Advertisement

Performance indicators for municipal solid waste management systems in Saudi Arabia: selection and ranking using fuzzy AHP and PROMETHEE II

  • Hatem Abdulaziz AlHumid
  • Husnain HaiderEmail author
  • Saleem S. AlSaleem
  • Md. Shafiquzamman
  • Rehan Sadiq
Original Paper
  • 31 Downloads

Abstract

Municipalities in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA) are managing their municipal solid waste management (MSWM) systems without a structured performance assessment mechanism. For long-term sustainability, all the key components of a MSWM system need to perform efficiently. Identifying suitable performance indicators (PIs) for the regions without having an established performance benchmarking process is a daunting task. A framework is developed to select the PIs for seven key components of MSWM systems, including public service and participation, personnel, physical assets, operational, environmental, sustainability, and financial. Initially, 87 potential PIs were identified under these components through an exhaustive review of literature and expert knowledge. Interview surveys were conducted with decision-makers from two municipalities and academia in the Qassim Region of KSA to evaluate the PIs against three decision criteria, i.e., “relevance,” “measurability,” and “understandability.” For addressing the uncertainties due to vagueness in group decision-making, criteria weights were established through fuzzy analytic hierarchy process (FAHP) while the linguistic scores (defined as fuzzy numbers) were aggregated using the Preference Ranking Organization Method for Enrichment Evaluation (PROMETHEE II). Finally, 61 PIs were selected and ranked, for the seven key components, by the decision-makers based on the outranking relationships. Network maps encompass the selected PIs using the decision-makers’ boundary and leave a choice for including additional PIs in future for continuous performance improvement. A conceptual performance assessment framework has also been proposed for practical implementation of the selected PIs for MSWM systems in KSA and other parts of Gulf region with similar conditions.

Keywords

Municipal solid waste management Performance benchmarking Performance indicators Multicriteria decision-making Fuzzy AHP PROMETHEE II 

Notes

Acknowledgments

The input of the personnel from the participating municipalities operating in Qassim Region for selecting the performance indicators is highly appreciated.

Compliance with ethical standards

Conflict of interest

The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.

