Theoretical Ecology

, Volume 4, Issue 4, pp 513–526 | Cite as

The role of discounting and dynamics in determining the economic efficiency of time-area closures for managing fishery bycatch

  • Paul R. Armsworth
  • Barbara A. Block
  • Josh Eagle
  • Joan E. Roughgarden
Original Paper

Abstract

Time-area closures are commonly used to manage fisheries bycatch and involve temporarily closing an area of the ocean to particular fishing gears. We examine conditions in which implementing a time-area closure would increase the economic value of fisheries, focusing on a case study application in the Gulf of Mexico. Pelagic longline fishermen catch the highly valued Atlantic bluefin tuna (Thunnus thynnus, Scombridae) on their Gulf of Mexico spawning grounds while fishing for Atlantic yellowfin tuna (Thunnus albacares). We analyze a multispecies, multifishery bioeconomic model that includes information on migratory patterns from electronic tagged bluefin tuna. We use dynamic optimization to identify management strategies that would maximize the net present value of tuna fisheries, allowing for discounting of future benefits and costs relative to the present. If past fishing mortality rates continue in Atlantic bluefin tuna fisheries, implementing a time-area closure in the Gulf of Mexico incurs economic costs. However, the net present value of the fisheries is increased by implementing a time-area closure as part of a broader commitment to rebuild the heavily depleted bluefin population, provided the discount rate and the costs of such a closure in forgone fishing opportunities are not too large. The increase in economic value offered by a time-area closure is small relative to the overall economic value of rebuilding itself and it may be economically optimal only to implement a closure once sufficient rebuilding has already taken place.

Keywords

Fisheries Economics Time-area closure Longline Bluefin tuna Yellowfin tuna Thunnus thynnus Thunnus albacares Gulf of Mexico Discounting Marine protected area 

Notes

Acknowledgements

We thank three anonymous referees for useful suggestions and A. Boustany, G. Daily, P. Ehrlich, L. Goulder, S. Miller and S. Teo for helpful discussions. The work was funded by a US–UK Fulbright scholarship to PRA, The Lenfest Ocean Program, and by grants from NOAA and the Packard Foundation to BAB.

Supplementary material

12080_2010_93_MOESM1_ESM.pdf (103 kb)
(PDF 102 kb)

