Advertisement

The Cuyahoga fire at fifty: a false history obscures the real water crisis that never ceased

  • John CroninEmail author
Articles with Attitude

Abstract

Popular history relates that on June 22, 1969, the Cuyahoga River burst into flames as it flowed through Cleveland, Ohio, on its way to Lake Erie. The nation responded with such outrage, the story continues, that the environmental movement was founded, the US Environmental Protection Agency was created, the 1972 Federal Clean Water Act written, and the modern era of environmental law launched. None of these assertions are true. As in the children’s game of telephone, a railroad trestle fire became a river conflagration, unfairly stigmatizing the Cuyahoga and the city of Cleveland, and casting in the shadows seminal events that formed the nation’s rich environmental history. Worse, the tale is used today as evidence that the nation’s waters are now well-protected when the condition of most is poor. This article surveys the history that actually paved the way for contemporary environmental policy, and describes how the Cuyahoga story has been used, even if unintentionally, to deflect attention from the failings of that policy. It is time for a new story, not only about the Cuyahoga but also the nation’s water crisis that never ceased. Shortcuts of convenience to environmental history should give way to a serious treatment of a deeply rooted American environmentalism that created bold goals the nation has yet to achieve. Environmental curricula should teach that statutes such as the Clean Water Act must be evaluated based on present performance, more than past accomplishments. In light of the profound threats to national water quality that still persist, environmental study programs should question, rather than accept on faith, the relevance of current law and policy. Perhaps students and a fresh generation of leaders will be inspired to write new laws, reform policies, halt pollution, and set environmental goals worthy of the twenty-first century.

Keywords

Cuyahoga River Clean Water Act Water crisis Water pollution Water policy Environmental law 

