Comprehensive assessment of spotty calcifications on computed tomography angiography: Comparison to plaque characteristics on intravascular ultrasound with radiofrequency backscatter analysis
- First Online:
- 602 Downloads
The purpose of the study was to systematically compare calcification patterns in plaques on computed tomography angiography (CTA) with plaque characteristics on intravascular ultrasound with radiofrequency backscatter analysis (IVUS-VH).
Methods and Results
In total, 108 patients underwent CTA and IVUS-VH. On CTA, calcification patterns in plaques were classified as non-calcified, spotty or dense calcifications. Plaques with spotty calcifications were differentiated into small spotty (<1 mm), intermediate spotty (1-3 mm) and large spotty calcifications (≥3 mm). Plaque characteristics deemed more high-risk on IVUS-VH were defined by % necrotic core (NC) and presence of thin cap fibroatheroma (TCFA). Overall, 300 plaques were identified both on CTA and IVUS-VH. % NC core was significantly higher in plaques with small spotty calcifications as compared to non-calcified plaques (20% vs 13%, P = .006). In addition, there was a trend for a higher % NC in plaques with small spotty calcifications than in plaques with intermediate spotty calcifications (20% vs 14%, P = .053). Plaques with small spotty calcifications had the highest % TCFA as compared to large spotty and dense calcifications (31% vs 9% and 31% vs 6%, P < .05).
Plaques with small spotty calcifications on CTA were related to plaque characteristics deemed more high-risk on IVUS-VH. Therefore, CTA may be valuable in the assessment of the vulnerable plaque.
Key WordsAtherosclerosis computed tomography (CT) vulnerable atherosclerotic plaque
Computed tomography angiography (CTA) is a rapidly evolving technique that has the ability to non-invasively and accurately detect significant coronary artery stenosis and coronary atherosclerotic plaque.1-5 A potentially interesting application of CTA would be the identification of patients or lesions that have an increased likelihood of plaque rupture leading to acute coronary events. Several previous studies have identified specific plaque characteristics which are frequently observed with CTA in patients presenting with acute coronary syndrome (ACS).6-8 Among these characteristics, a spotty pattern of calcifications has been related to the presence of ACS.6-8 Indeed, preliminary data with CTA demonstrated that culprit lesions in patients with ACS had a higher prevalence of smaller spotty calcifications than target lesions in patient with stable complaints.9 Moreover, the presence of spotty calcifications on CTA were associated with a higher likelihood of developing ACS.8
More detailed information on plaque characteristics can be obtained by intravascular ultrasound with radiofrequency backscatter analysis (IVUS-VH).10,11 This technique was developed to improve grayscale intravascular ultrasound tissue characterization and provide detailed quantitative information on plaque composition in vivo.12,13 Additionally, the presence of thin cap fibroatheroma (TCFA) on IVUS-VH was demonstrated to be independently predictive of major cardiovascular events during follow-up.14
However, the relation between calcification patterns on CTA and plaque characteristics on IVUS-VH has not been previously reported. Furthermore, in previous studies, the definition of spotty calcification on CTA has been variable. Indeed, definitions for spotty calcification on CTA have ranged from presence of any calcified material embedded in non-calcified plaque to a specific threshold regarding the size of calcification. Subsequently, due to the inconsistency of definitions, comparability of spotty calcifications on CTA between investigations is hampered. Therefore, the purpose of the study was to perform a systematic evaluation of plaques with different calcification patterns on CTA and relate this to plaque characteristics on IVUS-VH.
Patient Population and Study Protocol
A total of 108 patients were included in this evaluation who underwent CTA prior to invasive coronary angiography with IVUS-VH of 1 to 3 vessels, as part of clinical protocol. For this retrospective evaluation, consecutive patients were selected as part of an ongoing registry addressing the relative merits of CTA in relation to other imaging techniques.15 Patient with chest pain were referred for imaging for the non-invasive evaluation of coronary artery disease (CAD), according to clinical protocol. Thereafter, patients were referred for invasive coronary angiography in combination with IVUS-VH based on the patient’s clinical presentation and/or imaging results to further evaluate the extent and severity of CAD. During invasive coronary angiography, an experienced interventional cardiologist decided whether IVUS studies should be performed. Clinical history was evaluated between the CTA examination and invasive coronary angiography to ensure that neither acute coronary syndromes nor worsening of angina occurred between examinations. Exclusion criteria for CTA examination were: (i) (supra) ventricular arrhythmias, (ii) renal failure (glomerular filtration rate <30 mL/minute), (iii) known allergy to iodine contrast material, (iv) severe claustrophobia, (v) pregnancy. Patient data were prospectively collected in the departmental Cardiology Information System (EPD-Vision®, Leiden University Medical Center, Leiden, the Netherlands) and retrospectively analyzed. Our institutional review board does not require its approval and written informed consent for retrospective technical analysis of data, as was the case for this study. In each patient, the presence of risk factors for CAD and medication (use of aspirin, statins, beta-blocking medication and angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitors) were recorded.
