Secundum atrial septal defect in adults: a practical review and recent developments
- 1.2k Downloads
Secundum atrial septal defect (ASDII) is a common congenital heart defect that causes shunting of blood between the systemic and pulmonary circulations. Patients with an isolated ASDII often remain asymptomatic during childhood and adolescence. If the defect remains untreated, however, the rates of exercise intolerance, supraventricular arrhythmias, right ventricular dysfunction and pulmonary arterial hypertension (PAH) increase with patient age, and life expectancy is reduced. Transcatheter and surgical techniques both provide valid options for ASDII closure, the former being the preferred method. With the exception of those with severe and irreversible PAH, closure is beneficial to, and thus indicated in all patients with significant shunts, regardless of age and symptoms. The symptomatic and survival benefits conferred by defect closure are inversely related to patient age and the presence of PAH, supporting timely closure after diagnosis. In this paper we review the management of adult patients with an isolated ASDII, with a focus on aspects of importance to the decision regarding defect closure and medical follow-up.
KeywordsSecundum atrial septal defect Adult Diagnosis Transcatheter closure Surgery
Patients with an isolated secundum atrial septal defect (ASDII) have benefited from diagnostic and therapeutic advancements over the past decades. They can be diagnosed and treated early in life, but frequently remain asymptomatic and unrecognised well into adulthood. Consequently, these patients form a heterogeneous adult population regarding disease burden, risk of complications and required medical surveillance and treatment. In this paper we review the diagnosis and management of ASDII in adults, with attention to recent developments. We focus on the aspects relevant to the decision regarding defect closure, its benefits and limitations and the necessity for continued follow-up, that are important to the general cardiologist confronted with and caring for these patients.
Atrial septal defect (ASD) is a common congenital heart defect, with an estimated birth prevalence of 1.6 per 1000 live births and a 97 % probability of survival into adulthood [1, 2]. ASDII constitutes about 75 % of these defects, has a female predominance of approximately 2:1, and is frequently diagnosed in adulthood [3, 4].
Several genetic syndromes, such as Down, Holt-Oram and Noonan, are associated with ASDII . However, most secundum ASDs occur sporadically, complicating identification of possible causal genes. Nevertheless, several genes underlying ASDII have been identified, including transcription (co-)factor encoding genes such as GATA4, NKX2.5, and TBX5, and sarcomeric protein encoding genes such as ACTC1, MYH6 and MYH7. Secundum ASDs associated with atrioventricular block are linked to NKX2.5 mutations [6, 7]. Although a proportion of secundum ASDs are thus attributable to single-gene defects, its generally sporadic occurrence underlines a multifactorial causal mechanism, involving multiple susceptibility genes and environmental factors . Nevertheless, with familial occurrence of ASDII, cardiogenetic testing is worth consideration as this might identify a known gene mutation, prompt evaluation of and earlier diagnosis in relatives, and aid genetic counselling.
The direction and magnitude of flow through an ASDII depends on defect size and the relative compliance of the left and right heart chambers. Initial left-to-right shunting results from the greater compliance of the right ventricle and right atrium, relative to the left heart chambers. A haemodynamically significant shunt causes right-sided volume overload . Resultant right ventricular (RV) enlargement shifts the interventricular septum toward the left ventricle during diastole. This impairs left ventricular (LV) filling, leading to reduced LV stroke volume and cardiac output, and increased left-to-right shunting . A longstanding shunt results in reduced RV compliance, increased right-sided pressures and reduced left-to-right shunting. This can culminate in RV failure. Pulmonary vascular disease and pulmonary arterial hypertension (PAH) develop in a minority of patients, predominantly in females. Its aetiology is likely multifactorial, and not dependent on shunt size and duration alone. Eventually, pulmonary pressures can reach (supra)systemic levels, causing reversal of the intracardiac shunt: Eisenmenger physiology [3, 11].
Natural history and presenting symptoms
Patients with an isolated ASDII often remain asymptomatic during childhood and adolescence. However, most will become symptomatic from the third or fourth decade, and life expectancy is reduced overall . Common initial symptoms are exercise intolerance and fatigue, which may be aggravated by a supraventricular tachycardia (SVT). SVTs are not infrequently the first clinical manifestation of an ASDII in patients over 40 years . Eventually, right-sided heart failure can develop, often with mild to moderately elevated pulmonary arterial pressure (PAP) [12, 14]. Severe PAH, with possible progression to Eisenmenger physiology, ensues in a minority of patients . Occasionally, a suspected paradoxical systemic thromboembolism initially raises the suspicion of an ASDII being present .