Notes

References

  1. Adler J (2002) Fables of the Cuyahoga: reconstructing a history of environmental protection. Fordham Environ Law Rev:14–89.  https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.333140
  2. Adler RW, Landman JC, Cameron DM (1993) The CWA 20 years later. Island Press, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  3. Alinsky S (1971) Rules for radicals. Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  4. An Aroused Nation. (1969). An aroused nation seeks billions to dam the rising tide of pollution. The New York Times, p. 74Google Scholar
  5. Anderson FR (2011) NEPA in the courts: a legal analysis of the National Environmental Policy Act. Resour Future LIbrary Collection 1 (Policy and Governance)Google Scholar
  6. Andreen WL (2013) The Clean Water Act needs positive reform. The regulatory review. Retrieved from https://www.theregreview.org/2013/08/12/12-andreen-clean-water/. Accessed 26 April 2019Google Scholar
  7. Aspen_Institute_McCarthy (Producer) (2014) In Conversation with EPA administrator Gina McCarthy. [Video] Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V0tGc5G9f80. Accessed 26 April 2019
  8. Bazel LS (2003) The clean water act at thirty: a failure after all these years? Nat Resour Environ 18(2):5Google Scholar
  9. BBC (2018) Trump rolls back decades of clean water act protections. Retrieved from BBC News websiteGoogle Scholar
  10. Blake G (1969) Firm may not be liable for oil damages, The Des Moines RegisterGoogle Scholar
  11. Boxer B (2007) Senator Barbara Boxer “Newsmaker” speech on global warming National Press Club [Press release]. Retrieved from https://www.epw.senate.gov/public/_cache/files/4/c/4ce1f7fa-e580-4240-b984-e650df3760b7/01AFD79733D77F24A71FEF9DAFCCB056.senatorboxersnewsmakerspeechonglobalwarming.pdf. Accessed 26 April 2019
  12. Boyle RH (1969) The Hudson River: a natural and unnatural history. Norton and Company, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  13. Browner C (1994) The common sense initiative: A new generation of environmental protection. from sbc.edu http://gos.sbc.edu/b/browner.html. Accessed 26 April 2019
  14. Capacasa J (2012) Make some noise: the clean water act turns 40. from USEPA https://blog.epa.gov/blog/2012/10/make-some-noise-the-clean-water-act-turns-40/. Accessed 26 April 2019
  15. Carry M, Manning C, Loftus E, Sherman S (1996) Imagination inflation: imagining a childhood event inflates confidence that it occurred. Psychon Bull Rev 3(2):208–214CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Clean Water Act, 33 U.S. Code § 1251 (a), Cornell Law Library, Pub. L. No. 92–500 (1972)Google Scholar
  17. Coventry_Evening_Telegraph (1969) New oil leak threatens US coast. Coventry Evening Telegraph, p. 10Google Scholar
  18. Cronin J, Kennedy RF (1999) The riverkeepers, Touchstone edn. Scribner, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  19. Cronon W (n.d.) Environmentalism triumphant? . from williamcronon.net http://www.williamcronon.net/courses/460/handouts/460_handout_19_environmentalism_triumphant.html. Accessed 26 April 2019
  20. C-Span (2014) League of conservation voters capital dinner. https://www.c-span.org/video/?320153-2/president-addresses-league-conservation-voters. Accessed 26 April 2019
  21. Cumming HS (1916) In investigation of the pollution and sanitary conditions of the potomac watershed: with special reference to self purification and the sanitary condition of shellfish in the lower potomac river (Google Books ed., pp. 75, 230). https://books.google.com/books?id=XTQ8AQAAMAAJ&dq=Investigation+of+the+Pollution+and+Sanitary+Conditions+of+the+Potomac+Watershed:+With+Special+Reference+to+Self+Purification+and+the+Sanitary+Condition+of+Shellfish+in+the+Lower+Potomac+River&source=gbs_navlinks_s: U.S. Government Printing Office
  22. Cuyahoga river area of concern (2018) Retrieved from http://www.cuyahogaaoc.org/index.html. Accessed 26 April 2019
  23. Dalton KE (1989) Blowout heard around the world. Santa Barbara News-PressGoogle Scholar
  24. Davenport C (2018a) Trump prepares to unveil a vast reworking of clean water protections, The New York TimesGoogle Scholar
  25. Davenport C (2018b) Washington rolls back safety rules inspired by deepwater horizon disaster, News. The New York Times. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/27/climate/offshore-drilling-safety-deepwater-horizon.html. Accessed 26 April 2019
  26. DeFlorio-Barker S, Wing C, Jones RM, Dorevitch S (2018) Estimate of incidence and cost of recreational waterborne illness on United States surface waters. Environ Health 17(3)Google Scholar
