Submarine Groundwater Discharge to a High-Energy Surf Zone at Stinson Beach, California, Estimated Using Radium Isotopes
- First Online:
- Cite this article as:
- de Sieyes, N.R., Yamahara, K.M., Paytan, A. et al. Estuaries and Coasts (2011) 34: 256. doi:10.1007/s12237-010-9305-2
Two 14-day experiments conducted in the dry summer (July 2006) and wet winter (March 2007) seasons, respectively, examined tidal, wave-driven, and seasonal variability of submarine groundwater discharge (SGD) at Stinson Beach, CA, using natural radium tracers. Tide stage, tide range, breaker height, and season each explained a significant degree of radium variability in the surf zone. A mass balance of excess radium in the surf zone was used to estimate SGD for each season, confirming larger discharge rates during the wet season. Our results indicate median groundwater discharge rates of 6 to 8 L min−1 m−1 in July 2006 and 38 to 43 L min−1 m−1 in March 2007. SGD from 200 m of Stinson Beach in March 2007 contributed a flux of phosphate and dissolved inorganic nitrogen approximately equal to that associated with all local creeks and streams within 6 km of the study site at that time.
KeywordsSubmarine groundwater discharge Radium Nutrient flux California coast
Submarine groundwater discharge (SGD) is well documented as an important source of inorganic, organic, and microbial pollutants to the coastal ocean (Boehm et al. 2004; Bone et al. 2007; Santos et al. 2008). Numerous physical forcing mechanisms including meteoric hydraulic head, tide and wave pumping, seasonal precipitation/evapotranspiration cycles, and variations in groundwater density force the flow of groundwater to the ocean (Burnett et al. 2006). Due to interactions between multiple forcing mechanisms at any given location and time, SGD is temporally and spatially variable. Site-specific studies are often required to fully understand the timing, magnitude, and importance of SGD in a given region.
Many of the mechanisms that modulate SGD have been investigated numerically and through field studies. Tidal pumping has been explored on both the semidiurnal (Ataie-Ashtiani et al. 1999; Robinson et al. 2007) and fortnightly spring-neap timescales (Boehm et al. 2004; de Sieyes et al. 2008; Kim and Hwang 2002; Santos et al. 2009; Taniguchi 2002). Michael et al. (2005) documented a large, seasonally variable component of SGD controlled by precipitation/evapotranspiration cycles. Wave setup and run-up from breaking waves influence beach water table dynamics and drive SGD at coastal margins (King et al. 2009; Li et al. 2004; Longuet-Higgins 1983). However, breaking waves make direct discharge measurement by seepage meter impossible (Burnett et al. 2006; Huettel et al. 1996; Libelo and McIntyre 1994). This presents a unique challenge in studying SGD along coastlines with high wave energy where wave-driven SGD may be most important. In such environments, it is often necessary to estimate SGD by indirect techniques, such as those based on chemical tracers.
This study explores SGD variability at multiple timescales using naturally occurring radium isotopes as tracers of groundwater discharge. Moore and collaborators pioneered the use of the quartet of naturally occurring radium isotopes, which vary in half-life from 3.7 days to 1,600 years, as tracers for ocean mixing and groundwater input to coastal systems (Krest and Harvey 2003; Moore 1997, 2003). The divalent radium cation is bound to soil particles and rocks in freshwater but readily desorbs via ion exchange in the presence of high ionic strength solutions (Elsinger and Moore 1980). Accordingly, in coastal aquifers where saline groundwater mixes with fresh groundwater, high radium waters result. Open seawater is relatively radium deplete; therefore, radium activity above that of open seawater suggests a coastal source that in many cases is groundwater. Because radium isotopes behave conservatively in the nearshore after accounting for radioactive decay, the radium quartet is useful for characterizing ocean mixing and rates of submarine groundwater discharge (Charette et al. 2001; Moore 1996, 1999, 2000a, b, 2003).
The present study uses the two short-lived radium isotopes 223Ra (t1/2 = 11 days) and 224Ra (t1/2 = 3.6 days) and the long-lived isotope 226Ra (t1/2 = 1,600 years) to investigate how SGD at a wave-dominated California beach is modulated by semidiurnal tides, fortnightly neap-spring tides, swell events, and the seasonal precipitation cycle. The work was conducted at Stinson Beach, a small beach community north of San Francisco, CA, USA. Groundwater at the site is contaminated with nitrogen (nitrate and ammonium, primarily), orthophosphate, and human fecal bacteria from septic systems, and previous research at the site has documented nutrification of the nearshore coastal ocean by fresh SGD in the summer (de Sieyes et al. 2008). A previous experiment at this beach during dry summer weather estimated SGD using salinity as a groundwater tracer (de Sieyes et al. 2008). The present study builds on that previous study but uses an entirely new radium tracer dataset consisting of over 500 measurements to investigate the effects of waves, tides, and season on SGD.
