Abstract
This paper reports the compositional characterization of eighty-two glass fragments discovered in archaeological contexts at Tropaeum Traiani (Adamclisi, Constanţa county, Romania), most of them dated to the 4th–6th centuries AD, in an attempt to understand the glass consumption and circulation in the Lower Danube region during the Late Antique period. The analytical results were obtained using external Particle Induced X-ray Emission (PIXE) and Particle Induced Gamma-ray Emission (PIGE) techniques at the New AGLAE accelerator located in the basement of the Louvre Palace, Paris, France. The chemical data were compared to those on coeval glass finds from the literature. The naturally colored Tropaeum Traiani glass fragments turned out to belong to Série 2.1 of Foy, Série 3.2 of Foy, HIMT (high iron manganese titanium), and HIT (high iron titanium) compositional groups of Late Antique glass. The lack of color in several fragments was obtained either through the use of antimony or manganese compounds; intermediate recipes for colorless vessels, indicative for recycling procedures, were evidenced as well. The sample set also included several naturally colored blue and green glasses dated to the Early Roman period which showed compositional patterns typical for Roman Imperial glass. The variety in the chemistry of the vitreous finds reported in this paper, demonstrated by the identification of different glass types previously encountered in contemporary objects from many archaeological sites from the Mediterranean Sea and Balkan Mountains regions during the Late Antique period, reflects the trade connections of the settlements from the Lower Danube and the Black Sea region with the rest of the Roman world.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Geographical coordinates of Tropaeum Traiani archaeological site taken from Google Maps
References
Adkins L, Adkins RA (2004) Handbook to life in ancient Rome. Facts on file Inc., New York, pp 361–362
Aerts A, Velde B, Janssens K, Dijkman W (2003) Changes in silica sources in Roman and post-Roman glass. Spectrochim Acta B At Spectrosc 58:659–667
Al-Bashaireh K, Al-Mustafa S, Freestone IC, Al-Housan AQ (2016) Composition of Byzantine glasses from Umm el-Jimal, northeast Jordan: Insights into glass origins and recycling. J Cult Herit 21:809–818
Antonaras A (2008) Glass lamps of the Roman and Early Christian periods: evidence from the Thessaloniki area. In: Roman CA, Gudea N (eds) Lychnological acts 2. Acts of 2nd International Congress on Ancient and Middle Age lighting devices. Zalău - Cluj-Napoca, 13th-18th of May 2006. Trade and local production of lamps from the Prehistory until the Middle Age. Editura Mega, Cluj-Napoca, pp 23–30
Antonaras AC (2017) Glassware and glassworking in Thessaloniki. 1st century BC – 6th century AD. Archaeopress Roman Archaeology 27, Oxford
Băjenaru C, Bâltâc A (2000-2001) Depozitul de candele din sticlă descoperit la basilica episcopală de la Histria. Pontica 33-34:469–514
Băjenaru C, Bâltâc A (2006) Histria – bazilica episcopală. Catalogul descoperirilor de sticlă (1984-2000). Pontica 39:219–246
Bâltâc A (2007) Catalogue des découvertes. Objets de culte. In: Suceveanu A (ed) Histria XIII. La Basilique episcopale. Editura Academiei Române, Bucharest, pp 221–224
Balvanović R, Šmit Ž (2020) Sixth-century AD glassware from Jelica, Serbia—an increasingly complex picture of Late Antiquity glass composition. Archaeol Anthropol Sci 12:94
Barnea I (1975) Atriile bazilicilor paleocreştine de la Tropaeum Traiani. SCIVA 26:57–67
Barnea I (1978) Bazilica „Simplă” (A) de la Tropaeum Traiani. Pontica XI: 181-187
