A critical review of fault modeling of HVAC systems in buildings
- 30 Downloads
Buildings consumed about 40% of primary energy and 70% of the electricity in the U.S. It is well known that most buildings lose a portion of their desired and designed energy efficiency in the years after they are commissioned or recommissioned. Majority of the Heating, Ventilation, and Air-Conditioning (HVAC) systems have multiple faults residing in the systems causing either energy, thermal comfort, or indoor air quality penalties. There are hundreds of fault detection and diagnostics (FDD) algorithms available, but there is lacking a common framework to assess and validate those FDD algorithms. Fault modeling is one of the key components of such a framework. In general, fault modeling has two purposes: testing and assessment of FDD algorithms, and fault impacts analysis in terms of building energy consumption and occupants’ thermal comfort. It is expected that fault ranking from the fault impact analysis can facilitate building facility managers to make decisions. This paper provides a detailed review of current state-of-the-art for the fault modeling of HVAC systems in buildings, including fault model, fault occurrence probability, and fault simulation platform. Fault simulations considering fault occurrence probability can generate realistic faulty data across a variety of faulty operating conditions, and facilitate testing and assessment of different FDD algorithms. They can also help the fault impact study. Three research gaps are identified through this critical literature review: (1) The number of available fault models of HVAC systems is still limited. A fault model library could be developed to cover all common HVAC faults for both traditional and non-traditional HVAC systems. (2) It is imperative to include the fault occurrence probability in fault simulations for a realistic fault impacts analysis such as fault ranking. (3) Fault simulation platforms need further improvements to better facilitate the fault impact analysis.
Keywordsfault modeling fault simulation fault impact analysis fault occurrence
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- Allen JG, MacNaughton P, Satish U, Santanam S, Vallarino J, Spengler JD (2016). Associations of cognitive function scores with carbon dioxide, ventilation, and volatile organic compound exposures in office workers: a controlled exposure study of green and conventional office environments. Environmental Health Perspectives, 124: 805–812.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Basarkar M, Pang X, Wang L, Haves P, Hong T (2013). Modeling and simulation of HVAC faults in EnergyPlus. In: Proceedings of the 12th International IBPSA Building Simulation Conferenc, Sydney, Australia.Google Scholar
- Brambley MR, Haves P, McDonald SC, Torcellini P, Hansen DG, Holmberg D, Roth K (2005). Advanced sensors and controls for building applications: Market assessment and potential R&D pathways. Richland, WA, USA: Pacific Northwest National Laboratory.Google Scholar
- Brambley MR, Katipamula S (2009). Commercial building re-tuning: A low-cost approach to improved performance and energy efficiency. ASHRAE Journal, 51(10): 12–23.Google Scholar
- Bynum JD, Claridge DE, Curtin JM (2010). Development and testing of an automated building commissioning analysis tool (ABCAT). In: Proceeding of ASME 4th International Conference on Energy Sustainability ES2010, Phoenix, USA.Google Scholar
- Cheung H, Braun JE (2012a). Inverse modeling to simulate fault impacts for vapor compression equipment Part 1: Component modeling and validation. In: Proceedings of International Refrigeration and Air Conditioning Conference, West Lafayette, IN, USA.Google Scholar
- Cheung H, Braun JE (2012b). Inverse modeling to simulate fault impacts for vapor compression equipment Part 2: System modeling and validation. In: Proceedings of International Refrigeration and Air Conditioning Conference, West Lafayette, IN, USA.Google Scholar
- Cheung H, Braun JE (2015). Development of fault models for hybrid fault detection and diagnostics algorithm. Golden, CO, USA: National Renewable Energy Laboratory.Google Scholar
- Comstock M, Braun JE (2002). Fault detection and diagnostic (FDD) requirements and evaluation tools for chillers. ASHRAE Report, RP-1043.Google Scholar
- Comstock MC, Braun JE, Bernhard R (1999). Development of analysis tools for the evaluation of fault detection and diagnostics in chillers. Purdue University.Google Scholar
- Cowan A (2004). Review of recent commercial roof top unit field studies in the Pacific Northwest and California. White Salmon, WA, USA: New Buildings Institute.Google Scholar
- Curtin JM, Claridge DE, Painter F, Verdict M, Wang G, Liu M (2007). Development and testing of an automated building commissioning analysis tool (ABCAT). California Energy Commission, PIER Energy-Related Environmental Research Program, CEC-500-01-044-2007.Google Scholar
- Dechert S (2015). Better Buildings Saves Over $1 Billion In Energy, Opens Online Solution Center. Availabel at https://cleantechnica.com/2015/06/23/better-buildings-saves-1-billionenergy-opens-online-solution-center. Google Scholar
- Dey D, Dong B, Li Z (2016). A probabilistic framework to diagnose faults in air handling units. In: Proceedings of International High Performance Buildings Conference, West Lafayette, IN, USA.Google Scholar
- DOE (2011). Buildings energy data book. US Department of Energy. Available at http://buildingsdatabook.eere.energy.gov.