References

  1. Armsworth PR, Roughgarden JE (2001) An invitation to ecological economics. Trends Ecol Evol 16:229–234CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Armsworth PR, Block BA, Eagle J, Roughgarden JE (ABER10) (2010) The economic efficiency of a time-area closure to protect spawning bluefin tuna. J Appl Ecol 47:36–46CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Bertignac M, Campbell HF, Hampton J, Hand AJ (2001) Maximizing resource rent from the Western and Central Pacific tuna fisheries. Marine Res Econ 15:151–177Google Scholar
  4. Bishop RC, Samples KC (1980) Sport and commercial fishing conflicts—a theoretical analysis. J Environ Econ Manage 7:220–233CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Bjorndal T, Brasao A (2006) The East Atlantic bluefin tuna fisheries: stock collapse or recovery? Marine Res Econ 21:191–210Google Scholar
  6. Block BA, Dewar H, Blackwell SB, Williams TD, Prince ED, Farwell CJ, Boustany A, Teo SLH, Seitz A, Walli A, Fudge D (2001) Migratory movements, depth preferences, and thermal biology of Atlantic bluefin tuna. Science 293:1310–1314PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Block BA, Teo SLH, Walli A, Boustany A, Stokesbury MJW, Farwell CJ, Weng KC, Dewar H, Williams TD (2005) Electronic tagging and population structure of Atlantic bluefin tuna. Nature 434:1121–1127PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Brown GM, Roughgarden J (1997) A metapopulation model with private property and a common pool. Ecol Econ 22:65–71CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Carroll MT, Anderson JL, Martinez-Garmendia J (2001) Pricing U.S. North Atlantic bluefin tuna and implications for management. Agribusiness 17:243–254CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Clark CW (1990) Mathematical Bioeconomics: the Optimal Management of Renewable Resources, 2nd edn. Wiley, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  11. Cook BA, McCaw RL (1996) Sport and commercial fishing allocations for Atlantic salmon fisheries of the Miramichi River. Can J Agric Econ 44:165–171CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Costello C, Polasky S (2008) Optimal harvesting of stochastic spatial resources. J Environ Econ Manage 56:1–18CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Crowder LB, Osherenko G, Young OR, Airame S, Norse EA, Baron N, Day JC, Douvere F, Ehler CN, Halpern BS, Langdon SJ, McLeod KL, Ogden JC, Peach RE, Rosenberg AA, Wilson JA (2006) Resolving mismatches in U.S. ocean governance. Science 313:617–618PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Curtis R, Hicks RL (2000) The cost of sea turtle preservation: the case of Hawaii’s pelagic longliners. Amer J Ag Econ 82:1191–1197CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Dichmont CM, Pascoe S, Kompas T, Punt AE, Deng R (2010) On implementing maximum economic yield in commercial fisheries. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 107:16–21PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Fernandes L, Day J, Lewis A, Slegers S, Kerrigan B, Breen D, Cameron D, Jago B, Hall J, Lowe D, Innes J, Tanzer J, Chadwick V, Thompson L, Gorman K, Simmons M, Barnett B, Sampson K, De’ath G, Mapstone B, Marsh H, Possingham H, Ball I, Ward T, Dobbs K, Aumend J, Slater D, Stapleton K (2005) Establishing representative no-take areas in the Great Barrier Reef: large-scale implementation of theory on marine protected areas. Conserv Biol 19:1733–1744CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Fromentin JM, Powers JE (2005) Atlantic bluefin tuna: population dynamics, ecology, fisheries and management. Fish Fish 6:281–306Google Scholar
  18. Game ET, Grantham HS, Hobday AJ, Pressey RL, Lombard AT, Beckley LE, Gjerde K, Bustamante R, Possingham HP, Richardson AJ (2009) Pelagic protected areas: the missing dimension in ocean conservation. Trends Ecol Evol 24:360–369CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Goodyear CP (1999) An analysis of the possible utility of time-area closures to minimize billfish bycatch by US pelagic longlines. Fish Bull US 97:243–255Google Scholar
  20. Goulder LH, Stavins RN (2002) An eye on the future: discounting. Nature 419:673–674PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Grantham HS, Petersen SL, Possingham HP (2008) Reducing bycatch in the South African pelagic longline fishery: the utility of different approaches to fisheries closures. Endanger Species Res 5:291–299CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Halpern BS, McLeod KL, Rosenberg AA, Crowder LB (2008) Managing for cumulative impacts in ecosystem-based management through ocean zoning. Ocean Coast Manag 51:203–211CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Hiddink JG, Hutton T, Jennings S, Kaiser MJ (2006) Predicting the effects of area closures and fishing effort restrictions on the production, biomass, and species richness of benthic invertebrate communities. ICES J Mar Sci 63:822–830CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Hobday AJ, Hartmann K (2006) Near real-time spatial management based on habitat predictions for a longline bycatch species. Fisheries Manag Ecol 13:365–380CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Holland DS, Brazee RJ (1996) Marine reserves for fisheries management. Mar Res Econ 11:157–177Google Scholar
  26. International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas (ICCAT) (2009a) Report of the 2008 ICCAT bluefin stock assessment session. ICCAT Collective Volume of Scientific Papers 64:1–352Google Scholar
  27. International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas (ICCAT) (2009b) Report of the 2008 ICCAT yellowfin and skipjack stock assessments meeting. ICCAT Collective Volume of Scientific Papers 64:669–927Google Scholar
  28. Lang KL, Grimes CB, Shaw RF (1994) Variations in the age and growth of yellowfin tuna larvae, Thunnus albacares, collected about the Mississippi River plume. Environ Biol Fisches 39:259–270CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Larkin SL, Adams CM, Lee DJ (2000) Reported trip costs, gross revenues, and net returns for U.S. Atlantic pelagic longlining vessels. Mar Fish Rev 62:49–60Google Scholar
  30. Ludwig D (1980) Harvesting strategies for a randomly fluctuating population. J Conseil Int Explor Mer 39:168–174CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Martinez-Garmendia J, Anderson JL (2005) Conservation, markets, and fisheries policy: the North Atlantic bluefin tuna and the Japanese sashimi market. Agribusiness 21:17–36CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Matsuda H, Abrams PA (2006) Maximal yields from multispecies fisheries systems: rules for systems with multiple trophic levels. Ecol Appl 16:225–237PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Mesterton-Gibbons M (1996) A technique for finding optimal two-species harvesting policies. Ecol Model 92:235–244CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Murawski SA, Finn JT (1986) Optimal effort allocation among competing mixed-species fisheries, subject to fishing mortality constraints. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 43:90–100CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) (2006) Final consolidated Atlantic highly migratory species fishery management plan. National Oceanic Atmospheric Administration, National Marine Fisheries Service, Office of Sustainable Fisheries, Silver Spring, MDGoogle Scholar
  36. National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) (2009) Annual report of the United States of America to ICCAT. National Oceanic Atmospheric Administration, National Marine Fisheries Service, Office of Sustainable Fisheries, Silver Spring, MDGoogle Scholar
  37. Neubert MG, Herrera GE (2008) Triple benefits from spatial resource management. Theor Ecol 1:5–12CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Palumbi, SR (2004) Marine reserves and ocean neighbourhoods: the spatial scale of marine populations and their management. Annual Review of Environment and Resources 29:31–68CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Pintassilgo P, Costa Duarte C (2002) Optimal management of the Northern Atlantic bluefin tuna. Marine Res Econ 17:47–67Google Scholar
  40. Porch CE (2005) The sustainability of western Atlantic bluefin tuna: a warm-blooded fish in a hot-blooded fishery. Bull Mar Sci 76:363–384Google Scholar
  41. Power JH, May LN Jr. (1991) Satellite observed sea-surface temperatures and yellowfin tuna catch and effort in the Gulf of Mexico. Fish Bull US 89:429–439Google Scholar
  42. Powers JE, Abeare SM (2009) Fishing effort redistribution in response to area closures. Fish Res 99:216–225CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Safina C (1998) Song for the Blue Ocean: Encounters Along the World’s Coasts and Beneath the Seas. Henry Holt, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  44. Safina C, Klinger DH (2008) Collapse of bluefin tuna in the Western Atlantic. Conserv Biol 22:243–246PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Sanchirico JN, Wilen JE (2001) A bioeconomic model of marine reserve creation. J Environ Econ Manage 42:257–276CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Sanchirico JN, Malvadkar U, Hastings A, Wilen JE (2006) When are no-take zones an economically optimal fishery management strategy? Ecol Appl 16:1643–1659PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Sissenwine MP, Mace PM, Powers JE, Scott GP (1998) A commentary on Western Atlantic bluefin tuna assessments. Trans Am Fish Soc 127:838–855CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Smith MD, Wilen JE (2003) Economic impacts of marine reserves: the importance of spatial behavior. J Environ Econ Manage 46:183–206CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Smith MD, Lynham J, Sanchirico JN, Wilson JA (2010) Political economy of marine reserves: understanding the role of opportunity costs. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. doi: 10.1073/pnas.0907365107
  50. Teo SLH, Block BA (2010) Comparative influence of ocean conditions on yellowfin and Atlantic bluefin tuna catch from longlines in the Gulf of Mexico. PLoS ONE 5(5):e10756. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0010756 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Teo SLH, Boustany A, Dewar H, Stokesbury MJW, Weng KC, Beemer S, Seitz AC, Farwell CJ, Prince ED, Block BA (2007a) Annual migrations, diving behavior, and thermal biology of Atlantic bluefin tuna, Thunnus thynnus, on their Gulf of Mexico breeding grounds. Mar Biol 151:1–18CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Teo SLH, Boustany AM, Block BA (2007b) Oceanographic preferences of Atlantic bluefin tuna, Thunnus thynnus, on their Gulf of Mexico breeding grounds. Mar Biol 152:1105–1119CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. United States District Court for the District of Columbia (USDC DC) (2008) Blue Ocean Institute v. Gutierrez, 585 F. Supp. 2d 36 (DDC 2008)Google Scholar
  54. Walli A, Teo SLH, Boustany A, Farwell CJ, Williams T, Dewar H, Prince E, Block BA (2009) Seasonal movements, aggregations and diving behavior of Atlantic bluefin tuna (Thunnus thynnus) revealed with archival tags. PLoS ONE 4(7):e6151. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0006151 CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010

Authors and Affiliations

  • Paul R. Armsworth
    • 1
    • 2
  • Barbara A. Block
    • 3
  • Josh Eagle
    • 4
  • Joan E. Roughgarden
    • 5
  1. 1.Department of Animal and Plant SciencesUniversity of SheffieldSheffieldUK
  2. 2.Department of Ecology and Evolutionary BiologyUniversity of TennesseeKnoxvilleUSA
  3. 3.Hopkins Marine StationStanford UniversityPacific GroveUSA
  4. 4.School of LawUniversity of South CarolinaColumbiaUSA
  5. 5.Department of Biological SciencesStanford UniversityStanfordUSA

Personalised recommendations