Barnea I (ed), Barnea A, Cârstoiu MM, Cătăniciu IB, Papuc Gh (1979) Tropaeum Traiani, I, Cetatea. Editura Academiei Române, Bucureşti
Boţan SP (2015) Glass vessels between the Carpathian Mountains and the Pruth river. Mega Publishing House, Cluj Napoca
Boţan SP, Chiriac C (2011) Some general considerations regarding the discoveries of Roman glass vessels from (L)ibida – Slava Rusă (Tulcea County). Studia Antiqua et Archaeologica 17:163–181
Boţan SP, Elefterescu D (2018) Vase de sticlă de epocă romană descoperite la Durostorum/Ostrov – Ferma 4 (secolele I p. Chr. – IV p. Chr.) Bibliotheca Archaeologica Moldaviae
Boțan SP, Paraschiv D, Nuțu G (2010) Vase de sticlă romane și romano-bizantine descoperite în nordul Dobrogei. Arheol Mold 33:217–242
Boțan SP, Talmațchi G, Cristea-Stan D (2020) Câteva descoperiri vitrice din Dobrogea romană/ Glass finds from Roman Dobroudja. Peuce SN 18:263–300
Brems D, Degryse P (2014) Trace element analysis in provenancing Roman glass-making. Archaeometry 56:116–136
Brems D, Degryse P, Hasendoncks F, Gimeno D, Silvestri A, Vassilieva E, Luypaers S, Honings J (2012) Western Mediterranean sand deposits as a raw material for Roman glass production. J Archaeol Sci 39:2897–2907
Bucovală M (1968) Vase antice de sticlă la Tomis. Muzeul de Arheologie, Constanţa
Budzińska M (2016) Glass vessels from the sector X-P (1st-7th centuries A.D.). In: Biernacki AB (Ed) The large legionary thermae in Novae (Moesia Inferior)(2nd-4th centuries A.D.). Novae, Studies and Materials V, Institute of History AMU, Poznań, pp 275–411
Bugoi R, Poll I, Mănucu-Adameşteanu G, Neelmeijer C, Eder F (2013) Investigations of Byzantine glass bracelets from Nufăru, Romania using external PIXE-PIGE methods. J Archaeol Sci 40:2881–2891
Bugoi R, Poll I, Mănucu-Adameşteanu G, Calligaro T, Pichon L, Pacheco C (2016) PIXE-PIGE analyses of Byzantine glass bracelets (10th-13th centuries AD) from Isaccea, Romania. J Radioanal Nucl Chem 307:1021–1036
Bugoi R, Poll I, Mănucu-Adameşteanu G, Pacheco C, Lehuédé P (2018a) Compositional study of Byzantine glass bracelets discovered at the Lower Danube. Microchem J 137:223–230
Bugoi R, Alexandrescu CG, Panaite A (2018b) Chemical composition characterization of ancient glass finds from Troesmis – Turcoaia, Romania. Archaeol Anthropol Sci 10:571–586
Bugoi R, Măgureanu A, Măgureanu D, Lemasson Q (2020) IBA analyses on glass beads from the Migration Period. Nucl Inst Methods Phys Res B 478:150–157
Cagno S, Cosyns P, Izmer A, Vanhaecke F, Nys K, Janssens K (2014) Deeply colored and black-appearing Roman glass: a continued research. J Archaeol Sci 42:128–139
Calligaro T (2008) PIXE in the study of archaeological and historical glass. X-Ray Spectrom 37:169–177
Campbell JL, Boyd NI, Grassi N, Bonnick P, Maxwell JA (2010) The Guelph PIXE software package IV. Nucl Inst Methods Phys Res B 268:3356–3363
Ceglia A, Cosyns P, Nys K, Terryn H, Thienpont H, Meulebroeck W (2015) Late antique glass distribution and consumption in Cyprus: a chemical study. J Archaeol Sci 61:213–222
Ceglia A, Cosyns P, Schibille N, Meulebroeck W (2019) Unraveling provenance and recycling of late antique glass from Cyprus with trace elements. Archaeol Anthropol Sci 11:279–291
Chevalier P (1997-1998) Les luminaires paléochrétiens de Dalmatie romaine. Vjesnik za arheologiju i historiju dalmatinsku 90-91(1999):161–199
Cholakova A, Rehren Th (2018) A Late Antique manganese-decolourised glass composition: Interpreting patterns and mechanisms of distribution, in: Rosenow D, Phelps M, Meek A, Freestone IC (eds) Things that travelled. Mediterranean glass in the first millennium AD, pp 46-71
