Evidence for Ecosystem Changes Within a Temperate Lagoon Following a Hurricane-Induced Barrier Island Breach

  • Jill A. OlinEmail author
  • Robert M. Cerrato
  • Janet A. Nye
  • Skyler R. Sagarese
  • Matthew Sclafani
  • Joshua P. Zacharias
  • Michael G. Frisk
Special Issue: Hurricane Sandy Impacts and Responses


The Great South Bay (GSB) is a shallow temperate lagoon in New York, USA, that has experienced a long-term decline in ecosystem maturity, defined as possessing increased complexity, stability, and resilience, dating back to the nineteenth century that is attributed to the loss of filter-feeding and upper trophic-level diversity and biomass. The observed decline is hypothesized to result from reduced connectivity to the Atlantic Ocean following installation of permanent inlets along the barrier island that reduce the probability of “rapid state” change through breaching. In October 2012, Hurricane Sandy created a breach in Fire Island that increased connectivity between GSB and the ocean, resulting in higher bay-wide salinity. We hypothesized that increased connectivity would result in a state change reminiscent of a mature system, characterized by higher nekton and mobile invertebrate species richness and diversity, and occurrence of migratory biomass. Otter trawl surveys were conducted throughout GSB from 2013 through 2015 and compared to a pre-breach survey conducted in 2007. An increase in species richness, diversity, and biomass in the 3 years following the breach and a difference in the dominant species collected between sampling periods was observed. Transition in the nekton and mobile invertebrate assemblage was also observed, whereby the assemblages in 2007 and 2015 differed from 2013 and 2014, with the greatest differentiation between the 2007 and 2015 assemblages, highlighting the influence of the breach rather than seasonal and/or inter-annual variation in driving these assemblages. This temporal trajectory of assemblage change clearly aligned with observed changes in salinity; however, this conclusion should be interpreted with caution given the lack of pre-breach survey replication. Nonetheless, our findings suggest that even a modest breach can cause detectible change in the community assembly in GSB. The expanded community diversity observed in GSB is suggestive of initial recovery of ecosystem maturity and underscores the importance of breaching as fundamental in maintaining lagoon ecosystems.


Blue crab Lady crab Nekton Lagoon Estuary circulation Great South Bay Hurricane Sandy New York 



The authors thank T. Abruzzo, D. Bowman, T. Dolan, C. Harter, L. Henderson, I. Huang, E. Ingram, J. Labriola, E. Markowitz, C. Martinez, K. McCartin, M. Mitch, A. Molina, C. O’Leary, J. Reed, N. Rogers, J. Schweitzer, M. Wiggins, H. Xu, A. Younes, and C. Ziegler for the assistance with field collections and data management. The authors also thank the associate editor and two referees for detailed evaluations that improved this manuscript.

Funding Information

Funding was provided by New York Sea Grant (NYSG), the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC), and the National Park Service (NPS) to MGF, JAN, RMC, and MS.

Supplementary material

12237_2019_593_MOESM1_ESM.docx (17.9 mb)
ESM 1 (DOCX 18294 kb)