- EnergyPlus (2018a). Engineering Reference - EnergyPlus 8.7.Google Scholar
- EnergyPlus (2018b). Whole Building Energy Simulation Program from U.S. Department of Energy. Available at http://www.energyplus.gov.
- EnergyPro (2017). EnergyPro. Available at http://www.energysoft.com.
- Friedman H, Frank M, Claridge D, Heinemeier K, Crossman K, Crowe E, Toole C, Milesi-Ferretti NS, Choniere D (2012). Commissioning cost-benefit and persistence of savings: A report on cost-effective commissioning of existing and low energy buildings. Technical Note (NIST TN)-1727.Google Scholar
- Gorthala R (2017). Fault Detection and Diagnosis (FDD) Tools for Retro-Commissioning and Continuous Commissioning of HVAC and Refrigeration Systems. Available at https://www.energy.gov/eere/buildings/downloads/fault-detection-and-diagnosis-fdd-toolsretro-commissioning-and-continuous. Google Scholar
- Haves P (1997). Fault modelling in component-based HVAC simulation. In: Proceedings of the 5th International IBPSA Building Simulation Conference, Prague, Czech Republic.Google Scholar
- Heinemeier K (2012). Rooftop HVAC Fault Detection and Diagnostics: Technology and Market Review for Energy and Demand Savings Estimates. New Buildings Institute.Google Scholar
- Hoaglin DC (2004). g-and-h-Distributions. In: Kotz S, Read CB, Balakrishnan N, Vidakovic B, Johnson NL (eds), Encyclopedia of Statistical Sciences. John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Google Scholar
- Hyvärinen J, Kärki S (1996). Building optimization and fault diagnosis source book. IEA Annex, 25.Google Scholar
- Hyvärinen J, Kärki S (1997). Building optimization and fault diagnosis source book. IEA Annex 25, Final Report (Vol. I), Espoo, Finland.Google Scholar
- IBPSA (2018). Building Energy Software Tools. BEST Directory. Available at https://www.buildingenergysoftwaretools.com.
- Jacobs P, Smith V, Higgins C, Brost M (2003). Small commercial rooftops: field problems, solutions and the role of manufacturers. In: Proceedings of the National Conference on Building Commissioning.Google Scholar
- Katipamula S, Pratt RG, Chassin DP, Taylor ZT (1999). Automated fault detection and diagnostics for outdoor-air ventilation systems and economizers: Methodology and results from field testing. ASHRAE Transactions, 105(1): 555–567.Google Scholar
- Kelly G, Park C, Clark D, May W (1984). HVACSIM+ a dynamic building-HVAC-control systems simulation program. Paper presented at the Workshop on HVAC controls, Modeling, and Simulation.Google Scholar
- Khire R, Trcka M (2013). Model based failure mode effect analysis on whole building energy performance. In: Proceedings of the 13th International IBPSA Building Simulation Conference, Chambery, France.Google Scholar
- Knebel DE (1983). Simiplified Energy Analysis Using the Modified Bin Method. Atlanta, GA: American Society of Heating, Refrigerating, and Air-Conditioning Engineers.Google Scholar
- Li S, Wen J (2010). Development and validation of a dynamic air handling unit model, Part 1. ASHRAE Transactions, 116(1): 45–56.Google Scholar
- Li S, Wen J, Zhou X, Klaassen CJ (2010). Development and validation of a dynamic air handling unit model, Part 2. ASHRAE Transactions, 116(1): 57–73.Google Scholar
- Li Y, O’Neill Z (2016). An EnergyPlus/OpenStudio based Fault Simulator for Buildings. Paper presented at the 2016 ASHRAE Winter Meeting, Orlando, FL, USA.Google Scholar
- Lin G, Claridge DE (2009). Retrospective testing of an automated building commissioning analysis tool (ABCAT). Paper presented at the ASME 2009 3rd International Conference on Energy Sustainability collocated with the Heat Transfer and InterPACK09 Conferences.Google Scholar
- Lyu MR (1996). Handbook of Software Reliability Engineering. New York: McGraw-Hill.Google Scholar
- Myrefelt S (2004). Reliability and functional availability of HVAC systems. In: Proceedings of the 4th International Conference for Enhanced Building Operations, Paris, France.Google Scholar
- Narayanaswamy B, Balaji B, Gupta R, Agarwal Y (2014). Data driven investigation of faults in HVAC systems with model, cluster and compare (MCC). In: Proceedings of the 1st ACM Conference on Embedded Systems for Energy-Efficient Buildings, Memphis, TN, USA.Google Scholar
- NBI (2017). New Construction Guideline. Available at http://newbuildings.org/product/new-construction-guide.
