Advertisement

“Caught in the Same Webs”Service Providers’ Insights on Gender-Based and Structural Violence Among Female Temporary Foreign Workers in Canada

  • Chantal RobillardEmail author
  • Janet McLaughlin
  • Donald C. Cole
  • Biljana Vasilevska
  • Richard Gendron
Article

Abstract

Drawing on the experiences of service providers supporting live-in caregivers and migrant agricultural workers in two Canadian provinces (Ontario and Quebec), we explore how structural violence shapes the precarious conditions of female temporary foreign workers. Service providers emphasized how transnational social pressures on women to maintain employment, the captivity involved in women’s employment contracts, the limits on unionization, and women’s isolation and lack of privacy, act together to create an unbalanced relationship between the employer and female worker. In turn, this leads to precarious migration and work conditions that foster a vulnerability to violence and abuse while at the same time limiting access to and delivery of services and social support to female temporary foreign workers. Amid these restrictions, service providers focus on making a difference where they can through initiatives such as human rights education workshops, offering support, understanding Canadian regulation, and empowerment workshops. Greater Canadian national options for permanent residency status could provide a basis for adequate services to temporary foreign workers as part of their universal human rights. Temporary foreign workers contribute to Canadian society, making it encumbant upon the Canadian state to ensure the respect of their universal human rights.

Keywords

Migrant women Temporary foreign workers Precarious work Abuse Structural violence Access to services 

Notes

Acknowledgements

We would like to thank Dr. Philip Kelly from York University for his precious support in reviewing policies regulating the TFWP. We also would like to acknowledge the contribution from our research coordinators, professionals, and assistants to data collection and analysis, as well as overall management of the project: Pauline O’Connor, Alexandra Ricard-Guay, Maya Shapiro, Josephine Eric, Marilyn Ouellet, Didier Dupont, and Gabrielle Perras Saint-Jean. Most importantly, we would like to express our gratitude to the participants without whom this study would not have been possible.

Funding Information

The project received financial support from the Canadian Institutes of Health Research-Institute of Gender and Health (CIHR-IGH). The project could not have succeeded without the precious support from its partners: Association des aides familiales du Québec, Centre de recherche et de formation (CRF) of the Centre de santé et services sociaux (CSSS) de la Montagne, Centre d’appui des travailleurs agricoles de Saint-Rémi (ATA), Justicia for Migrant Workers, Migrant Workers Resource Centre (Hamilton), and Agriculture Workers Alliance (Canada).

Compliance with Ethical Standards

Signed informed consent was provided in keeping with ethics approval from the Centre de santé et des services sociaux de la Montagne, the Université du Québec à Montréal, and the Wilfrid Laurier University ethical review boards.

