Environmental legacy: the impact of the manufactured gas industry in the United States

Article

Abstract

Levels of concern over the air and water impacts of U.S. industrial wastes have existed for over a century. A focus on land contamination is a more recent development but also has earlier antecedents. Air, water, and land pollution were a matter of societal concern, even though they were not necessarily identified as “environmental” effects, and information about them can be found in a variety of reports and court cases. This paper will examine the pollution effects of the manufactured gas industry—an industry that was widely distributed in cities and towns throughout the nation in the period from approximately 1825–1950.

Keywords

Environmental legacy Manufactured gas industry Industrial wastes 

References

  1. Abell HC (1929) Changing over a city’s gas Supply. Natural Gas 10:36–71Google Scholar
  2. Anderson AH (1936) Natural gas comes to Detroit: appliance conversion. Gas Age Rec:703–704Google Scholar
  3. Bohan v. Port Jervis Gas Light Co., 122 N.Y 18, 24 N. E. 246, 9 L. R. A. 711 (1890).Google Scholar
  4. Brooklyn Eagle (1845).Google Scholar
  5. Brooklyn Eagle (1877, 1881, 1889, 1893, 1895).Google Scholar
  6. Brown RB (1919) Disposal of wastes from gas plants AGA Monthly IGoogle Scholar
  7. Carhart et. al. vs. the Auburn Gas Light Company, Cases in the Supreme Court, Monroe (1856)Google Scholar
  8. Carswell ED (1928) Tar Emulsion Proc Twentieth Annu Conv South Gas Assoc:56Google Scholar
  9. Castaneda CJ (1995) Regulated enterprise: natural gas pipelines and northeastern markets, 1938–1954. Ohio State University Press, ColumbusGoogle Scholar
  10. Castaneda CJ, Pratt JA (1993) Texas to the east: a strategic history of Texas Eastern Corporation. Texas A&M Press, College StationGoogle Scholar
  11. Cleveland and others vs. the Citizens Gas Light Company, 20 N.J. Eq. 201 5 C. E. Green (1869)Google Scholar
  12. Colten C (1991) A historical perspective on industrial wastes and groundwater contamination. Geogr Rev 81:215–228CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Colten C, Skinner PN (1995) The road to love canal. University of Texas Press, AustinGoogle Scholar
  14. Con Edison Turns on the Gas (1951) Bus Week:108–113Google Scholar
  15. Dutton LR (1919) The disposal of waste water from water gas plants on streams adjacent to parks. AGA Mon I:189–193Google Scholar
  16. Ellis MM (1937) Detection and measurement of stream pollution, bulletin of the U.S. Bureau of Fisheries vol 48. GPO, WashingtonGoogle Scholar
  17. EPA Mid-Atlantic Brownfields & Land Revitalization “Manufactured gas plants/coal tar sites”. http://www.epa.gov/reg3hwmd/bf-lr/regional/industry/manufactured.htm. Accessed November 12, 2012
  18. Fieldner AC (1931) Recent developments in by-products from bituminous coal, R. I. 3079. U.S. Bureau of Mines, WashingtonGoogle Scholar
  19. Franz DR (1981) An historical perspective on mollusks in Lower New York Harbor, with emphasis on oysters. In: Mayer GF (ed) Ecological stress and the New York bight: Science and Management Estuarine Research Federation, Columbia, SC, 181–197Google Scholar
  20. Pacific Coast Gas Association (1934) Gas engineers’ handbook, prepared by Gas Engineers’ Handbook Committee of the Pacific Coast Gas Association (1934). McGraw-Hill, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  21. Gas Research Institute management of manufactured gas plant sites (1987). Remediation Technologies, Pittsburgh, PAGoogle Scholar
  22. Goodell EB (1905) A review of the laws forbidding pollution of inland waters in the U.S, 2nd edn. USGS Water Supply Paper #152. GPO, WashingtonGoogle Scholar
  23. Gorman H (2001) Refining efficiency: pollution concerns, regulatory mechanisms, and technological change in the U.S. petroleum industry. University of Akron Press, AkronGoogle Scholar
  24. Gould JM (1946) Output and productivity in the electric and gas utilities. National Bureau of Economic Research. MA, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  25. Grozier D (1953) The Brooklyn Union Natural Gas conversion: biggest changeover in the world. Gas Age 111:39–41Google Scholar
  26. Gutsell JS (1921) Danger to fisheries from oil and tar pollution of waters, Bureau of Fisheries document no. 910. Government Printing Office, WashingtonGoogle Scholar
  27. Hart WB (1950) Stream protection and management. Proc AGA 32:412–413Google Scholar
  28. Hatheway AW (2012) Remediation of former mediation gas plants and other coal–tar sites. CRC Press, Boca RatonGoogle Scholar