  1. Anderson, L.G. 2017. Management implications of the influence of biological variability of invasive lionfish diet in Belize. Management 8 (1): 61–70.Google Scholar
  2. Bell, K.N.I., P.D. Cowley, A.K. Whitfield, (2001) Seasonality in Frequency of Marine Access to an Intermittently Open Estuary: Implications for Recruitment Strategies. Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science 52 (3):327–337.Google Scholar
  3. Buchheister, A., C.F. Bonzek, J. Gartland, and R.J. Latour. 2013. Patterns and drivers of the demersal fish community of Chesapeake Bay. Marine Ecology Progress Series 481: 161–180.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Carpenter, E.J., and B.M. Brinkhuis. 1991. Primary production and nitrogenous nutrients. In Great South Bay, ed. J.R., Schubel, T.M. Bell, H.H. Carter, 5–8. New York: New York State University Press.Google Scholar
  5. Casini, M., J. Hjelm, J.C. Molinero, J. Lövgren, M. Cardinale, V. Bartolino, A. Belgrano, and G. Kornilovs. 2009. Trophic cascades promote threshold-like shifts in pelagic marine ecosystems. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 106 (1): 197–202.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Cerrato, R.M., P.V. LoCicero, and S.L. Goodbred. 2013. Response of mollusc assemblages to climate variability and anthropogenic activities: a 4000-year record from a shallow bar-built lagoon system. Global Change Biology 19 (10): 3024–3036.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Christensen, V., and J. Maclean. 2011. Ecosystem Approaches to Fisheries: A Global Perspective. Cambridge University Press, New York, pp. 342.Google Scholar
  8. Conley, D.C. 1999. Observations on the impact of developing an inlet in a bar built estuary. Continental Shelf Research 19 (13): 1733–1754.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Daskalov, G.M., A.N. Grishin, S. Rodionov, and V. Mihneva. 2007. Trophic cascades triggered by overfishing reveal possible mechanisms of ecosystem regime shifts. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 104 (25): 10518–10523.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Davidson, R.J., and I.D. Marsden. 1987. Size relationships and relative growth of the New Zealand swimming crab Ovalipes catharus (White, 1843). Journal of Crustacean Biology 7 (2): 308–317.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Dickinson, C.L. 1938. Commercial fisheries. In A biological survey of the salt waters of Long Island. Part I, 15–46. New York State Conservation Department.Google Scholar
  12. Elliott, M., A.K. Whitfield, I.C. Potter, S.J.M. Blaber, D.P. Cyrus, F.G. Nordlie, and T.D. Harrison. 2007. The guild approach to categorizing estuarine fish assemblages: a global review. Fish and Fisheries 8 (3): 241–268.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Emanuel, K. 2005. Increasing destructiveness of tropical cyclones over the past 30 years. Nature 436 (7051): 686–688.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Frisk, M.G., and S.B. Munch. 2008. Great South Bay Fishery Independent Survey, 21. Stony Brook: School of Marine and Atmospheric Sciences. Stony Brook University.Google Scholar
  15. Froese, R., and D. Pauly. 2017. FishBase. World wide web electronic publication. (02/2017).
  16. Gabriel, R.H. 1921. The evolution of Long Island, 194. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
  17. Gobler, C.J., D.J. Lonsdale, and G.L. Boyer. 2005. A review of the causes, effects, and potential management of harmful brown tide blooms caused by Aureococcus anophagefferens. Estuaries 28 (5): 726–749.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Gobler, C.J., C.S. Young, J. Goleski, A. Stevens, J. Thickman, R.B. Wallace, P. Curran, F. Koch, Y. Kang, M.W. Lusty, T.K. Hattenrath-Lehmann, K. Langlois, and J.L. Collier. 2019. Accidental ecosystem restoration? Assessing the estuary-wide impacts of a new ocean inlet created by Hurricane Sandy. Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science 221: 132–146.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Graham, L.J., M. Botton, D. Hata, R.E. Loveland, and B.R. Murphy. 2009. Prosomal-width-to-weight relationships in American horseshoe crabs (Limulus polyphemus): examining conversion factors used to estimate landings. Fishery Bulletin 107: 235–243.Google Scholar
