Neural Stem Cell Transplantation as a Therapeutic Approach for Treating Lysosomal Storage Diseases
Treating the central nervous system manifestations of subjects with neuropathic lysosomal storage diseases remains a major technical challenge. This is because of the low efficiency by which lysosomal enzymes in systemic circulation are able to traverse the blood brain barrier into the central nervous system. Intracranial transplantation of neural stems cells genetically modified to overexpress the respective deficient enzymes represents a potential approach to addressing this group of diseases. The unique properties of neural stem cells and progenitor cells, such as their ability to migrate to distal sites, differentiate into various cell types and integrate within the host brain without disrupting normal function, making them particularly attractive therapeutic agents. In addition, neural stem cells are amenable to ex vivo propagation and modification by gene transfer vectors. In this regard, transplanted cells can serve not only as a source of lysosomal enzymes but also as a means to potentially repair the injured brain by replenishing the organ with healthy cells and effecting the release of neuroprotective factors. This review discusses some of the well-characterized neural stem cell types and their possible use in treating neuropathic lysosomal storage diseases such as the Niemann Pick A disease.
KeywordsNeural stem cells Neural progenitor cells Cell transplantation Lysosomal storage diseases Niemann Pick A disease
During the past decade, the potential of stem cell transplantation as a therapeutic modality for neurodegenerative and neurometabolic diseases has gained significantly increased interest. Potential applications of this technology include its use as a cell replacement or augmentation therapy and as a source of cellular factors that might be deficient in the host or trophic factors that promote survival and repair of the central nervous system (CNS) of the host. However, given the complexity of the cellular organization of the CNS, particularly in diseased states, their deployment as cellular vectors to prevent or ameliorate neurological disorders likely represents a more tenable short-term goal than that of a vehicle for cell replacement and regrowth of damaged circuitry.
Lysosomal storage diseases (LSDs) represent a group of more than 50 metabolic disorders caused by mutations in genes encoding catabolic enzymes involved in the normal degradation of macromolecules within the lysosomes . A deficiency in the activity of 1 or more of these lysosomal enzymes leads to the progressive accumulation of uncatabolized substrates and consequent cellular dysfunction and organ failure [1, 2]. Testing of cellular therapies in several animal models of LSDs has shown that a combination of gene and stem cell therapy might represent an optimal therapeutic paradigm. Further research is underway to bridge the preclinical development path to clinical studies in humans. Here, we discuss select examples of preclinical studies that highlight both the promise and challenges of this technology platform to treating LSDs.
Sources of Neural Stem Cells and Progenitor Cells
Neural stem cells (NSCs) have demonstrated the potential as a therapeutic modality for the repair of a number of CNS disorders. NSCs derived from either the developing or adult CNS are a heterogeneous population of mitotically active, self-renewing, and multipotent cells [3, 4]. They exhibit select cardinal features, such as the ability for unlimited self-renewal via asymmetric cell division, indefinite ability to proliferate in response to mitogens, and multipotency for the different neuroectodermal lineages of the CNS [5, 6, 7]. Self-renewal is defined as the capacity of a cellular clone to generate new stem cells with identical properties for multiple generations, a characteristic that can be prompted by the provision of mitogens . Multipotency refers to the capacity of clones derived from single founder stem cells to differentiate and generate multiple cell types of a particular germ layer. Neural progenitor cells (NPCs) derived form the CNS are also multipotent cells, capable of giving rise to neurons, astrocytes, and oligodendrocytes, but contrary to NSCs the NPCs have limited self-renewing capacity [5, 7]. NPCs are a step further along the path of differentiation than NSCs. Different, but well-defined procedures have been developed for the isolation, safe expansion, and maintenance of these cells in chemically defined media for several years [8, 9].