Methods and Materials
The climate at Stinson Beach is Mediterranean with an annual average rainfall of 60 to 120 cm occurring predominately between October and April (Stinson Beach County Water District 1998). During the dry season, Bolinas Lagoon (37.908 N, 122.682 W) and a local coastal hot spring (37.886 N, 122.630 W), are the only other potential sources of radium within 20 km of the study site (Fig. 1). Numerous ephemeral creeks deliver freshwater to the coastal ocean during the wet season but generally run dry by late summer (Stinson Beach County Water District 1998). Only Webb Creek (37.885 N, 122.629 W) discharges directly to the nearshore within 7 km of the site; all other creeks discharge to Bolinas Lagoon (Fig. 1).
Radium activities in the surf zone were monitored over semidiurnal and spring–neap tidal cycles during both the dry and rainy seasons. Fourteen-day experiments were conducted from 14 through 28 July 2006 and from 10 through 24 March 2007. During each study, neap tide (17 July 2006 and 11 March 2007, respectively) preceded the spring tide (24 July 2006 and 18 March 2007, respectively).
Tide, Wave, and Beach Conditions
Tide elevation measurements were obtained from a NOAA tide gauge at Point Reyes, approximately 30 km from Stinson Beach (http://tidesandcurrents.noaa.gov, Station ID 9415020, 38.00 N, 122.98 W). Tides along this coast are in phase at a spatial scale of 30 km, so this tide gauge gives excellent tide data for Stinson Beach. Data were recorded at 6-min intervals. Daily tidal range was calculated from daily maxima and minima. We define spring and neap tide as those days during the tidal cycle when tidal range is maximal and minimal, respectively.
Wave measurements were obtained from National Buoy Data Center buoy #46026 at San Francisco (http://www.ndbc.noaa.gov, 37.759 N 122.833 W), the closest directional wave buoy to the site. The buoy is located in 55 m of water 23 km due southwest (offshore) from the site. Spectral wave data were recorded at 1-h intervals.
A continuous record of surf zone breaker height was estimated from significant wave height and period for the duration of our study using the method of Komar (1998). This calculation assumes that wave energy is conserved from deep water to the surf zone and ignores the effects of refractive focusing, diffraction, bottom friction, currents, and wave–wave interactions. Stinson Beach lies in the wave shadow of nearby Bolinas Point and Duxbury Reef, so a correction factor was necessary to increase the accuracy of the breaker height predictions. Seven synoptic breaker height observations were made in the field using surfers riding breaking waves as benchmarks, a commonly used method for estimating breaker height (Caldwell 2005). These observations were compared to the continuous time series, and a correction factor was derived using linear regression. The Komar-estimated significant wave heights were multiplied by the correction factor to obtain a continuous time series of significant breaker heights. These data are used to explore correlative relationships between waves and SGD.
The tidal regime at Stinson Beach is mixed semidiurnal. To characterize tidal variation in radium activities, we sampled the surf zone at high-high and low-low tide along two cross-shore transects approximately every other day of each study. The two transects were located 100 m apart in the alongshore direction and extending from the water line out into the surf zone (Fig. 1). During both studies, the two sampling transects straddled a rip current, indicating that the two transects sampled distinct rip cells. Local knowledge of the site coupled with aerial observations from a high vantage point during each study confirmed the permanence of the rip cell location. During each sampling at the site, surf zone samples were collected along each transect at 0.2 and 0.7 m water depths referred to as “ankle” and “waist depths”, respectively (Fig. 2). These depths occurred well within the surf zone. Although a small sand bar was observed during each experiment, no distinct break was ever noted between an inner and outer surf zone at the site. In order to standardize sample collection depth, 0.2 and 0.7 m heights were noted on the legs of the two individuals who conducted all surf zone sampling. During sample collection, care was taken to collect a mixture of water from the entire water column from surface to sandy bottom. For the surf zone, nJul06 = 42 and nMar07 = 32.