References

  1. Ahma, A., Driver, N., McNally, M. J., & Stewart, D. E. (2009). “Why doesn’t she seek help for partner abuse?” An exploratory study with South Asian immigrant women. Social Science & Medicine, 69, 613–622.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Alboim, N., & Maytree. (2009). Adjusting the balance: fixing Canada’s economic immigration policies. Toronto: Maytree.Google Scholar
  3. Altman, M., & Pannell, K. (2012). Policy gaps and theory gaps: women and migrant domestic labor. Feminist Economics, 18(2), 291–315.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Association des Aides Familiales du Québec (AAFQ). (2008). Smuggling, trafficking and modern slavery of migrant caregivers in Québec. Montreal: Association des Aides Familiales du Québec.Google Scholar
  5. Baines, D., & Sharma, N. (2002). Migrant workers as non-citizens: the case against citizenship as a social policy concept. Studies in Political Economy, 69, 75–107.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Barber, P. G. (2000). Agency in Philippine women’s labour migration and provisional diaspora. Women's Studies International Forum, 23(4), 399–411.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Bhuyan, R. (2012). Negotiating citizenship on the frontlines: how the devolution of Canadian immigration policy shapes service delivery to women fleeing abuse. Law and Policy, 34(2), 211–236.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Bhuyan, R., & Smith-Carrier, T. (2010). Precarious migratory status in Canada: implications for social work and social service delivery. Canadian Social Work Journal, 12(1), 51–60.Google Scholar
  9. Binford, L. (2009). From fields of power to fields of seat: The dual process of constructing temporary migrant labour in Mexico and Canada. Third World Quarterly, 30(3), 503–517.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Choudry, A., & Smith, A.A. (2014). Unfree labour?: struggles of migrant and immigrant workers in Canada. https://secure.pmpress.org/index.php?l=product_detail&p=781. Accessed 28 January 2018.
  11. Citizenship and Immigration Canada - Research and Evaluation Branch (CIC) (2015). Canada facts and figures immigrant overview temporary residents. Table 2.3 and 2.4, 2005 to 2014. www.cic.gc.ca/english/pdf/2014-Facts-Figures-Temporary.pdf. Accessed 14 September 2016.
  12. Citizenship and Immigration Canada (CIC) (2016). What are the improvements to the caregiver program. Government of Canada. http://www.cic.gc.ca/English/helpcentre/answer.asp?qnum=912&top=28. Accessed 28 January 2018.
  13. Citizenship and Immigration Canada (CIC). (2017a). Find out if you can apply for permanent residence as a caregiver for children. Government of Canada. https://www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/services/immigrate-canada/caregivers/children/eligibility.html. Accessed 28 January 2018.
  14. Citizenship and Immigration Canada (CIC). (2017b). Find out if you’re eligible to apply for permanent residence—caring for people with high medical needs. Government of Canada. https://www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/services/immigrate-canada/caregivers/people-high-medical-needs/eligibility.html. Accessed 28 January 2018.
  15. Coalition for Migrant Worker Rights – Canada (CMWRC). (2016). Demands. http://migrantrights.ca/en/demands/. Accessed 23 August 2016.
  16. Commission des normes, de l'équité, de la santé et de la sécurité du travail (CNESST). (2016a). Travailleurs agricoles étrangers. Government of Quebec. http://www.csst.qc.ca/prevention/secteur/agriculture/Pages/travailleurs_agricoles_etrangers.aspx. Accessed 28 January 2018.
  17. Commission des normes, de l'équité, de la santé et de la sécurité du travail (CNESST) (2016b). Travailleurs agricoles : Les normes du travail au Québec. Government of Quebec. http://www.cnesst.gouv.qc.ca/Publications/200/Documents/DC200-1582web.pdf. Accessed 28 January 2018.
  18. Commission des normes, de l'équité, de la santé et de la sécurité du travail (CNESST). (2016c). Information kit intended for live-in caregivers and their employers. Government of Quebec. https://www.cnt.gouv.qc.ca/en/documentation-centre/information-kit/information-kit-intended-for-live-in-caregivers-and-their-employers/index.html. Accessed 28 January 2018.
  19. Crabtree, B. F., & Miller, W. L. (1999). Doing qualitative research in primary care: multiple strategies (2nd ed.). Newbury Park: Sage Publications.Google Scholar
