Job Autonomy of Long-Term Residential Care Assistive Personnel: A Six Country Comparison
Assistive personnel are the primary caregivers in long term residential care (LTRC) and their job autonomy is a major social determinant of health. Our goal is to explore experiences of assistive personnel in six industrialized countries (Canada, Germany, Norway, Sweden, England, and the U.S.), and consider innovations in the LTRC setting that might influence their job autonomy. The methodology is based on on-site observations at nursing homes and interviews with assistive personnel and other relevant LTRC staff in selected nursing homes in all six countries. Previously published statistical material from the study on staff characteristics like pay, formal education, unionization, employment-related benefits and extent of part-time work is employed as relevant context for discussing job autonomy. Our results show that assistive personnel are highly supportive of job autonomy though they interpret autonomy differently and report widely varying levels of job autonomy. Those LTRC organizations that have a reputation for encouraging autonomy of assistive personal, report recruiting is far easier even where there is a shortage. In some countries we were told that “resident-centered” (“person-centered”) care and a leveling of the division of labor, understood as more equal and horizontal division of labor, was on the rise and this could affect autonomy. Job autonomy is welcomed by assistive personnel. The wide variation in job autonomy across nursing homes and across countries is surprising. Within nursing homes variation may reflect imperfect or incomplete implementation of autonomy policies, or differential application of policies. The resident-centered philosophy and the leveling of the division of labor could make for greater autonomy for assistive personnel. These workplace innovations are not universal in all countries and they could be more difficult to apply where resources and commitment are lacking. The increasingly frail population of LTRC facilities and the general trend toward growth of specialized medical treatment within LTRC in some of the countries may support an argument for some limitations to job autonomy in assistive personnel. Autonomy is favored by assistive personnel though not all have it. The workplace innovations of resident-centered care and a leveling of the division of labor in LTRC, could make for a greater degree of autonomy for assistive personnel in the future, while increased demand for highly skilled care could work in the other direction.
KeywordsAssistive care Long term residential care Job autonomy Six countries
Compliance with Ethical Standards
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
As there is no person or personal data appearing in the paper, there is no one from whom a permission should be obtained in order to publish personal data.
Ethical Treatment of Experimental Subjects (Animal and Human)
Not relevant as no experiments have been carried out in this study.
- Armstrong, P., Banerjee, A., Szebehely, M., Armstrong, H., Daly, T., & Stirling, L. (2009). They deserve better: The long-term care experience in Canada and Scandinivia. Ottawa: Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives.Google Scholar
- Banerjee, A., Tamara D, Hugh A, Pat A, Stirling L,Szebeheley M. (2008). Out-of-control: Violence against personal support Workers in Long-Term Care.Google Scholar
- Bishop, C. E., Weinberg, D. B., Leutz, W., Dossa, A., Pfefferle, S. G., and Zincavage, R. M. (2008). Nursing assistants' job commitment: Effect of nursing home organizational factors and impact on resident well-being. Gerontologist, 48 Spec No 1, 36-45.Google Scholar
- Bongers, P. M., Kremer, A. M., & ter Laak, J. (2002). Are psychosocial factors, risk factors for symptoms and signs of the shoulder, elbow, or hand/wrist?: A review of the epidemiological literature. American Journal of Industrial Medicine, 41(5), 315–342. doi: 10.1002/ajim.10050.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Career Nursing Assistants. National Network of Career Nursing Assistants. (2009–2014). Retrieved February 22, 2014, from http://cna-network.org/career-nursing-assistance/.
- Colombo, F., Llena-Nozal, A, Mercier, J, Tjadens F. (2011). Help wanted? Providing and paying for long-term care.Google Scholar
- Daly, T., Szebehely, M. (2012). International Journal of Social Welfare, 21 (Unheard voices, unmapped terrain: Care work in long-term residential care for older people in Canada and Sweden), 139–148.Google Scholar
- Day, S. (2014) Making it work: A study of the decision-making processes of personal care workers in long-term residential care. Doctoral dissertation. Available at: http://yorkspace.library.yorku.ca/xmlui/handle/10315/29922
- Karasek, R., & Theorell, T. (1992). Healthy work: Stress, productivity and the reconstruction of working life. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
- Kokkonen, K. (2013). A Literature Review of Care Home Managers Wellbeing in Designing Wellbeing in Elderly Care Homes (S. R. a. S. V. Anneli Hujala Ed.): Aalto University Press.Google Scholar
- Laxer, K.; Jacobsen, FF.; Lloyd, L; Goldmann, M; Day, S; Choiniere, JA. & Rosenau, PV. (2015). Comparing nursing home assistive personnel in five countries. Ageing International, online publ. doi: 10.1007/s12126-015-9226-2.
- Liu, L. F., Liu, W. P., & Wang, J. Y. (2011). Work autonomy of certified nursing assistants in long-term care facilities: Discrepant perceptions between nursing supervisors and certified nursing assistants. Journal of the American Medical Directors Association, 12(7), 524–534. doi: 10.1016/j.jamda.2010.05.006.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Lohmann-Haislah, A. (2012). Stress report Germany 2012. Bundesanstalt für Arbeitsschutz und Arbeitsmedizin Dortmund.Google Scholar
- MOHLTC (2005) The Ontario Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care. The regulation of personal support workers the Minister’s question on February 7, 2005 the Honourable George Smitherman, Minister of Health and Long-Term Care.http://www.health.gov.on.ca/en/common/ministry/publications/reports/personal_support_workers/personal_support_workers.pdf.
- National Health Service (2013) , Retrieved 5 Nov. 2013, NHS Careers in Detail: Healthcare assistants/auxiliary nurses, http://www.nhscareers.nhs.uk/explore-by-career/wider-healthcare-team/careers-in-the-wider-healthcare-team/clinical-support-staff/healthcare-assistant/.
- Stagnitti, K., Schoo, A., Dunbar, J., & Reid, C. (2006). An exploration of issues of management and intention to stay: Allied health professionals in South West Victoria, Australia. Journal of Allied Health, 35(4), 226–232.Google Scholar
- Szebehely, M. (2006). Omsorgsvardag under skiftande organisatoriska villkor – en jämörande studie av den nordiska hemtjänesten. Tidsskrift for arbejdsliv, 8(1), 49–66.Google Scholar
- The Norwegian Directorate of Health (NDH) (2004). Hvordan holde orden i eget hus. Internkontroll i sosial- og helsetjenesten. Oslo: NDH.Google Scholar
- WHO (World Health Organization). (2010). Classifying health workers: Mapping occupations to the international standard classification. Geneva: WHO.Google Scholar