Precluding Nonviolence, Propelling Violence: The Effect of Internal Fragmentation on Movement Protest

Article

Abstract

Scholars often overlook that an adequate explanation of why a movement uses violent means of protest requires an account of why it does not instead use nonviolent means. This essay argues that while paths to violence are multiple, there is one prevailing path to nonviolent protest—that which opens when a movement is politically cohesive. Cohesion approximates a necessary condition for nonviolent protest because such protest requires coordination and collective restraint. Conversely, fragmentation generates incentives and opportunities that increase the likelihood that protest will become violent. This argument, specified in terms of composite mechanisms and demonstrated by overtime variation in the Palestinian case, critiques the assumption that movements can be treated as unitary actors. It also shifts attention from movements’ motivations to their organizational configurations.

Keywords

Nonviolence Violence Social movements Palestinians Middle East Arab–Israeli conflict 

Notes

Acknowledgments

The author is thankful for feedback on this paper gained at the Northwestern University Comparative Historical Social Science Workshop, University of Chicago Comparative Politics Workshop, Harvard University Middle East Politics Workshop, and Northeast Middle East Politics Workshop, among other conferences. She is also grateful for funding support for the research and writing of this article, provided by the United States Institute of Peace, the Palestinian American Research Center, the Harvard University–Hebrew University Graduate Fellowship, and the Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs at the John F. Kennedy School of Government.

