RETRACTED ARTICLE: Penetrator strength effect in long-rod critical ricochet angle
- 302 Downloads
3D numerical simulations were performed in order to further investigate the role of penetrator strength in the interaction of long-rods and oblique targets. Three distinctive regimes resulting from oblique impact depending on the obliquity, namely simple ricochet, critical ricochet and target perforation, were investigated in detail. Critical ricochet angles were calculated with a full 3D explicit finite element method for various impact velocities and strength of target plates and projectiles.
Numerical predictions were compared with existing two-dimensional analytical models and test results. It was predicted that critical ricochet angle increases with decreasing impact velocity and that higher ricochet angles were expected if higher strength target materials are employed. But there are differences between analytical models and 3D numerical simulation results or test results. The causes for these discrepancies are established by numerical simulations which explore the validity of the penetrator strength parameter in the analytical model as a physical entity.
As a matter of fact, in this paper we first investigate the role of penetrator dynamic strength using two-dimensional simulation which resulted in different penetrator strengths out of different impact velocities. Next, by applying these amounts for penetrator strength in Rosenberg analytical model the critical ricochet angle is calculated. Finally, a comparison between the present analytical method with the 3D simulation and test results shows that the new analytical approach leads to modified results with respect to Rosenberg ones.
KeywordsCritical ricochet angle Penetrator strength Numerical solution Long-Rod
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- J. A. Zukas, High Velocity Impact Dynamics, Wiley, (New York), (1990).Google Scholar
- R. M. Ogorkiewicz, Technology of Tanks, Coulsdon: Janes’s Information Group, (1991).Google Scholar
- W. Goldsmith and P. M. Cunningham, Kinematic Phenomena Observed During the Oblique Impact of a Sphere on a Beam, J. Appl. Mech., (Trans. ASME), (1956) 78 612.Google Scholar
- R. F. Recht and T. W. Ipson, The dynamics of terminal ballistics, Final Report No AD274128 (Denver: Denver Research Institute), (1962).Google Scholar
- S. A. Finnegan, L. F. Dimaranan, D. E. R. Heimdahl and J. K. Pringle, A study of obliquity effects on perforation and ricochet processes in thin plates impacted by compact fragments, Proc. 14th Int. Symp. Ballistics, (1993) p 661.Google Scholar
- Z. Rosenberg, Y. Yeshurun and M. Mayseless, On the. Ricochet of long rod projectiles, Proc. 11th Int. Symp. Ballistics, (1989) p. 501.Google Scholar
- H. Senf, H. Rothenhausler, F. Scharpf, A. Both and W. Pfang, Experimental and numerical investigation of the ricocheting of projectiles from metallic surfaces, Proc. 6th Int. Symp. Ballistics, (1981) p. 510.Google Scholar
- E. Roecker and C. Grabarek, The Effect of Yaw and Pitch on Long Rod Penetration into Rolled Homogeneous Armor at Various Obliquities, Proc. 9th Int. Symp. Ballistics, (1986) 2 467–473.Google Scholar
- J. Falcovitz, M. Mayseless, Z. Tauber, D. Keck, R. Kennedy, K. Ofstedhal and P. Sing, A Computer Model for Oblique Impact of a Rigid Projectile at Ductile Layered Targets, Proc. 11th Int. Symp. Ballistics, (1989) p. 311.Google Scholar
- G. R. Johnson, R. A. Stryk, T. J. Holmquist and O. A. Souka, Recent EPIC code developments for high velocity impact: 3D element arrangements and 2D fragment distributions, Int J Impact Eng, (1990), 281–294.Google Scholar
- G. Luttwak, Z. Rosenberg and Y. Kivity, Long rod penetration in oblique impact, AlP Conf Proc. (1996).Google Scholar
- V. Hohler and A. J. Stilp, Interferometric Investigation of Rod Deceleration During Impact Process, Proc. 6th Int. Symp. Ballistics, (1981) p. 333.Google Scholar
- G. F. Sislby, Penetration of semi-infinite steel targets by tungsten rods at 1.3 to 4.5 lcds, Proc. 8th Int. Symp. Ballistics, (1984) p. 31.Google Scholar
- C. E. Anderson, S. J. Bless, T. R. Sharron, S. Satapathy and M. J. Normandia, Investigation of yawed impact into a finite target, AlP Conf Proc., (1998) p. 925.Google Scholar
- M. Lee and S. J. Bless, Cavity models for solid and hollow projectiles, AlP Conf Proc., (1998) 925–928.Google Scholar
- C. Zienkiewicz and R. L. Taylor, The Finite Element Method 4th edn, McGraw-Hill, (New York), (1991) vol 2.Google Scholar
- US DoD Armour Plate, Steel, Wrought, Homogeneous Military Specification MIL-A-12560H (Amendment 3), (2000).Google Scholar
- G. R. Johnson and W. H. Cook, A constitutive model and data for metals subjected to large strains, high strain rates and high temperatures. Proceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Ballistics, (1983) p. 541.Google Scholar
- LsDyna User’s Manual version 970, (Livermore Software Technology Corporation), (2007).Google Scholar
- L. Woong, J. L. Heon and S. Hyunho, Ricochet of a tungsten heavy alloy long-rod projectile from deformable steel plates, Int. J. Appl,Phys, (2002) 35.Google Scholar