Advertisement

The old wood effect revisited: a comparison of radiocarbon dates of wood charcoal and short-lived taxa from Korea

  • Jangsuk Kim
  • David K. Wright
  • Jaehoon Hwang
  • Junkyu Kim
  • Yongje Oh
Original Paper
  • 19 Downloads

Abstract

Due to the “old wood effect,” wood is not an ideal material for radiocarbon dating if there are other options available. However, in regions where short-lived taxa are not well preserved, archeologists face a dilemma whether to use wood dates to construct archeological interpretations, often leading to controversies over validity of their chronologies. To systematically access this problem, this paper evaluates the intensity of the old wood effect in Korea. First we compared radiocarbon dates assayed from five wood and 32 soybean (Glycine max) samples obtained from a prehistoric pithouse in central-western Korea. Statistical analysis shows that there is no significant disparity in the ages between the materials in this case. To further assess the issue, we compared 24 cases from the Korean Radiocarbon Database in which both wood and short-lived taxa were found and dated from the same house feature. The results demonstrate that, in general, the old wood effect is not substantial in Korea. However, further analysis of these results suggests that the potential for an old wood effect increases slightly over time in Korea, despite the fact that there was no significant climatic change. We interpret the adoption of iron for woodcutting around the first century BCE as a catalyst for a noted increase in the thickness of wood timbers of houses, which consequently produced conditions more opportune for the occurrence of an old wood effect. It suggests that the variability of an old wood effect can be the result of technological factors even within the same general physical environment.

Keywords

Radiocarbon dating Old wood effect Korea Comparison Temporal variability 

Notes

Acknowledgments

We thank Sung-Mo Ahn, Jongtaik Choi, Seonho Choi, Jaeyong Lee, and Chuntaek Seong for valuable comments on earlier version of this paper. This paper is an advanced version of our previous preliminary report submitted to the Journal of Korean Ancient History (Hwang et al. 2016). The cases and numbers used in present paper have changed slightly because we adopted a more rigid assessment protocol than the previous report.

Funding information

This work was supported by the Ministry of Education of the Republic of Korea and the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF-2016S1A5B6924370).

