Journal of Labor Research

, Volume 19, Issue 3, pp 445–469 | Cite as

The determinants and effects of right-to-work laws: A review of the recent literature

  • William J. Moore
Symposium Fifty Years of Right to Work: Retrospect and Prospect

Abstract

I review the recent literature on the determinants and effects of right-to-work (RTW) laws. The focus is primarily on the econometric studies published since the early 1980s. Five major areas of impact are assessed: unionization, free riding, union organizing activities and successes in NLRB elections, wage structure, and state industrial development. While individual findings are quite sensitive to model specification, the accumulated evidence indicates that RTW laws have at least a significant short-run impact on all of these areas except perhaps wages.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Ahlburg, Dennis A. and James B. Dworkin. “The Influence of Macroeconomic Variables on the Probability of Union Decertification.” Journal of Labor Research 5 (Winter 1984): 13–28.Google Scholar
  2. Anderson, John C., Gloria Busman, and Charles A. O'Reilly III. “Union Decertification in the U.S.: 1947–1977.” Industrial Relations 19 (Winter 1980): 100–107.Google Scholar
  3. Becker, Brian E. and Richard U. Miller. “Patterns and Determinants of Union Growth in the Hospital Industry.” Journal of Labor Research 2 (Fall 1981): 309–28.Google Scholar
  4. Becker, Edmund R. and John Thomas Delaney. “South/Non-South Differentials in National Labor Relations Board Certification Election Outcomes: Comment.” Journal of Labor Research 4 (Fall 1983): 375–84.Google Scholar
  5. Bennett, James T. and Manuel H. Johnson. “The Impact of Right-to-Work Laws on the Economic Behavior of Local Unions: A Property Rights Perspective.” Journal of Labor Research 1 (Spring 1980): 1–27.Google Scholar
  6. Block, Richard N. “Union Organizing and the Allocation of Union Resources.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 34 (October 1980): 101–13.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. — and Steven L. Premack. “The Unionization Process: A Review of the Literature.” Advances in Industrial and Labor Relations 1 (1983): 31–70.Google Scholar
  8. — and Myron Roomkin. “A Preliminary Analysis of the Participation Rate and the Margin of Victory in NLRB Elections.” Proceedings of the Thirty-Fourth Winter Meeting. Madison, Wisc.: Industrial Relations Research Association, 1981: pp. 220–226.Google Scholar
  9. Booth, Alison L. “The Free Rider Problem and a Social Custom Model of Trade Union Membership.” Quarterly Journal of Economics 100 (February 1985): 253–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Calzonetti, F.J. and Robert T. Walker. “Factors Affecting Industrial Location Decisions: A Survey Approach.” In Industry Location and Public Policy. Edited by Henry W. Herzog, Jr. and Alan M. Schlottman. Knoxville: University of Tennessee Press, 1991: pp. 221–240.Google Scholar
  11. Cappelli, Peter and John Chalykoff. “The Effects of Management Industrial Relations Strategy: Results of a Recent Survey.” Proceedings of the Thirty-Eighth Annual Meeting. Madison, Wisc.: Industrial Relations Research Association, 1985: pp. 171–180.Google Scholar
  12. Carlton, Dennis W. “The Location and Employment Choices of New Firms: An Econometric Model with Discrete and Continuous Endogenous Variables.” Review of Economics and Statistics 65 (August 1983): 440–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. — “Why New Firms Locate Where They Do: An Econometric Model.” In Interregional Movements and Regional Growth. Edited by W. Wheaton. Washington, D.C.: Urban Institute, 1979: pp. 13–50.Google Scholar
  14. Carroll, Thomas M. “Right to Work Laws Do Matter.” Southern Economic Journal 50 (October 1993): 494–509.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Cobb, James C. The Selling of the South. Baton Rouge, La.: Louisiana State University Press, 1982.Google Scholar
  16. Cooke, William N. “Determinants of the Outcomes of Union Certification Elections.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 36 (April 1983): 402–14.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Coughlin, Cletus C., Joseph V. Terza, and Vachira Arromdee. “State Characteristics and the Location of Foreign Direct Investment within the United States.” Review of Economics and Statistics 73 (November 1991): 675–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Davis, Joe C. and John H. Huston. “Right-to-Work Laws and Free Riding.” Economic Inquiry 31 (January 1993): 52–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. — “Right-to-Work Laws and Union Density: New Evidence from Micro Data.” Journal of Labor Research 16 (Spring 1995): 223–29.Google Scholar
