Human Rights Review

, Volume 11, Issue 1, pp 17–44 | Cite as

Are There Universal Collective Rights?

Article

Abstract

The first part of the paper focuses on the current debate over the universality of human rights. After conceptually distinguishing between different types of universality, it employs Sen’s definition that the claim of a universal value is the one that people anywhere may have reason to see as valuable. When applied to human rights, this standard implies “thin” (relative, contingent) universality, which might be operationally worked-out as in Donnelly’s three-tiered scheme of conceptsconceptionsimplementations. The second part is devoted to collective rights, which have recently become a new topic of the human rights debate. This part provides the basis of political–philosophical justification and legal–theoretical conceptualization of collective rights, as rights directly vested in collective entities. The third part dwells on the problem of universality of collective rights. It differentiates between the three main collective entities in international law—peoples, minorities, and indigenous peoples—and investigates whether certain rights vested in these collectives might, according to Sen’s standard, acquire the status of the universal ones. After determining that some rights are, in principle, plausible candidates for such a status in international law, this paper concludes by taking notice of a number of the open issues that still need to be settled, primarily by the cooperative endeavor of international legal scholars and legal theorists.

Keywords

Universality Human rights Collective rights Peoples Minorities Indigenous peoples 

References

  1. Abu-Sahlieh, S.A.A. “Muslims and Human Rights: Challenges and Perspectives” in W. Schmale (ed), Human Rights and Cultural Diversity (Goldbach: Keip Publishing, 1993) 239–268Google Scholar
  2. Alexy, R. Theorie der juristichen Argumentation (Die theorie des rationalen Diskurses als Theorie der juristichen Begründung) (Frankfurt: Suhrkamp, 1983).Google Scholar
  3. An-Na’im, A. A. “The Contingent Universality of Human Rights: The Case of Freedom of Expression in African and Islamic Contexts” (1997) 11 Emory International Law Review 29, 30.Google Scholar
  4. An-Na “im, A. A. “Human Rights and the Challenge of Relevance: The Case of Collective Rights” in M. Castermans-Holleman (eds), The Role of the Nation-State in the 21st Century - Human Rights, International Organisations and Foreign Policy (Essays in Honour of Peter Beahr) (The Hague: Kluwer Law International, 1998) 8, note 11.Google Scholar
  5. Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics (translated and edited by Roger Crisp) (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, Book V, 2000), Ch. 7, 1134b, 93.Google Scholar
  6. Barbieri, W. “Group Rights and Muslim Diaspora” (1999) 21 Human Rights Quarterly 907, 918.Google Scholar
  7. Berry, B. Culture and Equality—An Egalitarian Critique of Multiculturalism (Cambridge: Polity Press, 2001) 112.Google Scholar
  8. Berting, J. “Societal Development in Relation to Human Rights, Rights of Peoples and Sociological Theory and Research” in G. B. Kutukdijan and A. Papisca (eds), Rights of Peoples (Padova: CEDAM, 1991) 7–30.Google Scholar
  9. Bobbio, N. The Age of Rights (Cambridge: Polity Press, 1996) 3–11Google Scholar
  10. Boshammer, S. Gruppen, Rechte, Gerechtigkeit (Berlin, New York: Walter de Gruyter, 2003)Google Scholar
  11. Buchanan, A.“The Role of Collective Rights in the Theory of Indigenous Peoples” Rights” (1993) 89 Transnational Law & Contemporary Problems 89, 92.Google Scholar
  12. Buchanan, A. “Liberalism and Group Rights” in J. L. Coleman and A. Buchanan (eds), In Harm”s Way - Essays in Honour of Joel Feinberg (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1994) 1–15Google Scholar
  13. Capotorti, F. “Are Minorities Entitled to Collective International Rights?” in Y. Dinstein (ed), The Protection of Minorities and Human Rights (Dordrecht: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 1992) 509.Google Scholar
  14. Cassese, A. Self-Determination of Peoples: A Legal Reappraisal (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995) 42–43.Google Scholar
  15. Chandler, D. “The OSCE and the Internationalisation of National Minority Rights” in K. Cordell (ed), Ethnicity and Democratisation in the New Europe (London and New York: Routledge, 1999) 61–73Google Scholar