At low-low tides only, groundwater immediately adjacent to the water line was sampled from shallow pits dug into the beach approximately 10 m back from the water line (nJul06 = 18 and nMar07 = 14; Fig. 2). In addition, subaerial seepage faces were sampled when they developed at the lowest tides (nJul06 = 17 and nMar07 = 2). On multiple days during each experiment, groundwater was sampled from temporary stainless steel drive-point piezometers installed into the top 2 m of the water table just above the high tide berm (nJul06 = 1 and nMar07 = 5).
The ebb flow from Bolinas Lagoon (37.908 N, 122.682 W) was sampled every 2 to 4 days during both studies (nJul06 = 4 and nMar07 = 7). The hot spring (37.886 N, 122.630 W) was sampled on 19 March 2007.
Clean, triple-rinsed 20-L collapsible low-density polyethylene containers were used for water collection. For a given water sample, a total of approximately 100 L was composited. A 1-L subsample was collected into a clean triple-rinsed bottle and used for all nonradium chemical analyses. All samples were analyzed for 223Ra and 224Ra. A subset of samples was analyzed for 226Ra including pits, seeps, offshore, Bolinas Lagoon, hot spring, and a subset of monitoring wells. In addition, surf zone samples collected at the high and low tide closest in time to the offshore sampling events during each experiment were analyzed for 226Ra.
On 16 and 17 March 2007, creeks flowing within 6 km of the site were surveyed for flow rate and nutrient concentration to provide estimates of creek-associated nutrient flux to the local coastal ocean. The survey included creeks flowing to Bolinas Lagoon (n = 11) as well as those discharging directly to the ocean (n = 1). Little to no creek discharge occurs during late summer at the site, precluding a similar survey during July 2006. First-order estimates of flow rate in each creek were measured via the float method (Weight and Sonderegger 2001) whereby velocity is measured by timing the travel of a float down a straight reach of a creek. Measurements were made following USGS guidelines as outlined in Rantz (1982). Surface velocities were converted to a depth-averaged velocity using a correction factor of 0.85 and multiplied by cross-sectional area to calculate flow rate. Reflecting the order-of-magnitude nature of our measurements, we conservatively assume 25% standard deviation associated with these flow rate measurements (Rantz 1982). Estimates of creek-associated nutrient flux were calculated by multiplying nutrient concentration by flow rate. Standard deviations of nutrient flux are calculated by propagating standard deviations of nutrient concentration and flow rates.
The concentrations of orthophosphate, silicate, and dissolved inorganic nitrogen were previously reported for all July 2006 water samples in de Sieyes et al. (2008). During the March experiment, a 30-mL aliquot of water was 0.2 µm PES filtered (Millipore, Billerica, MA, USA) and stored at −20°C for nutrient analyses. The concentrations of orthophosphate, silicate, nitrate, nitrite, and ammonium were measured by standard methods with a nutrient autoanalyzer (Lachat QuikChem 8000, Loveland, CO, USA). Detection limits are 0.2 µM nitrate, 0.1 µM nitrite, 0.1 µM phosphate, 1.0 µM silicate, and 0.1 µM ammonium. Dissolved inorganic nitrogen is reported as the sum of nitrate, nitrite, and ammonium. Five percent of nutrient samples were analyzed in duplicate, and standard deviation was <5% for each analyte.
Dissolved radium was extracted from ∼100 L water samples in the field by filtering through columns of MnO2-impregnated acrylic fiber at a flow rate not exceeding 1 L min−1 (Moore and Arnold 1996; Rama et al. 1987). Untreated acrylic fiber plugs were used to prevent the contamination of the MnO2 fiber by particulates. The fibers were removed from the columns and stored in plastic bags until processing, at which time they were rinsed with deionized water and hand-squeezed to remove excess water. Activities of the short-lived isotopes 223Ra and 224Ra were measured within 3 days of collection using a delayed coincidence counter (Moore 2003; Moore and Arnold 1996). Errors associated with radium analysis via this method are 10% (Moore 2003). Samples were not re-analyzed after collection to quantify 228Th-supported 224Ra activity. However, samples collected during subsequent experiments at the Stinson Beach site showed that 228Th-supported 224Ra activity accounts for approximately 3% or less of the original 224Ra activity (Black et al. 2009; Rama et al. 1987). Because 228Th-supported 224Ra activity at the site is small compared to the error associated with the 224Ra method, we assume for the purposes of this paper that all 224Ra in samples are excess 224Ra, i.e., 224Ra unsupported by 228Th decay in the sample.