  29. Hearings on the subject of the pollution of navigable waters. House of Representatives 67th Congress (1921)Google Scholar
  30. Herbert JH (1992) Clean cheap heat: the development of residential markets for natural gas in the United States. Praeger, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  31. Journal of the Senate of the State of New York (1845).Google Scholar
  32. LeCain T (2009) Mass destruction: the men and giant mines that wired America and scarred the planet. Rutgers University Press, New BrunswickGoogle Scholar
  33. Legislature NYS (1845) Chap. 201. In: Laws passed at sixty-eighth session (1845).Google Scholar
  34. Legislature NYS (1882) Chap. 410. In: Laws passed at the one hundred and fifth sessionGoogle Scholar
  35. Legislature NYS (1913) Chap. 508. In: Laws passed at the one-hundred and thirty-six session.Google Scholar
  36. Marsh MC (1907) The effects of some industrial wastes on fishes, United States Geological Survey, water-supply and irrigation paper 192. GPO, WashingtonGoogle Scholar
  37. Massachusetts Department of Public Utilities (1990) “Generic investigation of the facts surrounding and the ratemaking treatment of the costs of investigating and remediating hazardous wastes associated with the manufacture of gas during the period 1822–1978. Document in author’s possessionGoogle Scholar
  38. McDonald M (1885) Report on the pollution of the Potomac River by the discharge of waste products from gas manufacture, Bulletin of the U.S. Fish CommissionGoogle Scholar
  39. McKay WE (1901) Tar and water from Water-Gas Proc Am Gas and Light Assoc XLVI:xxviiGoogle Scholar
  40. Mellhenny JS (1905) Removal of the last traces of oil and tar from Water Condensation Am Gas Light J:766–768Google Scholar
  41. Minutes of the Pennsylvania Sanitary Water Board (1923-1940). Pennsylvania State Archives, Harrisburg, PAGoogle Scholar
  42. Mitchell PH (1912) The effect of water–gas tar on oysters. In: Bulletin of the US Bureau of Fisheries, XXXIIGoogle Scholar
  43. Montgomery SD, Phelps EB (1918) Stream pollution: a digest of judicial decisions and a compilation of legislation relating to the subject, Public Health Bulletin No. 87. GPO, WashingtonGoogle Scholar
  44. Morgan JJ, Stolzenbach CF (1934) Heavy oil tar emulsions in the water gas process, Pt. I AGA Monthly 245-248Google Scholar
  45. Morgan JJ, Stolzenbach CF (1934b) Heavy oil tar emulsions in the water gas process, Pt. II AGA Monthly:277–280Google Scholar
  46. Munroe CE (1912) By-products in gas manufacture. J of the Franklin Inst CLXXIV 1–34Google Scholar
  47. Murphy BL, Sparacio T, Shields WJ (2005) Manufactured gas plants—processses, historical development, and key issues in insurance coverage disputes. Environ Forensic 6:161–173CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Nelson TC (1920) The conservation of New Jersey’s oyster industry. In: N J Board of Shell Fisheries, Report, 1920. The State, TrentonGoogle Scholar
  49. Ottawa Gas Light and Coke Company v. Darlin Thompson 39 Ill. 598–601 (1864).Google Scholar
  50. Pensacola Gas Light Co. v. Pebble (1899) Supreme Court of Florida. Southern Reporter 5: 593–97Google Scholar
  51. Pollution by Oil (1923) The Coastal Waters of the United States: Preliminary report, Prepared by the Bureau of Mines in Cooperation with the American Petroleum Institute and American Steamship Owner's Association. National Archives, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  52. Pollution of Streams (1906) Progressive age: Gas–Electricity–Water XXIV:739–740Google Scholar
  53. Powell AR (1929) Report of subcommittee on disposal of waste from gas plants. Proceedings of the AGA 11:928–32Google Scholar
  54. Progress Report of Committee on Industrial Wastes in Relation to Water Supply (1923) JAWWA 10:420–422Google Scholar
  55. Progress report on recent developments in the field of industrial wastes in relation to water supply (1926) JAWWA 16:302–329Google Scholar
  56. Report of J. W. Mersereau (1890) State Oyster Protector, New York State Assembly Documents #37, Eighteenth Report of the New York Commissioner of Fisheries, albanyGoogle Scholar
  57. Report of the investigation of the Cedar River … in collaboration with the Division of Game and Fish (1930–1932). Minnesota State Archives, MinneapolisGoogle Scholar
  58. Report on the investigation of the pollution of the Straight and Cannon rivers (1928–1930). Minnesota State Archives, MinneapolisGoogle Scholar