The ideal donor cells for use in transplantation studies should be easy to isolate and produce in large numbers. They also need to be competent in effecting cellular or molecular replacement in the CNS without causing a deleterious outcome (e.g., tumor growth). For the past several years, protocols that allow for the generation of a large number of NPCs in vitro have been established, thereby supporting the concept that these cells might represent a renewable source of uncommitted, ready-to-use cells for transplantation purposes . Neural cells with stem cell properties have been isolated from fetal [11, 12], neonatal [13, 14], and adult  human brains, as well as rodent CNS using both epigenetic (with the mitogens epidermal growth factor  or basic fibroblast growth factor [16, 17, 18]) and genetic (with the reversible oncogenes v-Myc or large T antigen [19, 20]) strategies. NPCs can also be isolated from human fetal and adult tissue by enzymatic dissociation followed by expansion in the presence of specific growth factors rich and serum-deficient media. Additionally, fluorescence activated cell sorting and surface antigen-based cell sorting can be used to facilitate purification of the cells [11, 12, 13, 14]. Adult-derived NSCs and NPCs avoid the ethical concerns associated with fetal-derived cells. However, NSCs are more difficult to isolate from brain biopsies or autopsy samples [13, 14]. Additionally, human adult NSCs and NPCs do not show telomerase activity and have limited proliferation capacity following serial passaging in vitro . Although NPCs from different species respond positively to growth factors, their growth properties can differ depending on the conditions being used . NSCs can be expanded either as adherent cultures  or spherical aggregates termed “neurospheres” . In serum-free cultures supplemented with epidermal growth factor and/or fibroblast growth factor-2 multipotent NPCs are able to proliferate indefinitely. Moreover, these clones spontaneously differentiate into postmitotic CNS daughter cells (such as neurons, astrocytes, or oligodendrocytes) at withdrawal of the growth factors [5, 6, 10]. Brain-derived NPCs have received the most attention as a source of cells for neural cell replacement, and they have been widely used for proof-of-concept studies in animal models of diseases [23, 24]. However, the limited availability of donors and the difficulty associated with expanding cells derived from postmortem adult tissue coupled with the concern of potential immune rejection of transplanted cells provide challenges for their use as a source of donor cells for therapeutic applications.
NPCs have also been isolated from pluripotent human embryonic stem cells (ESCs) . ESCs derived from the inner cell mass of blastocyst stage embryos exhibit 2 unique characteristics: 1) an indefinite capacity for self-renewal and 2) pluripotency. ESCs can indefinitely divide into the undifferentiated state, and when exposed to certain conditions ESCs are able to differentiate into any cell type including neural progenitors; thus, ESCs are considered truly pluripotent . Improvements to methods to scale production of the ESCs to numbers necessary for transplantation have been recently described. Feeder independent growth of human ESCs (using protein components solely derived from recombinant sources or purified from human material) has been achieved [26, 27], as has the propagation (through continuous asymmetric cell division) of ESC-derived neural stem cells without the accompanying differentiation . These ESC-derived NPCs have been used in multiple animal studies. The transplanted cells have been shown to successfully be integrated and differentiated in a region-specific manner into neurons, astrocytes, and oligodendrocytes [29, 30]. Although, ESC-derived NPCs can potentially provide a limitless source of donor cells, several challenges remain a concern regarding the clinic use of these cells. First, as with NPCs and other allogenic transplants, there are concerns of immunorejection and the need of immunosuppression. Second, the presence of undifferentiated cells and increased risk of tumorigenesis. Protocols to avoid the formation of teratocarcinomas following transplantation of ESCs or ESC-derived NPCs are still being developed . Recently, a clinical trial aimed at repairing traumatic spinal cord injury using oligodendrocyte precursors derived from human ESCs received authorization from the regulatory agency .
Neural Cell-Mediated Therapy of Lysosomal Storage Diseases
The ability of human NPCs to participate in brain repair has recently been demonstrated in preclinical studies. Transplantation of human NPCs into rodent brains led to their subsequent migration along appropriate tracts and differentiation into neurons and glia in a region-specific manner [19, 24, 47, 48]. As such, NPCs can be considered a viable source of donor cells to achieve cell replacement and effect circuit repair in the CNS. However, depending on the nature of the disease, the deployment of NPCs as cellular vectors to provide trophic support of the host tissue or augment the levels of a deficient enzyme might be equally beneficial. In this regard, hereditary diseases, such as the LSDs, are appropriate candidates for cell-based therapy.