References

  1. Abduli MA, Naghib A, Yonesi M, Akbari A (2011) Life cycle assessment (LCA) of solid waste management strategies in Tehran: landfill and composting plus landfill. Environ Monit Assess 178(1–4):487–498CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Agamuthu P (2017) Waste management and recycling performance indicators: priorities and challenges, institute of biological sciences. University of Malaya, Kuala LumpurGoogle Scholar
  3. Al Mazrouei F (2015) Average annual production of household solid waste per person in the Kingdom. Al-Jazirah Daily, Al-Riyadh cityGoogle Scholar
  4. Al-Wabel MI, El-Saeid MH, Al-Turki AM, & Abdel-Nasser G (2011) Monitoring of pesticide residues in Saudi Arabia agricultural soils. Res J Environ Sci 5:269–278Google Scholar
  5. AlHumid HA, Haider H, AlSaleem SS, Alinizzi M, Shafiquzamman M, Sadiq R (2019) Performance assessment model for municipal solid waste management systems: conceptualization, development, and implementation. Environ. 16(2):1–25Google Scholar
  6. Alyaum (2015) The rate of production of solid household waste per day per person in KSA. Alyaum Daily, Dammam CityGoogle Scholar
  7. Anjum M, Miandad R, Waqas M, Ahmad I, Alafif ZOA, Aburiazaiza AS, Barakst MAE, Akhtar T (2016) Solid Waste Management in Saudi Arabia. Appl Agric Biotechnol 1(1):13–26Google Scholar
  8. Armijo C, Puma A, Ojeda S (2011) A set of indicators for waste management programs, 2nd international conference on environmental engineering and applications. Singapore, IPCBEE 17(2011):144–148Google Scholar
  9. Bautista J, Pereira J (2006) Modelling the problem of locating collection areas for urban waste management: an application to the metropolitan area of Barcelona. Omega 34(6):617–629CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Billa L, Pradhan B (2013) GIS Modeling for selection of a transfer station site for residential solid waste separation and recycling, Pertanika J. Sci & Technol 21(1):487–498Google Scholar
  11. Brans JP, Mareschal B, Vinke P (1984) PROMETHEE: a new family of outranking methods in MCDM. In: Brans JP (ed) Operational research IFORS 84. North-Holland, Amsterdam, pp 477–490Google Scholar
  12. Byamba B, Ishikawa M (2017) Municipal solid waste management in Ulaanbaatar Mongolia: systems analysis. Sustain 9(2017):896CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Căilean D, Teodosiu C (2016) An assessment of the Romanian solid waste management system based on sustainable development indicators. Sustain Prod Cons 8:45–56Google Scholar
  14. Capelli L, Sironi S, Del Rosso R, Céntola P, Rossi A, Austeri C (2011) Odour impact assessment in urban areas: case study of the city of Terni. Procedia Environ Sci 4:151–157CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Carl A, Myriam A, Helen A (2017) Urban development series – knowledge papers. World bank group, Washington DCGoogle Scholar
  16. Chang DY (1996) Applications of the extent analysis method on fuzzy AHP. Eur J Oper Res 95(3):649–655CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. CH2M Hill (1996) Hydrogeological Assessment Report for the Buena Vista Landfill and Vicinity, prepared for County of Santa Cruz, California, MayGoogle Scholar
  18. Dubanowitz AJ (2000) Design of a materials recovery facility (MRF) for processing the recyclable materials of New York City’s municipal solid waste. MSc dissertation, Department of Earth and Environmental Engineering, Foundation School of Engineering and Applied Science, Columbia University, New York, USAGoogle Scholar
  19. Filho WL, Brandli L, Moora H, Kruopiene J, Stenmarck A (2016) Benchmarking approaches and methods in the field of urban waste management. J Clean Prod 122:4377–4386CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Gautam AK, Kumar S (2005) Strategic planning of recycling options by multi-objective programming in a GIS environment. Clean Techn Environ Policy 7(4):306–316CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Grabow WO (2009) Encyclopedia of life support systems. Water and Health, Co. Ltd., OxfordGoogle Scholar
  22. Guerrini A, Carvalho P, Romano G, Marques RC, Leardini C (2017) Assessing efficiency drivers in municipal solid waste collection services through a non-parametric method. J Clean Prod 147:431–441CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Haider H, Sadiq R, Tesfamariam S (2014) Performance indicators for small and medium sized water supply systems: a review. Environ Rev 22(1):1–40CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Haider H, Sadiq R, Tesfamariam S (2016) Inter-utility performance benchmarking model for small-to-medium-sized water utilities: aggregated performance indices. J Water Resour Plan Manag 142(1):04015039CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Hayat S, Sheikh SH (2016) Municipal solid waste – engineering principles and management, Second edn. Urban Unit, LahoreGoogle Scholar
  26. Kabir G, Sumi RS (2014) Power substation location selection using fuzzy analytic hierarchy process and PROMETHEE: a case study from Bangladesh. Energy 72:717–730CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Kingdom of Saudi Arabia Vision 2030, <http://vision2030.gov.sa/sites/default/files/report/Saudi_Vision2030_EN_0.pdf>, retrieved on April, 2017Google Scholar