References

  1. Aitchison TC, Leese M, Michczynska DJ, Mook WG, Otlet RL, Ottaway BS, Pazdur MF, van der Plicht J, Reimer PJ, Robinson SW, Scott EM, Stuiver M, Weninger B (1989) A comparison of methods used for the calibration of radiocarbon dates. Radiocarbon 31(3):846–864CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Ahn J (2011) Chronology of Mumun-Pottery patterns by Ordination in the Southeastern Coastal Area. J Korean Ancient Hist Soc 73:67–110 (in Korean)Google Scholar
  3. Ahn SM (2012) Seeds and radiocarbon dating. J Korean Archaeol Soc 83:152–204 (in Korean)Google Scholar
  4. Allen MS, Huebert JM (2014) Short-lived plant materials, long-lived trees, and Polynesian 14C dating: consideration for 14C sample selection and documentation. Radiocarbon 56(1):257–276CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Bayliss A (2009) Rolling out revolution: using radiocarbon dating in archaeology. Radiocarbon 51(1):123–147CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Bowman S (1990) Radiocarbon dating. Univ of California Press, BerkeleyGoogle Scholar
  7. Bronk Ramsey C (1995) Radiocarbon calibration and analysis of stratigraphy: the OxCal program. Radiocarbon 37(2):425–430CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Bronk Ramsey C (2009) Bayesian analysis of radiocarbon dates. Radiocarbon 51(1):337–360CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Buck CE, Kenworthy JB, Litton CD, Smith AF (1991) Combining archaeological and radiocarbon information: a Bayesian approach to calibration. Antiquity 65(249):808–821CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Cao X, Herzschuh U, Ni J, Zhao Y, Böhmer T (2014) Spatial and temporal distributions of major tree taxa in eastern continental Asia during the last 22,000 years. Holocene 25:79–91CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Choi J, Lee Y, Lee J, Kim J (2017) Radiocarbon dating and the historical archaeology of Korea: an alternative interpretation of Hongryeonbong Fortress II in the three kingdoms period, Central Korea. J Field Archaeol 42(1):1–12CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Chung CH (2011) Holocene vegetation dynamics and its climatic implications inferred from pollen record in Boseong area, South Korea. Geosci J 15:257–264CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Chung CH, Lim HS, Yoon HI (2006) Vegetation and climate changes during the Late Pleistocene to Holocene inferred from pollen record in Jinju area, South Korea. Geosci J 10:423–431CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Cook RA, Comstock AR (2014) Evaluating the old wood problem in a temperate climate: a fort ancient case study. Am Antiq 79:763–775CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Grave P, Barbetti M (2001) Dating the city wall, fortifications, and the palace site at pagan. Asian Perspect 40(1):75–87CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Haesaerts P, Borziac I, Chekha VP, Chirica V, Drozdov NI, Koulakovska L, Orlova LA, van der Plicht J, Damblon F (2010) Charcoal and wood remains for radiocarbon dating Upper Pleistocene loess sequences in Eastern Europe and Central Siberia. Palaeogeogr Palaeoclimatol Palaeoecol 291(1–2):106–127CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Hangang Institute of Cultural Heritage (2016) Gwangmyeong Gahakdong san 100–3 site: excavation report in Suwon-Gwangmyeong Highway construction site, Hangang Institute of Cultural Heritage, Bucheon. (in Korean)Google Scholar
  18. Higham T (2011) European middle and upper Palaeolithic radiocarbon dates are often older than they look: problems with previous dates and some remedies. Antiquity 85(327):235–249CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Higham T, Douka K, Wood R, Bronk Ramsey C, Brock F, Basell L et al (2014) The timing and spatiotemporal patterning of Neanderthal disappearance. Nature 512(7514):306–309CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Hong SY, Minasny B, Zhang YS, Kim YH et al (2010) Digital soil mapping using legacy soil data in Korea. Paper presented at 19th World Congress of Soil Science, Soil Solutions for a Changing World. 1–6 August 2010, Brisbane, Australia. Published on DVDGoogle Scholar
  21. Huckleberry G, Rittenour T (2014) Combining radiocarbon and single-grain optically stimulated luminescence methods to accurately date pre-ceramic irrigation canals, Tucson, Arizona. J Archaeol Sci 41:156–170CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Hwang J, Kim J, Lee Y, Lee J, Song A, Kim JK, Park J, Yang J, Yang H, Kang S, Oh Y, Ahn SM, Choi J, Seong C, Wright David K, Choi S, Hyun C (2016) Radiocarbon dating and old wood effect: an experiment and archaeological assessment. J Korean Ancient Hist Soc 92:117–149 (In Korean)Google Scholar