  20. Crenshaw, K. W. (1994). Mapping the margins: intersectionality, identity politics, and violence against women of color. In M. Albertson Fineman & R. Mykitiuk (Eds.), The public nature of private violence (pp. 93–118). New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
  21. Cruz-Lopez, I.F. (2014). The Seasonal Agricultural Workers Program: looking at Mexican participation through a magnifying glass. Dissertation Abstracts International Section A: Humanities and Social Sciences, 74[8-A(E)], No Pagination Specified.Google Scholar
  22. Dauvergne, C., & Marsden, S. (2014). Beyond numbers versus rights: shifting the parameters of debate on temporary labour migration. Journal of International Migration and Integration, 15(3), 525–545.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Devinatz, V. G. (2015). Introduction to ““Slave-like conditions”: abuse of foreign workers in Canada”. Employee Responsibilities and Rights Journal, 27(3), 231–232.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Ehrenreich, B., & Hochschild, A. R. (Eds.). (2003). Global woman: nannies, maids, and sex workers in the new economy. New York: Metropolitan Books.Google Scholar
  25. Faraday, F. (2016). Canada’s choice decent work or entrenched exploitation for Canada’s migrant workers? Report prepared for Metlcalf Foundation. Toronto, ON. Retrieved from http://metcalffoundation.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Canadas-Choice-2.pdf. Accessed 14 September 2016.
  26. Farmer, P. (2004). An anthropology of structural violence. Current Anthropology, 45(3), 305–325.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Fédération des femmes du Québec (FTQ). (2017). Travailleuses domestiques et aides familiales. https://femmes.ftq.qc.ca/travailleuses-domestiques-et-aides-familiales/. Accessed 28 January 2018.
  28. Fudge, J. (2011). Global care chains, employment agencies, and the conundrum of jurisdiction: decent work for domestic workers in Canada. Canadian Journal of Women and the Law, 23(1), 235–264.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Goldring, L., & Landolt, P. (Eds.). (2013). Producing and negotiating non-citizenship: precarious legal status in Canada. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.Google Scholar
  30. Goldring, L., Berinstein, C., & Bernhard, J. (2009). Institutionalizing precarious migratory status in Canada. Citizenship Studies, 13(3), 239.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Grenn, O., & Ayalon, L. (2015). Whose right is it anyway? Familiarity with workers’ rights among older adults, family caregivers, and migrant live-in home care workers: implications for policy and practice. Educational Gerontology, 41(7), 471–481.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Guruge, S., & Humphreys, J. (2009). Les obstacles à l’accès aux services de soutien et à leur utilisation chez les immigrantes victimes de mauvais traitements. Canadian Journal of Nursing Research, 41(3), 64–84.Google Scholar
  33. Hanley, J., & Shragge, E. (2009). Organizing for immigrant rights: policy barriers and community campaigns. Journal of Community Practice, 17(1–2), 184–206.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Hennebry, J. (2012). Permanently temporary? Agricultural migrant workers and their integration in Canada. Montreal, Quebec: Institute for Research on Public Policy. http://irpp.org/wp-content/uploads/assets/research/diversity-immigration-and-integration/permanently-temporary/IRPP-Study-no26.pdf. Accessed 23 August 2016.
  35. Hennebry, J. (2014). Falling through the cracks? Migrant workers and the global social protection floor. Global Social Policy, 14(3), 369–388.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Hennebry, J., McLaughlin, J., & Prebisch, K. (2016). Out of the loop: (in)access to health care for migrant workers in Canada. Journal of International Migration and Integration, 17(2), 521–538.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Kelly, P. (2014). Canada’s live-in caregiver program. Asia Research Brief, 12. http://ycar.apps01.yorku.ca/wp-content/uploads/2013/09/caregivers-kelly.pdf. Accessed 29 January 2018.
