Hybrid breakdown and inbreeding depression for seed yield and early growth in 2nd-generation interspecific hybrids of larch (Larix x eurolepis x L.x eurolepis)
Advanced hybridization between first-generation interspecific hybrids is an attractive alternative to breed and mass-produce hybrid seed lots. Nevertheless it faces two major drawbacks, namely hybrid depression and inbreeding depression. Their impact may be highly detrimental on some traits (seed yield) especially for the highest level of consanguinity, but much less on some others (seed quality and early growth) as shown in this study for hybrid larch ( Larix x eurolepis ).
Mass-production of 1st-generation larch hybrids (Larix x eurolepis) in interspecific hybridization orchards is problematic. Alternatives are searched such as advanced-generation orchards combining 1st-generation hybrid clones.
Our aim was to investigate how important hybrid and inbreeding depressions can be in 2nd-generation hybrids with a special focus on reproductive success (and early growth) and their consequences on the success of advanced-generation hybridization seed orchards.
Second-generation hybrids were created by control crosses among 18 1st-generation (F1) hybrid clones with 3 different levels of relatedness (OC (outcrossed), HS (half-sib) and FS (full-sib)). Seed yield and quality and growth in nursery were assessed for the 3 groups and compared with related F1 crosses. Hybrid breakdown and inbreeding depression were then estimated.
F1 hybrids are fertile and mating among them is feasible. Nevertheless hybrid depression is observed when passing to 2nd-generation hybrids for crossing success rate (− 20%) and for seed yield (> 50% less filled seed/cone). Hybrid depression is reinforced by inbreeding and more severely with increasing consanguinity levels: negligible for HS, a supplementary drop of over 50% of seed yield is observed for FS. In contrast, seed quality traits as well as first-year growth are little impacted by both hybrid and inbreeding depressions. Nevertheless a great variation in inbreeding depression level exists among mother clones. Overall, total depression overpasses 70% for the FS parent group but is limited to less than 34% for OC parents for a synthetic trait (number of germinated seed/cone) and remains negligible for growth.
Advanced hybridization is possible with larch but with a more or less severe impact on reproductive success depending on level of relatedness among the parents. Growth seems much less impacted than reproduction and this is a promising result. The proper choice of 1st-generation parents is unavoidable for success of 2nd-generation seed orchards.
KeywordsInterspecific hybridization Hybrid breakdown Inbreeding Reproduction Seed Height
The author wishes to thank Bernard Lhomel, Patrick Simmer and Michel Vallance who conducted the technical work linked to control crossing, seed extraction and characterisation, and seed sowing.
This study received the financial support of EU-DG XII for the project ‘Towards a European larch Wood Chain’ (grant FAIR5-CT98-3354).
Compliance with ethical standards
Conflict of interest
The author declares that there is no conflict of interest.
- Bingham RT (1973) Possibilities for improvement of western white pine by inbreeding. USDA For Serv Res Pap INT-144Google Scholar
- Dieckert H (1964) Einige Untersuchungen zur Selbststerilität und Inzucht bei Fichte und Lärche. Silvae Genet 13:77–86Google Scholar
- Dietze W (1974) Beurteilung von Züchterischen Möglichkeiten zur Verbesserung quantitativer und qualitativer eigenschaften bei Europäischer Lärche (Larix decidua Mill.). Diss. zur Erlangung des Doktorgrades der Forstwissenschaftlichen Fakultät der Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität zu MünchenGoogle Scholar
- Ford GA, McKeand SE, Jett JB, Isik F (2015) Effects of inbreeding on growth and quality traits in loblolly pine. For Sci 61(3):579–585Google Scholar
- Franklin EC (1970) Survey of mutant forms and inbreeding depression in species of the family Pinaceae. USDA For Serv Res Pap SE:61Google Scholar
- Hall JP, Brown IR (1977) Embryo development and yield of seed in Larix. Silvae Genet 26(2–3):77–84Google Scholar
- Hyun SK (1974) The possibility of F2 utilization of Pinus rigida x taeda. Korean J Breeding 6(2):45–55Google Scholar
- Hyun SK (1976) Inter-specific hybridization in pines with special reference to Pinus rigida x taeda. Silvae Genet 25:188–191Google Scholar
- Kain DP (2003) Genetic parameters and improvement strategies for the Pinus elliottii var elliottii x Pinus caribaea var.hondurensis hybrid in Queensland, Australia. PhD thesis Australian National UniversityGoogle Scholar
- Levin DA (1978) The origin of isolating mechanisms in flowering plants. Evol Biol 11:185–317Google Scholar
- Nanson A (2004) Génétique et amélioration des arbres forestiers. Les Presses Agronomiques de Gembloux. GemblouxGoogle Scholar
- Nikles DG (1984) Establishment and progeny testing of clonal seed orchards of Pinus elliottii×P. caribaea F1 hybrids in Queensland. In Barnes RD, Gibson GL (ed), Proceedings of Provenance and Genetic Improvement Strategies in Tropical Forest Trees. Oxford Forestry Institute, Oxford, pp 567–568Google Scholar
- Owens JN (2008) The reproductive biology of western larch. FGC extension note 08Google Scholar
- Pâques LE (1995) Croisements contrôlés de mélèze. Bilan des activités 1987–1994. INRA, AGPF, Doc.interneGoogle Scholar
- Pâques, LE (2019) “Impact of hybrid and consanguinity depression on reproduction and early growth of second generation hybrid larch”. V1. Portail data Inra. [Dataset]. https://doi.org/10.15454/AMNDTO ,
- Pâques LE, Foffová E, Heinze B, Lelu-Walter MA, Liesebach M, Philippe G (2013) Larches (Larix sp.). Chapter 2. In Pâques LE (ed) Forest tree breeding in Europe. Current state-of-the-art and perspectives pp 13–122. Managing Forest Ecosystems, 25. Dordrecht, NLD: Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-007-6146-9_2 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Park YS, Fowler DP (1982) Effects of inbreeding and genetic variances in a natural population of tamarack (Larix laricina (Du Roi) K.Koch) in eastern Canada. Silvae Genet 31(1):21–26Google Scholar
- R Core Team (2014) R: a language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, AustriaGoogle Scholar
- Sarvas R (1962) Investigations of the flowering and seed crop of Pinus sylvestris. Commun Inst For Fenn 53:1–198Google Scholar
- Shearer RC (1990) Seed and pollen cone production in Larix occidentalis. In Turnbull JW (ed), ACIAR Proc on Tropical Tree seed research, series 28: pp 14–17Google Scholar
- Squillace AE, Kraus JF (1963) Effects of inbreeding on seed yield, germination, rate of germination, and seedling growth in Slash pine. In: Proc For Gen Workshop. Southern For Tree Imp Committee, Macon Ga, pp 59–63Google Scholar
- Williams CG, Savolainen O (1996) Inbreeding depression in conifers: implications for breeding strategy. For Sci 42(1):102–117Google Scholar
- Zobel BJ, Talbert JT (1984) Applied forest tree improvement. J Wiley & Sons, New YorkGoogle Scholar