Is it Easier to Match a Name to an Odor than Vice Versa?
- 83 Downloads
Previous literature and common belief suggest a cognitive asymmetry in the odor–name relationship such that it would be easier to match a name to an odor than the other way around. We tested whether it is more difficult to smell an odor and then choose a proper name among three alternatives than to read an odor name and then choose a matching odor among three alternatives. Although instances of an asymmetry are suggested, in both directions, depending on which odors or odor names are involved, the overall conclusion is that no general unidirectional asymmetry is evident. This was true for odorants of both high and low familiarity and identifiability. Different cognitive factors in a complete model of odor–name matching are identified and discussed.
KeywordsOdor Identification Odor Naming Cued Identification
We would like to thank Fredrik Gunne, Microsoft, Sweden, for data simulation and Ana Rita Dias for help with the data collection.
- Bell GA, Paton JE (2000) Verbal-cognitive strategy can influence odor judgment. The Aroma-Chology Review 10:3–9Google Scholar
- Desor JA, Beauchamp GK (1974) The human capacity to transmit olfactory information. Percept Psychophys 16(3):551–556Google Scholar
- De Wijk RA, Cain WS (1994a) Odor identification by name and edibility: life-span development and safety. Human Factors 36(1):182–187Google Scholar
- De Wijk RA, Cain WS (1994b) Odor quality: discrimination versus free and cued identification. Percept Psychophys 56(1):12–18Google Scholar
- De Wijk RA, Schab FR, Cain WS (1995) Odor identification. In: Schab FR, Crowder RG (eds) Memory for odors. Lawrence Erlbaum, Mahwah, pp 21–37Google Scholar
- Doty RL, Shaman P, Kimmelman CP, Dann MS (1984) University of Pennsylvania Smell Identification Test: a rapid quantitative olfactory function test for the clinic. Laryngoscope 94(2 Pt 1):176–178Google Scholar
- Kobal G, Hummel T, Sekinger B, Barz S, Roscher S, Wolf S (1996) “Sniffin’ Sticks”: screening of olfactory performance. Rhinology 34(4):222–226Google Scholar
- Olsson MJ, Cain WS (2003) Implicit and explicit memory for odors: hemispheric differences. Mem Cogn 31(1):44–50Google Scholar
- Olsson MJ, Jönsson FJ, Moeller P (2008) Is there an olfactory working memory? Unpublished manuscript.Google Scholar