CTA examination was performed using either a 64-row helical scanner (Aquilion 64, Toshiba Medical Systems, Toshiba Medical Systems, Otawara, Japan) or a 320-row volumetric scanner (Aquilion ONE, Toshiba Medical Systems, Otawara, Japan). If the patient’s heart rate was ≥65 beats/minute and no contra-indications existed, beta-blocking medication (metoprolol 50 or 100 mg, single oral dose, 1 hour prior to examination) was administered. Scan parameters for the 64-row contrast enhanced scan were: 400 ms gantry rotation time, collimation of 64 × 0.5 mm, tube voltage of 100-135 kV and tube current of 250-350 mA, depending on body posture. Non-ionic contrast material (Iomeron 400, Bracco, Milan, Italy or Ultravist 370, Bayer Schering Pharma AG Berlin, Germany) was administered with an amount of 80-110 mL followed by a saline flush with a flow rate of 5 mL/second. Datasets were reconstructed from the retrospectively gated raw data, the best phase was reconstructed with an interval of 0.3 mm. Using a single test slice reconstructed throughout the various phases of the heart cycle, other suitable R-R intervals were examined for additional reconstructions. Concerning the 320-row contrast enhanced scan; imaging was performed in a single volume using prospective triggering with exposure interval depending on the heart rate. If the heart rate was ≥65 beats/minute, the phase window was set 65%-85% of R-R interval, if the heart rate was stable and <60 beats/minute the phase window was set at 70%-80% of R-R interval. Scan parameters were: 350 ms gantry rotation time, 320 × 0.5 mm collimation, 100-135 kV tube voltage and a tube current of 400-580 mA, depending on body mass index (BMI). Overall, 60-90 mL contrast material (Iomeron 400, Bracco, Milan, Italy) was administered with a rate of 5-6 mL/second followed by a saline flush. Data acquisition was performed during an inspiratory breath hold of approximately 4-10 seconds. Subsequently, images were reconstructed in the best phase of the R-R interval and transferred to a remote workstation for post-processing.
CTA datasets were evaluated using dedicated software (Vitrea 2.0 or Vitrea FX 1.1 Vital images, Minnetonka, MN, USA). Analysis was performed with the use of available post-processing tools such as cross-sectional axial slices and multiplanar reconstructions. One experienced reader, blinded to the IVUS-VH results, evaluated the CTA datasets. The coronary arteries were divided into 17 segments according to the modified American Heart Association classification.16 Each segment was evaluated for the presence of any atherosclerotic plaque. Structures >1 mm2 within and/or adjacent to the coronary artery lumen, which could be clearly distinguished from the vessel lumen, were defined as atherosclerotic plaque.3
Conventional invasive coronary angiography was performed according to standard protocols. IVUS examinations were acquired with a 20 MHz, 2.9 F phased-array IVUS catheter, (Eagle Eye, Volcano Corporation, Rancho Cordova, CA, USA) and a dedicated IVUS-console (Volcano Corporation, Rancho Cordova, CA, USA) after intracoronary administration of nitroglycerine. Under fluoroscopic guidance, the IVUS catheter was introduced distally in the coronary artery and a motorized automated pullback with a continuous speed of 0.5 mm/second was used until the catheter reached the guiding catheter. Images were stored on CD-ROM or DVD for off-line analysis.
IVUS-VH analysis was performed by two experienced observers blinded to baseline patient characteristics and CTA findings with the use of dedicated software (QCU-CMS, version 4.59, Medis Medical Imaging Systems, Leiden, the Netherlands). First, contour detection (lumen and media interface) was performed manually with the use of cross-sectional views to provide compositional output.19 Secondly, on a frame-by-frame basis, the four different tissue components were differentiated and labeled with four different color-codes (fibrotic tissue was labeled in dark green, fibro-fatty tissue in light green, necrotic core in red and dense calcium in white), as validated previously.10 The mean percentage of each plaque component was obtained in the full length of the lesion observed on the CTA examination. A lesion on intravascular ultrasound imaging was defined as at least three consecutive frames with a plaque burden of at least 40%.20 In addition, the presence of the thin cap fibroatheroma (TCFA) was evaluated on a per-lesion basis. TCFA was defined as a lesion with a plaque burden ≥40%, presence of >10% confluent necrotic core on three consecutive frames and necrotic core in contact with the lumen for along the lumen circumference.14,21,22 High-risk plaque characteristics on IVUS-VH were defined by % of necrotic core and presence of TCFA.
