Journal of Labor Research

, Volume 25, Issue 2, pp 233–266 | Cite as

Reconsidering union wage effects: Surveying new evidence on an old topic

  • Barry T. Hirsch


I examine evidence on private sector union wage gaps in the United States. The consensus opinion among labor economists of an average union premium of roughly 15 percent is called into question. Two forms of measurement error bias downward standard wage gap estimates. Match bias results from Census earnings imputation procedures that do not include union status as a match criterion. Downward bias is roughly equal to the proportion of workers with imputed earnings, currently about 30 percent. Misclassification of union status causes additional attenuation in union gap measures. This bias has worsened as private sector density has declined, since an increasing proportion of workers designated as union are instead nonunion workers. Corrections for misclassification and match bias lead to estimated union gaps substantially higher than standard estimates, but with less of a downward trend since the mid 1980s. Private sector union gaps corrected for these biases are estimated from the CPS for 1973–2001. The uncorrected estimate for 2001 is .13 log points. Correction for match bias increases the gap to .18 log points; further correction for misclassification bias, based on an assumed 2 percent error rate, increases the gap to .24. Reexamination of the skill-upgrading hypothesis leads to the conclusion that higher union gap estimates are plausible. The conventional wisdom of a 15 percent union wage premium warrants reexamination.


Union Density Misclassification Rate Union Wage Nonunion Worker Nonunion Wage 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Abowd, John M. and Changhui Kang. “Simultaneous Determination of Wage Rates and Tenure.” Cornell University, March 2001.Google Scholar
  2. Abowd, John M. and Henry S. Farber. “Job Queues and the Union Status of Workers.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 35 (April 1982): 354–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Addison, John T. and Barry T. Hirsch. “Union Effects on Productivity, Profits, and Growth: Has the Long Run Arrived?” Journal of Labor Economics 7 (January 1989): 72–105.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Angrist, Joshua D. and Alan B. Krueger. “Empirical Strategies in Labor Economics.” In O. Ashenfelter and D. Card, eds. Handbook of Labor Economics, Vol. 3A. Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1999, pp. 1277–366.Google Scholar
  5. —. “Instrumental Variables and the Search for Identification: From Supply and Demand to Natural Experiments.” Journal of Economic Perspectives 15 (Fall 2001): 69–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Blanchflower, David G. “Changes Over Time in Union Relative Wage Effects in Great Britain and the United States.” In S. Daniel, P. Arestis and J. Grahl, eds. The History and Practice of Economics. Essays in Honor of Bernard Corry and Maurice Peston, Vol. 2. Northampton, Mass.: Edward Elgar, 1999, pp. 3–32.Google Scholar
  7. -. and Alex Bryson. “Changes Over Time in Union Relative Wage Effects in the UK and the US Revisited.” NBER Working Paper #9395, December 2002.Google Scholar
  8. Blanchflower, David G. and Richard B. Freeman. “Unionism in the United States and Other Advanced OECD Countries.” In M. Bognanno and M. Kleiner, eds. Labor Market Institutions and the Future Role of Unions. Cambridge, Mass.: Blackwell Publishers, 1992, pp. 56–79.Google Scholar
  9. Bloch, Farrell E. and Mark S. Kuskin. “Wage Determination in the Union and Nonunion Sectors.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 31 (January 1978): 183–92.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Bollinger, Christopher R. “Response Error and the Union Wage Differential.” Southern Economic Journal 68 (July 2001): 60–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Booth, Alison L. The Economics of the Trade Union. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995.Google Scholar
  12. -. and Mark L. Bryan. “The Union Membership Wage-Premium Puzzle: Is There a Free-Rider Problem?” Center for Economic Policy Research, Discussion Paper No. 2879, July 2001.Google Scholar
  13. Bratsberg, Bernt and James F. Ragan, Jr. “Changes in the Union Wage Premium by Industry.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 56 (October 2002): 65–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Brown, Charles and James Medoff. “The Employer Size-Wage Effect.” Journal of Political Economy 97 (October 1989): 1027–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Budd, John W. and In-Gang Na. “The Union Membership Wage Premium for Employees Covered by Collective Bargaining Agreements.” Journal of Labor Economics 18 (October 2000): 783–807.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Card, David. “The Effect of Unions on the Structure of Wages: A Longitudinal Analysis.” Econometrica 64 (July 1996): 957–79.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. -, Thomas Lemieux, and W. Craig Riddell. “Unionization and Wage Inequality: A Comparative Study of the U.S., the U.K., and Canada.” NBER Working Paper #9473, January 2003.Google Scholar
  18. Clark, Kim B. “Unionization and Firm Performance: The Impact on Profits, Growth, and Productivity.” American Economic Review 74 (December 1984): 893–919.Google Scholar
  19. Curme, Michael and David A. Macpherson. “Union Wage Differentials and the Effects of Industry and Local Union Density: Evidence from the 1980s.” Journal of Labor Research 12 (Fall 1991): 419–27.Google Scholar
  20. Duncan, Greg J. and Frank P. Stafford. “Do Union Members Receive Compensating Wage Differentials?“ American Economic Review 70 (June 1980): 355–71.Google Scholar
  21. Duncan, Gregory M. and Duane E. Leigh. “Wage Determination in the Union and Nonunion Sectors: A Sample Selectivity Approach.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 34 (October 1980): 24–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Farber, Henry S. “The Determination of the Union Status of Workers.” Econometrica 51 (September 1983): 1417–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. —. “The Analysis of Union Behavior.” In O. Ashenfelter and R. Layard, eds. Handbook of Labor Economics, Vol. II. Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1986, pp. 1039–89.Google Scholar
  24. —. “Mobility and Stability: The Dynamics of Job Change in Labor Markets.” In O. Ashenfelter and D. Card, eds. Handbook of Labor Economics, Vol. 3B. Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1999, pp. 2439–83.Google Scholar
  25. — and Bruce Western. “Accounting for the Decline of Unions in the Private Sector, 1973–1988.” In James T. Bennett and Bruce E. Kaufman, eds. The Future of Private Sector Unionism in the United States. Armonk, N.Y.: M.E. Sharpe, 2002, pp. 28–58.Google Scholar
  26. Freeman, Richard B. “The Exit-Voice Tradeoff in the Labor Market: Unionism, Job Tenure, Quits and Separations.” Quarterly Journal of Economics 94 (June 1980): 643–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. —. “Unionism and the Dispersion of Wages.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 34 (October 1980): 3–23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. —. “The Effect of Unionism on Fringe Benefits.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 34 (July 1981):489–509.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. —. “Union Wage Practices and Wage Dispersion within Establishments.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 36 (October 1982): 3–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. —. “Longitudinal Analyses of the Effects of Trade Unions.” Journal of Labor Economics 2 (January 1984): 1–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. —. “In Search of Union Wage Concessions in Standard Data Sets.” Industrial Relations 25 (Spring 1986): 131–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. — and James L. Medoff. “The Impact of the Percent Organized on Union and Nonunion Wages.” Review of Economics and Statistics 63 (November 1981): 561–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. —. What Do Unions Do? New York: Basic Books, 1984.Google Scholar
  34. Fuchs, Victor R., Alan B. Krueger, and James M. Poterba. “Economists' Views about Parameters, Values, and Policies: Survey Results in Labor and Public Economics.” Journal of Economic Literature 36 (September 1998): 1387–425.Google Scholar
  35. Giles, D.E.A. “The Interpretation of Dummy Variables in Semilogarithmic Equations: Unbiased Estimation.” Economics Letters 10 (1982): 77–79.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Grant, Darren. “A Comparison of the Cyclical Behavior of Union and Nonunion Wages in the United States.” Journal of Human Resources 36 (Winter 2001): 31–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Heckman, James J. and Solomon W. Polachek. “Empirical Evidence on the Functional Form of the Earnings-Schooling Relationship.” Journal of the American Statistical Association 69 (June 1974): 350–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Hirsch, Barry T. “The Interindustry Structure of Unionism, Earnings, and Earnings Dispersion.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 36 (October 1982): 22–39.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. —. Labor Unions and the Economic Performance of U.S. Firms. Kalamazoo, Mich.: Upjohn Institute for Employment Research, 1991.Google Scholar
  40. — and John T. Addison. The Economic Analysis of Unions: New Approaches and Evidence. Boston: Allen & Unwin, 1986.Google Scholar
  41. Hirsch, Barry T. and Mark C. Berger. “Union Membership Determination and Industry Characteristics.” Southern Economic Journal 50 (January 1984): 665–79.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Hirsch, Barry T. and David A. Macpherson. “Union Membership and Coverage Database from the Current Population Survey: Note.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 56 (January 2003): 349–54, and accompanying data site l Scholar
  43. Hirsch, Barry T., David A. Macpherson, and J. Michael DuMond. “Workers' Compensation Recipiency in Union and Nonunion Workplaces.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 50 (January 1997): 213–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Hirsch, Barry T., David A. Macpherson, and Edward J. Schumacher. “Measuring Union and Nonunion Wage Growth: Puzzles in Search of Solutions.” In P. Wunnava, ed. The Changing Role of Unions: New Forms of Representation. Armonk, N.Y.: M.E. Sharpe, 2004.Google Scholar
  45. Hirsch, Barry T. and Edward J. Schumacher. “Match Bias in Wage Gap Estimates Due to Earnings Imputation.” Journal of Labor Economics 22 (July 2004).Google Scholar