  27. Dreilling MC (2001) Solidarity and contention: the politics of security and sustainability in the NAFTA conflict. Taylor and Francis, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  28. Easton RO (1972) Black tide: the Santa Barbara oil spill and its consequences. Delacorte Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  29. Edmonds JB (1973) The National Environmental Policy Act applied to policy-level decisionmaking. Ecol Law Q 3(4):802Google Scholar
  30. Egan D (2017) The death and life of the Great Lakes. W.W. Norton & Company, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  31. eTown (2016) Co-founder of Earth Day, Denis Hayes on eTown (1992 & 2012). Retrieved from https://www.etown.org/etown-celebrates-earth-day-2016/. Accessed 26 April 2019
  32. Father Hudson (1881) April 23 ed., Vol. 25. Harper’s Weekly, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  33. Fischer R (2012) Happy 40th anniversary CWA! Retrieved from http://blog.nwf.org/2012/10/happy-40th-anniversary-clean-water-act/. Accessed 26 April 2019
  34. Flippen BJ (2000) Nixon and the environment. University of New Mexico Press, AlbuquerqueGoogle Scholar
  35. Gievet B (1969) Nixon pledges ‘better job’ on oil pollution. Independent Press-Telegram, p 1Google Scholar
  36. Gives sewage warning: Dr. Godfrey tells cities to halt pollution of the Hudson. (1938). The New York TimesGoogle Scholar
  37. Gold, A. (1990) New York's waters cleaner, but pollution is still daunting. The New York Times, p. B4Google Scholar
  38. Grant J (2017) How a burning river helped create the clean water act. from Allegheny Front https://www.alleghenyfront.org/how-a-burning-river-helped-create-the-clean-water-act/. Accessed 26 April 2019
  39. Greenberg P (2012) The Clean Water Act at 40: there’s still much left to do. Retrieved from https://e360.yale.edu/features/the_clean_water_act_at_40_theres_still_much_left_to_do. Accessed 26 April 2019
  40. Grevatt P (2014) Safe drinking water act turning 40. from USEPA https://blog.epa.gov/blog/2014/10/safe-drinking-water-act-turning-40/. Accessed 26 April 2019
  41. Incardona JP, Scholz NL (2018) Case study: the 2010 deepwater horizon oil spill and its environmental developmental impacts. In: Burggen W, Dubansky B (eds) Development and environment. Springer, Cham, pp 235–283CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Jackson H (1969) Statement on Bills to Authorize the Secretary of the Interior to Conduct Investigations, Studies, Surveys, and Research Relating to the Nation’s Ecological Systems, Natural Resources, and Environmental Quality, and to Establish a Council on Environmental Quality: Hearing on S. 1075, S. 237, and S. 1752. Paper presented at the Senate Committee on interior and insular affairs, U.S. Sen., 91st Cong., 1st SessGoogle Scholar
  43. Jackson L (2010) Memorandum from Lisa P. Jackson, Administrator to All EPA Employees. https://archive.epa.gov/epapages/newsroom_archive/newsreleases/bb39e443097b5df5852576a9006a5a86.html. Accessed 26 April 2019
  44. Janis S, Birney L, Newton R (2016) Billion oyster project: linking public school teaching and learning to ecological restoration of New York Harbor using innovative applications of environmental and digital technologies. Int J Digital Content Technol Appl 10(1):14Google Scholar
  45. Judge L (2012) What the Clean Water Act means to me. Retrieved from https://earthjustice.org/blog/2012-october/what-the-clean-water-act-means-to-me. Accessed 26 April 2019
  46. Karpinski G (2014) President Obama’s speech a sign of strength for environmental community. from Huffington Post https://www.huffpost.com/entry/president-obamas-speech-a_b_5543768. Accessed 26 April 2019
  47. Keiser DA, Shapiro JS (2017) Consequences of the Clean Water Act and the demand for water quality. National Bureau of Economic Research (Working Paper No. 23070)Google Scholar
  48. Latson J (2015) The burning river that sparked a revolution. Time. Retrieved from http://time.com/3921976/cuyahoga-fire/. Accessed 26 April 2019
  49. LCV (2014) President Barack Obama to be featured speaker at LCV’s Annual Capital Dinner. Retrieved from https://www.lcv.org/article/president-barack-obama-to-be-featured-speaker-at-lcvs-annual-capital-dinner/. Accessed 26 April 2019
  50. Lewis J (1985) The birth of the EPA. EPA Journal, November 1985. Retrieved from https://archive.epa.gov/epa/aboutepa/birth-epa.html. Accessed 26 April 2019
  51. Lipton E (2018) Offshore rules ‘written with human blood’. The New York Times. Retrieved from. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/10/business/offshore-drilling-trump-administration.html. Accessed 26 April 2019
  52. Livingston T (Producer) (2013) Video vault: WEWS archive footage of 1969 Cuyahoga River fire that sparked environmental movement. [Video] Retrieved from https://www.news5cleveland.com/news/news-archives/video-vault-wews-archive-footage-of-1969-cuyahoga-river-fire-that-sparked-environmental-movement. Accessed 26 April 2019