Lysosomal Storage Diseases
Lysosomal storage diseases are a diverse group of metabolic disorders that are typically inherited in an autosomal recessive manner . As an aggregate, LSDs affect approximately 1 in 7700 births with the most affected individuals showing a diffuse CNS involvement . LSDs are caused by a deficiency in 1 or more of the approximately 50 lysosomal enzymes described to date. This loss in enzyme activity leads to progressive accumulation of undegraded substrates in the lysosomes resulting in distension of the organelle, subsequent cellular malfunction, and clinical disease . Although lysosomal enzymes are constitutively expressed in all cell types, the extent of substrate accumulation for a particular LSD depends on the rate of production of that substrate in the different cells. Consequently, some LSDs have primarily a CNS presentation, whereas others have little or no CNS involvement. Treatments such as systemic enzyme replacement therapy and substrate reduction therapy have been shown to be effective for some LSDs, such as Gaucher, Fabry, Pompe, Mucopolysaccharidosis (MPS) type I, II, and VI diseases . Although systemically delivered recombinant enzymes are effective at correcting the visceral disease, they do not address the CNS manifestations because of their inability to traverse the BBB into the brain . Intracranial injections of recombinant lysosomal enzymes, viral vectors or stem cells encoding the deficient enzymes, or systemic infusions of modified enzymes that can transverse the BBB are being evaluated as potential approaches to address this limitation. This review is focused on neural cell-based strategies for treating the neuropathic LSDs.
The rationale for a cell-based therapeutic for the LSDs is predicated on the notion that delivery of a small number of cells will suffice to correct large regions of the brain. This supposition is borne of demonstrations that lysosomal enzymes are capable of undergoing diffusion and facilitating cross-correction of adjacent cells by virtue of the mannose 6-phosphate receptor present in most cell types in the CNS. Moreover, based on a large number of studies, it is anticipated that a low level reconstitution of enzyme activity in the cells will be therapeutic [51, 52, 53]. However, invasive intracranial delivery of the cells will be required to bypass the BBB [54, 55]. To maximize the expression and secretion of lysosomal enzymes, cells can be genetically modified by ex-vivo transduction of cells using well-established gene transfer methodologies prior to their transplantation. This strategy has been evaluated and shown to be effective in treating several mouse models of LSDs with neuropathic disease [56, 57, 58, 59]. The first demonstration of the therapeutic potential of NSCs came from studies in MPS VII mice using NPCs engineered to overexpress ß-glucuronidase (enzyme deficient in MPS VII disease) into the cerebral ventricles of mice. Transplantation of the gene-modified NPCs led to engraftment and differentiation of the donor cells, secretion of the enzyme, and cross-correction of adjacent cells . Similar findings were achieved using genetically modified human NPCs in this mouse model [56, 57]. Intracranial injections of gene-modified multipotent NPCs also resulted in a broad distribution of β-hexosaminidase, the enzyme deficient in Tay-Sachs disease, in the brains of transplanted mice . Transplantation of unmodified murine NSCs into neonatal Sandhoff diseased (another LSD) mice was also effective in delaying disease onset, reducing storage pathology, and extending longevity . These observations were extended to unmodified human NSCs isolated from the CNS and embryonic stem cells . Perhaps a more clinical relevance was the demonstration of efficacy with murine-derived NSCs in adult, symptomatic Sandhoff mice .
Cell-Mediated Gene Therapy
Recently, Tamaki et al.  also reported studies of transplantation of normal, nontumorogenic, and unmodified fetal human NSCs that had been grown as neurospheres (huCNS-SCs) into the brains of an immunodeficient mouse model of infantile neuronal ceroid lipofuscinosis (INCL). Extensive engraftment and migration of the transplanted cells were noted in the CNS that translated into widespread production of therapeutic levels of the lysosomal enzyme palmitoyl protein thioesterase-1, the enzyme deficient in INCL. Treated mice exhibited significantly reduced neuropathology, a delay in the loss of motor coordination, and an extended survival benefit . This demonstration that early intervention with cellular transplants of huCNS-SCs into the brains of INCL patients might allow for the sustained production of therapeutic levels of palmitoyl protein thioesterase-1 and consequent protection of host neurons was the experimental basis for the human clinical studies with banked huCNS-SCs. The first Food and Drug Administration-authorized human clinical trial using huCNS-SCs in the brains of children with INCL was initiated in 2006 [72, 73]. Results from the phase I clinical trial showed that transplantation of high doses of human NSCs (approximately 1 billion cells) into multiple sites of the brain (8 per patient) was well tolerated. Evidence of regional engraftment and survival of the transplanted cells was also noted. Based on the favorable safety data, a phase Ib trial in patients with less advanced stages of infantile or late infantile neuronal ceroid lipofuscinosis was initiated in 2010. Recently, this trial was terminated due to the lack of timely patient accrual. A gene therapy trial in 10 children with late infantile neuronal ceroid lipofuscinosis using an adeno-associated virus serotype 2 vector expressing human therapeutic levels of the lysosomal enzyme palmitoyl protein thioesterase-1 complementary DNA was also purported to be safe and result in a significant reduction in the rate of neurological decline as compared to control subjects . Conceptually, cell transplantation might offer additional advantages by replacing cells that might have been lost to disease, effecting more global distribution of the enzyme and secreting neuroprotective host factors.