References

  1. Abdel Jawad S. The Intifada's military lessons. Palestine Report. 2000.Google Scholar
  2. Abdel Majeed W. Al-shamuliya al-ijtimaiya lil-intifada: qira’a awaliya [The social inclusivity of the Intifada: a first reading]. Shu’un Filistiniya. 1988;193:3–21.Google Scholar
  3. Abu Toameh K. New Fatah groups controlled by PLO dissident in Lebanon. Jerusalem Post: 2002.Google Scholar
  4. Abu Toameh K. Talking at Cross Purposes. Jerusalem Post: 2003.Google Scholar
  5. Abu-Amr Z. Islamic fundamentalism in the West Bank and Gaza: Muslim Brotherhood and Islamic jihad. Bloomington: Indiana University Press; 1994.Google Scholar
  6. Al-Haq. Punishing a Nation: human rights violations during the Palestinian uprising, December 1987–December 1988. Boston: South End Press; 1990.Google Scholar
  7. Allen L. There are many reasons why: suicide bombers and martyrs in Palestine. Middle East Report. 2002;223:34–7.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Al-Madhoun RK. Al-intifada al-filastiniya: al-haykal al-tanthimi wa-asalib al-amal [The Palestinian uprising: structure and activities]. Acre: Dar al-Aswar; 1989.Google Scholar
  9. Al-Masri H. Filastin amaam muftaraq turuq [Palestine at a crossroads]. Majallat al-Dirasat al-Fiastiniyah. 2002;51:46–52.Google Scholar
  10. Amnesty International. Broken lives: a year of Intifada. London: AI. 2001.Google Scholar
  11. Andoni G. A comparative study of Intifada 1987 and Intifada 2000. In: Carey R, editor. The new Intifada: resisting Israel’s apartheid. London: Verso Books; 2001. p. 209–18.Google Scholar
  12. Ashrawi H. This Side of Peace. New York: Touchstone; 1995.Google Scholar
  13. B’Tselem. Excessive Force: human rights violations during IDF Actions in Area A Jerusalem; 2001.Google Scholar
  14. Bennet J. Isolated and Angry, Gaza Battles Itself, Too. New York Times. July 16, 2004.Google Scholar
  15. Bishara A. Ma ba’ad al-ijtiyah: fi qadaya al-istratijiyah al-wataniyah al-filastiniyah [In the wake of the Israeli invasion: issues of Palestinian national strategy]. Ramallah, West Bank: MUWATIN; 2002.Google Scholar
  16. Bloom M. Palestinian suicide bombing: popular support, market share, and outbidding. Poli Sci Q. 2004;119:61–88.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Brom S. The withdrawal from Southern Lebanon: one year later. Assessment August: Strategic; 2001.Google Scholar
  18. Brooks D. The culture of martyrdom. The Atlantic June 2002.Google Scholar
  19. Brubaker R, Laitin D. Ethnic and nationalist violence. Ann Rev Sociol. 1998;24:423–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Brynen R. The neopatrimonial dimension of Palestinian politics. J Pal Stud. 1995;25:23–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Bucaille L. Growing up Palestinian: Israeli occupation and the Intifada generation, trans. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 2004.Google Scholar
  22. Center for Palestine Research and Studies, Public Opinion Polls, September 1993.Google Scholar
  23. Cox GW, Shepsle KA. Majority cycling and agenda manipulation: Richard McKelvey’s contributions and legacy. In: Aldrich J, Alt JE, Lupia A, editors. A positive change in political science: the legacy of Richard McKelvey’s most influential writings. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press; 2007.Google Scholar
  24. Crenshaw M. Theories of terrorism: instrumental and organizational approaches. In: Rapoport DC, editor. Inside terrorist organizations. New York: Columbia University Press; 1988. p. 13–31.Google Scholar
  25. Dajani SR. The Intifada. Amman: University of Jordan Center for Hebraic Studies; 1990.Google Scholar
  26. Davenport C. Introduction. Repression and Mobilization: Insights from Political Science and Sociology. In Davenport C, Johnston H, Mueller C, editors. Repression and Mobilization. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press; 2005; vii–xli.Google Scholar
  27. DeNardo J. Power in numbers: the political strategy of protest and rebellion. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 1985.Google Scholar
  28. Gagnon VP. Ethnic nationalism and international conflict: the case of Serbia. Intl Security: Winter 1994/1995;19:130–66.Google Scholar
  29. Gamson WA. Strategy of social protest. Homewood, IL: Dorsey; 1975.Google Scholar
  30. Gardner JW. On leadership. New York: Free Press; 1993.Google Scholar
  31. Hage G. ‘Comes a time we are all enthusiasm:’ understanding Palestinian suicide bombers in times of exighophobia. Public Culture. 2003;15:65–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Hammami R. NGOs: the professionalisation of politics. Race and class. 1995;37:51–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Hardin R. One for all: the logic of group conflict. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 1995.Google Scholar