Plaques available on both CTA and IVUS-VH were included in the lesion based analysis. Plaque composition (% fibrotic, fibro-fatty, necrotic core, and dense calcium) and presence of TCFA was compared between lesions with different calcification patterns on CTA (non-calcified, small spotty calcifications, intermediate spotty calcifications, large spotty calcifications, and dense calcifications). If normally distributed, continuous values were expressed as means (±standard deviation) and differences in plaque composition and type were assessed using an analysis of variance (ANOVA). If not normally distributed, values were expressed as medians (interquartile range (IQR)) and differences in plaque composition and type were assessed using the Kruskall-Wallis test. To account for possible clustering of coronary artery plaques within patients, the generalized estimating equation (GEE) method was applied to evaluate the differences in plaque characteristics between the groups of different calcification patterns on CTA (non-calcified, small spotty calcifications, intermediate spotty calcifications, large spotty calcifications, and dense calcium). This was performed with proc GENMOD with a binominal distribution for the outcome variable, the link function specified as a logistical (presence of TCFA) or a linear (% fibrotic, fibro-fatty, necrotic core, and dense calcium) distribution and patients as separate subjects. Due to lack of power, we did not perform post-hoc analysis. A P value of <.05 was considered statistically significant. Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS 17.0 software (SPSS Inc., Chicago. Illinois).
Baseline patient characteristics
Number of patients
57 ± 10
Stable angina/suspected acute coronary syndrome
Family history of CAD
Obesity (≥30 kg/m2)
Medication at time of referral
Previous myocardial infarction
Baseline CTA and IVUS-VH Results
In total, 799 plaques were demonstrated on CTA and in 300 plaques (38%) IVUS-VH was also available. Of the 300 plaques identified on CTA, 78 plaques (26%) were non-calcified, 39 plaques (13%) had small spotty calcifications (<1 mm), 96 plaques (32%) had intermediate spotty calcifications (1-3 mm), 54 plaques (18%) had large spotty calcifications (≥3 mm), and 33 plaques (11%) had dense calcifications. On IVUS-VH, the average plaque length analyzed was 26 ± 18 mm. The most prevalent plaque component was fibrotic tissue (58%, IQR 50%-63%), followed by necrotic core (15%, IQR 10%-21%), fibro-fatty tissue (13%, IQR 8%-21%), and dense calcium (6%, IQR 3%-10%). Visual plaque assessment revealed that 52 plaques (17%) were classified as TCFA.
Comparison of Calcification Patterns on CTA and Plaque Composition on IVUS-VH
Plaque composition on intravascular ultrasound with radiofrequency backscatter analysis (IVUS-VH) is reported in relation to the different calcification patterns on computed tomography angiography (CTA)
Small spotty (<1 mm)
Intermediate spotty (1-3 mm)
Large spotty (≥3 mm)
Global P value
% Necrotic core
% Dense calcium
This study systematically evaluated the relation between different calcification patterns on CTA and plaque characteristics on invasive IVUS-VH. It was demonstrated that plaques with spotty calcifications, in particular the smaller spotty calcifications (<1 mm) had plaque characteristics deemed high-risk on IVUS-VH, as defined by a higher % of necrotic core and presence of TCFA.
Interestingly, the present findings are in line with histopathological studies which have reported that lesions associated with acute coronary events are often not heavily calcified.20,21,23 Burke et al21 studied the degree of calcification in serial sections of coronary arteries in sudden coronary death cases and observed that plaque ruptures showed relatively little calcification and that most acute plaque ruptures resulting in sudden death occurred in areas of only mild speckled calcification. Furthermore, smaller calcium deposits on grayscale IVUS have been related to more unstable clinical presentation such as unstable angina and myocardial infarction. Beckman et al24 measured the arc of calcium in lesions of 78 patients and found that the average arc of calcium was greatest (32° ± 7°) in patients with stable angina, less (15° ± 4°) in patients with unstable angina, and least (10° ± 5°) in patients with acute myocardial infarction (P < .014). In line with these findings, van der Hoeven et al18 studied 60 patients with acute myocardial infarction on grayscale IVUS and demonstrated that small calcified spots (arc <45°, length <1.5 mm) were more common in the culprit lesions as compared to the adjacent distal and proximal segments. Accordingly, Ehara et al25 confirmed the findings in a larger patient population of 178 patients with grayscale IVUS. The authors found that not only the frequency of calcium deposits was significantly different between patients with stable, unstable angina, and myocardial infarction but also calcium deposits were significantly longer in patients with stable angina (mean length of 4.3 ± 3.2 mm) as compared to patients with unstable angina (mean length of 1.9 ± 1.8) and myocardial infarction (mean length of 2.2 ± 1.6). Thus, these findings support the concept that there may be a significant difference in the pattern of coronary calcifications, particularly with respect to size and length of the deposits, among patients with stable and unstable angina.