The potential benefits of cell-mediated therapy for neurometabolic diseases include their ability to confer cell replacement or protection and repair the host nervous system. NSCs possess inherent properties for widespread distribution and the potential for cellular integration following transplantation. As such, they can be used as delivery vehicles for both normally expressed and genetically overexpressed enzymes that are deficient in their hosts [1, 75, 76, 77]. For lysosomal storage diseases, a cell-mediated therapeutic approach enlists the ability of transplanted cells to incorporate and produce the enzyme lacking in host cells, thereby preventing excessive lysosomal storage and the death of affected neurons or glia. Recent demonstrations of success in the treatment of several mouse models of LSDs with human neural cells that had been derived by multiple methods support this notion. However, although these studies showed substantial correction of pathology in the mouse brain, these findings will need to be extended to animals with a larger brain to move this therapeutic strategy into the clinic. The generation of NPCs from iPSCs may provide a large source of donor cells that evade ethical and immune concerns. However, for LSDs patient-derived iPSCs have to be transduced ex-vivo to express the relevant missing enzyme. Potential oncogenic challenges are being addressed using transposon and small molecule induction, as well as by predifferentiation and transdifferentiation. The efficacy and clinical feasibility of iPSC-derived NPC for cell-mediated therapy remain to be determined. Widespread distribution of therapeutic cells in larger brains for clinically relevant use will require the optimization of several factors including: 1) a well-characterized and nontumorigenic human-derived source of stem cells; 2) ex vivo modification of the cells by gene therapy to increase enzyme production, if necessary; 3) determining the number of injection sites and dose of cells to be delivered at each site to ensure effective distribution; 4) the location of the transplant site(s) in the brain for global distribution; and 5) the need for immunosupression for allogenic transplants. Due to the complexity of the neural circuitry, it may be unlikely that stem cell therapy will be able to reverse pathology in brains at the advanced stage of the disease. There is a potential to restore normal function for disability due to ongoing inflammation and cellular dysfunction secondary to lysosomal storage, but neuronal loss and scarring are probably irreversible processes. Thus, it is crucial in neurodegenerative diseases (e.g., with LSDs) to initiate therapy as early as possible for stem cell therapy to have a reasonable chance of succeeding. Furthermore, it remains to be determined whether reversal of pathological lesions will be able to arrest the decline in mental development that accompanies most subjects with lysosomal storage disorders. Nevertheless, the encouraging recent preclinical and clinical studies hold promise for the use of neural-derived cell therapy in the treatment of this group of neurometabolic disorders.
Special thanks to Alison Schroeer, principal medical illustrator, for the artwork in Figs. 1 and 4. LSS and SHC are employees of Genzyme. LSS has been listed as a co-inventor on two filed patents, on the “Cellular therapy for Neurometabolic disorders”, W02005016250A2 and W02005016250A3.
Full conflict of interest disclosure is available in the electronic supplementary material for this article.
- 9.Goldman S, Windrem M. Cell replacement therapy in neurological disease. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 2001;361:1463–1475.Google Scholar
- 21.Ostenfeld T, Caldwell MA, Prowse KR, Linskens MH, Jauniaux E, Svendsen CN. Human neural precursor cells express low levels of telomerase in vitro and show diminishing cell proliferation with extensive axonal outgrowth following transplantation. Exp Neurol 2000;164:215–226.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 43.Weiss ML, Troyer DL. Stem cells in the umbilical cord. Stem Cell Rev 2006;2:155–162.Google Scholar
- 53.Neufeld EF. Enzyme replacement therapy. In: Platt FM, Walkely SU, ed. Lysosomal disorders of the brain. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2004:327–338.Google Scholar