  34. Heacock R. From the Mediterranean to the Gulag and back again: the Palestinian Intifada and the Gulf War. Arab Stud Q. 1991;13:65–82.Google Scholar
  35. Hewitt JJ, Wilkenfeld J, Gurr TR. Peace and conflict 2010. College Park: Center for International Development and Conflict Management; 2010.Google Scholar
  36. Hilal J. Al-nizam al-siyasi al-filastini ba’ad Oslo: dirasah tahliliyah naqdiyah [The Palestinian political order after Oslo: a critical analytical study]. Ramallah: MUWATIN; 1998.Google Scholar
  37. Hilal J. Al-harakah al-wataniyah al-filitstiniyah amam su’al sa’ab. [The Palestinian national movement confronts difficult questions], Majallat al-dirasat al-fiastiniyah 2003;56:15–26.Google Scholar
  38. Hiltermann J. Behind the Intifada: labor and women’s movements in the Occupied Territories. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 1991.Google Scholar
  39. Hiltermann J. The Enemy inside the Intifada. Nation, September 10, 1990;229–234.Google Scholar
  40. Horowitz DL. Ethnic groups in conflict. Berkeley: University of California Press; 2000.Google Scholar
  41. Hroub K. Hamas: political thought and practice. Washington, DC: Institute of Palestine Studies; 2000.Google Scholar
  42. Human Rights Watch. Erased in a moment: suicide bombing attacks against Israeli civilians. New York; 2002.Google Scholar
  43. Hunter FR. The Palestinian uprising: a war by other means. London: I.B. Tauris; 1991.Google Scholar
  44. Huntington SP. Political order in changing societies. New Haven and London: Yale University Press; 1968.Google Scholar
  45. International Crisis Group. Who governs the West Bank? Palestinian administration under Israeli occupation. Middle East Report 2004:32.Google Scholar
  46. International Crisis Group. Iraq’s Muqtada al-Sadr: spoiler or stabiliser? Middle East Report: 2006:55.Google Scholar
  47. Israel Defense Forces Spokesman’s Unit. Incidents in Judea, Samaria and the Gaza District since the beginning of the uprising. Jerusalem; December, 1992.Google Scholar
  48. Jamal A. Barriers to democracy: the other side of social capital in Palestine and the Arab world. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 2007.Google Scholar
  49. Jarbawi A. Al-intifadah wa-al-qiyadat al-siyasiyah fi al-diffah al-harbiyah wa-qita’a gazzah: bahth fi al-nukbah al-siyasiyah [The Intifada and Political Leadership in the West Bank and Gaza Strip: A study in political elites]. Beirut: Dar al-Taliyah; 1989.Google Scholar
  50. Jarbawi A. Li-kay natathatta al-azmah: nahwa khuttah istratijiyah jadidah lil-amal al-Filastini [Overcoming the crisis: towards a new Palestinian strategy]. Birzeit: Brizeit University; 2001a.Google Scholar
  51. Jarbawi A. Critical reflections on one year of the Intifada. Between the Lines: 2001b.Google Scholar
  52. Jarbawi A, Pearlman W. Struggle in a post-charisma transition: rethinking Palestinian politics after Arafat. J Palest Stud. 2007;36:6–21.Google Scholar
  53. Jerusalem Media and Communication Center [JMCC]. The stone and the olive branch: four years of the Intifada: from Jabalia to Madrid. Jerusalem: JMCC; 1991.Google Scholar
  54. JMCC. Public Opinion Polls, June 2001 to October 2003, http://www.jmcc.org/polls.aspx.
  55. JMCC. Public Opinion Poll No. 51, June 2004, http://www.jmcc.org/polls.aspx.
  56. Kalyvas S. The ontology of ‘political violence’: action and identity in civil wars. Perspectives on Politics. 2003;1:475–94.Google Scholar
  57. Khalidi R. The Palestinian people: twenty-two years after 1967. In: Lockman Z, Beinin J, editors. Intifada: the Palestinian uprising against Israeli occupation. Washington, DC: Middle East Research and Information Project; 1989. p. 113–26.Google Scholar
  58. King ME. A quiet revolution: the first Palestinian Intifada and nonviolent resistance. New York: Nation Books; 2007.Google Scholar
  59. Kuttab D. The Palestinian uprising: the second phase, self-sufficiency. J Palest Stud. 1988a;17:36–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Kuttab D. A Profile of the Stonethrowers. J Palest Stud. 1988b;17:14–23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Kydd A, Walter BF. Sabotaging the peace: the politics of extremist violence. Int Organ. 2002;56:263–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Levitt M. Hizballah’s West Bank foothold. Washington Institute for Near East Policy Peacewatch 2003: 429.Google Scholar
  63. Lichbach M. Deterrence or escalation? The puzzle of aggregate studies of repression and dissent. J Confl Resolut. 1987;31:266–97.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. McAdam D. Culture and Social Movements. In: Crothers L, Lockhart C, editors. Culture and politics: a reader. New York: Macmillan; 2000. p. 253–68.Google Scholar