Transthoracic echocardiography (TTE) is the primary imaging modality for the diagnosis of an ASDII and assessing its haemodynamic consequences. RV volume overload, reflected by RV enlargement and diastolic flattening and paradoxical systolic movement of the interventricular septum, indicates a significant shunt . RV and PA pressures are estimated from the peak tricuspid regurgitation jet velocity. When TTE is inconclusive, contrast echocardiography can confirm the presence of an interatrial shunt. Transoesophageal echocardiography (TEE) is required for determining the feasibility of transcatheter closure (See ‘Closure strategy and post-procedural follow-up’ below) . Referral to an adult congenital heart disease (ACHD) centre for further imaging is indicated when interatrial shunting or RV overload is recognised, but cannot be explained.
Cardiac magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) can help clarify the morphology of the defect, and is the gold standard for measurement of ventricular volume and function [18, 19]. Cardiac computed tomography (CT) provides an alternative in patients with contraindications to MRI . Diagnostic catheterisation is only indicated when the possibility of closure is uncertain in patients with high estimated PAP on echocardiography, to assess (reactivity of) pulmonary vascular resistance (PVR) [9, 11].
Indications and contraindications for defect closure
PAH is not an absolute contraindication for defect closure . Although estimation of PAP on echocardiography is usually sufficient, a diagnostic catheterisation to determine (reactivity of) PVR is indicated in selected patients. Closure is indicated if PVR is < 5 Wood units (WU). If the PVR is ≥ 5 WU, closure can still be considered if the pulmonary-to-systemic flow ratio is > 1.5 and PVR or PAP is less than two-thirds of the systemic levels or reactive to a pulmonary vasodilator challenge or targeted pretreatment. Patients with severe and irreversible PAH are not eligible for closure, as the ASDII is then physiologically needed for RV decompression. Similarly, defect closure is contraindicated in case of significant LV dysfunction, as it then decompresses the LV. Thus, patients with PAH or poor LV function should be evaluated in ACHD centres, as they may require invasive pre-interventional testing and treatment .
Closure strategy and post-procedural follow-up
Surgical repair of secundum ASDs is an effective procedure with practically no perioperative mortality and minimal morbidity, although the latter is somewhat higher in elderly patients . Pericardial or synthetic patch closure is preferred over a direct suture, and generally completely terminates the shunt. Minimally invasive techniques have improved cosmetic outcomes, while maintaining the safety and efficacy of the traditional sternotomy . Postoperative follow-up should include ECG surveillance for SVTs, and echocardiographic assessment of residual shunting, RV size and function and PAP. Subsequent annual follow-up is recommended for patients with an ASDII repaired in adulthood, who have or develop SVTs, PAH, ventricular dysfunction or valvular lesions. Current guidelines state that regular follow-up is not required for patients repaired under the age of 25 without relevant complications or residuae . However, recent studies, and yet unpublished results from our own institution, show that even patients with early closure remain at risk of developing PAH late after closure [4, 27, 28]. This indicates that at least sporadic follow-up (i.e. once every 5 years) is indicated in all patients with a closed ASDII.
Effects of defect closure
Cardiac remodelling and exercise capacity. Closure of the ASDII results in right-sided volume unloading and reduction in RA and RV size. The remodelling process and associated increase in cardiopulmonary function commence immediately after closure and continue for several years [10, 35, 36]. Decreased RV volume improves ventricular interaction and LV filling. Subsequent increase in LV stroke volume and cardiac output is probably the main mechanism behind the improvement of exercise capacity after closure. These effects occur in patients of all ages, both symptomatic and asymptomatic. Although normal exercise capacity is reached in the majority, it may remain subnormal in those with poor cardiopulmonary function prior to closure . This supports timely closure of sizeable secundum ASDs, regardless of age and symptoms.
Pulmonary hypertension. After ASDII closure in childhood or adolescence, PAH development later in life is unlikely, although not completely obviated [4, 27, 28, 37]. Among untreated adults, older age, greater defect size and female sex are associated with a greater frequency of PAH. Provided that pulmonary vascular disease has not progressed irreversibly, device closure can safely and effectively reduce PAP. Higher PAP and younger age are associated with a greater chance and magnitude of reduction in PAP. However, normalisation of PAP occurs less frequently with more severe PAH . Moreover, if closure is performed late in life, the chance of PAH developing thereafter is increased . These data strengthen the rationale for early closure.
