Advertisement

WMU Journal of Maritime Affairs

, Volume 11, Issue 1, pp 129–141 | Cite as

The implications of piracy on marine insurance: some considerations for the shipowner

Article
  • 638 Downloads

Abstract

A prominent feature of modern day piracy is the ransom that is demanded for the safe release of the ship, cargo and crew. The recent upsurge of this type of piracy, in areas of the world that are of strategic importance to the shipping industry, has created many challenges for shipowners, underwriters and the law relating to marine insurance. The aim of this paper is to examine how the marine insurance market is being affected by the threat of modern day piracy, and seeks to identify the options that are available for the recovery of a ransom payment by the shipowner. Moreover, this study aims to identify the legal issues that might prevent a shipowner from recovering a ransom payment under an insurance policy or from the other interests in a common adventure. The study establishes that a reasonably made ransom payment by the shipowner will amount to an extraordinary expense that is taken to minimise or avert a loss. Such an act can generally be recovered under the insurance policy as a sue and labour expense or from other interests in the common adventure as a general average expense. However, illegality, unseaworthiness and exemption clauses in a marine policy are identified as being legal issues that may prevent a shipowner from recovering the ransom payment. Some of these problems may be overcome if clauses are carefully drafted to specifically cater for modern day piracy in a marine insurance policy. Several inconsistencies may also be resolved by transferring the piracy peril to war risks cover. The shipowner’s duty is to respond to the changing circumstances, by ensuring that his vessel is sufficiently equipped and the crew is properly trained to resist a hijacking.

Keywords

Piracy Ransom Marine insurance Sue and labour General average 

References

  1. Bennett H (2006) The law of marine insurance, 2nd edn. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  2. Brittin B (1986) International law for seagoing officers, 5th edn. Naval Institute, AnnapolisGoogle Scholar
  3. Bruce J (2008) Piracy: whose risk is it anyway? Loyds List, London, December 31Google Scholar
  4. Fahey M (2009) Shipowners could lose piracy claims. Fairplay 366(644):13Google Scholar
  5. Fahrey M (2009) P&I press for anti-piracy measures. Fairplay 367(6548):8Google Scholar
  6. Frank J (2009) Ransoms row puts hijacked crew at greater risk. Lloyd’s List, London, July 30Google Scholar
  7. Gauci G (2000) The obligation to sue and labour in the law of marine insurance—time to amend the statutory provisions? Int J Shipp Law 1–10:87–94Google Scholar
  8. Gauci G (2010) Held to ransom—piracy in modern times. University of Plymouth Piracy Conference, PlymouthGoogle Scholar
  9. Hodges S (1996) Law of marine insurance. Cavendish, LondonGoogle Scholar
  10. BBC News (2010, January 18) Somali pirates fight over huge tanker ransom. Retrieved February 24, 2010, from BBC News: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/africa/8464737.stm
  11. Parker B (2009) Paying the pirates. Lloyd’s Shipp Economosit, London, pp 22–25, JuneGoogle Scholar
  12. Rose F (2004) Marine insurance law and practice. MPG Books, BodminGoogle Scholar
  13. Rose F (2005) General average—law and practice, 2nd edn. LLP, LondonGoogle Scholar
  14. Rubin A (1998) The law of piracy, 2nd edn. Transnational Publishers, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  15. ICC Commercial Crimes Services (2011, May 23) Piracy News and Figures. Retrieved July 01, 2011, from ICC Commercial Crimes Services: http://www.icc-ccs.org/piracy-reporting-centre/piracynewsafigures
  16. Skuld (2010, March 26) Insurance. Retrieved March 26, 2010, from Skuld: http://www.skuld.com/templates/Page.aspx?id=2740
  17. Steer J (2009) Piracy and general average. Marit Risk Int 23(8):14–16Google Scholar
  18. Todd P (2009) Piracy for ransom: insurance issues. J Int Marit Law 15:307–321Google Scholar
  19. Townsend P (2009) No romance in modern piracy. Marit Risk Int 23(2):10–12Google Scholar
  20. West of England P&I Club (2009, March 27) Piracy—best management practices. Retrieved April 13, 2010, from West of England P&I Club: http://www.westpandi.com/WestPandI/News/Piracy+-+Best+Management+Practices.htm
  21. Wong R (2009, February) Piracy—does it give rise to a claim for general average? Retrieved April 08, 2010, from Institute of Sea Transport: http://www.seatransport.org/seaview.htm#87
  22. Xu J (2007, September) Piracy as a maritime offence: some public policy considerations. J Bus Law 639–655Google Scholar

Copyright information

© World Maritime University 2012

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.University of PlymouthPlymouthUK
  2. 2.NicosiaCyprus

Personalised recommendations