  23. Hwang J, Yang H (2015) Radiocarbon dating and early bronze age chronology revised. J Honam Archaeol Soc 50:30–51 (In Korean)Google Scholar
  24. Hwang SI, Yoon SO (2005) The change of vegetation and climate during late Quaternary in Korea. Jirihak Nongu 24:154–180 (In Korean)Google Scholar
  25. Jang BO, Yang DY, Kim JY, Choi KR (2006) Postglacial vegetation history of the Central Western region of the Korean peninsula. J Ecol Environ 29:573–580Google Scholar
  26. Jeon S (2017) Reconsideration of the chronology of the settlements along the Upper Youngsan River during the Proto-Three Kingdoms and Three Kingdoms Periods. Youngnam Archaeological Review 79:63–100 (in Korean)Google Scholar
  27. Kibblewhite M, Tóth G, Hermann T (2015) Predicting the preservation of cultural artefacts and buried materials in soil. Sci Total Environ 529:249–263CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Kim I (2018) Reconsideration on the C14 age dating period of the Bronze Age through the emergence time of the mandolin shaped bronze dagger. Youngnam Archaeological Review 80:63–100 (in Korean)Google Scholar
  29. Kim J (2001) Elite strategies and the spread of technological innovation: the spread of iron in the Bronze Age Societies of Denmark and Southern Korea. J Anthropol Archaeol 20:442–478CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Kim J (2003) Land-use conflict and the rate of transition to agricultural economy: a comparative study of southern Scandinavia and central-western Korea. J Archaeol Method Theory 10(3):277–321CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Kim J (2010) Opportunistic versus target mode: prey choice changes in central-western Korean prehistory. J Anthropol Archaeol 29(1):80–93CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Kim J (2012) The appearance and spread of “Jangran-hyung Jars” in South Korea. Kogohak 11(3):5–49 (in Korean)Google Scholar
  33. Kim J (2014a) Interdisciplinary research in Archaeology, Physics and Statistics for radiocarbon dating. In proceedings of 38th meeting of Korean Archaeology, The Korean Archaeological Society, Seoul. (in Korean)Google Scholar
  34. Kim J (2014b) Chronology and understandings of formal variability in Korean Archaeology. J Korean Ancient Hist 83:5–32 (in Korean)Google Scholar
  35. Kim J, Kim JK (2016) Radiocarbon dates and pottery chronology of the proto-three kingdoms and three kingdoms periods: Central, Hoseo, and Jeonbuk areas of Korea. J Korean Archaeol Soc 100:46–85 (in Korean)Google Scholar
  36. Kim J, Wright DK, Lee Y, Lee J, Choi S, Kim JK, Ahn SM, Choi J, Seong C, Hyun CH, Hwang J, Yang H, Yang J (2016) AMS dates from two archaeological sites of Korea: blind tests. Radiocarbon 58(1):115–130CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Kong WS, Koo KA, Choi K, Yang JC, Shin CH, Lee SG (2016) Historic vegetation and environmental changes since the 15th century in the Korean Peninsula. Quat Int 392:25–36CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Korean Archaeological Society (2010) Lectures on Korean Archaeology. Sahoepyongron, Seoul (In Korean)Google Scholar
  39. Lee N (2002) Aspect of early iron culture inflowed in Korean Peninsula: the aspect before the establishment of Lo-lang. Journal of the Korean ancient historical. Society 36:31–51 (in Korean)Google Scholar
  40. Lee S (2016) About the archaeological record of the south Korean proto-historic period. Kogohak 15(2):5–41 (in Korean)Google Scholar
  41. Libby WF (1963) The accuracy of radiocarbon dates. Antiquity 37(147):213–219CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Nahm WH, Kim JK, Yang DY, Kim JY, Yi S, Yu KM (2006) Holocene paleosols of the Upo wetland, Korea: their implications for wetland formation. Quat Int 144:53–60CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Nelson DE, Korteling RG, Stott WR (1977) Carbon-14: direct detection at natural concentrations. Science 198:507–508CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Neustupný E (1970) A new epoch in radiocarbon dating. Antiquity 44(173):38–45CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Nolan KC (2012) Temporal hygiene: problems in cultural chronology of the late prehistoric period of the middle Ohio River valley. Southeast Archaeol 31:185–206CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Park J, Constantine M (2015) Multi-proxy evidence for Late-Holocene agricultural activities from coastal lagoons on the East Coast of Korea. In: Kashiwaya K, Shen J, Kim JY (eds) Earth surface processes and environmental changes in East Asia: records from lake-catchment systems. Springer Japan, Tokyo, pp 201–220CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Park J, Yu KB, Lim HS, Shin YH (2012) Holocene environmental changes on the east coast of Korea. J Paleolimnol 48:535–544CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Pettitt PB, Davies W, Gamble CS, Richards MB (2003) Palaeolithic