  28. Kjeldsen P, Barlaz M, Rooker A (2002) Present and long-term composition of MSW landfill leachate: a review. Crit Rev Environ Sci Technol 32(4):297–336CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Kuaie M (2014) Quantity of waste in the Kingdom and what is recycled in the Gulf. Al-Riyadh Daily, Al-Riyadh CityGoogle Scholar
  30. Kulikowska D (2011) Nitrogen removal from landfill leachate via the nitrite route. Braz J Chem Eng 29(2):211–219CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Mendes P, Santos AC, Nunes LM, Teixeira MR (2013) Evaluating municipal solid waste management performance in regions with strong seasonal variability. Econ Indic 30:170–177CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Nizami AS (2015) Waste recycling in Saudi Arabia, Ecomena, Doha (Qatar). October 2017Google Scholar
  33. Ouda O (2013) Reviewing the waste-to-energy potential in Saudi Arabia. Presented in ENERWASTE driving sustainable waste to energy conversion. 17-20th march 2013, Abu Dhabi, UAEGoogle Scholar
  34. Pires A, Martinho G, Chang N (2011) Solid waste management in European countries: a review of systems analysis techniques. Environ Manag 92:1033–1050Google Scholar
  35. Population.city (2018) http://population.city/saudi-arabia/buraydah/, retrieved on February 2018
  36. Pressley PN, Levis JW, Damgaard A, Barlaz MA, DeCarolis JF (2015) Analysis of material recovery facilities for use in life-cycle assessment. Waste Manag 35(2015):307–317CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Royal Commission for Jubail, 2017, Cleanliness management, https://www.rcjy.gov.sa/ar-SA/Yanbu/MediaCenter/News/Pages/sul18.aspx, retrieved on October 2017
  38. Saaty TL (1980) The analytical hierarchical process. Wiley, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  39. Saaty TL, Vargas LG (1984) Inconsistency and rank preservation. J Math Psychol 28(2):205–214CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Saaty TL, Vargas LG (1991) Prediction, projection and forecasting. Kluwer Academic Publishers, DordrechtCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Sackey LNA, Meizah K (2015) Assessment of the quality of leachate at Sarbah landfill site at Weija in Accra. J Environ Chem Ecotox 7(6):56–61CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Sanjeevi V, Shahabudeen P (2015) Development of performance indicators for municipal solid waste management (PIMS): a review. Waste Manag 33(12):1052–1065CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Selvan S, Palanivel M, Jayakumar R, Jennifer S (2015) Environmental impact analysis of physico chemical characterization of landfill leachate from municipal solid waste (MSW) dump yard in Dharapuram town, Tamil Nadu, India. Int Res J Environ Sci 5:1–7Google Scholar
  44. Sepco (2017) <http://www.sepcoenvironment.com/construction-waste-management/> retrieved on 5th December 2017
  45. Sequeiros B (2012) Application of performance indicators in municipal waste services. Técnico Lisboa, 767, pp.1–10Google Scholar
  46. Tchobanglous G, Theisen H, Vigil SA (1993) Integrated solid waste management – engineering principles and management issues. McGraw-Hill International, USAGoogle Scholar
  47. TECHNEAU (2007) Assessing consumer preferences for drinking water services- methods for water utilities. An integrated project funded by the European Commission under the sixth framework programme, sustainable development, global change and ecosystems. Thematic Priority Area. EUGoogle Scholar
  48. Teixeira C, Neves E (2001) Gestão de Resíduos – Indicadores de Desempenho de Sistemas. Sector Editorial dos SDE, Série Didáctica – Ciências AplicadasGoogle Scholar
  49. Tseng ML (2011) Importance–performance analysis of municipal solid waste management in uncertainty. Environ Monit Assess 174(1–4):171–187CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Vanhoof K, Ruan D, Li T, Wets G (2009) Intelligent decision making systems, Proceedings of the 4th international ISKE conference world scientific proceedings series computers engineering and information science, vol 2. World Scientific, HasseltGoogle Scholar
  51. Walker E (2017) Visual impact updated draft technical work plan summer. Walker environmental www.walkerea.com
  52. Yesiller N, Hanson J (2003) Analysis of temperatures at a municipal solid waste landfill. Ninth International Waste Management and Landfill Symposium, pp 1–10Google Scholar
  53. Yildirim V, Memisoglu T, Bediroglu S, Colak HE (2018) Municipal solid waste landfill site selection using multi-criteria decision making and GIS: case study of Bursa province. J Environ Eng Landsc Manag 26(2):107–119CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Zafar S (2015) Solid waste management in Saudi Arabia. Published in Ecomena on 28th March 2015, Doha, QatarGoogle Scholar
  55. Zaman A (2014) Measuring waste management performance using the zero waste index: the case of Adelaide, Australia. J Clean Prod 66:407–419CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Saudi Society for Geosciences 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  • Hatem Abdulaziz AlHumid
    • 1
  • Husnain Haider
    • 2
    Email author
  • Saleem S. AlSaleem
    • 2
  • Md. Shafiquzamman
    • 2
  • Rehan Sadiq
    • 3
  1. 1.Project Management DepartmentMunicipality of UnayzahUnayzahSaudi Arabia
  2. 2.Civil Engineering Department, College of EngineeringQassim UniversityBuraydahSaudi Arabia
  3. 3.School of EngineeringUniversity of British Columbia (Okanagan)KelownaCanada

Personalised recommendations