  16. Claude, I. National Minorities: An International Problem (Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press, 1955) 21Google Scholar
  17. Clinton, R. N. “The Rights of Indigenous Peoples as Collective Group Rights” (1990) 32 Arizona Law Review 739Google Scholar
  18. Crawford, J. “The Rights of Peoples: “Peoples” or “Governments”?” in J. Crawford (ed), The Rights of Peoples (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1988) 57.Google Scholar
  19. Crawford, J. “The Right to Self-Determination in International Law: Its Development and Future” in P. Alston (ed), Peoples” Rights (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001) 64.Google Scholar
  20. Cronin, K. “Defining “Group Rights” (2004) 69 Irish Theological Quarterly 99CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Dinstein, Y. “Collective Human Rights of Peoples and Minorities” (1976) 25 International and Comparative Law Quarterly 102CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Donnelly, J. “The Relative Universality of Human Rights” (2007) 29 Human Rights Quarterly 281, 291Google Scholar
  23. Dworkin, R. Taking Rights Seriously (Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, 1977) 91, note 1.Google Scholar
  24. Franck, T.“The Emerging Right to Democratic Governance” (1992) 86 The American Journal of International Law 46CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Franck, T. M. Fairness in International Law and Institutions (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1995) 140, 143.Google Scholar
  26. Franck, T. M. “Is Personal Freedom a Western Value?” (1997) 91 American Journal of International Law 593, 622–623Google Scholar
  27. Franck, T. M., The Empowered Self—Law and Society in the Age of Individualism (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999) 252, 253.Google Scholar
  28. Freeman, M. “Are There Collective Human Rights?” (1995) 43 Political Studies 25, 38Google Scholar
  29. Galenkamp, M. “Collective Rights: Much Ado About Nothing?” (1991) 9 Netherlands Quarterly for Human Rights 291, 293Google Scholar
  30. Habermas, J. “Wahrheitstheorien” in H. Fahrenbach (ed), Wirklichkeit und Reflexion (Festschrift Walter Schulz zum 60. Geburtstag) (Pfullingen: Neske, 1973) 211–265Google Scholar
  31. Habermas, J. Moralbewußtsein und kommunikatives Handeln (Frankfurt: Suhrkamp, 1983)Google Scholar
  32. Haksar, V. “Collective Rights and the Value of Groups” (1998) 41 Inquiry 21, 41Google Scholar
  33. Hart, H.L.A. “Are There Any Natural Rights?” (1955) 64 The Philosophical Review 175CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Hartney, M. “Some Confusions Concerning Collective Rights” (1991) 4 Canadian Journal of Law and Jurisprudence 293, 294.Google Scholar
  35. Holland, T. E. The Elements of Jurisprudence (1882, Clarck: The Lawbook Exchange Ltd, 2006) 121Google Scholar
  36. Ignatieff, M. “The Attack on Human Rights” (November/December 2001a) Foreign Affairs 102, 102.Google Scholar
  37. Ignatieff, M. Human Rights as Politics and Idolatry (New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 2001b) 56.Google Scholar
  38. Jones, P. “Human Rights, Group Rights, and Peoples” Rights” (1999) 21 Human Rights Quarterly 80, 86.Google Scholar
  39. Jones, P. “Individuals, Communities and Human Rights” (2000) 26 Review of International Studies 199, 205.Google Scholar
  40. Jovanović, M. A. “Recognizing Minority Identities Through Collective Rights” (2005) 27 Human Rights Quarterly 627Google Scholar
  41. Kelsen, H. Introduction to the Problems of Legal Theory (Translation of the first edition of the Reine Rechtslehre, by B. L. Paulson and S. L. Paulson) (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1992) 53.Google Scholar
  42. Kingsbury, B. “Reconciling Five Competing Conceptual Structures of Indigenous Peoples” Claims in International and Comparative Law” (2001–2002) 34 New York University Journal of International Law and Politics 189Google Scholar
  43. Kis, J. “Beyond the Nation State” (1996) 63 Social Research 191, 227Google Scholar
  44. Kukathas, C. “Are There Any Cultural Rights?” in J. Stapleton (ed), Group Rights (Bristol: Thoemmes Press, 1995) 283Google Scholar