radiocarbon chronology: quantifying our confidence beyond two half-lives. J Archaeol Sci 30:1685–1693CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Pike AW, Hoffmann DL, García-Diez M, Pettitt PB, Alcolea J, De Balbin R et al (2012) U-series dating of Paleolithic art in 11 caves in Spain. Science 336(6087):1409–1413CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Regev L, Eckmeier E, Mintz E, Weiner S, Boaretto E (2011) Radiocarbon concentrations of wood ash calcite: potential for dating. Radiocarbon 53(1):117–127CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Reimer PJ, Baillie MGL, Bard E, Bayliss A, Beck JW, Bertrand CJH, Blackwell PG et al (2004) IntCal04 terrstrial radiocarbon age calibration, 0-26 cal KYR BP. Radiocarbon 46(3):1029–1058CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Reimer PJ, Bard E, Bayliss A, Beck JW, Blackwell PG, Bronk Ramsey C, Buck CE, Cheng H, Edwards RL, Friedrich M, Grootes PM, Guilderson TP, Haflidason H, Hajdas I, Hatté C, Heaton TJ, Hoffmann DL, Hogg AG, Hughen KA, Kaiser KF, Kromer B, Manning SW, Niu M, Reimer RW, Richards DA, Scott EM, Southon JR, Staff RA, Turney CSM, van der Plicht J (2013) Intcal13 and marine13 radiocarbon age calibration curves 0–50,000 years cal BP. Radiocarbon 55(4):1869–1887CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Schiffer MB (1986) Radiocarbon dating and the “old wood” problem: the case of the Hohokam chronology. J Archaeol Sci 13:13–30CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Scott EM, Cook GT, Naysmith P (2007) Error and uncertainty in radiocarbon measurements. Radiocarbon 49(2):427–440CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Shott MJ (1992) Radiocarbon dating as a probabilistic technique: the Childers site and late woodland occupation in the Ohio Valley. Am Antiq 57:202–230CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Stuiver M, Pearson GW, Branziunas TF (1986) Radiocarbon age calibration of marine samples back to 9000 cal yr BP. Radiocarbon 28(2):980–1021CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Stuiver M, Reimer PJ, Bard E, Beck JW, Burr GS, Hughen KA, Kromer B, McCormac G, van der Plicht J, Spurk M (1998) Intcal98 radiocarbon age calibration, 24,000–0 cal BP. Radiocarbon 40(3):1041–1083CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Stuiver M, Suess HE (1966) On the relationship between radiocarbon dates and true sample ages. Radiocarbon 8:534–540CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Suess HE (1970) Bristlecone-pine calibration of the radiocarbon time-scale 5200 BC to the present. Radiocarbon variations and absolute chronology. Proceedings of XIIth Nobel Symposium 1970:303–308Google Scholar
  60. Ward GK, Wilson SR (1978) Procedures for comparing and combining radiocarbon age determinations: a critique. Archaeometry 20(1):19–31CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Wilson SR, Ward GK (1981) Evaluation and clustering of radiocarbon age determination: procedures and paradigms. Archaemetry 23(1):19–39CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Wright DK (2017) Accuracy vs. precision: understanding potential errors from radiocarbon dating on African landscapes. Afr Archaeol Rev 34(3):303–319CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Yi S, Kim JY (2011) Pollen analysis at Paju Unjeong, South Korea: implications of land-use changes since the late Neolithic. The Holocene 22:227–234CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Yi S, Kim JY, Yang DY, Oh KC, Hong SS (2008) Mid-and Late-Holocene palynofloral and environmental change of Korean central region. Quat Int 176:112–120CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Yi S, Yang DY, Jia H (2012) Pollen record of agricultural cultivation in the west–central Korean Peninsula since the Neolithic Age. Quat Int 254:49–57CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Yoon SO, Ahn EJ, Kim HS, Hwang SI (2013) Paleoclimate changes and agriculture activities since ancient times around Gonggeomji, Sangju-si, Gyeongsangbuk-do, South Korea. Journal of the Korean Geomorphological Assoication 20(4):147–163 (In Korean)Google Scholar
  67. Yoon SO, Kim HR, Hwang S, Choi J (2012) Holocene vegetation and climatic change inferred from isopollen maps on the Korean Peninsula. Quat Int 254:58–67CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Zilhão J (2001) Radiocarbon evidence for maritime pioneer colonization at the origins of farming in west Mediterranean Europe. Proc Natl Acad Sci 98(24):14180–14181CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany, part of Springer Nature 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Archaeology and Art HistorySeoul National UniversitySeoulRepublic of Korea
  2. 2.Department of ArchaeologyChungnam National UniversityDaejeonRepublic of Korea

Personalised recommendations