  20. Delaney, John Thomas. “Union Success in Hospital Representation Elections.” Industrial Relations 20 (Spring 1981): 149–61.Google Scholar
  21. Dickens, William T. and Jonathan S. Leonard. “Accounting for the Decline in Union Membership, 1950–1980.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 38 (April 1985): 323–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. —, Douglas R. Wholey, and James C. Robinson. “Correlates of Union Support in NLRB Elections.” Industrial Relations 26 (Fall 1987): 240–52.Google Scholar
  23. Elliott, Ralph D. and James R. Huffman. “The Impact of Right-to-Work Laws on Employer Unfair Labor Practice Charges.” Journal of Labor Research 5 (Spring 1994): 165–76.Google Scholar
  24. Ellwood, David T. and Glenn Fine. “The Impact of Right-to-Work Laws on Union Organizing.” Journal of Political Economy 95 (April 1987): 250–73.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Fantus Company. “A Study of the Business Climate of the States.” Prepared for the Illinois Manufacturers Association. Chicago, November 1975.Google Scholar
  26. Farber, Henry S. “The Extent of Unionization in the United States.” In Challenges and Choices Facing American Unions. Edited by Thomas Kochan. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 1985: 15–43.Google Scholar
  27. — “Right-to-Work Laws and the Extent of Unionism.” Journal of Labor Economics 2 (July 1984): 319–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Fiorito, Jack. “Research on Unions: Agenda for the 1990s.” Proceedings of the Forty-Third Annual Meet-ing. Madison, Wisc.: Industrial Relations Research Association, 1990: pp. 284–286.Google Scholar
  29. — and Charles R. Greer. “Determinants of U.S. Unionism: Past Research and Future Needs.” Industrial Relations 21 (Winter 1982): 1–21.Google Scholar
  30. Florkowski, Gary and Michael Schuster. “Predicting the Decisions to Vote and Support Unions in Certification Elections: An Integrated Perspective.” Journal of Labor Research 8 (Spring 1987): 191–207.Google Scholar
  31. Freeman, Richard B. “Contraction and Expansion: The Divergence of Private Sector and Public Sector Unionism in the United States.” Journal of Economic Perspectives 2 (Spring 1988): 63–88.Google Scholar
  32. — “Why Are Unions Faring Poorly in NLRB Representation Elections?” In Challenges and Choices Facing American Unions. Edited by Thomas Kochan. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 1985, pp. 45–64.Google Scholar
  33. Fulmer, William E. “When Employees Want To Oust Their Union.” Harvard Business Review 56 (March/April 1978): 163–70.Google Scholar
  34. Garofalo, Gasper A. and Desinder M. Malhotra. “An Integrated Model of the Economic Effects of Rightto-Work Laws.” Journal of Labor Research 13 (Summer 1992): 293–305.Google Scholar
  35. Hirsch, Barry T. “The Determinants of Unionization: An Analysis of Interarea Differences.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 33 (January 1980): 147–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Holmes, Thomas J. The Effects of State Policies on the Location of Industry; Evidence From State Borders. Minneapolis: Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, Research Department Staff Report 205, December 1995.Google Scholar
  37. Hundley, Greg. “Collective Bargaining Coverage of Union Members and Nonmembers in the Public Sector.” Industrial Relations 32 (Winter 1993): 72–93.Google Scholar
  38. — “Who Joins Unions in the Public Sector? The Effects of Individual Characteristics and the Law.” Journal of Labor Research 9 (Fall 1988): 301–23.Google Scholar
  39. Hunt, Janet C. and Rudolph A. White. “The Effects of Management Practices on Union Election Returns.” Journal of Labor Research 6 (Fall 1985): 389–403.Google Scholar
  40. — “The Effects of Right-to-Work Legislation on Union Outcomes: Additional Evidence.” Journal of Labor Research 4 (Winter 1983): 47–63.Google Scholar
  41. Hyclak, Thomas. “Union-Nonunion Wage Changes and Voting Trends in Union Representation Elections.” Proceedings of the Thirty-Fourth Winter Meeting. Madison, Wisc.: Industrial Relations Research Association, 1981, pp. 344–50.Google Scholar
  42. Ichniowski, Casey and Jeffrey S. Zax. “Right-to-Work Laws, Free Riders, and Unionization in the Local Public Sector.” Journal of Labor Economics 9 (January 1991): 255–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Jermier, John M., Cynthia Fryer Cohen, and Jeannie Gaines. “Paying Dues to the Union: A Study of Blue-Collar Workers in a Right-to-Work Environment.” Journal of Labor Research 9 (Spring 1988): 167–81.Google Scholar
  44. —, Cynthia Fryer Cohen, Kathleen J. Powers, and Jeannie Gaines. “Paying Dues: Police Unionism in a ‘Right-to-Work’ Environment.” Industrial Relations 25 (Fall 1986): 265–75.Google Scholar