Non-invasively, calcium scoring with electron beam computed tomography (EBCT) showed similar findings. Although a higher calcium score has been related to larger plaque areas and worse prognosis,26 when comparing coronary calcium scores of patients with stable angina to patients with acute myocardial infarction, significant differences were observed.27 Extensive calcium was more often present in the coronary arteries of patients with chronic stable angina, whereas patients with acute myocardial infarction demonstrated a more diffuse pattern of calcifications. More interestingly, using contrast-enhanced CTA, the presence of spotty calcifications were frequently present in lesions of patients with ACS but rarely observed in culprit lesions of patients with stable CAD.9 Similarly, Motoyama et al7,8 demonstrated both retrospectively and prospectively with CTA that non-calcified plaques with spotty calcifications and positive remodeling were associated with a higher likelihood of the development of ACS. However, unlike this study, the aforementioned findings were not related to invasive observations. Interestingly, a previous study by our institution evaluated the association between plaque composition on CTA and the presence of high-risk features on IVUS-VH in a smaller population of 50 patients.28 It was demonstrated that the more high-risk plaques (TCFA) were most often present in mixed plaques (32%) on CTA. Although similar to the current findings, the % of TCFA in mixed plaques was higher in the previous evaluation than in the current study (31%). This could probably be explained by difference in the size and baseline characteristics of the patient population. In addition, the amount of dense calcium in the current study is somewhat lower than reported in other studies. However, this could be explained by the inclusion of a substantial number (65%) of patients presenting with acute coronary syndrome, known to have substantially less calcified arteries.
Interestingly, earlier investigations have used various definitions of spotty calcifications on CTA. For instance, some investigations described spotty calcification as any calcified material embedded within a non-calcified plaque, whereas other use a threshold of calcified material less than 3 mm in size.7,9,29 However, a comprehensive approach for the evaluation of the extent of the spotty calcifications on CTA is preferred, thereby improving reproducibility and use in risk stratification. The strength of the current study is that a systematic approach for the evaluation of spotty calcifications was applied, demonstrating that indeed the smaller spotty calcifications were related to the plaque characteristics deemed more high-risk such as necrotic core and presence of TCFA.
Importantly, the findings are clinically relevant considering that CTA is increasingly used for the assessment of CAD and the use of this technique is extended from assessment of stenosis to the evaluation of the vessel wall. Nevertheless, even with the latest generation CTA scanners, exact identification of the lipid core and thin fibrous cap is not feasible at the moment. Therefore, assessment of spotty calcification on CTA may be beneficial for individualized risk stratification in combination with other high-risk features such as cardiovascular risk factors and biomarkers. Perhaps, CTA has a potential application in the context of identifying the “vulnerable” patient at risk for ACS. However, the clinical and prognostic impact of these findings has to be evaluated in future prospective studies.
First, due to the limitations of intravascular ultrasound, not all plaques on CTA were also evaluated by IVUS-VH. In addition, detection of the thin fibrous cap (<65 μm) is not yet feasible as IVUS-VH has a limited radial resolution of only 100 μm. Furthermore, it has been suggested that dense calcium on IVUS-VH is related to artifacts in the form of a halo of necrotic core surrounding dense calcium. However, no standardized method for correcting for this issue is currently available. Additionally, no other high risk plaque characteristics were assessed on CTA. Potentially, incorporating other CTA variables such as degree of stenosis and overall plaque burden, may allow for better risk stratification. In addition, this study performed a retrospective analysis of data possibly introducing a bias with regards to lesion selection. Future evaluations examining on the relationship between calcification patterns on CTA and IVUS-VH characteristics should be performed in a more prospective manner. Moreover, reproducibility information on the measurement of calcification on CTA was not provided. Lastly, CTA is inherently associated with radiation exposure. However, recently, dose-saving algorithms and prospective ECG triggering were introduced to substantially reduce radiation dose.30
The current study demonstrated that plaques with small spotty calcifications on CTA were related to plaque characteristics deemed more high-risk on invasive IVUS-VH. Therefore, CTA may be valuable in the assessment of the vulnerable plaque.