  38. Kouta, C., Pithara, C., Zobnina, A., Apostolidou, Z., Christodoulou, J., Papadakaki, M., & Chliaoutakis, J. (2015). A systematic review of training interventions addressing sexual violence against marginalized at-risk groups of women. Heath Education Research, 30(6), 971–984.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Liang, L. (2011). The making of an ‘ideal’ live-in migrant care worker: recruiting, training, matching and disciplining. Ethnic and Racial Studies, 34(11), 1815–1834.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Magalhaes, L., Carrasco, C., & Gastaldo, D. (2010). Undocumented migrants in Canada: a scope literature review on health, access to services, and working conditions. Journal of Immigrant and Minority Health, 12(1), 132.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. McLaughlin, J. (2009). Migration and health: implications for development. A case study of Mexican and Jamaican migrants in Canada’s Seasonal Agricultural Workers Program. Policy paper. Canadian Foundation for the Americas (FOCAL). http://www.focal.ca/pdf/Migrant%20Health%20McLaughlin%202009.pdf. Accessed 23 August 2016.
  42. McLaughlin, J. (2010). Classifying “ideal migrant workers”: Mexican and Jamaican transnational farmworkers in Canada. Focaal--Journal of Global and Historical Anthropology, 2010(57), 79–94.Google Scholar
  43. McLaughlin, J., & Hennebry J. (2013). Pathways to precarity: structural vulnerabilities and lived consequences for migrant farmworkers in Canada. Chapter in Producing and negotiating non-citizenship: precarious legal status in Canada. Luin Goldring and Patricia Landolt (eds.) University of Toronto Press, 175–194.Google Scholar
  44. McLaughlin, J., & Hennebry, J. (2015). Managed into the margins: examining citizenship and human rights of migrant workers in Canada. In R.E. Howard-Hassmann and M. Walton-Roberts (Ed.), The human right to citizenship: a slippery concept. Pennsylvania: Philadelphia, 176–190.Google Scholar
  45. McLaughlin, J., Hennebry, J., & Haines, T. (2014). Paper versus practice: occupational health and safety protections and realities for temporary foreign agricultural workers in Ontario. Pistes: Interdisciplinary Journal of Work and Health, 16(2), 2–17.Google Scholar
  46. McLaughlin, J., Don Wells, A. L., & Diaz, A. (2017). ‘Temporary workers’, temporary fathers: transnational family impacts of Canada’s Seasonal Agricultural Workers’ Program. Relations Industrielles, 72(4), 682–709.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Munroe, V. E. (2005). A tale of two servitudes: defining and implementing a domestic response to trafficking of women for prostitution in the UK and Australia. Social & Legal Studies, 14(1), 91–114.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Nakache, D., & Kinoshita, P. (2010). The Canadian Temporary Foreign Worker Program: do short-term economic needs prevail over human rights concerns? Institute for Research on Public Policy. http://irpp.org/wp-content/uploads/assets/research/diversity-immigration-and-integration/new-research-article-3/IRPP-Study-no5.pdf. Accessed 23 August 2016.
  49. Noakes, S. (2015). Sex abuse case highlights vulnerability of workers on visas. CBC news. http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/sex-abuse-case-highlights-vulnerability-of-workers-on-visas-1.3129909. Accessed 23 August 2016.
  50. North South Institute. (2006). Migrant workers in Canada: a review of the Canadian Seasonal Agricultural Workers Program. North-South Policy Institute. http://www.nsi-ins.ca/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/2006-Migrant-Workers-in-Canada-A-review-of-the-Canadian-Seasonal-Agricultural-Workers-Program.pdf. Accessed 23 August 2016.
  51. Ollus, N. (2016). Forced flexibility and exploitation: experiences of migrant workers in the cleaning industry. Nordic Journal of Working Life Studies, 6(1), 25–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Ontario Ministry of Labour (2018). Domestic workers. Government of Ontario. https://www.labour.gov.on.ca/english/es/pubs/factsheets/fs_domestics.php. Accessed 28 January 2018.
  53. Oxman-Martinez, J., Hanley, J., Lach, L., Khanlou, N., Weerasinghe, S., & Agnew, V. (2005). Intersection of Canadian policy parameters affecting women with precarious immigration status: a baseline for understanding barriers to health. Journal of Immigrant Health, 7(4), 247–258.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Özden, C., & Schiff, M. (2006). International migration, remittances and the brain drain. Washington: World Bank and Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