  53. Llewellyn LG, Peiser C (1973) NEPA and the environmental movement: a brief history. National Bureau of StandardsGoogle Scholar
  54. Loftus EF (1997) Creating false memories. Sci Am 70Google Scholar
  55. Lytle MH (2007) The gentle subversive: Rachel Carson, silent spring, and the rise of the environmental movement. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  56. McCarthy G (2013) EPA's themes - meeting the challenge ahead. from US Environmental Protection Agency https://archive.epa.gov/epa/history/epas-themes-meeting-challenge-ahead.html. Accessed 26 April 2019
  57. Merchant C (1998) Green vs. Gold: sources in California’s environmental history. Island Press, Washingotn, DCGoogle Scholar
  58. Milazzo PC (2016) Unlikely environmentalists: congress and clean water, 1945–1972, Kindle edn. W.W. Norton & Company, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  59. Muskie ES (1978) The meaning of the 1977 Clean Water Act. EPA J 4(7)Google Scholar
  60. Newman R (1972) Burn on. On sail away. Downtown Music Publishing, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  61. Nicholas Institute for Environmental Policy Solutions (2009) Considering the Clean Water Act. The Johnson Foundation at WingspreadGoogle Scholar
  62. Nixon R (1969) Inaugural address, January 20, 1969. from American Presidency Project https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/documents/inaugural-address-1. Accessed 26 April 2019
  63. Nixon R (1970) Message to the congress transmitting reorganization plan 3 of 1970: Environmental Protection Agency. from The American Presidency Project http://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/ws/index.php?pid=2576. Accessed 26 April 2019
  64. Nixon_Santa_Barbara, R (1969) Statement on coastal oil pollution at Santa Barbara, California. https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/documents/statement-coastal-oil-pollutionsanta-barbara-california. Accessed 26 April 2019
  65. Nixon_SOTU, R (1970) Annual message to the Congress on the State of the Union. from Gerard Peters, John T. WoolleyGoogle Scholar
  66. Nixon_veto, R (1972) Veto of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act Amendments of 1972. from Gerhard PetersGoogle Scholar
  67. NOAA (2014) 45 years after the Santa Barbara oil spill, looking at a historic disaster through technology from National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration https://response.restoration.noaa.gov/about/media/45-years-after-santa-barbara-oil-spill-looking-historic-disaster-through-technology.html. Accessed 26 April 2019
  68. NOAA (2015) Where were NOAA oil spill responses in 2014? , from Office of Response and Restoration. National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration https://response.restoration.noaa.gov/about/media/information-about-oil-spills-your-fingertips.html. Accessed 26 April 2019
  69. NOAA (2018) Largest oil spills affecting U.S. waters since 1969. from National Oceanographic and atmospheric administration https://response.restoration.noaa.gov/oil-and-chemical-spills/oil-spills/largest-oil-spills-affecting-us-waters-1969.html. Accessed 26 April 2019
  70. NOAA_Update (2015) NOAA update on the Santa Barbara oil spill of 2015 https://response.restoration.noaa.gov/about/media/noaa-update-santa-barbara-oil-spill.html. Accessed 26 April 2019
  71. Obama B (2013) Remarks by President Barack Obama on climate change. from Obama White House https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/the-press-office/2013/06/25/remarks-president-climate-change. Accessed 26 April 2019
  72. Obama B (2014) Remarks by president Barack Obama at the league of conservation votersGoogle Scholar
  73. Ohio_History_Connection (n.d.). Cuyahoga River Fire. Retrieved from http://www.ohiohistorycentral.org/w/Cuyahoga_River_Fire. Accessed 26 April 2019
  74. Oil Slick Still Threat to California Coast (1969 2). Columbus Dispatch, p. 12AGoogle Scholar
  75. Owens MJ, Zengel S, Graham A, Nixon Z, Allard T (2013) Extent and degree of shoreline oiling: deepwater horizon oil spill, Gulf of Mexico, USA.  https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0065087
  76. Reynolds, K. (2008). Risk of waterborne illness via drinking water in the United States. from the Obama White House remarks by the president at league of conservation voters capital dinner. Rev Environ Contam Toxicol, 192, 117–158Google Scholar
  77. Rivers and Harbors Act, 33 U.S. Code § 411, § 407, https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/33/chapter-9/subchapter-I (1899)
  78. Ruckelshaus WD (1985) Environmental protection: a brief history of the environmental movement in America and the implications abroad Lewis and Clark Environmental Review, 15(Spring), 457Google Scholar
  79. Semple RB, J. (1970) Nixon, stressing quality of life, asks in state of union message for Battle to save environment. The New York Times, p 1Google Scholar