  45. Kymlicka, W. Multicultural Citizenship—A Liberal Theory of Minority Rights (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1995) 45.Google Scholar
  46. Kymlicka, W. “Two Models of Pluralism and Tolerance” in D. Heyd (ed.), Toleration: An Elusive Virtue (New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1996) 81–105.Google Scholar
  47. Maitland, F. W. Collected Papers (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1911)Google Scholar
  48. Margalit, A. and Raz, J. “National Self-Determination” in W. Kymlicka (ed), The Rights of Minority Cultures (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1995) 87.Google Scholar
  49. Miller, D. “Group Rights, Human Rights and Citizenship” (2002) 10 European Journal of Philosophy 178, 178.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Mitnick, E. J. Rights, Groups, and Self-Invention (Group-Differentiated Rights in Liberal Theory) (Aldershot: Ashgate, 2006) viiiGoogle Scholar
  51. Müllerson, R. “Universal Human Rights in Multicultural World” in E.R. May and A.E. Laiou (eds), The Dumbarton Oaks Conventions and the United Nations 1944–1994 (Washington: Dumbarton Oaks Research Library and Collection, 1998) 113Google Scholar
  52. Nickel, J. W. Making Sense of Human Rights - Philosophical Reflections on the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (Berkley: University of California Press, 1987), 6.Google Scholar
  53. Oestreich, J. E. “Liberal Theory and Minority Group Rights” (1999) 21 Human Rights Quarterly 108, 113Google Scholar
  54. Onuma, Y. “In Quest of Intercivilizational Human Rights: “Universal” vs. “Relative”—Human Rights Viewed From an Asian Perspective” (2000) 1 Asia Pacific Journal on Human Rights and the Law, 53Google Scholar
  55. Patten, A. and Kymlicka, W. “Introduction: Language Rights and Political Theory: Context, Issues, and Approaches” in A. Patten and W. Kymlicka (eds), Language Rights and Political Theory (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003) 26Google Scholar
  56. Phillips, A. and Rosas, A. (eds), Universal Minority Rights (Abo and London: Abo Akademi University for Human Rights, 1995) 305Google Scholar
  57. Pollis, A., and Schwab, P. “Human Rights: A Western Construct With Limited Applicability”, in A. Pollis and P. Schwab (eds), Human Rights: Cultural and Ideological Perspectives (New York: Praeger, 1979) 1–18Google Scholar
  58. Ragazzi, M. The Concept of International Obligations (Oxford: Erga Omnes, Clarendon Press, 1997Google Scholar
  59. Rawls, J. “Justice as Fairness: Political Not Metaphysical” in S. Avineri and A. De-Shalit (eds), Communitarism and Individualism (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1992) 189Google Scholar
  60. Rawls, J. The Law of Peoples (with The Idea of Public Reason Revisited) (Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, 1999)Google Scholar
  61. Réaume, D. “Individuals, Groups, and Rights to Public Goods” (1988) 38 The University of Toronto Law Journal 1–27CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Reed Garet, R. The Existence of Groups: An Adjudicative Theory of Group Rights (Ann Arbor: University Microfilms International, 1981).Google Scholar
  63. Remington, R. A. and Miles, M. T. “Language and Ethnic (National) Politics in Serbia and New Mexico: A Cross-System Comparison” in M. Macura, Vojislav Stanovčić (eds), Položaj manjina u Saveznoj Republici Jugoslaviji (The Status of Minorities in the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia) (Belgrade: SANU, 1996) 525Google Scholar
  64. Roach, S. C. “Minority Rights and an Emergent International Right to Autonomy: A Historical and Normative Assessment” 2004 11 International Journal on Minority and Group Rights 411CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Rodríguez-Abascal, L. “On the Admissibility of Group Rights” (2003) 9 Annual Survey of International and Comparative Law 101, 106.Google Scholar
  66. Rosenfeld, M. “Can Human Rights Bridge the Gap Between Universalism and Relativism? A Pluralist Assessment Based on the Rights of Minorities” (1999) 30 Columbia Human Rights Law Review 249, 252.Google Scholar
  67. Samu, M. “The Collective Rights of the Minorities and their Quality as Constituent of the State” in K. Kulcsár and D. Szabo (eds), Dual Images—Multiculturalism on Two Sides of the Atlantic (Budapest: The Royal Society of Canada and Institute for Political Science of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences, 1996) 180Google Scholar