226Ra activity was measured via its 218Po daughter following Kim et al. (2001). Mn-impregnated fibers were aged for at least 6 months to allow for decay of the short-lived isotopes. Fibers were then moistened with deionized water to obtain constant recoil efficiency, sealed in an air-tight helium-flushed glass tube, and incubated for at least 3 weeks to allow in-growth of 222Rn daughter product to reach activities within 0.1% of secular equilibrium. Standard error calculated from duplicate (n = 34), triplicate (n = 3), and quadruplicate (n = 6) analysis of individual fibers was 13%.
Statistical analysis was performed using Matlab (Natick, MA, USA). Parametric statistical methods were chosen because groups of data in general were normally distributed based on the Lilliefors test of normality. Correlation coefficients between measured continuous parameters were determined using Pearson’s product-moment correlations, and sample groups were compared using Student’s t test. Statistical results were deemed significant if p < 0.05. Unless otherwise noted, summarized data reported in the text are average ± standard deviation.
Tide stage, daily calculated tide ranges, observed breaker heights, and times of surf zone and offshore sampling events are shown for both experiments in Fig. 3. Tidal range during July 2006 was approximately sinusoidal with a fortnightly period, with highest tidal range occurring around the day of the new moon. In March 2007, one or more long-period tidal oscillations slightly reduced the tide range during the new moon.
Breaker heights calculated from buoy data following Komar (1998) were compared with observations made in the surf zone, as described in the “Methods and Materials” section. A correction factor of 0.36 was used based on linear regression of observed and predicted breaker heights. This correction factor was applied to the entire predicted breaker dataset. Corrected predictions of breaker height are plotted with observed breaker heights in Fig. 3. Root mean square error between observed and predicted breaker heights was 19%.
Breaker heights in the surf zone during the July 2006 experiment were smaller and more stable (71 ± 12 cm) compared to the March 2007 experiment when breakers were significantly larger and more variable (104 ± 23 cm; t = −4.8, p < 0.05; Fig. 3). Field observations confirmed the arrival of multiple large swell events at the beach during the March 2007 experiment.
According to Stinson Beach County Water District records, 2.1 and 24.7 cm of rainfall had fallen in the 3 months prior to the July 2006 and March 2007 studies, highlighting the Mediterranean climate at the site. Rainfall during the actual experiments themselves was slight, with only 0.05 and 0.3 cm falling during the July 2006 and March 2007 studies, respectively.
Average concentrations ± standard deviation of phosphate, silicate, dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN), 223Ra, and 224Ra as a function of sample type for both experiments
223Ra (dpm 100 L−1)
224Ra (dpm 100 L−1)
2.7 ± 0.2
140.6 ± 17.8
27.0 ± 12.3
7.8 ± 2.7
117.9 ± 29.6
2.4 ± 0.3
102.4 ± 18.4
22.3 ± 9.4
4.0 ± 1.4
70.1 ± 17.5
1.7 ± 0.2
44.9 ± 5.4
19.3 ± 3.2
1.7 ± 0.7
30.0 ± 10.3
1.6 ± 0.3
40.8 ± 3.9
17.9 ± 3.5
0.7 ± 0.3
12.2 ± 6.3
1.6 ± 0.1
45.9 ± 3.5
16.1 ± 1.9
2.2 ± 0.4
45.2 ± 15.2
2.6 ± 0.3
130.1 ± 15.4
30.4 ± 6.5
8.4 ± 3.0
106.7 ± 35.2
2.1 ± 0.1
105.9 ± 15.7
29.7 ± 4.4
5.1 ± 0.0
88.8 ± 1.8
1.2 ± 0.3
26.0 ± 5.5
15.4 ± 3.5
1.5 ± 0.6
23.5 ± 6.7
1.1 ± 0.1
28.8 ± 9.6
15.6 ± 2.1
0.6 ± 0.2
9.3 ± 2.7
1.4 ± 0.1
40.6 ± 8.9
9.3 ± 2.4
4.2 ± 0.9
67.2 ± 9.4
223Ra and 224Ra
All samples were analyzed for the two short-lived radium isotopes 223Ra and 224Ra (Table 1). As with nutrient concentrations, activities of 223Ra and 224Ra activities were enriched in pit and seep samples compared to surf zone and offshore samples, suggesting groundwater-associated discharge of radium to the nearshore. In March 2007, a single sample collected from Webb Creek, the only major creek in the area discharging directly to the ocean, contained 223Ra and 224Ra activities of 0.5 and 4.3 dpm (100 L)−1, respectively.