Cholakova A, Rehren Th, Freestone IC (2016) Compositional identification of 6th century AD glass from the Lower Danube. J Archaeol Sci Rep 7:625–632
Cliante L, Ţârlea A (2019) The 6th century AD glass stemmed goblets from excavations in Histria (Centre-North Sector). Peuce SN 17:235–248
Cliante L, Ţârlea A (2020) Secondary glass kilns and local glass production in Tomis during the Roman times. Center for Comparative History of Ancient Societies (CICSA) Journal 6:117–133
Conte C, Chinni T, Arletti R, Vandini M (2014) Butrint (Albania) between eastern and western Mediterranean glass production: EMPA and LA-ICP-MS of late antique and early medieval finds. J Archaeol Sci 49:6–20
De Juan Ares J, Schibille N, Molina Vidal J, Sanchez de Prado MD (2019) The supply of glass at Portus Ilicitanus (Alicante, Spain): a meta-analysis of HIMT glasses. Archaeometry 61:647–662
Drăghici C (2012) Glassware from Tomis. Chronological and typological aspects. In: Ignatiadou D, Antonaras A (eds), Annales du 18e Congres de lˈAssociation Internationale pour lˈHistoire du Verre (Thessaloniki 2009), pp 211-216
Drauschke J, Greiff S (2010) Chemical aspects of Byzantine glass from Caričin Grad/Iustiniana Prima (Serbia). In: Drauschke J, Keller D (eds) Glass in Byzantium: production, usage, analyses: International workshop organised by the Byzantine Archaeology Mainz, 17th-18th of January 2008, Römisch-Germanisches Zentralmuseum. Verlag des Römisch-Germanischen Zentralmuseums, Mainz, pp 25-46
Foster H, Jackson CM (2009) The composition of ‘naturally coloured’ late Roman vessel glass from Britain and the implications for models of glass production and supply. J Archaeol Sci 36:189–204
Foy D, Picon M, Vichy M, Thirion-Merle V (2003) Caractérisation des verres de la fin de l’Antiquité en Mediterranée occidentale: l’émergence de nouveaux courants commerciaux. In: Foy D, Nenna MD (eds) Échanges et commerce du verre dans le monde antique. Actes du colloque de l’AIHV, Aix-en-Provence et Marseille, Juin 2001. Monographies Instrumentum 24. Monique Mergoil, Montagnac, pp 41–85
Freestone IC (1994) Appendix: chemical analysis of “raw” glass fragments. In: Hurst HR (ed) Excavations at Carthage II, 1. The circular harbor. The site and finds other than pottery. Oxford University Press for British Academy, Oxford
Freestone IC (2005) The provenance of ancient glass through compositional analysis. Material Research Society Symposium Proceedings 852:OO8.1.1–OO8.1.13
Freestone IC (2015) The recycling and reuse of Roman glass: analytical approaches. Journal of Glass Studies 57:29–40
Freestone IC (2021) Glass production in the first millennium CE: a compositional perspective. In: Klimscha F (ed) Glas und Glasproduktion in Ur und Frühgeschichtlicher Zeit. TOPOI, Berlin, pp 243–262
Freestone IC, Greenwood R, Gorin Rosen Y (2002) Byzantine and early Islamic glassmaking in the Eastern Mediterranean: production and distribution of primary glass. In: Kordas G (ed) Hyalos=Vitrum=Glass: history, technology and conservation of glass and vitreous materials in the Hellenic world. Glasnet Publications, Athens, Athens, pp 167–174
Freestone IC, Degryse P, Lankton J, Gratuze B, Schneider J (2018) HIMT, glass composition and commodity branding in the primary glass industry. In: Rosenow D, Phelps M, Meek A, Freestone IC (eds) Things that travelled. Mediterranean glass in the first millenium CE. UCL Press, London, pp 159–190
Gliozzo E (2017) The composition of colourless glass: a review. Archaeol Anthropol Sci 9:455–483
