Teletoxicology: Patient Assessment Using Wearable Audiovisual Streaming Technology
Audiovisual streaming technologies allow detailed remote patient assessment and have been suggested to change management and enhance triage. The advent of wearable, head-mounted devices (HMDs) permits advanced teletoxicology at a relatively low cost. A previously published pilot study supports the feasibility of using the HMD Google Glass® (Google Inc.; Mountain View, CA) for teletoxicology consultation. This study examines the reliability, accuracy, and precision of the poisoned patient assessment when performed remotely via Google Glass®.
A prospective observational cohort study was performed on 50 patients admitted to a tertiary care center inpatient toxicology service. Toxicology fellows wore Google Glass® and transmitted secure, real-time video and audio of the initial physical examination to a remote investigator not involved in the subject’s care. High-resolution still photos of electrocardiograms (ECGs) were transmitted to the remote investigator. On-site and remote investigators recorded physical examination findings and ECG interpretation. Both investigators completed a brief survey about the acceptability and reliability of the streaming technology for each encounter. Kappa scores and simple agreement were calculated for each examination finding and electrocardiogram parameter. Reliability scores and reliability difference were calculated and compared for each encounter.
Data were available for analysis of 17 categories of examination and ECG findings. Simple agreement between on-site and remote investigators ranged from 68 to 100 % (median = 94 %, IQR = 10.5). Kappa scores could be calculated for 11/17 parameters and demonstrated slight to fair agreement for two parameters and moderate to almost perfect agreement for nine parameters (median = 0.653; substantial agreement). The lowest Kappa scores were for pupil size and response to light. On a 100-mm visual analog scale (VAS), mean comfort level was 93 and mean reliability rating was 89 for on-site investigators. For remote users, the mean comfort and reliability ratings were 99 and 86, respectively. The average difference in reliability scores between on-site and remote investigators was 2.6, with the difference increasing as reliability scores decreased.
Remote evaluation of poisoned patients via Google Glass® is possible with a high degree of agreement on examination findings and ECG interpretation. Evaluation of pupil size and response to light is limited, likely by the quality of streaming video. Users of Google Glass® for teletoxicology reported high levels of comfort with the technology and found it reliable, though as reported reliability decreased, remote users were most affected. Further study should compare patient-centered outcomes when using HMDs for consultation to those resulting from telephone consultation.
KeywordsTelemedicine Google glass Toxicology Wearable devices Telehealth
The authors wish to especially thank Angela Padilla-Jones, RN, BSN, for her efforts in coordinating this research.
Compliance with Ethical Standards
This observational cohort study was reviewed and approved by our institutional review board and complied with our center’s best practices for human subject research. A waiver of consent was granted after demonstration of minimal potential harm to patients and strict compliance with information confidentiality practices.
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Sources of Funding
Funding was provided by Banner Health and the Banner – University Medical Center Phoenix, Department of Graduate Medical Education.
Previous Presentation(s) of Data
- 11.Walker T. Google Glass: tech giant to halt sales of headset in current form—but vows to look to future. 2015. In: http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/google-glass-tech-giant-to-halt-sales-of-headset-in-its-current-form-but-vows-to-look-to-future-9981488.html. Accessed 23 Dec 2015.
- 12.Paul F. Heads up: Google Glass may be coming back. 2015. http://www.networkworld.com/article/2926442/wireless/heads-up-google-glass-may-be-coming-back.html. Accessed 23 Dec 2015.