To investigate homogeneity of Ra activities in the alongshore direction during each experiment, we tested whether 223Ra and 224Ra activities measured at the two cross-shore transects (Fig. 1) were significantly different using Student’s t test (t statistics not shown). For both the July 2006 and March 2007 studies, 223Ra and 224Ra activities collected from pits along the two transects were not significantly different (0.34 ≤ p ≤ 0.90), suggesting groundwater activities are relatively homogeneous at this spatial scale. No significant differences were found between the samples collected at ankle depth along the two transects (0.55 < p < 0.69) or at waist depth along the two transects (0.36 < p < 0.99). The lack of significant differences between surf zone activities along the two transects indicates that radium activities are relatively homogeneous in the surf zone in the alongshore direction on the hundred meter scale.
We tested whether the surf zone was well mixed in the cross-shore direction with respect to 223Ra and 224Ra by comparing activities of ankle and waist depth samples for each experiment. In July 2007, 223Ra samples collected at ankle and waist depth were not significantly different (t223,Jul06 = 1.28, p = 0.20). In all other comparisons, activities at ankle depth were significantly higher than at waist depth (t223,Mar07 = 2.57, p = 0.01; t224,Jul06 = 2.24, p = 0.028; t224,Mar07 = 3.59, p < 10−3). The cross-shore variation within the surf zone was on the order of 10–25% of the mean radium activity at ankle depth. This variability is small compared to the differences between the surf zone and other major sample groups including Bolinas Lagoon, offshore waters, pits, and seeps. For the purposes of further analysis, we group ankle- and waist-deep surf zone samples for each isotope, referring to them collectively as the surf zone sample group.
t and p values for 223Ra (upper right half) and 224Ra (lower left half) comparisons across groups and experiments
Ebb flow from Bolinas Lagoon was enriched in 223Ra and 224Ra relative to offshore waters during both experiments (Table 2; Fig. 5), suggesting submarine groundwater discharge to the lagoon throughout the year. During the March 2007 experiment, the lagoon was also enriched in both isotopes relative to surf zone waters whereas during the July 2006 experiment, the lagoon was significantly enriched over surf zone activities in 224Ra but differences in 223Ra activities were not significant. Mean 223Ra and 224Ra activities in Bolinas Lagoon were higher than mean surf zone activities by 170% and 190% in March 2007 and by 40% and 50% in July 2006. In comparison, Bolinas Lagoon waters contained significantly less of each isotope than groundwater samples from pits during the July 2006 experiment. The same relationship was true for 224Ra in March 2007, but differences in 223Ra were not statistically significant.
Radium activities in sample groups were compared between the two experiments to test for seasonal differences. 223Ra and 224Ra activities in pit and seep samples were not different between summer and winter, indicating a seasonally stable groundwater end member with respect to 223Ra and 224Ra activities (Table 2; Fig. 5). Activities of the longer-lived isotope 223Ra in the surf zone were not significantly different between the two experiments, but 224Ra activities in the surf zone were significantly lower during the March 2007 experiment relative to July 2006 by 22%. Differences between offshore 223Ra and 224Ra activities during the two studies were insignificant. Bolinas Lagoon was significantly enriched in 223Ra and 224Ra by 86% and 49%, respectively, during the March 2007 experiment compared to the July 2006 experiment.
To test the role of tide level in explaining radium variability in the surf zone, the four samples collected in the surf zone during each low-tide sampling event were grouped and compared by paired t test to the corresponding four samples collected during the previous high tide. In July 2006, 223Ra and 224Ra activities in the surf zone were significantly higher at low tides than at preceding high tides (t223,Jul06 = −4.89, p < 10−4; t224,Jul06 = −6.65, p < 10−6), with mean 223Ra and 224Ra activities at low tides 87% and 95% higher than at preceding high tides, respectively. In March 2007, mean 223Ra and 224Ra activities were 80% and 60% higher at low tides than at preceding high tides, respectively, but the difference was only statistically significant for 223Ra (t223,Mar07 = −3.36, p = 0.0024; t224,Mar07 = −2.00, p = 0.055).