Gliozzo E, Turchiano M, Giannetti F, Santagostino Barbone A (2016) Late antique glass vessels and production indicators from the town of Herdonia (Foggia, Italy): new data on CaO-rich/weak HIMT glass. Archaeometry 58:81–112
Gliozzo E, Braschi E, Giannetti F, Langone A, Turchiano M (2019) New geochemical and isotopic insights into the Late Antique Apulian glass and the HIMT1 and HIMT2 glass productions—the glass vessels from San Giusto (Foggia, Italy) and the diagrams for provenance studies. Archaeol Anthropol Sci 11:141–170
Gratuze B, Pactat I, Schibille N (2018) Changes in the signature of cobalt colorants in Late Antique and Early Islamic glass production. Minerals 8:225
Grünewald M, Hartmann S (2015) Überlegungen zum Glasrecycling der Antike im Bereich des heutigen Deutschlands. In: Heinrich P, Miks C, Wieland M (eds) Non solum ... sed etiam. Festschrift für Thomas Fischer zum, vol 65. Geburtstag. Verlag Marie Leidorf, Rahden/Westfalen, pp 153–164
Hirvonen JP (1995) Nuclear Reaction Analysis: Particle Gamma Reactions. In: Tesmer JR, Nastasi M (eds) Handbook of modern ion beam materials analysis. Materials Research Society, Pittsburgh, pp 167–192
Isings C (1957) Roman glass from dated finds. Archaeologica Traectina, Groningen - Djakarta
Jackson C, Foster H (2014) The last Roman glass in Britain: recycling at the periphery of the empire. In: Keller D, Price J, Jackson C (eds) Neighbours and successors of Rome: traditions of glass production and use in Europe and the Middle East in the Later 1st Millennium AD. Oxbow Books, Oxford & Philadelphia, pp 6–14
Kabakchieva G (1987) Produzione vetraria di Oescus. Note preliminari Ratiariensia 3-4:171–176
Keller D (2005) Social and economic aspects of glass recycling. In: Bruhn J, Croxford B, Grigoropoulos D (eds) TRAC 2004: Proceedings of the Fourteenth Annual Theoretical Roman Archaeology Conference. Oxbow Books, Oxford, pp 65–78
Komp J (2007) Römisches Fensterglas aus dem Rheingebiet. Archäologisch-naturwissenschaftliche Studien zu seiner Herstellung, Qualität und Verbreitung sowie der Zusammensetzung der verwendeten Rohgläser. Frankfurter elektronische Rundschau zur Altertumskunde 5
Kuleff I, Djingova R (1999) Archaeometric investigation of Roman glass finds from Bulgaria. Berliner Beiträge fur Archäometrie 16:183–198
Küppers H (2007) DuMont Farbenatlas, 10. Auflage edn. DuMont Literatur und Kunst Verlag, Köln
Maltoni S, Chinni T, Vandini M, Cirelli E, Silvestri A, Molin G (2015) Archaeological and archaeometric study of the glass finds from the ancient harbour of Classe (Ravenna- Italy): new evidence. Heritage Science 3:13
Maltoni S, Silvestri A, Marcante A, Molin G (2016) The transition from Roman to Late Antique glass: new insights from the Domus of Tito Macro in Aquileia (Italy). J Archaeol Sci 73:1–16
Marić Stojanović M, Šmit Ž, Glumac M, Mutić J (2015) PIXE–PIGE investigation of Roman Imperial vessels and window glass from Mt. Kosmaj, Serbia (Moesia Superior) Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports 1: 53–63
Mirti P, Casoli A, Appolonia L (1993) Scientific analysis of Roman glass from Augusta Praetoria. Archaeometry 35:225–240
Nenna MD, Picon M, Vichy M (2000) Ateliers primaires et secondaires en Egypte à l'époque gréco-romaine. In: Nenna MD (ed) La route du verre: ateliers primaires et secondaires de verriers du second millénaire av. J.-C. au Moyen-Age Travaux de la Maison de l’Orient Méditerranéen 33 Maison de l’Orient Méditerranéen-Jean Pouilloux, Lyon, pp 97–112
Nenna MD, Picon M, Thirion-Merle V, Vichy M (2003) Ateliers primaires du Wadi Natrun: nouvelles découvertes. AIHV Annales du 16e Congrés pp 59–63
