Evaluation of estimates of crown condition in forest monitoring: comparison between visual estimation and automated crown image analysis
- 170 Downloads
In long-term forest monitoring, tree crown condition has been visually rated to diagnose tree vigor and forest condition. However, visual estimates are subjective. A semiautomatic image analysis system, called CROCO, was developed to estimate crown condition quantitatively. CROCO calculates a DSO value which decrease with increasing crown transparency.
This study aims to verify visual estimates objectively using CROCO and to assess characteristics of visual estimates and DSO values by comparing the effectiveness as indicators of radial growth.
Crown condition of Abies mariesii was visually rated using a vitality index, and DSO values of the same trees were calculated.
When the top of the tree was intact, the trees with a higher vitality index showed a significantly higher DSO. Vitality index showed the strongest relationship with DBH increment for 8 years. DSO had a significant relationship with DBH increment by adding information of the crown top condition.
Analysis of tree crown images is effective to verify visual estimates. Vitality index is a synthetic index involving factors affecting radial growth. DSO could be utilized similarly to vitality index, as an indicator of radial growth, by addition of information on crown size and/or shape.
KeywordsCrown condition Visual estimation Image analysis CROCO Crown transparency Abies mariesii
We are grateful to Ms. Yuka Maeda for assistance with the operation of CROCO. Toyama Prefecture and the Toyama District Forest Office granted permission to conduct research on Mt. Tateyama.
This study was supported by Toyama Prefecture and Kyusyu University.
- Ferretti M, Baratozzi L, Cenni E, Cozzi A, Savini P (1998) Crown transparency of beech (Fagus sylvatica L.) in the Northern Appennines (Italy) - Status, changes and relationships with site characteristics and other indices of tree condition. Chemosphere 36:1037–1042. doi: 10.1016/S0045-6535(97)10168-0 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Forestry Agency (2003) Dai 2 ki sanseiu tou shinrin suitai monitaringu zigyou houkokusyo. Forest Agency, Tokyo (in Japanese)Google Scholar
- Ghosh S, Innes JL, Hoffmann C (1995) Observer variation as a source of error in assessments of crown condition through time. For Sci 41:235–254Google Scholar
- ICP Forests (2009) The condition of forests in Europe. 2009 executive report. United Nations Economic Commision for Europe, BrusselsGoogle Scholar
- ICP Forests (2010) Manual on methods and criteria for harmonized sampling, assessment, monitoring and analysis of the effects of air pollution on forests. http://www.icp-forests.org/Manual.htm Accessed 16 July 2011
- Kawano S (1999) Disturbance and conservation of the subalpine-alpine vegetation and biota in the Tateyama-Kurobe National Park, the Japan North Alps in Central Honshu, Japan: The results of long-term monitoring. Jap J Ecol 49:313–320 (in Japanese)Google Scholar
- Kawano S, Katoh T (2000) Implications of long-term monitoring on the tree growth exposed to air pollution and an assessment of its effects. Jap J Ecol 50:289–295 (in Japanese)Google Scholar
- Ministry of the Environment (2002) Long-term acid deposition monitoring. Ministry of the Environment, TokyoGoogle Scholar
- Mizoue N (2001) Fractal analysis of tree crown images in relation to crown transparency. J For Plann 7:79–87Google Scholar
- Mizoue N (2002) CROCO: semi-automatic image analysis system for crown condition assessment in forest health monitoring. J For Plann 8:17–24Google Scholar
- Mizoue N, Inoue A (2001) Automatic thresholding of tree crown image. J For Plann 6:75–80Google Scholar
- Mizoue N, Masutani T (1994) Fractal on the vertical section form of tree crowns. J Jap For Soc 76:242–248 (in Japanese with English summary)Google Scholar
- R Development Core Team (2008) R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, ViennaGoogle Scholar
- Toyama Prefecture (2008) Kankyouhendou to Tateyama no shizen (II) - Tateyama shokusei monitaringu dai II ki chousa seika houkokusyo. Toyama Prefectural Government, Toyama (in Japanese)Google Scholar
- Yoshida S, Mizoue N (2003) Crown health monitoring for old-trees on the Abies-Tsuga natural forest on Kirishima National Park in Kagoshima pref., Japan (IV). Kyushu. J For Res 56:161–164 (in Japanese)Google Scholar