Radium activity in the surf zone was compared to daily tidal range in order to examine the role of fortnightly neap–spring tidal variability on surf zone radium activity. Neither 223Ra nor 224Ra activity in the surf zone was significantly correlated to tidal range when grouped by experiment (r223,Jul06 = 0.22, p = 0.055; r223,Mar07 = 0.12, p = 0.37; r224,Jul06 = 0.16, p = 0.18; r224,Mar07 = 0.24, p = 0.070). When samples from both experiments were grouped together, a significant positive correlation emerged between tidal range and both 223Ra and 224Ra (r223 = 0.20, p = 0.019; r224 = 0.26, p = 0.0022).
A similar comparison was made for each experiment to investigate the correlation between average daily breaker height on surf zone radium activity. During the July 2006 experiment, 223Ra and 224Ra activities in the surf zone were significantly negatively correlated with breaker height (r223 = −0.44, p = 0.0001; r224 = −0.43, p = 0.0001). Interestingly, during the March 2007 experiment when breaking waves in the surf zone were noticeably larger, the short-lived isotope 224Ra in the surf zone was significantly positively correlated with breaker height (r224 = 0.38, p = 0.0043). No significant relationship existed between daily mean breaker height and 223Ra in the surf zone during the March 2007 experiment (r223 = 0.19, p = 0.14).
Results of the creek survey
Flow Rate (L min−1)
Fphosphate (mmol min−1)
Fsilicate (mmol min−1)
FDIN (mmol min−1)
Black Rock Creek
Pike County Gulch
Stinson Gulch #1
Stinson Gulch #2
Stinson Gulch #3
During both the summer and winter studies, 223Ra activities in the surf zone were significantly higher at low tides than at preceding high tides. For 224Ra, the same trend was observed although results were statistically significant only for the July 2006 experiment. The increased 223Ra and 224Ra activities observed during low tides suggest discharge of tidally pumped, radium-enriched groundwater out of the beach aquifer during ebb tides. This interpretation is consistent with results from other studies documenting tidal pumping (Boehm et al. 2004). An alternative explanation for the increased radium activity between low and high tide is that the surf zone becomes enriched in radium at low tide by the outflow of Bolinas Lagoon. However, it should be noted that sediment transport studies suggest that ebb outflow from Bolinas Lagoon typically flows toward the northwest, away from our sampling sites (Philip Williams & Associates 2005). This suggests that Bolinas ebb flow is not directed to the south, toward our study site.
The magnitude of SGD forced by tidal pumping is directly affected by the magnitude of tidal range, or the difference in elevation between high and low tide (Ataie-Ashtiani et al. 2001). Assuming constant rates of cross-shore mixing, one might expect that SGD-associated radium would increase in the surf zone during periods of highest tidal range. Indeed, tidal range during our studies did explain 4% and 7% of the variation in 223Ra and 224Ra in the surf zone, respectively. This significant positive correlation is consistent with previous studies concluding that tidal range does influence the magnitude of tidal pumping of groundwater from the beach aquifer, with the greatest discharge occurring at or around spring tide (Li et al. 1999; Rapaglia 2005; de Sieyes et al. 2008).
An alternative interpretation of the radium enrichment of the surf zone at spring tide is that Bolinas Lagoon is disproportionately enriching the surf zone with radium at that point in the fortnightly tidal cycle. While increases in tidally pumped groundwater during periods of increased tidal range are consistent with the numerical simulations of others (Ataie-Ashtiani et al. 2001), we cannot discount this possibility. However, as mentioned before, the limited available data on ebb flow from the lagoon mouth is not consistent with this interpretation (Philip Williams & Associates 2005). More specific work following radium activity in the ebb plumes from the lagoon is needed to quantitatively evaluate the contribution of this source.
The role of wave setup and wave run-up in driving SGD has been explored by other researchers numerically and using field measurements. Increases in breaker height have been shown not only to increase wave pumping of SGD (Longuet-Higgins 1983) but also to increase cross-shore mixing in the nearshore (Pearson et al. 2002). Significant negative correlations were observed between breaker height and activities of 223Ra or 224Ra in the surf zone during the July 2006 experiment, with breaker height explaining 44% and 43% of activity for the two isotopes, respectively. The negative correlations in the summer experiment suggest either reduced discharge during periods of higher breaking waves, increased cross-shore mixing with radium-poor offshore waters, or both. Given the expected role of waves in driving groundwater flow (larger waves, larger setup, and thus larger wave pumped SGD), our results suggest that, during summer when breaker height is comparatively small, the net effect of increased breaker height is increased mixing with radium-poor offshore waters rather than decreased discharge. During the March 2007 experiment when breaker height was larger and more variable compared to the summer, surf zone activities of the short-lived isotope 224Ra were significantly positively correlated with breaker height. In March, variations in breaker height explained 38% of the radium variability. This relationship is consistent with increased wave-driven SGD during large winter swell events. To the best of our knowledge, no other studies have observed a significant relationship between breaker height and groundwater tracer concentrations in open waters receiving SGD.