Nenna MD (2014) Egyptian glass abroad: HIMT glass and its markets. In: Bailey J, Jackson C, Keller D, Price J (eds) Neighbours and successors of Rome. Oxbowbooks, Oxford & Philadelphia, Traditions of glass production in use in Europe and the Middle East in the later first millenium AD, pp 177–193
Neri E, Verità M, Biron I, Guerra MF (2016) Glass and gold: analyses of 4th-12th centuries Levantine mosaic tesserae. A contribution to technological and chronological knowledge Journal of Archaeological Science 70:158–171
Olczak J (1998) Produkcja szkła w rzymskim i wczesnobizantyjskim Novae w świetle źródeł archeologicznych (Mezja Dolna). Wydawnictwo Naukowe Uniwersystetu Mikołaja Kopernika, Torun
Opaiţ A, Opaiţ C, Bănică T (1990) Complexul monastic paleocreştin de la Slava Rusă. Revista Monumentelor Istorice 59:18–28
Panaite A (2006) Adamclisi, jud. Constanța, Tropaeum Traiani, punct Cetate: Sector A – la nord de Basilica A, Cronica Cercetărilor Arheologice, campania 2005:33
Panaite A (2007) Adamclisi, jud. Constanța, Tropaeum Traiani, punct Cetate: Sector A – la nord de Basilica A, Cronica Cercetărilor Arheologice, campania 2006:23
Panaite A (2009) Adamclisi, jud. Constanța, Tropaeum Traiani, punct Cetate: Sector A – la nord de Basilica A, Cronica Cercetărilor Arheologice, campania 2008 (= Valahica XXI), pp 66–67
Panaite A (2010) Adamclisi, jud. Constanța, Tropaeum Traiani, punct Cetate: Sector A – la nord de Basilica A, Cronica Cercetărilor Arheologice, campania 2009:13–14
Panaite A (2011) Adamclisi, jud. Constanța, Tropaeum Traiani, punct Cetate: Sector A – la nord de Basilica A, Cronica Cercetărilor Arheologice, campania 2010:10
Panaite A (2012) Adamclisi, jud. Constanța, Tropaeum Traiani, punct Cetate: Sector A – la nord de Basilica A, Cronica Cercetărilor Arheologice, campania 2011:15–16
Panaite A (2013) Adamclisi, jud. Constanța, Tropaeum Traiani, punct Cetate: Sector A – la nord de Basilica A, Cronica Cercetărilor Arheologice, campania 2012:15
Panaite A (2014) Adamclisi, jud. Constanța, Tropaeum Traiani, punct Cetate: Sector A – la nord de Basilica A, Cronica Cercetărilor Arheologice, campania 2013:13
Panaite A (2015) Adamclisi, jud. Constanța, Tropaeum Traiani, punct Cetate: Sector A – la nord de Basilica A, Cronica Cercetărilor Arheologice, campania 2014:19–20
Panaite A (2016) Adamclisi, jud. Constanța, Tropaeum Traiani, punct Cetate: Sector A – la nord de Basilica A, Cronica Cercetărilor Arheologice, campania 2015:17
Panaite A (2017) Adamclisi, jud. Constanța, Tropaeum Traiani, punct Cetate: Sector A – la nord de Basilica A, Cronica Cercetărilor Arheologice, campania 2016:12
Paynter S, Jackson C (2019) Clarity and brilliance: antimony in colourless natron glass explored using Roman glass found in Britain. Archaeol Anthropol Sci 11:1533–1551
Pichon L, Beck L, Walter P, Moignard B, Guillou T (2010) A new mapping acquisition and processing system for simultaneous PIXE-RBS analysis with external beam. Nucl Inst Methods Phys Res B 268:2028–2033
Pichon L, Moignard B, Lemasson Q, Pacheco C, Walter P (2014) Development of a multi-detector and a systematic imaging system on the AGLAE external beam. Nucl Inst Methods Phys Res B 318:27–31
Pichon L, Calligaro T, Lemasson Q, Moignard B, Pacheco C (2015) Programs for visualization, handling and quantification of PIXE maps at the AGLAE facility. Nucl Inst Methods Phys Res B 363:48–54
Rehren Th, Brüggler M (2015) Composition and production of late antique glass bowls type Helle. Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports 3: 171–180
Rehren Th, Cholakova A (2010) The early Byzantine HIMT glass from Dichin, northern Bulgaria. Interdisciplinary Studies 22-23:81–961.