Patients with an ASDII, open or closed, and PAH should be referred to an ACHD centre. As their haemodynamic balance is readily disrupted, planned medication changes or interventions should be discussed with their specialised caregiver. Moreover, the prescription of disease-targeting therapy such as the endothelin antagonist bosentan is restricted to these specialists. When PAH develops late after closure, other non-shunt-related risk factors should be ruled out to appropriately target therapy [9, 11].
Supraventricular tachycardias are common late in the natural history of an ASDII [13, 21], and defect closure is of preventive, but not therapeutic value in this regard. Thus, SVTs are not a decisive indication for defect closure in the absence of other symptomatology. Among patients who underwent closure in childhood or early adolescence, SVTs are rare during long-term follow-up . Those with a history of SVT or PAH and those treated later in life, especially at ages over 40 years, remain at increased risk [13, 21, 38]. Paroxysmal SVTs may not recur after closure, but chronic SVTs usually persist. Concomitant Maze procedure during surgery or electrical cardioversion at the time of device closure is worth consideration [9, 38, 39]. Class III antiarrhythmic agents may be the most effective in maintaining sinus rhythm after cardioversion in these patients .
In patients developing symptomatic drug-resistant atrial fibrillation after closure, catheter ablation is an effective treatment. Perceived difficulty in obtaining prerequisite left atrial access may discourage its utilisation in patients with an ASD closure device. However, intracardiac echocardiography-guided transseptal catheter ablation is safe and effective, even in the presence of a closure device. Left atrial access is generally achieved through residual native septum. In the absence of a suitable native septal area, direct puncture of the Amplatzer device is possible, at the cost of greater technical difficulty and longer procedural time. Although no long-term data are available, complications and residual shunts are rare with both approaches . Retrograde aortic access using remote magnetic navigation may provide an alternative approach .
Survival. Closure confers a survival benefit in all ASDII patients, regardless of age . However, eventual life expectancy is dependent on age at closure. An often-cited study into the long-term outcome after surgical repair showed normal survival after closure under the age of 25. In contrast, patients operated later in life, especially at ages over 40, experienced increased mortality . Percutaneous closure can be expected to confer a survival benefit at least similar to that reported in surgical series, but a randomised comparison to prove and quantify this benefit would be unethical in the current era. The excellent survival of the contemporary ASDII population is confirmed by unpublished data from our own institution which suggest normal overall life expectancy, although this appears to be restricted to the female majority [43, 44].
Sports participation, diving and high altitude
The basis for recommendations regarding the safety of competitive sports participation is the individual patients’ abilities, haemodynamics and risk of decompensation or dysrhythmias. Nevertheless, general recommendations can be given. Evaluation should include a comprehensive history and physical examination, ECG, chest X-ray, TTE and exercise testing. Before or from 6 months after defect closure, asymptomatic patients with normal PAP can participate in all sports, while restriction to low-intensity sports is indicated when PAH is present. Eisenmenger physiology precludes sports participation. In the presence of symptomatic dysrhythmias, second-degree or third-degree heart block or ventricular dysfunction, individual evaluation and exercise prescription are indicated, for which we refer to the current guidelines .
Scuba diving carries the risk of developing decompression illness (DCI), which results from gasses coming out of solution into bubbles in blood and tissue upon ascent from a dive. Although absolute risk remains low, divers with an interatrial communication are at increased risk for major neurological DCI . The presumed mechanism is paradoxical embolisation of venous gas bubbles to the systemic arterial circulation. The association between interatrial shunts and neurological DCI has mainly been studied in divers with a patent foramen ovale, but the same principles apply to ASDII. Defect closure might prevent the occurrence of neurological DCI in divers, but this was shown in only one small prospective study . Based on the above, screening for an interatrial shunt may be indicated in divers that have developed DCI. When present, closure of the interatrial defect may prevent occurrence of major DCI, but the evidence is scarce and abstinence from diving might be advisable.