SGD Estimates and Seasonal Comparison
Numerous lines of evidence support the use of the two short-lived radium isotopes 223Ra and 224Ra as tracers of beach groundwater flow to the ocean. The decrease in activity from groundwater to surf zone and Bolinas Lagoon waters to offshore waters is consistent with the conceptual model of a groundwater tracer source discharging in this setting. Conversely, no consistent, statistically significant patterns emerged that suggested beach groundwater as the primary source of the long-lived isotope 226Ra to the nearshore. This lack of a clear pattern may be a combination of the multiple sources of the long-lived isotope 226Ra in this environment, including beach groundwater, 226Ra from hot springs, the outflow of Bolinas Lagoon, and possibly the outflow of San Francisco Bay, which was not investigated in this study. Point Reyes is a major upwelling center, and upwelled waters may also be another important source of 226Ra to the coastal ocean in this area. 226Ra activities monitored during the experiment were inconsistent with the assumptions required of methods using the offshore decay of groundwater-derived 226Ra to calculate groundwater discharge (Moore 2000b, 2003). For this reason, we chose to estimate SGD using a mass balance of short-lived radium isotopes in the surf zone (Boehm et al. 2004; Paytan et al. 2006).
Given that the 223Ra and 224Ra activities were lower in Webb Creek than in offshore waters, they very likely do not contribute significant short-lived radium isotopes to the nearshore. For this reason, inputs from the creek are ignored in the mass balance. The mass balance assumes that all radium in the surf zone is derived from beach groundwater and not from other sources including Bolinas Lagoon, upwelled seawater, or San Francisco Bay.
SGD estimates were previously reported for this site using salinity as a tracer and models of saline groundwater discharge and found to be between 17 and 23 L min−1 m−1 during the dry season (de Sieyes et al. 2008). Those estimates are a factor of two to three higher than the median radium-based discharge rates reported here for the dry season. Discrepancies in SGD estimates obtained by independent methods is not unusual (Burnett et al. 2006).
A comparison of our radium-derived SGD estimates with those from locations with similar climates (Southern California and Israel) indicates our estimates are within the range of those previous reported. Boehm et al. (2006) estimated dry season discharge rates between 4.2 and 8.9 L min−1 m−1 at Huntington Beach, CA, using a radium-based eddy diffusivity approach. Shellenbarger et al. (2006) reported annual average discharge rates of 1.0 to 4.5 L min−1 m−1 in the Gulf of Aqaba, Israel, based on a coastal box model approach using radium as a groundwater tracer. These ranges match well with the median discharge estimates of 6 and 8 L min−1 m−1 we report for Stinson Beach for dry weather.
SGD estimates were significantly greater in March 2007 than in July 2006 based on both 223Ra (t = −40.5, p < 10−10) and 224Ra (t = −38.7, p < 10−10). This difference is driven mathematically by seasonal differences in radium activities and surf zone volume (Vprism), as Vprism is larger in winter than in summer due to larger waves breaking farther offshore in winter months. The large degree to which our median SGD estimates vary from summer and winter may result from the strongly seasonal precipitation–evapotranspiration cycle experienced in the Mediterranean climate of coastal Central California.
Using Monte Carlo simulations allowed us to incorporate quantifiable uncertainties of input terms into our SGD estimates. Specifically, the radium activities incorporated in each model run were chosen based on standard deviations about mean radium activities for each sample group. The model also used a wide range of surf zone residence times, 1 to 4 h, reflecting the uncertainty of that model input for the surf zone at the field site. Uncertainty was not quantifiable for the rip cell volume term (Vprism), which was assumed constant in all simulations for a given experiment. Future work should examine uncertainty in this parameter.
Bolinas Lagoon was significantly enriched in both 223Ra and 224Ra during the March 2007 experiment compared to the July 2006. Because flow in this lagoon is dominated by tidal exchange (Philip Williams & Associates 2005; Ritter 1973), we can assume that residence time therein likely remains approximately stable on the seasonal timescale. It follows that higher 223Ra and 224Ra activities in the lagoon in March are evidence of increased groundwater flux during the winter experiment, consistent with the seasonal variation in SGD reported above for the Stinson Beach shoreline. An estimate of either residence time or tidal exchange ratio could be used in conjunction with the radium activities presented here to estimate SGD to Bolinas Lagoon. Unfortunately, to the best of our knowledge, no published values exist for these parameters, and such a calculation is not possible at this time. The role played by SGD in the Bolinas Lagoon ecosystem, which has itself been recognized as an internationally significant ecological resource, should be a focus of future research.
