Google Scholar
- Marty, M.E. 1994. Literalism versus everything else: A continuing conflict. Bible Review 10(1): 38–43, 50.Google Scholar
- McGrade, A.S. 1998. Reason. In The study of Anglicanism, ed. Stephen Sykes, John E. Booty, and Jonathan Knight, 115–128. London: SPCK/Fortress Press.Google Scholar
- Mickelsen, Alvera M. 1986. Women, authority & the Bible. Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press.Google Scholar
- Norusis, Marija. 2011. IBM SPSS Statistics 19 statistical procedures companion. Chicago, IL: SPSS.Google Scholar
- Peek, Charles W., George D. Lowe, and L. Susan Williamson. 1991. Gender and God’s Word: Another look at religious fundamentalism and sexism. Social Forces 69(4): 1205–1221.Google Scholar
- Petre, Jonathan. 1994. By sex divided: The Church of England and women priests. London: Fount.Google Scholar
- Pierce, Ronald W., Rebecca Merrill Groothuis, and Gordon D. Fee. 2005. Discovering biblical equality: Complementarity without hierarchy. Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press.Google Scholar
- Randall, Kelvin. 2005. Evangelicals etcetera: Conflict and conviction in the Church of England’s parties. Aldershot: Ashgate.Google Scholar
- Reform. Covenant statement. http://reform.org.uk/about/reform-covenant. Accessed 6 January 2012.
- Scotland, Nigel. 2004. Evangelical Anglicans in a revolutionary age, 1789–1901. Carlisle: Paternoster.Google Scholar
- Sinha, Cynthia B. 2003. Opposition to women clergy: Directive from God? Examining fundamental gender inequality in the religious sector. Paper presented at the Southern Sociological Society Annual Meeting, New Orleans, 27–30 March 2003.Google Scholar
- Smidt, C. 1989. Identifying Evangelical respondents: an analysis of “born-again” and Bible questions used across different surveys. In Religion and political behavior in the United States, ed. T. Jelen, 23–43. New York: Praeger.Google Scholar
- Sykes, Stephen, John E. Booty, and Jonathan Knight (eds.). 1998. The study of Anglicanism. London: SPCK/Fortress Press.Google Scholar
- Village, Andrew. 2005b. Christian belief about the Bible and the Holy Spirit in relation to psychological type. Research in the Social Scientific Study of Religion 16(1): 1–16.Google Scholar
- Village, Andrew. 2006. Biblical interpretative horizons and ordinary readers: An empirical study. Research in the Social Scientific Study of Religion 17(1): 157–176.Google Scholar
- Village, Andrew. 2007. The Bible and lay people: An empirical approach to ordinary hermeneutics. Aldershot: Ashgate.Google Scholar
- Village, Andrew. 2010. English Anglicanism: Construct validity of a scale of Anglo-catholic versus evangelical self-identification. Paper presented at the meeting of the International Society of Empirical Research in Theology (ISERT), Rome, 14–18 April 2010.Google Scholar
- Village, Andrew, and Leslie J. Francis. 2009. The mind of the Anglican clergy: Assessing attitudes and beliefs in the Church of England. Lampeter: Edwin Mellen Press.Google Scholar
- Wakeman, Hilary (ed.). 1996. Women priests: The first years. London: Darton, Longman and Todd.Google Scholar
- Warner, Rob. 2007. Reinventing English evangelicalism, 1966–2001: A theological and sociological study. Milton Keynes: Paternoster.Google Scholar
- Watt, David Harrington. 2002. Bible-carrying Christians: Conservative Protestants and social power. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Wilcox, C. 1989. The New Christian Right and the mobilization of the Evangelicals. In Religion and political behavior in the United States, ed. Ted G. Jelen, 139–156. New York: Praeger.Google Scholar
- Wuthnow, Robert, and John Hyde Evans (eds.). 2002. The quiet hand of God: Faith-based activism and the public role of mainline Protestantism. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
- Young, Frances. 2008. Hermeneutical questions: The ordination of women in the light of biblical and patristic typology. In Women and ordination in the Christian churches: International perspectives, ed. Ian Jones, Janet Wootton, and Kirsty Thorpe, 21–39. London; New York: T & T Clark.Google Scholar
- Zigerell, L.J. 2010. Science knowledge and biblical literalism. Public Understanding of Science. doi: 10.1177/0963662510391723.