  80. Silbergeld EK, Graham JP (2008) The Cuyahoga is still burning. Environ Health Perspect 116(4)Google Scholar
  81. Lawrence C. Smith, Smith, L. M., & Ashcroft, P. A. (2010/2011). Analysis of environmental and economic damages from British petroleum’s deepwater horizon oil spill. Albany Law Rev, 74, 563Google Scholar
  82. Sneed A (2017) Trump’s order may foul U.S. drinking water supply. Scientific American. Retrieved from https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/trump-rsquo-s-order-may-foul-u-s-drinking-water-supply/. Accessed 26 April 2019
  83. Snell D (1969) Iridescent gift of death. Life 66:23–27Google Scholar
  84. Sofaer AD (1976) Interim opinion and order in the matter of alleged violations of sections 17-0501, 17-0511, and 11-0503 of environmental conservation law of the state of New York by General Electric Company. State of New York Department of Environmental Conservation 2833Google Scholar
  85. Stradling D, Stradling R (2008) Perceptions of the burning river: deindustrialization and Cleveland's Cuyahoga River. Environ Hist 13(3):515–535CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. Stradling D, Stradling R (2015) Where the river burned: Carl stokes and the struggle to save Cleveland, Kindle edn. Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NYGoogle Scholar
  87. The health of the nation’s river (2006) Washington Post. Retrieved from http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/07/13/AR2006071301412.html. Accessed 26 April 2019
  88. Time (1969) America’s sewage system and the price of optimism. Time, August 1, 1969Google Scholar
  89. Train RE (1996) The environmental record of the Nixon administration. Pres Stud Q 26(1):185–196Google Scholar
  90. Trimborn H (1969) Battle shaping up over offshore oil. Los Angeles Times, p 1Google Scholar
  91. Troubled Waters (Film) (1964) from IMDb.com http://www.imdb.com/title/tt5175016/fullcredits?ref_=tt_ov_st_sm. Accessed 26 April 2019
  92. US_Senate (n.d.) Gaylord Nelson promotes the first Earth Day. https://www.senate.gov/artandhistory/history/minute/Gaylord_Nelson_Promotes_the_First_Earth_Day.htm. Accessed 26 April 2019
  93. US_Senate (Producer) (1964) Troubled Waters: A Report by the Committee on Public Works of the United States Senate. [Video] Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KXNMGYuznzU. Accessed 26 April 2019
  94. USEPA_Cuyahoga (n.d.) About Cuyahoga River area of concern. https://www.epa.gov/cuyahoga-river-aoc/about-cuyahoga-river-aoc. Accessed 26 April 2019
  95. USEPA_Fish (2013) National list of fish advisories. from US Environmental Protection Agency https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2015-06/documents/technical-factsheet-2011.pdf. Accessed 26 April 2019
  96. USEPA_Hudson (n.d.) Hudson River PCBs superfund site. from USEPA https://www3.epa.gov/hudson/cleanup.html#quest1. Accessed 26 April 2019
  97. USEPA_Survey (2013) EPA survey finds more than half of the nation’s river and stream miles in poor condition. https://yosemite.epa.gov/opa/admpress.nsf/6427a6b7538955c585257359003f0230/c967210c37cffb6885257b3a004cfaf6!OpenDocument&Start=1&Count=5&Expand=4. Accessed 26 April 2019
  98. USEPA_Watershed (n.d.) Watershed Academy Web Training certificate: introduction to the Clean Water Act. from USEPA https://cfpub.epa.gov/watertrain/moduleFrame.cfm?parent_object_id=2571. Accessed 26 April 2019
  99. USIA (1999) Troubled waters: managing our vital resources. United States Informatin Agency: Global Issues, 34Google Scholar
  100. Welch N (2018) Get oil out founder and dolphin sculptor bud bottoms dies. Santa Barbara Independent. Retrieved from https://www.independent.com/2018/09/24/get-oil-out-founder-and-dolphin-sculptor-bud-bottoms-dies/. Accessed 26 April 2019
  101. White T (2000) Randy Newman’s America: a portrait of the artist Billboard, 17Google Scholar
  102. White_House (Producer) (2014) President Obama Speaks to the League of Conservation Voters. [YouTube VIdeo] Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7hpm-RsNwBc. Accessed 26 April 2019
  103. Wikipedia (2018) Cuyahoga river. from Wikipedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuyahoga_River. Accessed 26 April 2019
  104. WWF (2006) Chinese River dolphin (Baiji) feared extinct, hope remains for finless porpoise. from World Wildlife Fund https://www.worldwildlife.org/press-releases/chinese-river-dolphin-baiji-feared-extinct-hope-remains-for-finless-porpoise. Accessed 26 April 2019
  105. Young G (1970) Our ecological crisis: pollution, threat to man’s only home. National Geographic 138Google Scholar

Copyright information

© AESS 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Dyson College Institute for Sustainability and the EnvironmentPace UniversityPleasantvilleUSA

Personalised recommendations