Our previous work at the site has shown that groundwater at Stinson Beach is a major source of nutrients to the coastal ocean, with nutrient pollution in fresh groundwater due at least in part to the high density of septic systems in the community. A comparison between groundwater-associated nutrient flux and that from creeks discharging locally during the March 2007 experiment further supports this conclusion. Total creek-associated nutrient flux (± standard deviation) in March 2007 was estimated at 10 ± 3 mmol min−1 phosphate, 4 ± 1 mol min−1 silicate, and 200 ± 50 mmol min−1 dissolved inorganic nitrogen. Assuming SGD-associated flux in March 2007 is the product of the median 223Ra-based SGD estimate, 38 L min−1 m−1, and mean pit nutrient concentrations of 2.6, 130, and 30.4 µM phosphate, silicate, and DIN, respectively, total SGD-associated flux at the study site in March 2007 was 99 µmol phosphate min−1 m−1, 4,940 µmol silicate min−1 m−1, and 1,160 µmol DIN min−1 m−1. In other words, SGD from the short 200-m stretch of Stinson Beach where our experiments were conducted was responsible for a nutrient flux approximately equal to the total creek-associated flux of phosphate and dissolved inorganic nitrogen discharged within 6 km of the study site in March 2007. Surface water runoff in late summer along this area of coast was negligible, so a similar calculation for the July 2006 experiment was not made, but we can conclude that discharge of nutrient-enriched groundwater discharge at Stinson Beach likely plays a particularly significant role in the local marine nutrient budget during the summer months. This highlights the importance of groundwater protection at Stinson Beach and similar coastal settings where discharge of groundwater to the coastal ocean occurs.
Submarine groundwater discharge was documented at Stinson Beach during two experiments. With the exception of 224Ra during the March 2007 experiment, short-lived radium isotope activities in the surf zone were significantly higher at low tide relative to high tide, indicating the importance of tidal pumping along this coastline. Tidal range correlated significantly with 223Ra and 224Ra activity in the surf zone suggesting that the magnitude of discharge is controlled to some degree by the tidal range, with maximal discharge occurring during spring tide. Increases in wave action at the beach had a significant but opposite effect on radium activities in the surf zone during the summer and winter studies, highlighting the roles of waves in driving both SGD and cross-shore mixing. The arrival of large swell events at the beach in winter appeared to increase radium-enriched SGD to the surf zone.
This study did not investigate the potential effects of large-scale changes in flow and mixing from tides, wind, waves, upwelling, and other physical processes which may be influencing radium activities in the nearshore. Future studies investigating these processes would be useful in fully understanding the sources, fate, and transport of radium in coastal waters.
226Ra was enriched in offshore waters relative to surf zone waters at the site, indicating shoreline groundwater discharge was not the sole source of 226Ra to the nearshore. Bolinas Lagoon, San Francisco Bay, upwelling, and hydrothermal springs may all be substantial sources of 226Ra to the coastal ocean. 226Ra was not useful as a tracer for calculating SGD at this site.
SGD at Stinson Beach is seasonally variable, with increased discharge occurring in the winter. Nutrient fluxes associated with SGD during winter months were large, even compared to nutrient loading associated with surface runoff in the area. The high degree of nutrient loading is consistent with previous studies at the site, which attribute the high concentrations of nitrogen and phosphate to the high density of septic systems used for wastewater treatment in the community. This study highlights the importance of groundwater quality protection in areas such as Stinson Beach and nearby Bolinas Lagoon, where SGD-associated nutrient flux can be a major component of the local marine biogeochemical budget.
This research was supported by the National Sea Grant College Program of the US Department of Commerce’s National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration under NOAA Grant NA04OAR4170038, Project R/CZ-197, through the California Sea Grant College Program. The views expressed herein do not necessarily reflect the views of California Sea Grant. The authors acknowledge Karen Knee and Eric Foote for assistance in the field and/or suggestions for improving the manuscript. We acknowledge comments from the editor, associate editor, and two reviewers that improved the manuscript.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.