- O’Neill Z, Chang X (2011). A modelica-based dynamic fault simulator for air handler units. Paper presented at the ASHRAE Annual Meeting, Montreal, QC, Canada.Google Scholar
- Otto K, Eisenhower B, O’Neill Z, Yuan S, Mezic I, Narayanan S (2012). Prioritizing building system energy failure modes using whole building energy simulation. In: Proceedings of IBPSA-USA Building Simulation Conference (SimBuild 2012), Madison, WI, USA.Google Scholar
- Pourarian S, Wen J, Li X, Veronica DA, Zhou X, Liu R (2014). Tools for evaluating fault detection and diagnostic methods for dual duct double fan systems. In: Proceedings of ASHRAE/IBPSA-USA Building Simulation Conference. Atlanta, GA, USA.Google Scholar
- Pourarian S (2015). Tools for evaluating fault detection and diagnostic methods for HVAC secondary systems. PhD Thesis, Drexel University, USA.Google Scholar
- Qian D, Li Y, Niu F, O’Neill Z (2018). Nationwide savings analysis of a variety of energy conservation measures. Paper presented at the ASHRAE Winter Meeting, Chicago, IL, USA.Google Scholar
- Rayner G (1999). Statistical methodologies for quantile-based distributional families. PhD Thesis, Queensland University of Technology, Australia.Google Scholar
- Reddy TA (2007a). Formulation of a generic methodology for assessing FDD methods and its specific adoption to large chillers. ASHRAE Transactions, 113(2): 334–342.Google Scholar
- Reddy TA (2007c). Development and evaluation of a simple modelbased automated fault detection and diagnosis (FDD) method suitable for process faults of large chillers. ASHRAE Transactions, 113(2): 27–39.Google Scholar
- Roth KW, Westphalen D, Llana P, Feng M (2004). The energy impact of faults in US commercial buildings. In: Proceedings of International Refrigeration and Air Conditioning Conference, West Lafayette, IN, USA.Google Scholar
- Roth KW, Westphalen D, Feng MY, Llana P, Quartararo L (2005). Energy impact of commercial building controls and performance diagnostics: Market characterization, energy impact of building faults and energy savings potential. Report for the US Department of Energy.Google Scholar
- Stamatis DH (2003). Failure mode and effect analysis: FMEA from theory to execution. Milwaukee, WI, USA: ASQ Quality Press.Google Scholar
- Title-24 (2017). Title 24: Building Energy Efficiency Program. Available at http://www.energy.ca.gov/title24.
- Tomczyk J (2002). Diagnosing A Restricted Liquid Line Can Be Tricky. Available at https://www.achrnews.com/articles/90784-diagnosinga-restricted-liquid-line-can-be-tricky. Google Scholar
- TRNSYS (2017). Transient System Simulation Tool. Available at http://www.trnsys.com.
- Wang L, Hong T (2012). Modeling and simulation of HVAC faulty operations and performance degradation due to maintenance issues. In: Proceedings of the 1st IBPSA Asia Building Simulation Conference (ASim 2012), Shanghai, China.Google Scholar
- Wen J, Li S (2011). Tools for evaluating fault detection and diagnostic methods for air-handling units: Final report. Drexel University.Google Scholar
- Yuill DP (2014). Development of methodologies for evaluating performance of fault detection and diagnostics protocols applied to unitary air-conditioning equipment. PhD Thesis, Purdue University, USA.Google Scholar
- Yuill DP, Cheung H, Braun JE (2014). Validation of a fault-modeling equipped vapor compression system model using a fault detection and diagnostics evaluation tool. In: Proceedings of the 15th International Refrigeration and Air Conditioning Conference, West Lafayette, IN, USA.Google Scholar
- Zhang R, Hong T (2016). Modeling and simulation of operational faults of HVAC systems using EnergyPlus. In: Proceedings of Building Performance Modeling Conference, Salt Lake City, UT, USA.Google Scholar