  68. Sanders, D. “Collective Rights” (1991) 13 Human Rights Quarterly 368CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Schauer, F. “Free Speech and Cultural Contingency of Constitutional Categories” in M. Rosenfeld (ed), Constitutionalism, Identity, Difference, and Legitimacy (Theoretical Perspectives) (Durham and London: Duke University Press, 1994) 367.Google Scholar
  70. Sen, A. “Democracy as a Universal Value” (1999) 10 Journal of Democracy 3, 12.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  71. Sieghart, P. The International Law of Human Rights (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1983) 367–378Google Scholar
  72. Sohn, L. B. “The Rights of Minorities” in L. Henkin (ed), The International Bill of Rights—The Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (New York: Columbia University Press, 1981) 282Google Scholar
  73. Sweet, W. “Theories of Rights and Political and Legal Instruments” in W. Sweet (ed), Philosophical Theory and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (Ottawa: University of Ottawa Press, 2003) 14Google Scholar
  74. Swepston, L. “Indigenous Peoples in International Law and Organizations” in J. Castellino and N. Walsh (eds), International Law and Indigenous Peoples (Leiden, Boston: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 2005) 54–58Google Scholar
  75. Taylor, C. “The Politics of Recognition” in A. Gutmann (ed), Multiculturalism (Examining the Politics of Recognition) (New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1994) 59.Google Scholar
  76. Taylor, C. “Irreducible Social Goods” in Philosophical Arguments (Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, 1997) 137Google Scholar
  77. The Executive Board, American Anthropological Association, “Statement on Human Rights” (1947) 49 American Anthropologist 539, 543.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  78. Thornberry, P. “The Democratic or Internal Aspect of Self-Determination With Some Remarks on Federalism” in C. Tomushat (ed), Modern Law of Self-Determination (Dordrecht: Martinus Nijhoff, 1993) 101Google Scholar
  79. Thornberry, P. “The Principle of Self-Determination” in V. Lowe and C. Warbrick (eds), The United Nations and the Principles of International Law (Essays in Memory of Michael Akehurts) (London and New York: Routledge, 1994) 183–184Google Scholar
  80. Thornberry, P. “Minority and Indigenous Rights at “The End of History” (2002) 2 Ethnicities 515, 517.Google Scholar
  81. Tretter, H. “Der Schutz etnischer Minderheiten durch kollektive und indviduelle Rechte” in F. Ermacora et al (eds), Volksgruppen im Spannungsfeld von Recht und Souveränität in Mittel-und Ost Europa, Braumülle (Wien, 1993) 164, note 1Google Scholar
  82. Troebst, S. The Council of Europe’s Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities Revisited, European Centre for Minority Issues, Flensburg, Working Paper # 2, 1998.Google Scholar
  83. Ulfstein, G. “Indigenous Peoples” Right to Land” (2004) 8 Max Planck UNYB1, 3.Google Scholar
  84. Van Dyke, V. “Human Rights and the Rights of Groups” (1974) 18 American Journal of Political Science 725CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  85. Van Dyke, V. “Collective Entities and Moral Rights: Problems in Liberal–Democratic Thought” (1982) 44 The Journal of Politics 21, 21CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. Van Dyke, V. “The Individual, the State, and Ethnic Communities in Political Theory” in W. Kymlicka (ed), The Rights of Minority Cultures (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1995) 33Google Scholar
  87. von Gierke, O. Die Genossenschaftstheorie und die deutsche Rechtsprechung (Berlin, Weidmannsche Buchhandlung, 1887)Google Scholar
  88. Waldron, J. “How to Argue for a Universal Claim” (1999) 30 Columbia Human Rights Law Review 305, 306Google Scholar
  89. Wall, S. “Collective Rights and Individual Autonomy” (2007) 117 Ethics 234CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  90. Walzer, M. On Toleration (New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1997) 17–18, 67Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2008

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Faculty of LawUniversity of BelgradeBelgradeSerbia

Personalised recommendations