  20. Greene, G. 1982. Hard clams, competitors, predators, and physical parameters in Great South Bay, NY. Draft Report Submitted to US Environmental Protection Agency, Region II, 157. New York: by Wapora Inc.Google Scholar
  21. Greenwood, M.F.D., P.W. Stevens, and R.E. Matheson. 2006. Effects of the 2004 hurricanes on the fish assemblages in two proximate southwest Florida estuaries: Changes in the context of inter-annual variability. Estuaries and Coasts 29 (6): 985–996.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Guerao, G., and G. Rotllant. 2009. Survival and growth of post-settlement juveniles of the spider crab Maja brachydactyla (Brachyura: Majoidea) reared under individual culture system. Aquaculture 289 (1-2): 181–184.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Hall, Q.A., M.M. Reese Robillard, J.A. Williams, M.J. Ajemian, and G.W. Stunz. 2016. Re-opening of a remote tidal inlet increases recruitment of estuarine-dependent nekton. Estuaries and Coasts 39 (6): 1769–1784.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Hanlon, J.R. 1983. Fish and wildlife resource studies for the Fire Island Inlet to Montauk Point, New York, beach erosion control and hurricane protection project reformulation study. Fish and Wildlife Service, Region 5: 44.Google Scholar
  25. Hattenrath-Lehmann, T.K., and C.J. Gobler. 2016. Historical occurrence and status of harmful algal blooms in Suffolk County, NY, USA. Available: Accessed November 2018.
  26. Hauser, S., M.S. Meixler, and M. Laba. 2015. Quantification of impacts and ecosystem services loss in New Jersey coastal wetlands due to Hurricane Sandy storm surge. Wetlands 35 (6): 1137–1148.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Henry, D.K., S. Cooke-Hull, J. Savukinas, F. Yu, N. Elo, and B. VanArnum. 2013. Economic impact of Hurricane Sandy: potential economic activity lost and gained in New Jersey and New York, 35. Washington, DC: US Department of Commerce.Google Scholar
  28. Hindrichs, C., C.N. Flagg, and R.E. Wilson. 2018. Great South Bay after Sandy: changes in circulation and flushing due to new inlet. Estuaries and Coasts 41 (8): 2172–2190.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Hinga, K.R. 2005. Water quality and ecology of great South Bay (Fire Island National Seashore Science Synthesis Paper). Technical Report NPS/NER/NRTR – 2005/019, 54. Boston: National Park Service.Google Scholar
  30. Hoff, J.G., and R.M. Ibara. 1977. Factors affecting the seasonal abundance, composition and diversity of fishes in a Southeastern New England estuary. Estuarine and Coastal Marine Science 5 (5): 665–678.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Kimball, M.E., J.M. Miller, P.E. Whitfield, and J.A. Hare. 2004. Thermal tolerance and potential distribution of invasive lionfish (Pterois volitans/miles complex) on the east coast of the United States. Marine Ecology Progress Series 283: 269–278.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Leatherman, S.P. 1985. Geomorphic and stratigraphic analysis of Fire Island. Marine Geology 63 (1-4): 173–195.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Legendre, P., and L. Legendre. 1998. Numerical ecology, 852. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science.Google Scholar
  34. Lin, N., R.E. Kopp, B.P. Horton, and J.P. Donnelly. 2016. Hurricane Sandy’s flood frequency increasing from year 1800 to 2100. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 113 (43): 12071–12075.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Lipcius, R.N., and W.T. Stockhausen. 2002. Concurrent decline of the spawning stock, recruitment, larval abundance and size of the blue crab Callinectes sapidus in Chesapeake Bay. Marine Ecology Progress Series 226: 45–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Manly, B.F.J. 1991. Randomization and Monte Carlo methods in biology, 480. London: Chapman & Hall.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Martino, E.J., and K.W. Able. 2003. Fish assemblages across the marine to low salinity transition zone of a temperate estuary. Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science 56 (5-6): 969–987.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. McCann, K.S. 2000. The diversity-stability debate. Nature 405 (6783): 228–233.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. McGarigal, K., S. Cushman, and S. Stafford. 2000. Multivariate statistics for wildlife and ecology research, 283. New York: Springer-Verlag.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. McHugh, J.L. 1991. The hard clam fishery, past and present. In The Great South Bay, ed. J.R. Schubel, T.M. Bell, and H.H. Carter, 55–65. New York: State University of New York Press.Google Scholar
  41. Milbrandt, E.C., J.M. Greenawalt-Boswell, P.D. Sokoloff, and S.A. Bortone. 2006. Impact and response of southwest Florida mangroves to the 2004 hurricane season. Estuaries and Coasts 29 (6): 979–984.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Milbrandt, E.C., R.D. Bartleson, L.D. Coen, O. Rybak, M.A. Thompson, J.E. DeAngelo, and P.W. Stevens. 2012. Local and regional effects of reopening a tidal inlet on estuarine water quality, seagrass habitat and fish assemblages. Continental Shelf Research 41: 1–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Morton, R.A., and A.H. Sallenger. 2003. Morphological impacts of extreme storms on sandy beaches and barriers. Journal of Coastal Research 19 (3): 560–573.Google Scholar
  44. Nixon, S.W., S.L. Granger, D.I. Taylor, P.W. Johnson, and B.A. Buckley. 1994. Subtidal volume fluxes, nutrient inputs and the brown tide – an alternate hypothesis. Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science 39 (3): 303–312.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Nuttall, M.A. 2010. Historical recount of the Great South Bay ecosystem, Long Island, New York and a quantitative assessment of the ecosystem structure of great South Bay using Ecopath. MS Thesis. Stony Brook University, Stony Brook, New York, pp. 210.Google Scholar
  46. Nuttall, M.A., A. Jordaan, R.M. Cerrato, and M.G. Frisk. 2011. Identifying 120 years of decline in ecosystem structure and maturity of Great South Bay, New York using the Ecopath modelling approach. Ecological Modelling 222 (18): 3335–3345.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Odum, E.P. 1969. The strategy of ecosystem development. Science 164 (3877): 262–270.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Oksanen, J., F.G. Blanchet, M. Friendly, R. Kindt, P. Legendre, D. McGlinn, P.R. Minchin, R.B. O’Hara, G.L. Simpson, P. Solymos, M.H.H. Stevens, E. Szoecs, and H. Wagner. 2016. Community ecology package in R. 2017-01-17 19:41:27.Google Scholar
  49. Olin, J.A., P.W. Stevens, S.A. Rush, N.E. Hussey, and A.T. Fisk. 2015. Loss of seasonal variability in nekton community structure in a tidal river: evidence for homogenization in a flow-altered system. Hydrobiologia 744 (1): 271–286.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Paerl, H.W., L.M. Valdes, B.L. Peierls, J.E. Adolf, and L.W. Harding. 2006. Anthropogenic and climatic influences on the eutrophication of large estuarine ecosystems. Limnology and Oceanography 51 (1part2): 448–462.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Pikitch, E. K., C. Santora, E. A. Babcock, A. Bakun, R. Bonfil, D. O. Conover, P. Dayton, P. Doukakis, D. Fluharty, B. Heneman, E. D. Houde, J. Link, P. A. Livingston, M. Mangel M. K., McAllister, J. Pope, K. J. Sainsbury. 2004 Ecosystem-based fishery management. Science 305(5682): 346–347.Google Scholar
  52. Pimm, S.L. 1984. The complexity and stability of ecosystems. Nature 307 (5949): 321–326.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. R Development Core. 2016. R: A language and environment for statistical computing. Vienna: R Foundation for statistical computing Scholar
