Graphic determination of available energy-saving potential in a reservoir pumping application with variable-speed operation
Centrifugal pumps represent a notable share of electricity consumption in motor-driven systems. Many studies have verified the energy-saving potential in these systems with device improvements and by modification of the applied flow control method or characteristics of the surrounding process. The best approach for reaching a more energy-efficient reservoir pumping system has to be determined for each system separately, making the analysis too laborious for a typical system operator. This paper proposes the application of graphic analysis tool for determination of the available energy saving potential in a reservoir pumping application. To realize this object, this paper studies how the available energy-saving potential in a reservoir pumping system is affected by two different variable-speed control schemes and by surrounding process variables, namely the static head variation and friction factor. Based on conducted simulations, generic graphs for determination of the available energy saving potential in the reservoir pumping application are formed, and their applicability is tested with two real-life cases. The produced graphs for available energy-saving potential seem to provide feasible results when compared to the case studies, justifying their use for instance in energy audits. Hence, this paper provides an effective tool for pumping station operators to assess economic feasibility of a variable-speed operation in their systems. However, further testing is required to see whether the resulted graphs are representing reality in all situations that can be described with static head and its variation.
KeywordsEnergy audits Energy efficiency Pumps Reservoir pumping application Variable-speed drives
This work was carried out in the Efficient Energy Use (EFEU) research program coordinated by CLIC Innovation Ltd. with funding from the Finnish Funding Agency for Technology and Innovation, Tekes. Research work has also been funded by Academy of Finland.
Compliance with ethical standards
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
- Barnes S. (2014). Energy efficient variable frequency drives and submersible pumps. Proceedings of Australia’s international water conference and exhibition (Ozwater’14). Brisbane, Australia.Google Scholar
- Bene J. (2013). Pump schedule optimization techniques for water distribution systems. Oulu.Google Scholar
- dos Santos, J. N., & Seleghim Jr., P. (2005). Optimized strategies for fluid transport and reservoirs management. Revista Minerva–Pesquisa & Tecnologia, 2(1), 91–98.Google Scholar
- Flygt (2015). Variable speed wastewater pumping, white paper.Google Scholar
- Hovstadius, G. (1999). Economical aspects of adjustable speed drives in pumping systems. Proceedings of 21st National Industrial Energy Technology Conference. May 12–13. 1999. Houston, Texas, USA.Google Scholar
- Hovstadius G. (2005). Getting it right, applying a systems approach to variable speed pumping. Proceedings of 4th international conference on energy efficiency in motor driven systems (EEMODS ‘05), Heidelberg, Germany.Google Scholar
- Kallesøe C. S. (2005). Fault detection and isolation in centrifugal pumps. Aalborg.Google Scholar
- Lindstedt M. & Karvinen R. (2015). Optimal speed control of two unequal parallel pumps in reservoir filling: minimum energy with fixed time. Proceedings of ECOS 2015—28th international conference on efficiency, cost, Simulation and environmental impact of energy systems. Pau, France.Google Scholar
- Middleton, P. (2014). SmartRun, VSDs and optimised wastewater pumping. Mechanical Technology, 34–−37.Google Scholar
- Nesbitt B. (2006). Handbook of pumps and pumping: Pumping manual international.Google Scholar
- Pump Systems Matter & Hydraulic Institute (2008). Optimizing pumping systems guidebook.Google Scholar
- Ruuskanen A. (2007). Optimization of energy consumption in wastewater pumping. Helsinki.Google Scholar
- Sârbu, I., & Borza, I. (1998). Energetic optimization of water pumping in distribution systems. Periodica Polytechnica Ser. Mech. Eng., 42(2), 141–152.Google Scholar
- Schützhold J., Benath K., Müller V. & Hofmann W. (2013). Design criteria for energy efficient pump drive systems. Proceedings of EPE’13 ECCE Europe Conference. Lille, France.Google Scholar
- Shankar, A., Kalaiselvan, V., Umashankar, S., Paramasivam, S., & Haginovszki, R. (2016). A comprehensive review on energy efficiency enhancement initiatives in centrifugal pumping system. Applied Energy, 181, 491–513.Google Scholar
- Tamminen J., Viholainen J., Ahonen T. & Tolvanen J. (2013). Sensorless specific energy optimization of a variable-speed-driven pumping system. Proceedings of 8th international conference on energy efficiency in motor driven systems (EEMODS’13). Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.Google Scholar