Dr Schalij has research grants from Boston Scientific (Natick, USA), Medtronic (Minneapolis, United States) and Biotronik (Berlin, Germany). Dr Jukema receives grants from Biotronik (Berlin, Germany), Boston Scientific (Natick, USA), Astra Zeneca (London, United Kingdom), Pfizer (New York, United States), MSD (New Jersey, United States). Dr Bax has research grants from Medtronic (Minneapolis, United States), Boston Scientific (Natick, United States), BMS medical imaging (New York, United States), St. Jude Medical (St. Paul, United States), GE Healthcare (Chalfont St Giles, United Kingdom), Biotronik (Berlin, Germany), and Edwards Lifesciences (Irvine, United States).
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.
- 2.Budoff MJ, Dowe D, Jollis JG, Gitter M, Sutherland J, Halamert E, et al. Diagnostic performance of 64-multidetector row coronary computed tomographic angiography for evaluation of coronary artery stenosis in individuals without known coronary artery disease: Results from the prospective multicenter ACCURACY (Assessment by Coronary Computed Tomographic Angiography of Individuals Undergoing Invasive Coronary Angiography) trial. J Am Coll Cardiol 2008;52:1724-32.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 3.Leber AW, Knez A, Becker A, Becker C, von ZF, Nikolaou K, et al. Accuracy of multidetector spiral computed tomography in identifying and differentiating the composition of coronary atherosclerotic plaques: A comparative study with intracoronary ultrasound. J Am Coll Cardiol 2004;43:1241-7.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 5.Van Velzen JE, Schuijf JD, De Graaf FR, Boersma E, Pundziute G, Spano F, et al. Diagnostic performance of non-invasive multidetector computed tomography coronary angiography to detect coronary artery disease using different endpoints: Detection of significant stenosis vs. detection of atherosclerosis. Eur Heart J 2011;32:637-45.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 6.Hoffmann U, Moselewski F, Nieman K, Jang I, Ferencik M, Rahman A. Noninvasive assessment of plaque morphology and composition in culprit and stable lesions in acute coronary syndrome and stable lesions in stable angina by multidetector computed tomography. J Am Coll Cardiol 2006;47:1655-62.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 13.Voros S, Rinehart S, Qian Z, Vazquez G, Anderson H, Murrieta L, et al. Prospective validation of standardized, 3-dimensional, quantitative coronary computed tomographic plaque measurements using radiofrequency backscatter intravascular ultrasound as reference standard in intermediate coronary arterial lesions: Results from the ATLANTA (assessment of tissue characteristics, lesion morphology, and hemodynamics by angiography with fractional flow reserve, intravascular ultrasound and virtual histology, and noninvasive computed tomography in atherosclerotic plaques) I study. JACC Cardiovasc Interv 2011;4:198-208.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 16.Austen WG, Edwards JE, Frye RL, Gensini GG, Gott VL, Griffith LS, et al. A reporting system on patients evaluated for coronary artery disease. Report of the Ad Hoc Committee for Grading of Coronary Artery Disease, Council on Cardiovascular Surgery, American Heart Association. Circulation 1975;51:5-40.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- 17.Kitagawa T, Yamamoto H, Horiguchi J, Ohhashi N, Tadehara F, Shokawa T, et al. Characterization of noncalcified coronary plaques and identification of culprit lesions in patients with acute coronary syndrome by 64-slice computed tomography. JACC Cardiovasc Imaging 2009;2:153-60.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 19.Mintz GS, Nissen SE, Anderson WD, Bailey SR, Erbel R, Fitzgerald PJ, et al. American College of Cardiology Clinical Expert Consensus Document on Standards for Acquisition, Measurement and Reporting of Intravascular Ultrasound Studies (IVUS). A report of the American College of Cardiology Task Force on Clinical Expert Consensus Documents. J Am Coll Cardiol 2001;37:1478-92.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 29.Utsunomiya H, Yamamoto H, Kunita E, Kitagawa T, Ohashi N, Oka T, et al. Combined presence of aortic valve calcification and mitral annular calcification as a marker of the extent and vulnerable characteristics of coronary artery plaque assessed by 64-multidetector computed tomography. Atherosclerosis 2010;213:166-72.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar