Advertisement

The Quarterly Journal of Austrian Economics

, Volume 11, Issue 3–4, pp 230–241 | Cite as

The Great Depression: Mises vs. Fisher

  • Mark Thornton
Article
  • 56 Downloads

Abstract

Ludwig von Mises established the foundations of modern Austrian economics while Irving Fisher established the foundations of modern mainstream macroeconomics and central bank policy. Fisher helped create and was a proponent of mathematical economics, statistics and index numbers, and a monetary policy that “stabilized” the value of the dollar. Fisher claimed that his scientific approach established a new era of prosperity during the 1920s. Mises published a book in 1928 that critiqued Fisher’s approach and predicted that it would lead to an economic crisis and collapse. Before the stock market crash in 1929 Fisher proclaimed a perpetual prosperity for the economy and continued to recommend investing in stocks long after the market had collapsed. In this important case study, Mises passed the “market test” while Fisher lost his personal fortune during an economic crisis that his economics help create.

Keywords

Ludwig von Mises Irving Fisher Great Depression Methodology 

References

  1. Ekelund, Robert B., Jr., and Mark Thornton. 1986. “Schumpeterian Analysis, Supply Side Economics, and Macroeconomic Policy in the 1920s.” Review of Social Economy 19(3):221–37.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Fisher, Irving. [1892] 1925. Mathematical Investigations in the Theory of Value and Prices. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
  3. Fisher, Irving. 1906. “Economics as a Science.” Science 24(609):257–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Fisher, Irving. 1907. “Why has the Doctrine of Laissez Faire been Abandoned?” Science 25(627):18–27.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Fisher, Irving. 1913. The Purchasing Power of Money: Its Determination and Relation to Credit, Interest, and Crisis. New York: Macmillan.Google Scholar
  6. Fisher, Irving. [1922] 1927. The Making of Index Numbers: A Study of their Varieties, Tests, and Reliability. Boston, New York: Houghton Mifflin.Google Scholar
  7. Fisher, Irving. 1925. “Our Unstable Dollar and the So-Called Business Cycle.” Journal of the American Statistical Association 20(15):179–202.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Fisher, Irving. [1926] 1976. “I Discovered the Phillips Curve: A Statistical Relationship between Unemployment and Price Changes.” Journal of Political Economy 81(2):496–502.Google Scholar
  9. Fisher, Irving. 1929a. New York Herald Tribune. 5 September. Reprinted in Edward Angly, Oh Yeah? New York: Viking Press, 1931.Google Scholar
  10. Fisher, Irving. 1929b. “Fisher Sees Stocks Permanently High.” New York Times. 16 October. Reprinted in Edward Angly, Oh Yeah? New York: Viking Press, 1931.Google Scholar
  11. Fisher, Irving. 1929c. New York Herald Tribune. 22 October. Reprinted in Edward Angly, Oh Yeah? New York: Viking Press, 1931.Google Scholar
  12. Fisher, Irving. 1929d. New York Herald Tribute. 24 October. Reprinted in Edward Angly, Oh Yeah? New York: Viking Press, 1931.Google Scholar
  13. Fisher, Irving. 1929e. Quoted in “Overeager ‘Shoestring’ Traders Caused Crash in Market, Says Fisher.” New York Herald Tribune. 3 November. Reprinted in Edward Angly, Oh Yeah? New York: Viking Press, 1931.Google Scholar
  14. Fisher, Irving. 1932. Booms and Depressions: Some First Principles. New York: Adelphi Company.Google Scholar
  15. Fisher, Irving N. 1956. My Father, Irving Fisher. New York: Comet Press Books.Google Scholar
  16. Formaini, Robert L. 2005. “Irving Fisher: Origins of Modern Central Bank Policy.” Economic Insights 10, no 1. Dallas, Texas: Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas.Google Scholar
  17. Friedman, Milton. 1993 “The ‘Plucking Model’ of Business Cycle Fluctuations Revisited.” Economic Inquiry 31(2):171–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Friedman, Milton. 1997. “Rx for Japan.” Wall Street Journal. 17 December.Google Scholar
  19. Friedman, Milton, and Anna J. Schwartz. 1963. A Monetary History of the United States: 1867–1960. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
  20. Gertchev, Nikolay. 2004. “Dehomogenizing Mises’ Monetary Thought.” Journal of Libertarian Studies 18(3):57–90.Google Scholar
  21. Hoover, Kevin D. 2006. “Microfoundations and the Ontology of Macroeconomics.” (September 24). Available at SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=932945.
  22. Lavoie, Don. 1981. “A Critique of the Standard Account of the Socialist Calculation Debate.” Journal of Libertarian Studies 5(1):41–87.Google Scholar
  23. Leonard, Thomas C. 2005a. “Retrospectives: Eugenics and Economics in the Progressive Era.” Journal of Economic Perspectives 19(4):207–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Leonard, Thomas C. 2005b. “Mistaking Eugenics for Social Darwinism: Why Eugenics is Missing from the History of American Economics.” History of Political Economy 37(Supplement):200–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Leonard, Thomas C. 2005c. “Protecting Family and Race: The Progressive Case for Regulating Women’s Work.” American Journal of Economics and Sociology 64(3):757–91.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Long, Roderick T. 2006. “Realism and Abstraction in Economics: Aristotle and Mises versus Friedman.” Quarterly Journal of Austrian Economics 9(3):3–23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Mises, Ludwig von. [1912] 1981. The Theory of Money and Credit. Indianapolis, Ind.: Liberty Classics.Google Scholar
  28. Mises, Ludwig von. [1928] 1978. Geldwertstabilisierung and Konjunkturpolitik [Monetary stabilization and cyclical policy]. Jena: Gustav Fischer. English translation by Bettina Bien Greaves, On the Manipulation of Money and Credit. Dobbs Ferry, N.Y.: Free Market Books.Google Scholar
  29. Parrish, Michael E. 1994. The Anxious Decades. New York: W.W. Norton.Google Scholar
  30. Rothbard, Murray N. 1963. America’s Great Depression. New York: Richardson & Snyder.Google Scholar
  31. Rothbard, Murray N. 1991 “The End of Socialism and the Socialist Calculation Debate Revisited.” Review of Austrian Economics 5(2):51–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Rothbard, Murray N. [1971] 2002a. “Milton Friedman Unraveled.” Journal of Libertarian Studies 16(4):37–54.Google Scholar
  33. Rothbard, Murray N. 2002b. A History of Money and Banking in the United States: The Colonial Era to World War II. Ed. Joseph T. Salerno. Auburn, Ala.: Ludwig von Mises Institute.Google Scholar
  34. Rothbard, Murray N. [1962] 2004. Man, Economy, and State with Power and Market. Scholar’s Edition. Auburn, Ala.: Ludwig von Mises Institute.Google Scholar
  35. Salerno, Joseph T. 1990. “Postscript: Why a Socialist Economy is Impossible,” in Mises’s Economic Calculation in the Socialist Commonwealth, Auburn, Ala.: Ludwig von Mises Institute. Pp. 51–71.Google Scholar
  36. Skousen, Mark. 1991. Economics on Trial: Lies, Myths, and Realities, Homewood, Ill.: Business One Irvin.Google Scholar
  37. Skousen, Mark. 1993. “Who Predicted the 1929 Crash?” In The Meaning of Ludwig von Mises: Contributions in Economics, Sociology, Epistemology, and Political Philosophy. Ed. Jeffrey Herbener. Norwell, Mass.: Kluwer Academic Publishers.Google Scholar
  38. Thornton, Mark. 2004a. “Uncomfortable Parallels.” www.LewRockwell.com. April 18.
  39. Thornton, Mark. 2004b. “The ‘New Economists’ and the Great Depression of the 1970s.” Mises Daily Article. www.Mises.org. May, 7.
  40. Thornton, Mark. 2004c. “The Japanese Bubble Economy.” www.LewRockwell.com. May 23.
  41. Thornton, Mark. 2004d. “Housing: Too Good to be True.” Mises Daily Article. www.Mises.org, June 4.
  42. Thornton, Mark. 2006. “The Economics of Housing Bubbles.” Mises Institute Working Paper. June 12 and forthcoming in America’s Housing Crisis: A Case of Government Failure. Eds. Benjamin Powell and Randall Holcombe. Forthcoming.Google Scholar
  43. Tobin, James. 1985. “Neoclassical Economics in America.” American Economic Review 75, no. 6 (December):28–38.Google Scholar
  44. Tobin, James. 1987. “Irving Fisher.” The New Palgrave: A Dictionary of Economics. Ed. John Eatwell, Murray Milgate, and Peter Newman. New York: Stockton Press. Vol. 2. Pp 369–76.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Ludwig von Mises Institute 2008

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Ludwig von Mises InstituteAuburnUSA

Personalised recommendations