Regardless of health status, residing at high altitude exposes the individual to lower environmental partial oxygen pressures and lower arterial oxygen tensions, with the risk of maladaptation and height-related diseases. These issues should be addressed in pretravel counselling . Evidence-based recommendations for stays at high altitude in adult ASDII patients are not available. However, patients with uncomplicated defects should not require additional assessment. In contrast, patients with PAH or cyanosis require echocardiographic assessment of RV function and PAP, as well as cardiopulmonary exercise testing. At high altitude, hypoxic pulmonary vasoconstriction raises PVR resulting in persistent elevation of PAP. Consequently, RV workload and right-to-left shunting increase, predisposing these patients to RV failure, severe hypoxaemia and the development of high altitude pulmonary oedema . Cyanotic patients with coexisting anaemia, ventricular dysfunction or low exercise capacity should avoid stays at high altitude (> 1800 m), as should those with PAP > 35 mmHg. If they do travel to such altitudes, supplemental oxygen is to be advised. Pharmacological prophylaxis (nifedipine, sildenafil) can be considered for those with milder PAH. The evidence upon which these recommendations are based has been reviewed by Luks et al. .
Women with an open ASDII not complicated by PAH generally tolerate pregnancy well. Defect closure before pregnancy, however, might lower the risk of paradoxical embolus and functional deterioration. Moreover, compared with the general population, women with an open ASD have increased risks of pre-eclampsia, foetal loss and low birth weight. In contrast, outcome for women with a closed ASD is similar to that of the general population . Thus, if the diagnosis has been established, closure of the defect before pregnancy is preferable.
Pregnancy is contraindicated in women with severe PAH, especially in those with Eisenmenger physiology. Patients and partners should be counselled about avoiding pregnancy. Referral to a high-risk obstetrical specialist is recommended for selecting contraceptive methods, as all carry specific risks .
Patients with an ASDII that causes enlargement of the right heart chambers are subject to important age-related morbidity and reduced life-expectancy. All haemodynamically significant secundum ASDs should be closed, regardless of age and symptoms, preferably using a transcatheter device. Current evidence suggests the beneficial effects of defect closure to be inversely related to patient age, supporting timely closure after diagnosis. Treated patients, especially those with pre-existing PAH or dysrhythmia and those treated later in life, remain at increased risk for cardiovascular morbidity and should stay under medical surveillance.
The work performed for this review was carried out in the context of the Parelsnoer Institute (PSI). PSI is part of and funded by the Dutch Federation of University Medical Centers.
Conflict of interest
- 1.Van der Linde D, Konings EEM, Slager MA, et al. Birth prevalence of congenital heart disease worldwide: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2011;58:2241–7.Google Scholar
- 5.Pierpont ME, Basson CT, Benson DW, et al. Genetic basis for congenital heart defects: current knowledge a scientific statement from the American Heart Association Congenital Cardiac Defects Committee, Council on Cardiovascular Disease in the Young: endorsed by the American Academy of Pediatrics. Circulation. 2007;115:3015–38.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- 9.Baumgartner H, Bonhoeffer P, Groot NMSD, et al. ESC Guidelines for the management of grown-up congenital heart disease (new version 2010) The Task Force on the Management of Grown-up Congenital Heart Disease of the European Society of Cardiology (ESC). Eur Heart J. 2010;31:2915–57.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- 19.Pérez Matos AJ, Planken RN, Bouma BJ, et al. Unroofed coronary sinus newly diagnosed in adult patients after corrected congenital heart disease. Neth Heart J. 2014;22:240–5.Google Scholar
- 32.Abaci A, Unlu S, Alsancak Y, Kaya U, Sezenoz B. Short and long term complications of device closure of atrial septal defect and patent foramen ovale: meta-analysis of 28,142 patients from 203 studies: complications of ASD and PFO Closure. Catheter Cardiovasc Interv. 2013;82:1123–38.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- 33.Mullen MJ, Hildick-Smith D, De Giovanni JV, et al. BioSTAR Evaluation STudy (BEST): a prospective, multicenter, phase I clinical trial to evaluate the feasibility, efficacy, and safety of the BioSTAR bioabsorbable septal repair implant for the closure of atrial-level shunts. Circulation. 2006;114:1962–7.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- 46.Lairez O, Cournot M, Minville V, et al. Risk of neurological decompression sickness in the diver with a right-to-left shunt: literature review and meta-analysis. J Sport Med. 2009;19:231–5.Google Scholar
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License which permits any use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and the source are credited.