  55. Pierre, M. (2005). Les facteurs d’exclusion faisant obstacle à l’intégration socioéconomique de certains groupes de femmes immigrées au Québec: Un état des lieux. Nouvelles Pratiques Sociales, 17(2), 75–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Polanco, G., & Zell, S. (2017). English as a border-drawing matter: language and the regulation of migrant service worker mobility in international labor markets. Journal of International Migration and Integration, 18(1), 267–289.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Potter, M., & Hamilton, J. (2014). Picking on vulnerable migrants: precarity and the mushroom industry in Northern Ireland. Work, Employment and Society, 28(3), 390–406.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Pottie, K., Ng, E., Spitzer, D., Mohammed, A., & Glzier, R. (2008). Language proficiency, gender and self-reported health: an analysis of the first two waves of the longitudinal survey of immigrants to Canada. Canadian Journal of Public Health, 99(6), 505–510.Google Scholar
  59. Pratt, G. (2009). Circulating sadness: witnessing Filipina mothers’ stories of family separation. Gender, Place and Culture, 16(1), 3–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Preibisch, K. (2005). Gender transformation odysseys: tracing the experiences of transnational migrant women in rural Canada. Canadian Women Studies, 24(4), 91–97.Google Scholar
  61. Preibisch, K. L., & Encalada Grez, E. (2010). The other side of el otro lado: Mexican migrant women and labor flexibility in Canadian agriculture. Signs, 35(2), 289–316.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Preibisch, K. L., & Encalada Grez, E. (2013). Between hearts and pockets: locating the outcomes of transnational homemaking practices among Mexican women in Canada’s temporary migration programmes. Citizenship Studies, 17(6–7), 785–802.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Rousseau, C., Kuile, S., Munoz, M., Nadeau, L., Ouimet, M., Kirmayer, L., & Crépeau, F. (2008). Health care access for refugees and immigrants with precarious status. Revue Canadienne de Santé Publique, 99(4), 290–292.Google Scholar
  64. Shantz, J. (2015). “Slave-like conditions”: abuse of foreign workers in Canada. Employee Responsibilities and Rights Journal, 27(3), 233–239.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Sharma, N. R. (2006). Home economics: nationalism and the making of ‘migrant workers’ in Canada. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.Google Scholar
  66. UFCW Canada and the Agricultural Workers Alliance. (2011). UFCW Canada report on the status of migrant farm workers in Canada, 2010–2011. http://s3.amazonaws.com/migrants_heroku_production/datas/487/UFCW-Status_of_MF_Workers_2010-2011_EN_original.pdf?1358374318. Accessed 23 August 2016.
  67. UFCW Canada and the Agriculture Workers’ Alliance (2014). The great Canadian rip-off! An economic case for restoring full EI special benefits access to SAWP workers. http://www.ufcw.ca/templates/ufcwcanada/images/directions14/march/1420/The-Great-Canadian-Rip-Off-An-Economic-Case-for-Restoring-Full-EI-Special-Benefits-Access-to-SAWP-Workers.pdf. Accessed 28 January 2018.
  68. Ullah, A. K. M. (2013). Exposure to remittances: theoretical and empirical implications for gender. Journal of International Migration and Integration, 14(3), 475–492.Google Scholar
  69. Wells, D., McLaughlin, J., Lyn, A., & Diaz, A. (2014). Sustaining North-South migrant precarity: remittances and transnational families in Canada’s seasonal agricultural program. Just Labour, 22.Google Scholar
  70. Welsh, S., Carr, J., & MacQuarrie, B. (2006). “I’m not thinking of it as sexual harassment”: understanding harassment across race and citizenship. Gender & Society, 20(1), 87–107.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  71. Weston, A. (2007). The changing economic context for Canada’s Seasonal Agricultural Workers Program. Ottawa: North-South Institute.Google Scholar
  72. Wilson, J. B., Rappleyea, D. L., Hodgson, J. L., Hall, T. L., & White, M. B. (2015). Intimate partner violence screening among migrant/seasonal farmworker women and healthcare: a policy brief. Journal of Community Health: The Publication for Health Promotion and Disease Prevention, 39(2), 372–377.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V., part of Springer Nature 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of SexologyUniversité du Québec à MontréalMontrealCanada
  2. 2.Health Studies ProgramWilfrid Laurier UniversityBrantfordCanada
  3. 3.Dalla Lana School of Public HealthUniversity of TorontoTorontoCanada

Personalised recommendations