  45. Jones, Ethel. “Union/Nonunion Differentials: Membership or Coverage.” Journal of Human Resources 17 (1982): 276–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Katz, Lawrence. “Union Status Determination and the Free-Rider Problem in Right-to-Work States.” Working Paper OBIR-7, University of California at Berkeley, 1985.Google Scholar
  47. Kochan, Thomas A., Robert B. McKersie, and John Chalykoff. “The Effects of Corporate Strategy and Workplace Innovation on Union Representation.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 39 (July 1986): 487–501.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Koeller, C. Timothy. “Determinants of Decertification Activity: An Interstate Analysis.” Industrial Relations 29 (Fall 1990): 491–500.Google Scholar
  49. — “Employer Unfair Labor Practices and Union Organizing Activity. A Simultaneous Equation Model.” Journal of Labor Research 13 (Spring 1992): 173–87.Google Scholar
  50. — “Union Activity and the Decline in American Trade Union Membership.” Journal of Labor Research 15 (Winter 1994): 19–32.Google Scholar
  51. — “Wages, Trade Union Activity, and the Political Environment of Unionism: A Simultaneous Equation Model.” Journal of Labor Research 6 (Spring 1985): 147–65.Google Scholar
  52. Krislov, Joseph. “Union Decertification.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 9 (July 1956): 589–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Lazear, Edward P. “A Competitive Theory of Monopoly Unionism.” American Economic Review 83 (September 1983): 631–43.Google Scholar
  54. — “Symposium on Public and Private Unionization.” Journal of Economic Perspectives 2 (Spring 1988): 59–62.Google Scholar
  55. Lumsden, Keith and Craig Peterson. “The Effect of Right-to-Work Laws on Unionization in the United States.” Journal of Political Economy 83 (December 1975): 1237–48.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Maranto, Cheryl L. and Jack Fiorito. “The Effect of Union Characteristics on the Outcome of NLRB Certification Elections.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 40 (January 1987): 225–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Meyer, David and Trevor Bain. “Union Decertification Election Outcomes: Bargaining Unit Characteristics and Union Resources.” Journal of Labor Research 15 (Spring 1994): 117–36.Google Scholar
  58. Moore, William J. “Membership and Wage Impact of Right-to-Work Laws.” Journal of Labor Research 1 (Fall 1980): 349–68.Google Scholar
  59. —, and Robert J. Newman. “A Cross-Section Analysis of the Postwar Decline in American Trade Union Membership.” Journal of Labor Research 9 (Spring 1988): 111–25.Google Scholar
  60. — “On the Prospects for American Trade Union Growth: A Cross-Section Analysis.” Review of Economics and Statistics 57 (November 1975): 435–5.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. — “The Effects of Right-To-Work Laws: A Review of the Literature.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 38 (July 1985): 571–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. — and R. William Thomas. “Determinants of the Passage of Right-To-Work Laws: An Alternative Explanation.” Journal of Law and Economics 17 (April 1974): 197–211.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Moore, William J., James A. Dunlevy, and Robert J. Newman. “Do Right to Work Laws Matters? Comment.” Southern Economic Journal 53 (October 1986): 515–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Naylor, Robin. “Strikes, Free Riders, and Social Customs.” Quarterly Journal of Economics 104 (November 1989): 771–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Newman, Robert J. “Industry Migration and Growth in the South.” Review of Economics and Statistics 65 (February 1983): 76–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Growth in the American South. New York: New York University Press, 1984.Google Scholar
  67. Nieswiadomy, Michael, Daniel J. Slottje, and Kathy Hayes. “The Impact of Unionization, Right-to-Work Laws, and Female Labor Force Participation on Earnings Inequality across States.” Journal of Labor Research 12 (Spring 1991): 185–95.Google Scholar
  68. Oaxaca, Ronald. “Male-Female Wage Differentials in Urban Labor Markets.” International Economic Review 14 (October 1973): 693–709.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Olsen, Randell. “Comment on the Effect of Unions on Earnings and Earnings on Unions: A Mixed Logit Approach.” International Economic Review 19 (1): 259–61.Google Scholar
  70. Palomba, Neil A. and Catherine Palomba. “Right-To-Work Laws: A Suggested Economic Rational.” Journal of Law and Economics 14 (October 1971): 475–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  71. Pearce, Thomas G. and Richard B. Peterson. “Regionally in NLRB Decertification Cases.” Journal of Labor Research 8 (Summer 1987): 253–69.Google Scholar