  54. Reese, M.M., G.W. Stunz, and A.M. Bushon. 2008. Recruitment of estuarine-dependent nekton through a new tidal inlet: the opening of Packery Channel in Corpus Christi, TX, USA. Estuaries and Coasts 31 (6): 1143–1157.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Rozas, L.R., C.W. Martin, and J.F. Valentine. 2013. Effects of reduced hydrological connectivity on the nursery use of shallow estuarine habtiats within a river delta. Marine Ecology Progress Series 492: 9–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Sancho, G., P.R. Kingsley-Smith, J.A. Morris, C.A. Toline, V. McDonough, and S.M. Doty. 2018. Invasive lionfish (Pterois volitans/miles) feeding ecology in Biscayne National Park, Florida, USA. Biological Invasions 20 (9): 2343–2361.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Scheffer, M., S. Carpenter, J.A. Foley, C. Folkes, and B. Walker. 2001. Catastrophic shifts in ecosystems. Nature 413 (6856): 591–596.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Schofield, P.J. 2009. Geographic extent and chronology of the invasion of non-native lionfish (Pterois volitans [Linnaeus 1758] and P. miles [Bennett 1828]) in the Western North Atlantic and Caribbean Sea. Aquatic Invasions 4 (3): 473–479.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Schreiber, R.A. 1973. The fishes of Great South Bay. MS Thesis. State University of New York, Stony Brook, NY, pp. 199.Google Scholar
  60. Schubel, J.R. 1991. Introduction. In The Great South Bay, ed. J.R. Schubel, T.M. Bell, and H.H. Carter, 1–4. New York: State University of New York Press.Google Scholar
  61. Sweet, W., C. Zervas, S. Gill, and J. Park. 2013. Hurricane Sandy inundation probabilities today and tomorrow. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society 94 (9): S17–S20.Google Scholar
  62. Syuhada, I. 2011. Density, distribution and life history characteristics of the mantis shrimp, Squilla empusa, in the muddy sediments of Narragansett Bay, RI. MS Thesis. University of Rhode Island, Kingston, Rhode Island, pp. 88.Google Scholar
  63. ter Braak, C.J.F. 1986. Canonical correspondence analysis: a new eigenvector technique for multivariate direct gradient analysis. Ecology 67 (5): 1167–1179.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. ter Braak, C.J.F., and P. Smilauer. 2012. Canoco reference manual and user’s guide., 496. Ithaca: Microcomputer power.Google Scholar
  65. Thorne, E. 1928. Great South Bay as a shark nursery. Bulletin of New York Zoological Society 21 (4): 114–115.Google Scholar
  66. Tinoco, A.I. 2017. Effects of Hurricane Sandy on Great South Bay, Long Island: assessing water quality, seagrass and associated nekton communities. MS Thesis, Stony Brook University, Stony Brook, New York, pp. 88.Google Scholar
  67. Van Popering, M.J., and J.B. Glancy. 1947. History of the shellfish industry in Great South Bay, New York, unpublished manuscript. pp. 20.Google Scholar
  68. Whitfield, P.E., T. Gardner, S.P. Vives, M.R. Gilligan, W.R. Courtenay, G.C. Ray, and J.A. Hare. 2002. Biological invasion of the Indo-Pacific lionfish Pterois volitans along the Atlantic coast of North America. Marine Ecology Progress Series 235: 289–297.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Wood, S.N. 2003. Thin plate regression splines. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society (B) 65 (1): 95–114.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. Young, G.C., and I.C. Potter. 2002. Influence of exceptionally high salinities, marked variations in freshwater discharge and opening of estuary mouth on the characteristics of the ichthyofauna of a normally closed estuary. Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science 55 (2): 223–246.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Coastal and Estuarine Research Federation 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  • Jill A. Olin
    • 1
    • 2
    Email author
  • Robert M. Cerrato
    • 1
  • Janet A. Nye
    • 1
  • Skyler R. Sagarese
    • 1
    • 3
  • Matthew Sclafani
    • 4
  • Joshua P. Zacharias
    • 1
  • Michael G. Frisk
    • 1
  1. 1.School of Marine & Atmospheric SciencesStony Brook UniversityStony BrookUSA
  2. 2.Great Lakes Research CenterMichigan Technological UniversityHoughtonUSA
  3. 3.NOAA/NMFS, Southeast Fisheries Science CenterMiamiUSA
  4. 4.Cornell Cooperative Extension-Suffolk County, Extension Education CenterRiverheadUSA

Personalised recommendations