Rehren Th, Cholakova A (2014) Glass supply and consumption in the Late Roman and early Byzantine site Dichin, northern Bulgaria. In: Keller D, Price J, Jackson C (eds) Neighbours and successors of Rome: traditions of glass production and use in Europe and the Middle East in the later 1st millennium AD. Oxbow Books, Oxford & Philadelphia, pp 83–94
Rosenow D, Rehren Th (2014) Herding cats: Roman to late antique glass groups from Bubastis, northern Egypt. J Archaeol Sci 49:170–184
Rütti B (1991) Die römischen Gläser aus Augst und Kaiseraugst. Forschungen in Augst 13. Amt für Museen und Archäologie des Kantons Basel-Landschaft, Augst.
Salomon J, Dran JC, Guillou T, Moignard B, Pichon L, Walter P, Mathis F (2008) Present and future role of ion beam analysis in the study of cultural heritage materials: the example of the AGLAE facility. Nucl Inst Methods Phys Res B 266:2273–2278
Schibille N, Sterret-Krause A, Freestone IC (2017) Glass groups, glass supply and recycling in Late Roman Carthage. Archaeol Anthropol Sci 9:1223–1241
Shortland AJ, Schachner L, Freestone I, Tite M (2006) Natron as a flux in the early vitreous materials industry: sources, beginnings and reasons for decline. J Archaeol Sci 33:521–530
Silvestri A, Molin G, Salviulo G (2005) Roman and Medieval glass from the Italian area: bulk characterization and relationships with production technologies. Archaeometry 47:797–816
Silvestri A, Molin G, Salviulo G (2008a) The colourless glass of Iulia Felix. J Archaeol Sci 35:331–341
Silvestri A, Molin G, Salviulo G (2008b) The coloured glass of Iulia Felix. J Archaeol Sci 35:1489–1501
Smith T, Henderson J, Faber EW (2016) Early Byzantine glass supply and consumption: the case of Dichin, Bulgaria. In: Henderson J (ed) Fuxi Gan, Qinghui Li. World Scientific, Recent advances in the scientific research on ancient glass and glaze, pp 207–231
Stawiarska T (2014) Roman and Early Byzantine glass from Romania and Northern Bulgaria. Bibliotheca Antiqua XXIV, Polish Academy of Science, Warsaw
Suceveanu A, Barnea A (1991) La Dobrudja romaine. Editura Enciclopedică, București
Ţârlea A, Cliante L (2020) 'Put the lights on': Early Byzantine stemmed goblets and lamps from the Acropolis Centre-South Sector in Histria (I). Peuce SN 18:301–332
Uboldi M (1995) Diffusione delle lampade vitree in età tardoantica e altomedievale e spunti per una tipologia. Archeologia medievale XXII:93–145
Acknowledgements
The authors kindly thank Quentin Lemasson, Laurent Pichon, and Claire Pacheco from Centre de Recherche et de Restauration des Musées de France (C2RMF), Paris, France, for their technical support during the experiment performed at the AGLAE accelerator.
The New AGLAE facility (ANR-10-EQPX-22) was used to perform the analyses reported in this paper.
Roxana Bugoi acknowledges the continuous assistance and advice of Patrice Lehuédé from C2RMF.
Roxana Bugoi is grateful to Eugen Nicolae from Institutul de Arheologie “Vasile Pârvan,” Bucharest, who had the idea of this interdisciplinary collaboration.
Adriana Panaite warmly thanks Iuliana Barnea from Institutul de Arheologie “Vasile Pârvan” for her help in preparing Figs. 1, 2, to 3.
Adela Ichimescu from IFIN-HH is kindly thanked for her help in revising the language of the final version.
The insightful comments of the two anonymous reviewers and of the editor helped us to improve this paper. Any remaining errors are ours.
The financial support of Access to Research Infrastructures activity in the 7th Framework Programme of the EU CHARISMA Cultural Heritage Advanced Research Infrastructures—Synergy for a Multidisciplinary Approach to Conservation/Restoration—Grant Agreement n. 228330 is gratefully acknowledged.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bugoi, R., Panaite, A. & Alexandrescu, CG. Chemical analyses on Roman and Late Antique glass finds from the Lower Danube: the case of Tropaeum Traiani. Archaeol Anthropol Sci 13, 148 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12520-021-01310-7
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12520-021-01310-7