  72. Peterson, Richard B., Thomas W. Lee, and Barbara Finnegan. “Strategies and Tactics in Union Organizing Campaigns.” Industrial Relations 31 (Spring 1992): 370–81.Google Scholar
  73. Plaut, Thomas R. and Joseph E. Pluta. “Business Climate, Taxes and Expenditures, and State Industrial Growth in the United States.” Southern Economic Journal 50 (July 1983): 99–119.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Reder, Melvin W. “The Rise and Fall of Unions: The Public Sector and the Private.” Journal of Economic Perspectives 2 (Spring 1988): 89–110.Google Scholar
  75. Reed, Thomas F. “Do Union Organizers Matter? Individual Differences, Campaign Practices, and Representation Election Outcomes.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 43 (October 1989): 103–19.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  76. Reid, Joseph D. Jr. and Roger L. Faith. “Right-to-Work and Union Compensation Structure.” Journal of Labor Research 8 (Spring 1987): 111–30.Google Scholar
  77. Rose, Joseph and Gary N. Chaison. “New Measures of Union Organizing Effectiveness.” Industrial Relations 29 (Fall 1990): 457–68.Google Scholar
  78. Schmenner, Roger W. Making Business Location Decisions. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice Hall, 1982.Google Scholar
  79. —, Joel C. Huber, and Randall L. Cook. “Geographic Differences and the Location of New Manufacturing Facilities.” Journal of Urban Economics 21 (1987): 83–104.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  80. Scott, Clyde, Anson Seers, and Robert Culpepper. “Determinants of Union Election Outcomes in the Non-hospital Health Care Industry.” Journal of Labor Research 17 (Fall 1996): 701–715.Google Scholar
  81. Scott, Clyde and Jim Simpson. “An Empirical Analysis of Union Election Outcomes in the Elective Utility Industry.” Journal of Labor Research 14 (Summer 1993): 355–65.Google Scholar
  82. Seeber, Ronald L. and William N. Cooke. “The Decline in Union Success in NLRB Representation Elections.” Industrial Relations 22 (Winter 1983): 34–44.Google Scholar
  83. Sobel, Russell S. “Empirical Evidence on the Union Free-Rider Problem: Do Right-to-Work Laws Matter?” Journal of Labor Research 16 (Summer 1995): 347–65.Google Scholar
  84. Soffer, Benson and Michael Korenich. “‘Right To Work’ Laws As a Location Factor: The Industrialization Experience of Agricultural States.” Journal of Regional Science 3 (1961): 41–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  85. Stephan, Paula E. and Bruce E. Kaufman. “Factors Leading to a Decline in Union Win Rates: 1973–1981.” Proceedings of the Thirty-Ninth Winter Meeting. Madison, Wisc.: Industrial Relations Research Association, 1986, pp. 296–305.Google Scholar
  86. Stepina, Lee P. and Jack Fiorito. “Toward a Comprehensive Theory of Union Growth and Decline.” Industrial Relations 25 (Fall 1986): 248–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  87. Tollefson, John O. and Joseph A. Pichler. “A Comment On Right-To-Work Laws: A Suggested Economic Rationale.” Journal of Law and Economics 17 (April 1974): 193–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  88. Voos, Paula B. “Trends in Union Organizing Expenditures, 1953–1977.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 38 (October 1984): 52–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  89. Warren, Ronald S. and Robert P. Strauss. “A Mixed Logit Model of the Relationship between Unionization and Right-To-Work Legislation.” Journal of Political Economy 87 (June 1979): 648–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  90. Wessels, Walter J. “Economic Effects of Right to Work Laws.” Journal of Labor Research 2 (Spring 1981): 55–75.Google Scholar
  91. Woodward, Douglas P. and Norman J. Glickman. “Regional and Local Determinants of Foreign Firm Location in the United States.” In Industry Location and Public Policy. Edited by Henry W. Herzog, Jr., and Alan M. Schlottmann. Knoxville: University of Tennessee Press, 1991, pp. 190–217.Google Scholar
  92. Zax, Jeffrey S. and Casey Ichniowski. “Bargaining Laws and Unionization in the Local Public Sector.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 43 (April 1990): 447–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  93. — “Excludability and the Effects of Free Riders: Right-To-Work Laws and Local Public Sector Unionization.” Public Finance Quarterly 19 (July 1991): 293–315.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer 1998

Authors and Affiliations

  • William J. Moore
    • 1
  1. 1.Louisiana State UniversityBaton Rouge

Personalised recommendations