  59. Reports of Water Supply and Sewerage (1908), Massachusetts State Board of Health Engineering Department, Massachusetts State Board of Health, to X. H. Goodnough, Chief Engineer, State Board of Health, “Pollution of Malden River,” V. II, July to September 1908. Massachusetts State Archives, Boston, MAGoogle Scholar
  60. Ripp JA, Unites DF (2013) State of remediation at former manufactured gas plant Sites. Paper presented at the EPRI MPG 2013 Symp, Savannah, GAGoogle Scholar
  61. Rosen CM (2003) ‘Knowing’ industrial pollution: nuisance law and the power of tradition in a time of rapid economic change, 1840–1864. Environ Hist 8:565–597CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Safford AT (1907) Wastes from Lowell Gas Light Company’s yards. J Assoc Eng Soc 39:169–198Google Scholar
  63. Schivelbusch W (1995) Disenchanted night: the industrialization of light in the nineteenth century. University of California Press, BerkeleyGoogle Scholar
  64. New York Penal Code Section 1759 (1909). In: N Y State Penal Code of 1909, Chap 40Google Scholar
  65. Seely HK (1927) Report of Subcommittee on Water Gas Tar Emulsions, their prevention, treatment, and utilization. AGA ProcGoogle Scholar
  66. Seely HK (1928) Report of the Subcommittee on Water Gas Tar Production. AGA ProcGoogle Scholar
  67. Statement of Capt. J.C. Fremont (1924) United States Navy, Supervisor New York Harbor. GPO, WashingtonGoogle Scholar
  68. Steere FW (1922) Producer gas technology. In: Bacon RF, Hamor WA (eds) American fuels, vol II. McGraw-Hill, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  69. Stotz L, Jamison A (1938) History of the gas industry. Stettiner Bros, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  70. Tarr JA (1999) Transforming an energy system: the evolution of the manufactured gas industry and the transition to natural gas in the United States. In: Coutard O (ed) The governance of large technical systems. Routledge, New York, 19–37Google Scholar
  71. Tarr JA (1996) The search for the ultimate sink: urban pollution in historical perspective. University of Akron Press, Akron, OhioGoogle Scholar
  72. Tarr JA (2005) The city and technology. In: Pursell C (ed) A companion to American technology. Blackwell Publishing, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  73. Taylor R (1926) “Pollution of navigable waters and nonnavigable tributaries thereof” to the Secretary of War. National Archives, WashingtonGoogle Scholar
  74. The disposal of the waste products of gas works (1908) Eng Rec 58:434–443Google Scholar
  75. Thomas A (1916) Report on conditions at Richmond, Virginia and vicinity concerning the pollution of the James River as affecting fishery resources. National Archives, WashingtonGoogle Scholar
  76. Tomory L (2012) Progressive enlightenment: the origins of the gaslight industry, 1780–1820. MIT Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  77. Troesken W (2006) Regime Change and Corruption: A History of Public Utility Regulation. In: E Glaeser and C Goldin (eds) Corruption and Reform: Lessons from America’s Economic History. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 259–83Google Scholar
  78. Unites D. Environmental impacts of manufactured gas plant demolition: examples from site remediation experience. http://www.geiconsultants.com/stuff/../O/environmentalimpactsmgpdemo.pdf. Accessed August 4, 2011
  79. Ward HB (1919) Stream pollution in New York State: a preliminary investigation of the problem from the standpoint of the biologist. New York State Conservation Commission, AlbanyGoogle Scholar
  80. Wardale NH (1930) Gas plant waste disposal Proc, Pac Coast Gas Assoc:363Google Scholar
  81. Warrick LF (1950) Stream protection and management. Proc AGA 32:412–413Google Scholar
  82. Whipple GC (1908) Gas wastes. In: Report of the State Sewerage Commission to the [New Jersey] Legislature of 1908. N.J. State Printer, Somerville, 145–169Google Scholar
  83. Willien LJ (1919) Report of the Committee on Disposal of Waste from Gas Plants. In: AGA Proc. American Gas Association, New York, 274–280Google Scholar
  84. Willien LJ (1920) To avoid stream pollution. Gas Rec 18:31–34Google Scholar
  85. Willien LJ (1923) Water gas tar emulsions. AGA Proc:1349Google Scholar

Copyright information

© AESS 2014

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Departments of History, Engineering & Public Policy, and Heinz College of Public Policy and ManagementCarnegie Mellon UniversityPittsburghUSA
  2. 2.Departments of Civil and Environmental Engineering, and Engineering and Public PolicyCarnegie Mellon UniversityPittsburghUSA

Personalised recommendations