  46. —. “Unions, Wages, and Skills.” Journal of Human Resources 33 (Winter 1998): 201–19.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Hirsch, Barry T., Michael L. Wachter, and James W. Gillula. “Postal Service Compensation and the Comparability Standard.” Research in Labor Economics 18 (1999): 243–79.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Hwang, Hae-shin, W. Robert Reed, and Carlton Hubbard. “Compensating Wage Differentials and Unobserved Productivity.” Journal of Political Economy 100 (August 1992): 835–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Jarrell, Stephen B. and T.D. Stanley. “A Meta-Analysis of the Union-Nonunion Wage Gap.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 44 (October 1990): 54–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Jones, Ethel B. “Union/Nonunion Wage Differentials: Membership or Coverage?” Journal of Human Resources 17 (Spring 1982): 276–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Kalachek, Edward and Frederic Raines. “Trade Unions and Hiring Standards.” Journal of Labor Research 1 (Spring 1980): 63–75.Google Scholar
  52. Lazear, Edward P. “A Competitive Theory of Monopoly Unionism.” American Economic Review 73 (September 1983): 631–43.Google Scholar
  53. Lee, Lung-Fei. “Unionism and Wage Rates: A Simultaneous Equations Model with Qualitative and Limited Dependent Variables.” International Economic Review 19 (June 1978): 415–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Lemieux, Thomas. “Estimating the Effects of Unions on Wage Inequality in a Panel Data Model with Comparative Advantage and Non-Random Selection.” Journal of Labor Economics 16 (June 1978): 261–91.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Lettau, Michael K., Mark A. Loewenstein, and Aaron T. Cushner. “Explaining the Differential Growth Rates of the ECI and the ECEC.” Compensation and Working Conditions 2 (Summer 1997): 15–23.Google Scholar
  56. Lewis, H. Gregg. Unionism and Relative Wages in the United States: An Empirical Inquiry. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1963.Google Scholar
  57. —. Union Relative Wage Effects: A Survey. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1986.Google Scholar
  58. Macpherson, David A. “Trade Unions and Labor's Share in U.S. Manufacturing Industries.” International Journal of Industrial Organization 8 (March 1990): 143–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Mellow, Wesley. “Unionism and Wages: A Longitudinal Analysis.” Review of Economics and Statistics 63 (February 1981): 43–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. — and Hal Sider. “Accuracy of Response in Labor Market Surveys: Evidence and Implications.” Journal of Labor Economics 1 (October 1983): 331–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Mincer, Jacob. Schooling, Experience, and Earnings. New York: Columbia University Press, 1974.Google Scholar
  62. —. “Union Effects: Wages, Turnover, and Job Training.” In J.D. Reid, Jr., ed. New Approaches to Labor Unions. Greenwich, Conn.: JAI Press, 1983, pp. 217–52.Google Scholar
  63. Oi, Walter Y. and Todd L. Idson. “Firm Size and Wages.” In O. Ashenfelter and D. Card, eds. Handbook of Labor Economics, Vol. 3B. Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1999, pp. 2165–214.Google Scholar
  64. Pencavel, John H. “The Demand for Union Services: An Exercise.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 24 (January 1971): 180–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Robinson, Chris. “The Joint Determination of Union Status and Union Wage Effects: Some Tests of Alternative Models.” Journal of Political Economy 97 (June 1989): 639–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Rosen, Sherwin. “The Theory of Equalizing Differentials.” In O. C. Ashenfelter and R. Layard, eds. Handbook of Labor Economics, Vol. 1. Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1986, pp. 641–92.Google Scholar
  67. Schumacher, Edward J. “What Explains Wage Differences between Union Members and Covered Non-members?” Southern Economic Journal 65 (January 1999): 493–512.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Viscusi, W. Kip and Joseph E. Aldy. “The Value of a Statistical Life: A Critical Review of Market Estimates Throughout the World.” NBER Working Paper #9487, February 2003.Google Scholar
  69. Wessels, Walter. “Do Unionized Firms Hire Better Workers?” Economic Inquiry 32 (October 1994): 616–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. Willis, Robert J. “Wage Determinants: A Survey and Reinterpretation of Human Capital Earnings Functions.” In O.C. Ashenfelter and R. Layard, eds. Handbook of Labor Economics, Vol. 1. Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1986, pp. 525–602.Google Scholar
  71. U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics. Employment Cost Index, Historical Listing. January 30, 2003. Available at Scholar
  72. U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics. Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, Historical Listing (Annual) 1986–2001. June 19, 2002. Available at Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer 2004

Authors and Affiliations

  • Barry T. Hirsch
    • 1
  1. 1.Trinity UniversitySan AntonioIZA Bonn

Personalised recommendations