  65. McLauchlin T, Pearlman W. Out-group conflict, in-group unity? Exploring the effect of repression on movement fragmentation. J Con Res. 2012;56:40–66.Google Scholar
  66. Mishal S, Aharoni R. Speaking stones: communiqués from the Intifada underground. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press; 1994.Google Scholar
  67. Oberschal A. Social conflict and social movements. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall; 1973.Google Scholar
  68. Parker C. Resignation or revolt? Socio-political development and the challenges of peace in Palestine. London: I.B. Tauris; 1999.Google Scholar
  69. Parsons N. The politics of the Palestinian Authority: from Oslo to al-Aqsa. New York: Routledge; 2005.Google Scholar
  70. Pearlman W. Occupied voices: stories of everyday life from the second Intifada. Nation Books; 2003.Google Scholar
  71. Pearlman W. A composite-actor approach to conflict behavior. In: Lawrence A, Chenoweth E, editors. rethinking violence: states and non-state actors in conflict. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press; 2010. p. 197–219.Google Scholar
  72. Pearlman W. Violence, nonviolence, and the Palestinian national movement. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2011.Google Scholar
  73. Pinto C, Jardine M. East Timor’s unfinished struggle: inside the Timorese Resistance. Cambridge: South End Press; 1997.Google Scholar
  74. Pressman J. Visions in collision: what happened at Camp David and Taba? Int Secur. 2003;28:5–43.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. Program on International Policy Attitudes. The potential for a nonviolent Intifada: a study of Palestinian and Israeli Jewish public attitudes. 2002.Google Scholar
  76. Rabushka A, Shepsle K. Politics in Plural Societies. Columbus: Charles E. Merrill; 1972.Google Scholar
  77. Rigby A. Living the Intifada. London: Zed Books; 1991.Google Scholar
  78. Riker WH. Implications from the disequilibrium of majority rule for the study of institutions. Am Polit Sci Rev. 1980;74:432–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. Robinson GE. Building a Palestinian state: the incomplete revolution. Bloomington: Indiana University Press; 1997.Google Scholar
  80. Roy S. Gaza: new dynamics of civic disintegration. J Palest Stud. 1993;22:20–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  81. Sara F. Al-buniya al-ijtimaiya lil-intifada al-Filistiniya [The Intifada’s social structure]. Shu’un Filistiniya: 1988: 189.Google Scholar
  82. Sayigh Y. Armed struggle and the search for state: the Palestinian national movement, 1949–1993. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 1997.Google Scholar
  83. Sayigh Y. Arafat and the anatomy of a revolt. Survival. 2001;43:47–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  84. Schiff Z and Ya’ari E. Intifada: The Palestinian Uprising: Israel’s Third Front. New York: Touchstone; 1989.Google Scholar
  85. Sebag R. Lebanon: the Intifada’s false premise. The Middle East Quarterly 2002: 9.Google Scholar
  86. Shalev A. The Intifada: causes and effects. Tel Aviv: Jaffee Center; 1991.Google Scholar
  87. Sharp G. The politics of nonviolent action. Boston: Porter Sargent; 1973.Google Scholar
  88. Stedman SJ. Spoiler problems in peace processes. Int Secur. 1997;22:5–53.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  89. Stephan M. Nonviolent insurgency: the role of civilian-based resistance in the East Timorese, Palestinian, and Kosovo Albanian self-determination struggles. Tufts University: Unpublished Dissertation; 2005.Google Scholar
  90. Stork J. The significance of stones: notes from the seventh month. In: Lockman Z, Beinin J, editors. Intifada: the Palestinian uprising against Israeli occupation. Washington, DC: Middle East Research and Information Project; 1989. p. 67–79.Google Scholar
  91. Tessler M. A History of the Israeli–Palestinian Conflict. Bloomington: Indiana University Press; 1994.Google Scholar
  92. Tilly C. The politics of collective violence. New York: Cambridge University Press; 2003.Google Scholar
  93. Tilly C. Repression, mobilization, and explanation. In: Davenport C, Johnston H, Mueller C, editors. Repression and mobilization. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press; 2005. p. 211–26.Google Scholar
  94. U.S. Department of State. Country Reports on Human Rights Practices for 1988, ‘The Occupied Territories. J Palest Stud. 1989;28:114–6.Google Scholar
  95. Usher G. Facing defeat: the Intifada two years on. J Palest Stud. 2003;32:21–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2012

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Political ScienceNorthwestern UniversityEvanstonUSA

Personalised recommendations